Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dr. Ashok Singhvi v. Union Of India, Through The Additional S.g. And Another

Rajasthan High Court
Jul 6, 2020
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These bail applications under Section 439 Cr.P.C. have been filed by the accused applicants in Sessions Case No. 1/2019 pending before the Special Court (Money Laundering Act, 2002), Jaipur Metropolitan, Jaipur. The case involves offences under Sections 3 and 4 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, concerning Rs. 2.55 Crores identified as tainted money linked to a scheduled offence of corruption in the mining department of the Rajasthan State Government.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the accused applicants are entitled to bail under Section 439 Cr.P.C. in the context of offences under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, given the nature and gravity of the alleged offences.
  2. Whether parity with co-accused persons granted bail by a coordinate bench can be a ground for granting bail to the present applicants.
  3. Whether the bar on granting bail under Section 45 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act applies to the accused applicants, considering the prima facie case against them.
  4. The relevance of the accused applicants’ conduct, role in the offence, and evidence available in deciding bail applications in economic offences.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

  • Co-accused persons similarly situated have been granted bail by a coordinate bench, and the present applicants’ cases are not distinguishable from theirs.
  • The applicants are not required for investigation as the Enforcement Directorate has already filed the complaint, and their statements were recorded with full cooperation.
  • The applicants were not arrested during investigation, nor were arrest warrants sought against them.
  • They have already been granted bail in the scheduled offences on which the PMLA case is based.
  • Applicants could not appear immediately after summons due to pursuing legal remedies.
  • They satisfy the conditions of the triple test for bail, similar to co-accused persons granted bail.
  • Reliance was placed on several judicial precedents supporting bail and parity.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Bail in economic offences must be considered on distinct criteria due to their impact on the economy and society.
  • Granting bail solely on the ground of parity with co-accused is impermissible; each accused’s role, conduct, and prima facie case must be considered.
  • The prima facie case against the applicants under the PML Act is strong and was upheld by this court and the Supreme Court.
  • Section 45 of the PML Act bars bail if a prima facie case is made out.
  • The applicants are kingpins: Ashok Singhvi was Principal Secretary of the Mines Department and misused his position for bribes; Rashid Sheikh arranged a significant portion of the tainted money.
  • Strong evidence including call recordings, bank details, and other documentary evidence connects the applicants to the crime.
  • The applicants evaded the trial process by surrendering late, unlike other co-accused who surrendered timely as per Supreme Court orders.
  • No illegality or infirmity was shown in the trial court’s order rejecting bail.
  • Reliance was placed on numerous Supreme Court and High Court decisions emphasizing strict scrutiny in bail matters for economic offences.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sita Ram v. State Of Rajasthan [1994 (1) RLW 227] Principles related to bail and parity among accused Applicants relied on this judgment to argue parity with co-accused granted bail.
Suraj v. State of Rajasthan [RLW 1986 Raj. 325] Bail considerations in similar cases Applicants cited for parity and bail principles.
Data Ram Singh v. State of U.P [(2018) 3 SCC 22] Legal standards for bail in economic offences Applicants cited to support bail application.
P. Chidambaram v. CBI [AIR 2019 SC 5273] Criteria for bail in economic offences and investigation Applicants relied on this for bail arguments.
P. Chidambaram v. Directorate Of Enforcement [(2019) 5 SCC 715 : AIR 2019 SC 1669] Scope of bail under PMLA and economic offences Applicants cited in support of bail.
Sanjay Chandra v. CBI [(2012) 1 SCC 40] Considerations in granting bail in economic offences Applicants cited for bail on parity.
Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) [(2020 SCC OnLine SC 98)] Bail principles in economic offence cases Applicants cited for bail arguments.
S. Kassi v. State [JT 2020 (6) SC 363] Binding nature of coordinate bench decisions on bail Court referred to this to explain the binding effect of coordinate bench orders and the need for larger bench if disagreement arises.
Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra [2011 Cr.L.R. (SC) 1] Bail jurisprudence and role of accused Applicants relied on this precedent.
Kanwar Singh Meena v. State of Rajasthan [(2012) 12 SCC 180] Strict scrutiny in bail for economic offences Respondent relied on this to oppose bail.
State Of U.P Through CBI v. Amarmani Tripathi [(2005) 8 SCC 21] Criteria for bail in economic offences Respondent cited to emphasize seriousness of economic offences.
Mahipal v. Rajesh Kumar @ Polia, Criminal Appeal No. 1843/2019 @ SLP (Cri.) No. 6339/2019 Role of accused and evidence in bail consideration Respondent cited to underline importance of individual role.
State of Orissa v. Mahimananda Mishra [(2018) 10 SCC 516] Bail in economic offences Respondent relied on this decision.
Shyam Sunder Singhvi v. Union of India, SB Cr. Revision Petition No. 273/2019 Consideration of bail in serious economic crimes Respondent cited to oppose bail.
Dr. Ashok Singhvi v. State of Rajasthan [SB Cr. Misc. (Pet.) No. 2805/2016] Previous bail applications and conduct of accused Respondent cited to highlight accused’s conduct and case facts.
Y.S Jagan Mohan Reddy v. Central Bureau Of Investigation [(2013) 7 SCC 439] Bail in corruption and economic offences Respondent relied on this precedent.
Serious Fraud Investigation Office v. Nittin Johari [(2019) 9 SCC 165] Strict approach to bail in economic offences Respondent cited to stress caution in bail grant.
State of Gujarat v. Mohanlal Jitamalji Porwal [(1987) 2 SCC 364] Principles relating to grant of bail Respondent cited to oppose bail.
Pankaj Jain v. Union of India [(2018) 5 SCC 743] Bail considerations in economic offences Respondent relied on this judgment.
Nikesh Tarachand Shah v. Union of India [(2018) 11 SCC 1] Stringent scrutiny in bail for economic offences Respondent cited to emphasize gravity of offence.
Other judgments including Sanjay Sethi v. Union of India, Nitin Johari v. Serious Fraud Investigation Office, Oro Trade Network (India) Limited v. Rajesh Kumar Sharma, Arpit Jain v. Union of India, and Sandeep Kumar Agrawal v. Union of India Various principles on bail in economic offences and conduct of accused Respondent cited these to support opposition to bail.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the bail applications by carefully considering the submissions of both parties and the judicial precedents cited. It acknowledged the principle that coordinate benches are generally bound by earlier coordinate bench decisions to maintain judicial discipline, as explained in S. Kasi v. State. However, the court emphasized that bail decisions must consider the individual role of each accused, the evidence against them, their conduct, and the nature of the offence.

