- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mohd. Rashid v. Director, Local Bodies, New Secretariat And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellants are aspirants for direct recruitment to the posts of Administrative Officer/Assistant Assessor and Collector in the North, South and East Delhi Municipal Corporations. An advertisement dated 12-9-2013 (Advertisement No. 3 of 2013) invited applications to fill 30 such vacancies through direct recruitment.
Employees already working as Lower Division Clerks and promoted as Upper Division/Head Clerks filed an Original Application before the Central Administrative Tribunal challenging the advertisement on the ground that the applicable Recruitment Rules required the Corporations to consider promotion (and deputation) before resorting to direct recruitment. The Tribunal dismissed that application on 28-5-2015, but the Delhi High Court, by order dated 1-9-2016, held that the Corporations had not complied with the Recruitment Rules and restrained them from proceeding with direct recruitment until efforts were made to fill the vacancies by promotion, transfer, or deputation.
The present appeals before the Supreme Court are by the direct-recruitment candidates challenging the High Court’s order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Municipal Corporations had complied with the amended 2013 Recruitment Rules requiring 50% of the posts to be filled by promotion (failing which by direct recruitment) and the remaining 50% by deputation (failing which by direct recruitment).
- Whether aspirants who responded to the 2013 advertisement acquired any enforceable or indefeasible right to appointment to the advertised posts.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India, (1991) 3 SCC 47 | No candidate acquires an indefeasible right to appointment merely because his/her name appears in a merit list; the State is not bound to fill all advertised vacancies. | Relied upon to hold that the appellants, even if selected, have no vested right to appointment and cannot compel the Corporations to recruit them. |
| State of Haryana v. Subash Chander Marwaha, (1974) 3 SCC 220 | The State has discretion not to fill all vacancies provided the decision is bona fide. | Cited (through Shankarsan Dash) to reinforce that non-filling of posts is permissible when justified. |
| Neelima Shangla v. State of Haryana, (1986) 4 SCC 268 | Reaffirms that advertisement is only an invitation to apply and does not confer a right to appointment. | Referenced to support the absence of an enforceable right in favour of the appellants. |
| Jatinder Kumar v. State of Punjab, (1985) 1 SCC 122 | Similar principle on the State’s discretion in filling vacancies. | Referenced consistently with the above cases. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
1. The Court examined affidavits filed by the North, South and East Delhi Municipal Corporations detailing promotions and proposed deputations after the 17-6-2013 amendment to the Recruitment Rules. The data showed regular promotions through Departmental Selection Committees and ongoing efforts to fill the deputation quota, with applications invited and received.
2. On that factual basis, the Court concluded that the Corporations were in fact adhering to the statutory mandate: 50% of posts were being considered for promotion and 50% for deputation, with direct recruitment only if those channels failed.
3. Applying the principle in Shankarsan Dash, the Court held that the appellants, as mere aspirants responding to an advertisement whose selection process had not been completed, possessed no vested or indefeasible right to appointment.
4. Because the Corporations were acting within the framework of the Recruitment Rules and the appellants had no enforceable right, the High Court’s interference was found unwarranted; consequently, the appeals lacked merit.
Holding and Implications
Appeals Dismissed.
The Supreme Court affirmed that municipal authorities may proceed first with promotions and deputations in accordance with the Recruitment Rules and are not obliged to appoint the appellants merely because they applied pursuant to the 2013 advertisement. The decision clarifies that job advertisements create no enforceable right to appointment and that statutory recruitment hierarchies (promotion/deputation before direct recruitment) must be respected. No new legal precedent was set beyond applying established principles on recruitment discretion.
Hemant Gupta, J.— The candidates for direct recruitment to the posts of Administrative Officer/Assistant Assessor and Collector (for short, “the posts in question”) are in appeals before this Court directed against an order passed by the High Court of Delhi on 1-9-2016 2016 SCC OnLine Del 5015.
