- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramhari Gurjar v. State Of U.P. And Others
Summary of Judgment — Vivek Kumar Birla, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner applied to appear in the Assistant Teacher Recruitment Examination, 2019 (ATRE-2019). In the online application form he filled for the ATRE-2019, the petitioner indicated his vertical reservation as OBC (column-9) but did not fill column-10 which related to Special Reservation/Physically Handicapped (horizontal reservation). The application was filled prior to 22 December 2018 and the written examination was held on 06.01.2019. The petitioner obtained a Disability Certificate from the Office of Chief Medical Officer, Mathura on 08.07.2019 (showing 42% permanent physical impairment), i.e., after the written examination. Following a Government Order dated 13.05.2020, the recruitment process for 69,000 posts commenced and a notification dated 16.05.2020 permitted qualified candidates to submit an online application between 18.05.2020 and 26.05.2020. The petitioner seeks a writ of mandamus directing the Secretary, U.P. Basic Education Board to consider his selection in respect of the Physically Handicapped Quota of the OBC category and to allow him to correct his earlier omission (i.e., claim the special reservation).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner can be permitted at the recruitment stage to correct his earlier online application (filed prior to 22.12.2018 and for which he appeared in ATRE-2019 on 06.01.2019) to claim horizontal reservation under the Physically Handicapped Quota when he did not claim that reservation in column-10 at the time of initial application?
- Whether the recruitment process is a continuous process (so that omissions at the initial application stage cannot be corrected later) or whether separate stages (eligibility test and subsequent recruitment) permit correction of category/reservation claims at the recruitment stage?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner did not have an option to correct the Special Category/Handicapped designation in the later online application form (Annexure-9) and therefore was deprived of making a claim regarding Special Reservation/Handicapped Category.
- The columns (1–13) in the later online application (Annexure-9) were identical to the original application form used for ATRE-2019; because the petitioner had not claimed handicap reservation in column-10 earlier, and since there was no modification in the form, he could not now make that claim.
- There are two distinct stages — (a) the eligibility test (ATRE-2019) and (b) the recruitment process — and since these are different stages, he should be permitted to correct the form and claim Special Reservation at the recruitment stage.
- The petitioner relied on the Division Bench judgment in Raghvendra Pratap Singh v. State of U.P. (dated 06.05.2020) particularly paragraphs 65–69, to support the contention that relief ought to be granted at the recruitment stage.
Respondent's (State) Arguments
- The process is continuous: the identical online forms were used in continuation of the recruitment process and the Quality Point Marks were fixed on the basis of ATRE-2019 results; therefore the petitioner's contention of discrete stages is incorrect.
- On the facts of this case, the petitioner is not entitled to consideration of his late claim for special reservation because he did not claim it earlier.
- The petitioner's arguments for permitting correction of details and claims were rejected by this Court in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava v. State of U.P., and the same reasoning applies here.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava v. State of U.P. (Writ-A No. 4070 of 2020) | The judgment considered prayer for permitting rectification of incorrect entries in online application forms of ATRE-2019. Paragraphs 18 and 20 were quoted to show that courts will not intervene where candidates commit mistakes in filling application forms and that candidates must bear the consequences of failing to fill forms correctly. | This Court relied on Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava to reject the petitioner's request for correction and quoted paras 18 and 20 to support the view that errors of the petitioners cannot be remedied at this stage. |
| Raghvendra Pratap Singh v. State of U.P. (Special Appeal No. 156 of 2019) | The opinion notes this decision dealt with claims of Shiksha Mitras for weightage under the 1981 Rules; the present text does not set out a broader legal rule from that case. | The petitioner relied on Raghvendra Pratap Singh, but the Court distinguished it: the Division Bench's observations were held to be not helpful because that case turned on its own facts and concerned a different issue (Shiksha Mitras and 1981 Rules). |
| Km. Archana Rastogi v. State of U.P. | The present opinion states this case was considered in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava; the text does not state the specific principle drawn from it here. | The opinion records that this judgment was among those considered in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava, which led to dismissal of a similar petition; this Court therefore treats it as part of the precedential context relied upon in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava. |
| Km. Richa Pandey v. Examination Regulatory Authority (decided 18.02.2014) | The present opinion indicates this case was considered in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava; the text does not specify the precise rule applied. | It formed part of the set of authorities considered in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava, which resulted in dismissal of the petition seeking corrections. |