In the instant case, the court found that the applicants hold a major and distinct role in the alleged conspiracy, with Ashok Singhvi identified as the principal kingpin holding a high official position, and Rashid Sheikh playing a key role in arranging a substantial portion of the tainted money. The court noted strong evidence such as telephone records and bank details connecting them to the offence.

Furthermore, the court highlighted the applicants’ conduct in evading trial by surrendering late, unlike other co-accused who respected the Supreme Court’s order and surrendered timely. The court rejected the argument that bail granted to co-accused persons on different footing could be a ground for bail for the applicants. It also upheld the applicability of Section 45 of the PML Act, which bars bail if a prima facie case is made out.

Thus, the court concluded that the applicants’ cases are not similar to those of co-accused persons granted bail and that granting bail to them would adversely affect society given the severe nature of the economic offence.

Holding and Implications

The court DISMISSED the bail applications of the accused applicants.

This decision directly affects the applicants by denying their release on bail, reinforcing the principle that bail in economic offences involving serious corruption and money laundering must be granted with strict scrutiny of the accused’s role, conduct, and evidence against them. The court did not set any new precedent but applied established legal principles to the facts of the case, underscoring that parity with co-accused is not an automatic ground for bail when the accused have distinct and major roles in the offence.

Show all summary ...

Satish Kumar Sharma, J.:— These bail applications under Section 439 Cr.P.C. have been filed by the accused applicants in Sessions Case No. 1/2019 pending in the court of Special Court (Money Laundering Act, 2002) Jaipur Metropolitan, Jaipur for offence under Section 3/4 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 involving an amount of Rs. 2.55 Crores as tainted money of scheduled offence of corruption in mining department of the State Government of Rajasthan.

2. Heard learned counsel for both the sides and perused the material available on record as well as written submissions filed on behalf of non applicants.

3. Mr. Anil Upman and Mr. Deepak Chauhan learned counsel for both the accused applicants have submitted that similarly situated co-accused persons have been enlarged on bail by the coordinate bench of this court vide order dated 12-5-2020 and the case of accused applicants is not distinguishable from them. Both the applicants are not required for the purpose of investigation/enquiry as the Enforcement Directorate has already filed the complaint in the matter. During the course of investigation, statements of both the applicants were recorded and they fully cooperated in the investigation. Neither they were arrested during the course of investigation, nor there was any prayer to summon them through arrest warrants. Both the applicants have already been granted bail in the scheduled offences, on the basis of which this case has been registered. Both the applicants could not appear before the trial court immediately after the summoning by the trial court, as they were pursuing legal remedies available to them. Both the applicants also satisfy the conditions of triple test on the basis of which other co-accused persons have been granted bail. The bail applications should be allowed. Learned counsel for the applicants have relied upon the judgments in Sita Ram v. State Of Rajasthan [1994 (1) RLW 227], Suraj v. State of Rajasthan [RLW 1986 Raj. 325], Data Ram Singh v. State of U.P. [(2018) 3 SCC 22], P. Chidambaram v. CBI [AIR 2019 SC 5273], P. Chidambaram v. Directorate Of Enforcement . [(2019) 5 SCC 715 : AIR 2019 SC 1669], Sanjay Chandra v. CBI [(2012) 1 SCC 40], Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) [(2020 SCC OnLine SC 98], S. Kassi v. State [JT 2020 (6) SC 363] and Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra [2011 Cr.L.R. (SC) 1].

