- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Barak Alloy v. Union Of India Rep. By The Secretary To The Govt Of India And Others
Achintya Malla Bujor Barua, J.:— Heard Dr. Ashok Saraf, learned senior counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S.C. Keyal, learned ASGI for the GST and Excise Department.
2. Issue notice returnable 2(two) weeks.
3. Extra copies to the respondents within 7 (seven) days.
4. The petitioner in course of their economic activities under the Northeast Industrial Policy, 2007 were entitled to certain exemption in the payment of excise duty. Along with excise duty, as per the relevant law in force at that period to time they were also required to pay certain education cess & secondary and higher education cess.
5. The education cess & secondary and higher education cess were required to have been calculated on the basis of the excise duty payable.
6. In the circumstance, a question had arisen as to whether in view of the exemption granted to the excise duty the petitioner would also be entitled to an exemption to the payment of education cess & secondary and higher education cess. The said question was decided by the Supreme Court in its pronouncement in SRD Nutrients Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Guwahati reported in (2018) 1 SCC 105 wherein in paragraph 27 of the said judgment it was held that the appellants therein were entitled to refund of education cess and higher education cess which was paid along with the excise duty once the excise duty itself was exempted from levy.
7. In the resultant circumstance, by the order dated 13.02.2019 of the Assistant Commissioner, Excise, GST and Central Excise, certain amounts were sanctioned for being refunded to the petitioner and accordingly the refunds were given effect. Subsequent thereto, the Supreme Court in its pronouncement in Unicorn Industries v. Union of India reports in 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1567 in paragraph 49 had held as under:
“49. The reason employed in SRD Nutrients Private Limited (supra) that there was nil excise duty, as such, additional duty cannot be charged, is also equally unacceptable as additional duty can always be determined and merely exemption granted in respect of a particular excise duty, cannot come in the way of determination of yet another duty based thereupon. The proposition urged that simply because one kind of duty is exempted, other kinds of duties automatically fall, cannot be accepted as there is no difficulty in making the computation of additional duties, which are payable under NCCD, education cess, secondary and higher education cess. Moreover, statutory notification must cover specifically the duty exempted. When a particular kind of duty is exempted, other types of duty or cess imposed by different legislation for a different purpose cannot be said to have been exempted.
51. Thus, it is clear that before the Division Bench deciding SRD Nutrients Private Limited and Bajaj Auto Limited (supra), the previous binding decisions of three-Judge Bench in Modi Rubber (supra) and Rita Textiles Private Limited (supra) were not placed for consideration. Thus, the decisions in SRD Nutrients Private Limited and (supra) and Rita Textile Private Limited (supra) are binding on us being of Coordinate Bench, and we respectfully follow them. We did not find any ground to take a different view.“
8. In view of the subsequent judgment of the Supreme Court in Unicorn Industries (supra) the respondent authorities had issued the demand cum show cause notice dated 09.06.2020 to the petitioner by which a question was raised that the earlier refund of the education cess & secondary and higher education cess given to them has now become erroneous refunds and therefore, a recovery be made under section 11(A-1) of the Central Excise Act 1944. The demand cum show-cause notice dated 09.06.2020 is assailed in this writ petition on the ground that the condition precedent to invoke the power under section 11(A-1) is that the refund made must be erroneous. It is contended when the refund was given effect during the period prior to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Unicorn Industries (supra), at that point of time the proposition laid down in SRD Nutrients Private Limited (supra) was in force which had decided in favour of such refunds. Accordingly, it is contended that when the refund was made the law in force was that such refunds were justified and therefore, the refund was not erroneous.
9. It being so, condition precedent of section 11(A-1) of the Excise Central Act, 1944 is not satisfied.
10. In the above circumstance, a question for determination would be as to whether the proposition of law laid down in Unicorn Industries (supra) would render the refund made to the petitioner to be erroneous.
11. In view of the above, until further orders we stay the operation of the demand cum-show-cause notice dated 09.06.2020.
12. Mr. B. Sarma, learned counsel appearing for the GST and Excise Department has stated that an affidavit had been filed in WP(C) No. 1366/2020 wherein also the same issue is involved. Mr. B. Sarma states that said affidavit would cover all other writ petitions wherein the same issue had been raised.
13. Ms. P. Das, learned counsel also appearing for the Excise Department in some other writ petitions also involving the same question, desires to file a separate affidavit-in-opposition.
14. In view of the situation, Mr. B. Sarma, may serve a copy of the affidavit-in-opposition to the learned counsel for the petitioners, in all such writ petitions, involving the same question, where Mr. B. Sarma appears for the GST and Excise Department.
15. Similarly, in the matters where Mr. S.C. Keyal, learned ASGI appears for the GST and Excise Department, if so advised, a separate affidavit may be filed within a period 2(two) weeks.
16. As prayed, 2(two) weeks is allowed to file the affidavit-in-opposition.
17. Similarly, the said affidavit-in-opposition be served to the learned counsel for all such writ petitions where similar issue is involved in which Mr. S.C. Keyal learned ASGI appears for the GST and Excise Department.
18. Upon the affidavits being served on the petitioners, any reply, if so advised, may be filed by the petitioners within a period of 2(two) weeks thereafter.
19. As agreed upon list the matter on 06.10.2020 for further consideration. Till the next date fixed, the recovery of the higher education cess already refunded by the department to the petitioner shall not be recovered.
20. Mr. B. Sarma, makes a further prayer that in some of the writ petitions where he appears for the GST and Excise Department, additional affidavit would also be filed. We also allow the prayer, but such affidavit be filed within a period of 2(two) weeks and the copy of the same be served on the learned counsel for the petitioners. The petitioners if so advised may file their reply to such additional affidavit within a period of 2 (two) weeks thereafter.
Alert