| Ram Manohar Yadav v. State of U.P. (decided 30.05.2013) | Referenced as one of several authorities considered in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava; the specific principle from this case is not detailed in the present opinion. | Listed among the cases considered in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava and relied upon in support of refusing correction requests. |
| Arti Verma v. State of U.P. | Referenced as one of several authorities considered; the present opinion does not specify the rule cited from it. | Included among the cases reviewed in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava which informed dismissal of similar petitions. |
| Kanchan Bala v. State of U.P. | Referenced as one of several authorities considered; no specific rule extracted in the present opinion. | Included among authorities considered in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava in rejecting correction claims. |
| Jai Karan Singh v. State of U.P. | Referenced as one of several authorities considered; the present opinion does not state the principle cited. | Part of the body of authorities considered in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava that support non-interference with candidates' application errors. |
| Karnataka Public Service Commission v. B.M. Vijaya Shankar, (1992) 2 SCC 206 : AIR 1992 SC 952 | Cited among authorities considered in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava; the current opinion does not elaborate the specific principle drawn from this decision. | Listed as one of the Supreme Court/Division Bench precedents taken into account in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava, which led to dismissal of the petition seeking corrections. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's reasoning follows a factual and precedent-based analysis:
- The Court examined the application form and records and found that the petitioner, while claiming OBC vertical reservation (column-9), had not filled column-10 for Special Reservation/Physically Handicapped at the time of applying for ATRE-2019. This omission is admitted by the petitioner.
- Chronology: the petitioner completed the online application prior to 22.12.2018, obtained an Admit Card for the written examination held on 06.01.2019, but the Disability Certificate was issued only on 08.07.2019 (after both the application and the examination). The Disability Certificate therefore post-dates both the filing of the application and the examination.
- The Court observed that the later online application form (issued after the 16.05.2020 notification) retained the same columns (1–13) as the original, and the heading of that form indicates it was to be filled by candidates who had cleared ATRE-2019, i.e., the later stage continued from the original application/eligibility stage. The Court therefore treated the recruitment as a continuous process beginning with the initial application for the ATRE-2019.
- On the merits, the Court held that because the petitioner did not claim Special Reservation at the initial stage and obtained the Disability Certificate only after the examination, the petitioner cannot be permitted to agitate incorporation of the special reservation claim at this stage.
- The Court considered relevant precedent. It relied on Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava, where similar prayers for correction of online applications were rejected. Paragraphs 18 and 20 of Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava (quoted in the present opinion) emphasize that courts generally do not interfere where candidates commit mistakes in applications, that such errors are not necessarily "human error" excusing the omission, and that candidates must bear the consequences of failing to fill application forms correctly.
- The Court examined the petitioner's reliance on Raghvendra Pratap Singh and concluded that those Division Bench observations concerned a different factual and legal matrix (claims by Shiksha Mitras for weightage under the 1981 Rules) and were therefore not helpful or applicable to the present case.
- On these combined considerations — the admitted omission in the original application, the timing of the Disability Certificate, the characterization of the recruitment as a continuous process, and earlier authority refusing similar corrective relief — the Court concluded that the petitioner's claim for incorporation of Special Reservation cannot be permitted.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition is dismissed.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the petitioner will not be permitted to correct his earlier application to claim horizontal reservation under the Physically Handicapped Quota and his selection will not be reconsidered on that basis.
- The Court relied on existing authority (notably Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava) to refuse the requested corrective relief; the opinion distinguishes the Raghvendra Pratap Singh decision as factually inapplicable. The judgment does not announce any new legal principle beyond applying existing precedents and the facts of the case.
This summary is strictly based on the content of the provided opinion and does not introduce information not present in that text.
Vivek Kumar Birla, J.:— Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned Standing Counsel for the State of U.P.
2. Present petition has been filed with the following prayer:—
“Issue writ, order or direction in the nature of Mandamus directing the Secretary, U.P. Basic Education Board, Prayagraj to consider the selection of the petitioner in reference to selection on 69000 posts of Assistant Teacher to be appointed in different Primary Schools of different districts of the State of Uttar Pradesh under Physically Handicapped Quota of OBC Category initiated vide Government Order dated 13.05.2020 issued by Special Secretary, Government of U.P., Lucknow within stipulated period of time as fixed by this Hon'ble Court.”