4. Mr. R.D. Rastogi, learned ASG assisted with Mr. Anand Sharma has vehemently opposed the bail applications with the submissions that as per settled legal position expounded by Hon'ble Supreme Court in series of judgments, bail in economic offences must be considered on altogether distinct criteria as the same affect the economy as a whole and destroy the very basic fiber of the Society. The bail cannot be granted solely on the ground of parity i.e. co-accused persons have been granted bail, but while considering the bail application, the prima-facie case, role of each accused, conduct of the accused and other relevant factors should be taken into account. In this case most important factor of prima-facie case in the light of relevant provision of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (hereinafter ‘the PML Act’) has not been considered by Hon'ble coordinate Bench and therefore, the department is in the process of getting cancelled the bail granted to co-accused persons. Since scheduled offences and other offences of IPC are totally distinct from the offences punishable in PML Act, the applicants are not entitled for bail on the basis of bail granted to them for the scheduled offence related to this case. As per Section 45 of the PML Act, bail cannot be granted to the accused if prima-facie offence is made out against him. In this case, cognizance order and the order of rejecting the application for conversion of non bailable warrants into bailable were challenged by the accused applicants but the same were confirmed by this court as well as by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Hence, it cannot be disputed that prima-facie offence is made out against the applicants. Thus, the bar on granting bail to the applicants under Section 45 of the PML Act is squarely applicable in this case. It was further submitted that it is also settled legal position that the accused is not entitled for bail solely on the ground that he was not arrested during enquiry/investigation, and filing of complaint/charge sheet indicates that offence is made out against the accused. Both the accused applicants are kingpin of this case, accused applicant Ashok Singhvi was holding the post of Principle Secretary, Department of Mines, Government of Rajasthan. He misused the position to earn bribe in a planned conspiracy. A total amount of Rs. 2.55 crores were seized and recovered in the raid conducted by the Anti Corruption Bureau, out of which Rs. 1.58 crores were arranged by the applicant Mohd. Rashid Sheikh. Strong evidence in the form of call recordings, bank account details, other ocular, documentary and circumstantial evidence is available in view of which they cannot claim parity with those co-accused persons, who have been granted bail. Besides above position, the conduct of the present applicants differentiates them from other co-accused persons because they themselves surrendered before the trial court on 19-2-2020/17-3-2020, as per order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India whereas present accused applicants despite being fully aware of the situation did not surrender on 17-02-2020 in parity with other co-accused persons, rather they surrendered on 1-6-2020 and 19-6-2020, respectively. The accused applicants have not been able to point out any illegality or infirmity in the order of the trial court rejecting the bail applications. Thus in view of factual matrix of the case and applicable legal provisions, no case of bail is made out at all and the bail applications deserve to be dismissed. He placed reliance on the judgments in Kanwar Singh Meena v. State of Rajasthan [(2012) 12 SCC 180], State Of U.P Through Cbi v. Amarmani Tripathi . [(2005) 8 SCC 21], Mahipal v. Rajesh Kumar @ Polia, Criminal Appeal No. 1843/2019 @ SLP (Cri.) No. 6339/2019 decided on 5-12-2019, State of Orissa v. Mahimananda Mishra [(2018) 10 SCC 516], Shyam Sunder Singhvi v. Union of India, SB Cr. Revision Petition No. 273/2019 decided on 24-1-2020, Shyam Sunder Singhvi v. Union of India [Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No. 792/2020 decided on 10-2-2020], Dr. Ashok Singhvi v. State of Rajasthan [SB Cr. Misc. (Pet.) No. 2805/2016 decided on 23-3-2018], Dr. Ashok Singhvi v. State of Rajasthan [Special Leave to Appeal (Crl.) No. 7267/2018 decided on 24-9-2018], Dr. Shivender Mohan Singh v. State of NCT of Delhi [W.P. (Crl) Urgent 10/2020 decided on 6-4-2020], Suo motu v. State of Rajasthan [DB Civil Writ Petition No. 5618/2020 decided on 17-5-2020], Y.S Jagan Mohan Reddy v. Central Bureau Of Investigation . of Investigation [(2013) 7 SCC 439], Serious Fraud Investigation Office v. Nittin Johari [(2019) 9 SCC 165], State of Gujarat v. Mohanlal Jitamalji Porwal [(1987) 2 SCC 364], Pankaj Jain v. Union of India [(2018) 5 SCC 743], Dinesh Kumar v. State of M.P. [M.Cr.C. No. 9763/2020 decided on 19-3-2020], Nikesh Tarachand Shah v. Union of India [(2018) 11 SCC 1], Rakesh Manekchand Kothari v. Union of India [2015 SCC OnLine Guj 3507], VGN Developers P. Ltd. v. The Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, [Cri.O.P. No. 9796/2019 decided on 4-10-2019], Anand Chauhan v. Directorate of Enforcement [2017 SCC OnLine Del 7790], Virupakshappa Gouda v. State of Karnataka [(2017) 5 SCC 406], Sanjay Sethi v. Union of India [SLP (Criminal) No. 2224/2020 decided on 12-3-2020], Nitin Johari v. Serious Fraud Investigation Office [Bail Appln. No. 1971/2019 decided on 27-1-2020], Oro Trade Network (India) Limited v. Rajesh Kumar Sharma [SB Cr. Miscellaneous Bail Application No. 14613/2018 decided on 6-12-2018], Arpit Jain v. Union of India [SB Cr. Misc. Bail Application No. 16957/2017 decided on 18-12-2017], Smt. Himani Munjal [SB Cr. Miscellaneous Bail Application No. 10350/2018 decided on 10-9-2018] and Sandeep Kumar Agrawal v. Union of India [SB Cr. Miscellaneous Bail Application No. 7499/2018 decided on 5-7-2018].