2. The candidates who were initially appointed as Lower Division Clerks and promoted as Upper Division Clerks/Head Clerks invoked the jurisdiction of the Central Administrative Tribunal (for short, “the Tribunal”) challenging Advertisement No. 3 of 2013 dated 12-9-2013 whereby, the respondents set in process to fill up the posts advertised by way of direct recruitment. The argument was that the Recruitment Regulations for the post of Administrative Officer/Assistant Assessor and Collector in North, South and East Delhi Municipal Corporations, 2013 (for short, “the Recruitment Rules”) contemplate that the vacancies for the posts in question are to be filled up by promotion failing which by direct recruitment. It was thus alleged that without resorting to promotion by convening meeting of the Departmental Promotion Committee (for short “DPC”), the alternative process of direct recruitment cannot be resorted to.
3. The said original application was dismissed by the Tribunal on 28-5-2015 OA No. 1935 of 2015 by observing that the recruitment process is not against the constitutional provisions but the promotion must also not be tempered with. In the writ petition directed against such order, the High Court held that the respondents have failed to comply with the Recruitment Rules and that only after the respondents are unable to fill up the vacancies either by promotion or by transfer or by deputation, the Department would be entitled to publish the advertisement to fill up the vacancies. It was also found that no effort has been made to hold DPC to carry out promotions nor the respondents have explored the possibility to fill up the vacancies either by transfer or deputation.
4. The advertisement was published to fill up 30 vacancies by direct recruitment to the posts in question out of which 8 were reserved for Other Backward Classes, 4 for Scheduled Castes, 2 for Scheduled Tribes and 16 were meant for General category candidates including 1 post meant to be filled up by physically handicapped candidate which is a horizontal reservation.
5. The Recruitment Rules were amended on 17-6-2013 i.e. before the advertisement was issued on 12-9-2013. The amended rule reads as under:
“1. Name of the Post Administrative Officer/Assistant Assessor and Collector 10. Method of recruitment whether by direct recruitment or by promotion or by deputation/absorption and % of the vacancies to be filled by various method. (i) 50% by promotion, failing which by direct recruitment. (ii) 50% by deputation, failing which by direct recruitment.”
6. A perusal of the above Rule shows that 50% of the posts are to be filled up by promotion. If the posts are not filled up by promotion, the same are to be filled up by direct recruitment. Similarly, 50% of the posts are meant to be filled up by deputation. If the deputationists are not available, the same are to be filled up by direct recruitment.
7. An affidavit dated 7-8-2019 has been filed on behalf of North Delhi Municipal Corporation (for short, “North DMC”) as to how after the amendment of the Rules, the number of posts falling to the promotion quota have been filled up. The assertions in the affidavit are as under:
“5. (i) After notification of new Recruitment Rules dated 17-6-2013, the promotion to the post of Admn. Officer/AA&C (2013) was held as under:
Sanctioned post in promotion quota Filled up Vacant Filled up after DSC dated 30-8-2013 Vacant after DSC dated 30-8-2013 Total 58 33 25 25 00
(ii) The promotion to the post of Admn. Officer/AA&C (2014) was held as under:
Sanctioned post in promotion quota Filled up Vacant Filled up after DSC dated 31-1-2014 Vacant after DSC dated 31-1-2014 Total 58 48 10 4 06
(iii) The promotion to the post of Admn. Officer/AA&C (2015) was held as under:
Sanctioned post in promotion quota Filled up Vacant Filled up after DSC dated 22-7-2014 Vacant after DSC dated 22-7-2014 Total 58 23 35 31 04
(iv) The promotion to the post of Admn. Officer/AA&C (2016) was held as under:
Sanctioned post in promotion quota Filled up Vacant Filled up after DSC dated 8-7-2015 Vacant after DSC dated 8-7-2015 Total 58 34 24 22 02
(v) The promotion to the post of Admn. Officer/AA&C (2017) was held as under:
Sanctioned post in promotion quota Filled up Vacant Filled up after DSC dated 8-7-2015 Vacant after DSC dated 8-7-2015 Total 68 14 54 38 16 (including 3 SC & 1 ST)
(vi) That at present details of vacancy position of Administrative Officer/AA&C in all three Corporations under Promotion Quota as on 1-7-2019 is as under, which is dealt by the North DMC being Nodal Corporation for promotion for all the three Corporations:
Sanctioned post Filled up post Vacant Post Promotion Quota 72 54 (including 23 LAC given by SDMC) 18
Note: A DSC is under process, wherein 94 Section Officers, Private Secretaries and Translators are being considered for promotion to the post of Admn. Officer/AA&C.”
