- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Konan Kodio Ganstone And Others v. State Of Maharashtra Through Police Station Officer .
Factual and Procedural Background
This is a concurring opinion by M.G. Sewlikar, J., who read and agreed with the operative part of the Judgment delivered by Hon'ble Shri Justice T.V. Nalawade but reserved reasons. The petitions are Writ Petition Nos. 548 of 2020, 552 of 2020 and 554 of 2020. The petitioners are foreign nationals prosecuted under various provisions including Sections 188, 269, 270 and 290 of the Indian Penal Code, Sections 37(1)(3) r/w 135 of the Maharashtra Police Act, 1951, Section 11 of the Maharashtra Covid-19 Measures and Rules, 2020, Sections 2, 3 and 4 of the Epidemic Diseases Act, 1897, Section 14(b) of the Foreigners Act, 1946 and Section 51(b) of the Disaster Management Act, 2005. The judge reviewed the record and provided reasons for agreeing with the operative relief granted, while dissenting from certain observations in paragraph 35 of the earlier judgment.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the material on record establishes that the foreign nationals were infected with COVID-19 at the time of landing or violated visa conditions.
- Whether the material shows that the foreign nationals were propagating religion.
- Whether continuation of prosecution, given the available material, would amount to an abuse of the process of court and whether the charge-sheets/FIRs should be quashed.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's reasoning, based on the material before it, proceeded as follows:
- The material on record did not show that the foreign nationals were infected with COVID-19 when they landed in India.
- The material did not show that the foreign nationals violated visa conditions; the judge expressly noted that visiting religious places does not amount to violating visa conditions.
- Witness statements recorded during investigation did not show that the foreign nationals were propagating religion.
- Given the absence of evidence to make out the offences under the cited provisions, continuation of prosecution would constitute an abuse of the process of the court.
- The judge therefore concluded that none of the offences were made out on the material and that the charge-sheets deserved to be quashed.
- The judge disagreed with paragraph 35 of the earlier opinion on the ground that the observations in that paragraph were unsupported by allegations in the petitions or by evidence, and thus were outside the scope of the petitions.
Holding and Implications
All petitions are allowed; First Information Reports and the charge-sheets are quashed.
Direct effect: The prosecutions against the petitioners in Writ Petition Nos. 548 of 2020, 552 of 2020 and 554 of 2020 are terminated by quashing of the FIRs and charge-sheets.
No broader implications or precedential holdings beyond the direct relief to the petitioners are discussed in the opinion.
M.G. Sewlikar, J.:— I had privilege to read the Judgment of Brother Hon'ble Shri Justice T.V. Nalawade. While pronouncing the Judgmente it was observed that I agree with the operative part of the Judgment but I do not agree with some reasoning and the reasons were reserved. Nowe I proceed to give the reasons.
2. The petitioners in Writ Petition Nos. 548 of 2020e 552 of 2020 and 554 of 2020 are prosecuted for the offences punishable under Sections 188e 269e 270 and 290 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)e Sections 37(1)(3) r/w. 135 of Maharashtra Police Acte 1951e Section 11 of the Maharashtra Covid-19 Measures and Rulese 2020e Sections 2e 3 and 4 of Epidemic Diseases Acte 1897e Section 14(b) of Foreigners Acte 1946 and Section 51(b) of the Disaster Management Acte 2005.
3. The material placed on record does not show that when the foreign nationals landed in Indiae they were infected with Covid-19. Similarlye the material placed on record does not show that the foreign nationals violated visa conditions. Visiting religious places does not amount to violating visa conditions. The statements of the witnesses recorded during the investigation do not show that the foreign nationals were propagating religion. Continuation of prosecution against the petitioners in these circumstances would be an abuse of process of Court. Since none of the offences under the aforesaid Sections are made oute the charge-sheets deserve to be quashed. Thereforee I agree with all the observations of my learned Brother except the observations contained in paragraph No. 35. Paragraph No. 35 reads as under:
“35) There were protests by taking processionse holding Dharana at many places in India from atleast from prior to January 2020. Most of the persons participated in protest were Muslims. It is their contention that Citizenship Amendment Acte 2019 is discriminatory against the Muslims. They believe that Indian Citizenship will not be granted to Muslim refugees and migrants. They were protesting against National Registration of Citizenship (NRC). There were protests on large scale not only in Delhie but in the most of the States in India. It can be said that due to the present action taken fear was created in the minds of those Muslims. This action indirectly gave warning to Indian Muslims that action in any form and for any thing can be taken against Muslims. It was indicated that even for keeping contact with Muslims of other countriese action will be taken against them. Thuse there is smell of malice to the action taken against these foreigners and Muslim for their alleged activities. The circumstances like malice is important consideration when relief is claimed of quashing of F.I.R. and the case itself.”
4. I fnd it difcult to concur with these observations as allegations in this respect are not made in the petitions nor there is any evidence in this regard. Thereforee in my opinion these observations are outside the scope of the petitions.
5. All the petitions are therefore allowed.
6. First Information Reports and the charge-sheets are quashed.
Alert