5. The contentions put forth by both the sides have been carefully considered in the light of judicial pronouncements referred to above.

6. Learned counsel for both the accused applicants have urged for bail mainly on the basis of parity with those co-accused persons, who have been enlarged on bail by coordinate bench of this court.

7. In this regard, the legal position expounded in S. Kasi v. State (supra) and other judgments cited on behalf of the applicants cannot be disputed that in order to maintain judicial discipline, a coordinate bench is bound to follow the judicial decision of earlier coordinate bench. If the coordinate bench does not agree with the principle of law enunciated by another coordinate bench, the matter must be referred to a larger bench.

8. While having full respect to the coordinate bench of this Court and without making any comment on its order, suffice it to note the relevant legal position expounded in above referred judgments that while granting or refusing bail to an accused in a particular case, the role of every accused in the alleged crime along with other relevant factors are to be considered. A particular accused cannot claim to be released on bail only on the ground of grant of bail to other co-accused person. Accordingly even the same bench in a given case grants bail to an accused and refuses to another one having different footings.

9. In the instant case, other co-accused persons have been enlarged on bail by the coordinate bench of this court but the case of present applicants is not similar to those co-accused persons looking to their major role in the alleged crime, the evidence collected against them, their conduct of evading trial and other relevant factors.

10. Without expressing any opinion to the merits of the case, suffice it to say that the record of the case prima facie reveals that being Principle Secretary of Mining Department, accused Ashok Singhvi has been main kingpin of the conspiracy, in furtherance of which a huge amount of Rs. 2.55 crores was collected as bribe. Ample evidence including telephone recording, call details is available on the record which very well connects him with the crime. Likewise, accused Rashid Sheikh has also played a key role in the scheduled offence as he admittedly arranged Rs. 1.58 crores out of total tainted money of Rs. 2.55 crores.

11. Besides above distinct major role of the present applicants, other co-accused persons, who have been granted bail, had surrendered themselves before the trial court within the stipulated time as per the order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India and thus they shown respect to the legal system but the present applicants, who were well aware of the order of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India, willfully evaded the process without any cogent reasons and instead of 17-02-2020, they surrendered before the trial court only on 1-6-2020 and 19-6-2020.

12. In view of settled legal position and the fact of finality of cognizance order in this case, such contentions of applicants are not tenable that they are entitled for bail due to bail in scheduled offence or they were not arrested during the course of investigation.

13. It has not been held in the judgments, cited by counsel for the applicants, that a particular accused having different footings or distinguished case is entitled for bail only on the basis of bail granted to other co-accused, hence the same do not help the applicants.

14. In view of the above, the case of both the present accused applicants cannot be said to be similar to that of those co-accused persons who have been enlarged on bail by coordinate bench of this court, therefore, keeping in view the specific major role of the present accused applicants, strong evidence available against them, their conduct to evade the trial, probable impact on the Society on granting bail to present accused applicants having distinct status in this economic offence of severe nature of rampant corruption in Government departments and all other relevant factors as envisaged in PML Act, as well as in above referred judicial pronouncements, both the present applicants do not deserve to be enlarged on bail.

15. As a result, the applications of both the present accused applicants are hereby dismissed.