3. The petitioner has appeared in the examination conducted by the State Government being Assistant Teacher Recruitment Examination, 2019 (hereinafter referred to as ATRE-2019). The petitioner had filled up the application form, wherein admittedly he had not disclosed any kind of reservation insofar as his present claim regarding horizontal reservation in the Handicapped Quota is concerned.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner has admitted this fact that he has not filled up column-10 of the form for appearing in the ATRE-2019 which is regarding Viklangta/Vishesh Arakshan (Handicapped/Special Reservation). Admittedly, by not filing up this column, no reservation was claimed in this category by the petitioner. This fact is admitted to learned counsel for the petitioner. He was issued Admit Card for appearing in the ATRE-2019 (Annexure-2 to the Writ Petition). A perusal of the aforesaid Admit Card clearly discloses the date of Written Examination as 06.01.2019.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner has further admitted that the application form for appearing in the aforesaid examination was filled up by the petitioner prior to 22 December, 2018. It is also admitted that the petitioner has obtained Disability Certificate from the Office of Chief Medical Officer, Mathura on 08.07.2019, whereby he has been shown to be suffering from 42% permanent physical impairment due to accidental injury. Clearly, this Certificate was obtained after about 8 months from the date of filing of the application form for appearing in the ATRE-2019, wherein the petitioner has admittedly not claimed any reservation in Handicapped Quota/Special Reservation. This Disability Certificate has been issued after about 6 months from date of appearance in the Written Examination. Pursuant to the issuance of Government Order dated 13.05.2020, recruitment process was started and the Secretary U.P. Basic Education Board, Prayagraj also issued a Notification dated 16.05.2020 allowing the qualified candidates to submit their online application form from 18.05.2020 to 26.05.2020, which is Annexure-8 to the Writ Petition.
6. Submission of learned counsel for the petitioner is that no option is made available to the petitioner for correcting the Special Category/Reservation i.e. physically Handicapped Category in this online application form. It has been categorically stated by learned counsel for the petitioner that in this application form (Annexure-9 to the Writ Petition), columns 1-13 are identical as existed in the application form (which is not annexed with the petition) which was filled by the petitioner at the time of applying for online application for appearing in the ATRE-2019. He further submits that earlier he has admittedly not claimed any reservation in column-10 of the said application form that he is a physically handicapped person or is claiming any special reservation and since there was no modification in the application form, therefore, he has been deprived of making claim regarding Special Reservation/Handicapped Category. He submits that the claim of the petitioner is liable to be considered and he is liable to be permitted to make correction in the form and to make claim regarding his Special Reservation/Handicapped Category. He further submits that there are two stages of the entire exercise and both the stages are entirely different. One is the stage of the Eligibility Test for which he has filled up the online form for appearing before the Examination Authority and second stage is the recruitment process, therefore, he is liable to be permitted to make correction in the form for special reservation being extended to him. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on the judgment of Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court dated 06.05.2020 in Special Appeal No. 156 of 2019 (Raghvendra Pratap Singh v. State of U.P.) along with other connected Special Appeals. He has drawn attention to the paragraphs 65-69 of the Judgment. Submission, therefore, is that such benefit is to be extended in the light of the observation made by Hon'ble Division Bench at the stage of recruitment process.
7. Per contra, learned Standing Counsel submits that it is a continuous process and in continuation of process of recruitment, online applications were invited for appearing in the ATRE-2019. He submits that it is only for this purpose and reason, the identical forms were provided and the Quality Point Marks are fixed on the basis of that result of the ATRE-2019 only. Therefore, there can be no doubt that it is a continuous process. He further submits that on the facts of the present case also, the petitioner is not entitled for consideration of his claim. Learned Standing Counsel further submits that the arguments of the petitioner that the petitioner is entitled for correction of the details and claim cannot be considered as it was never claimed earlier and the identical arguments of learned counsel for the petitioner have already been rejected by this Court in Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava v. State of U.P..