8. It is also mentioned that seniority list of feeder cadre has not been finalised on account of pendency of the matter before the Tribunal and the High Court and that in terms of directions of the High Court, recommendation of the review DPC has been placed before the High Court and the matter is pending consideration before the High Court.
9. The said affidavit also gives the details of the manner of posts falling under the deputation quota. It is mentioned that each of the three Municipal Corporations deal with the deputation quota at their own level. However, the vacancies of the North DMC are stated to be as under:
“(vii) Deputation Quota: The posts under deputation quota are being dealt by the Corporation concerned separately at their own level, the vacancy position of North DMC is as under:
North DMC Sanctioned Filled Vacant 25 4 21
Note: As per Recruitment Rules North DMC has already invited applications for filling up the post of Admn. Officer/AA&C under deputation quota vide circular dated 6-2-2019 and subsequent reminders dated 12-7-2019. 11 applications for appointment to the post of Admn. Officer/AA&C on deputation basis have been received till date. The last date of receipt of application is 31-8-2019.
The abovesaid table shows that the vacancy to the post of Admn. Officer/AA&C has been filled up by the department regularly after notification of new Recruitment Rules dated 17-6-2013.”
10. Thus, in respect of 25 vacancies falling to the share of the North DMC, it is mentioned that there are 21 vacant posts and that applications have been invited to fill up the deputation quota vide circular dated 6-2-2019. 11 applications have been received though the last date of the receipt of the applications was 31-8-2019.
11. In respect of deputation quota in South Delhi Municipal Corporation, it is mentioned in the separate affidavit that out of 32 posts falling to the quota of deputationists, 13 posts are vacant as on 1-8-2019. By a separate affidavit filed on behalf of East Delhi Municipal Corporation, it is mentioned that out of 14 sanctioned posts, 5 posts are falling vacant against the deputation quota.
12. From the above information placed on record, we find that the Recruitment Rules providing 50% quota to be filled up by promotion failing which by direct recruitment and another 50% by deputation quota failing which by direct recruitment are being followed by the municipal bodies.
13. The appellants who are aspirants for direct recruitment have no right for appointment merely because at one point of time the vacancies were advertised. The candidates such as the appellants cannot claim any right of appointment merely for the reason that they responded to an advertisement published on 12-9-2013. Even after completion of the selection process, the candidates even on the merit list do not have any vested right to seek appointment only for the reason that their names appear on the merit list. In Shankarsan Dash v. Union of India (1991) 3 SCC 47, a Constitution Bench of this Court held that a candidate seeking appointment to a civil post cannot be regarded to have acquired an indefeasible right to appointment in such post merely because of the appearance of his name in the merit list. This Court held as under:
“7. It is not correct to say that if a number of vacancies are notified for appointment and adequate number of candidates are found fit, the successful candidates acquire an indefeasible right to be appointed which cannot be legitimately denied. Ordinarily the notification merely amounts to an invitation to qualified candidates to apply for recruitment and on their selection they do not acquire any right to the post. Unless the relevant recruitment rules so indicate, the State is under no legal duty to fill up all or any of the vacancies. However, it does not mean that the State has the licence of acting in an arbitrary manner. The decision not to fill up the vacancies has to be taken bona fide for appropriate reasons. And if the vacancies or any of them are filled up, the State is bound to respect the comparative merit of the candidates, as reflected at the recruitment test, and no discrimination can be permitted. This correct position has been consistently followed by this Court, and we do not find any discordant note in the decisions in State of Haryana v. Subash Chander Marwaha (1974) 3 SCC 220; Neelima Shangla v. State of Haryana (1986) 4 SCC 268 or Jatinder Kumar v. State of Punjab (1985) 1 SCC 122.”
14. Since the selection process has not been completed and keeping in view the mandate of the statutory rules, we find that the appellants have no right to dispute the action of the municipal bodies to fill up the posts either by way of promotion or by deputation as such posts are being filled up in terms of mandate of the Rules. It is always open to the municipal bodies to fill up the vacant posts by way of direct recruitment after the posts by way of promotion and/or deputation quota are not filled up either on the basis of recruitment process already initiated or to be initiated afresh.
15. Consequently, we do not find any merit in the present appeals. Accordingly, the same are dismissed.
Alert