8. I have considered the rival submissions of the parties and perused the record.
9. On perusal of record, I find that admittedly, the petitioner has filled up his application form for appearing in the Sahayak Adhyapak Bharti Pariksha-2019 i.e. Assistant Teacher Recruitment Examination-2019 (ATRE-2019). He has also appeared in the Written Examination held on 06.01.2019. It is admitted to the learned counsel for the petitioner and also as reflected from perusal of paragraph-2 of the writ petition, the petitioner, although, has claimed reservation in the category of OBC as disclosed in column-9 of the application form as reflected on Annexure-9 at page 83 of the Writ Petition, but column-10 regarding Special Reservation was not filled up. It is admitted to the petitioner that the columns no. 1-13 are identical in nature as given at page 83 (after issuance of the Notification dated 16.05.2020) and the details as given which were required to be filled up at the time of applying for ATRE-2019. In column-10 of the application form the petitioner had never claimed Special Reservation under the Handicapped Quota at the time of applying for ATRE-2019. Therefore, it is clear that petitioner has claimed vertical reservation in the OBC category, however, he has not claimed any horizontal reservation of the Physically Handicapped Quota in the selection process of 69,000 posts of Assistant Teacher. It is not in dispute that Quality Point Marks were fixed as per the ATRE-2019. Further, heading of the application form (Annexure-9) at page 83 clearly mentions that this is an application form to be filled up by the candidates who have cleared ATRE-2019. It also mentions the number of candidates i.e. 1,46,060 candidates. The heading is “Parishadiya Prathmik Vidyalyayee 69000 Sahayak Adhyapako Ki Bharti Hetu Aayojit Likhit Pariksha me Uttirna 146060 Abhyarthiyo ke Niyukti Hetu Aavedan Patra ka Print.” It, therefore, cannot be disputed that it is a continuous process which started with the filling up application form for appearing in the ATRE-2019 and petitioner had not claimed any horizontal reservation in Handicapped Quota at the time of filing of the application form. Insofar as the case of the petitioner is concerned, it is also pertinent to note that admittedly, he filled up the online application form prior to 22 December, 2018. He was issued Admit Card which discloses the date of Written Examination as 06.01.2019. However, his Disability Certificate was issued by the Office of Chief Medical Officer, Mathura, U.P. on 08.07.2019, which admittedly, was issued for the first time after about 6 months from the date of his appearance in the Written Examination. Therefore, on merits also, the claim of the petitioner for incorporation of his claim for Special Reservation under the Physically Handicapped Quota cannot be permitted to be agitated at this stage. In Writ-A No. 4070 of 2020 (Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava v. State of U.P.), the similar arguments regarding permitting corrections were considered and prayer for such correction has already been rejected by this Court.
10. In Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava (Supra) also prayer was for granting an opportunity to rectify the incorrect entries made by the petitioners in their online application form of ATRE-2019. It was further prayed that respondents be directed to consider the claim of the petitioner for selection on the basis of original education testimonials. After considering various Hon'ble Division Bench and Hon'ble Supreme Court Judgments rendered in the cases of Km. Archana Rastogi v. State of U.P., 2012 (3) ADJ 219, Km. Richa Pandey v. Examination Regulatory Authority decided on 18.02.2014, Ram Manohar Yadav v. State Of U.P.. decided on 30.05.2013, Arti Verma v. State of U.P., Kanchan Bala v. State of U.P., Jai Karan Singh v. State of U.P. and Karnataka Public Service Commission v. B.M. Vijaya Shankar reported in (1992) 2 SCC 206 : AIR 1992 SC 952, the petition was dismissed. I do not wish to burden my judgment by quoting or refering to them again. However, paragraphs 18 and 20 of Ashutosh Kumar Srivastava (Supra) are quoted as under:—
“18. In so far as the cases cited by the learned counsel for the petitioners are concerned, the same will not help the petitioners since in large number of cases observations were duly made by different Division Benches of this Court that in case any mistake was committed by the candidates during the course of examination, the writ court will not interfere in the matter.
20. The error committed by the candidates cannot be said to be human in nature. The petitioners should have read the instructions that were issued time and again and should have correctly filled the entries relating to the marks obtained by them in their previous examinations. The contention that this was an error committed by the Computer Operator cannot simply be accepted. If the Courts were to accept such a plea of the petitioners, then this would result in a situation where the petitioners would get the benefit of a wrong if the wrong claim went unnoticed and if noticed the petitioners could always turn around and claim that this was a result of a human error. Each candidate necessarily must bear the consequences of his failure to fill up the application form correctly. From perusal of the record, I am of the opinion that the error/errors committed by the petitioners are neither minor nor are human error/errors.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
11. Insofar as the observation of Hon'ble Division Bench in Raghuvendra Pratap Singh (Supra) is concerned, the same are of no help to the petitioner as admittedly, the question of claim of Shiksha Mitras to grant benefit of weightage in the 1981 Rules was under consideration and, thus, the said judgment turns on its own facts and is clearly not applicable in this case in the light of the facts of this case and the issue involved herein. Insofar as claiming the benefit of horizontal reservation under the Physically Handicapped Quota is concerned, this column always existed in recruitment process and once it has not been claimed at the initial stage, the petitioner cannot be permitted to claim reservation under the special category, provision for disclosure whereof was provided at the initial stage itself.
12. The petition is devoid of merits and is, accordingly, dismissed.
Alert