Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bihar Staff Selection Commission And Others v. Arun Kumar And Others

Supreme Court Of India
May 6, 2020
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Bihar Staff Selection Commission (BSSC) advertised 1,569 Class III vacancies on 18-6-2010. After the preliminary examination (12-4-2012) and a court-mandated re-declaration of those results, 27,289 candidates qualified for the main examination held on 27-10-2013. A BSSC expert committee later recommended changes to 13 questions, triggering five writ petitions in the Patna High Court.

A Single Judge (2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961) deleted four questions and ordered re-evaluation; BSSC complied and made appointments. On appeal, a Division Bench (2015 SCC OnLine Pat 4893) altered the key for four questions and directed that newly-qualifying candidates be accommodated without dislodging those already appointed. Multiple aggrieved candidates and BSSC challenged that decision before the Supreme Court, which on 25-9-2019 constituted a fresh three-member expert committee to assess disputed questions 61, 69, 82, 98, 107, 111, 119, 124, 125 and 135. The committee’s unanimous report (4-11-2019) supplied corrected answers or advised deletion where appropriate, leading to the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether courts may undertake or compel re-evaluation of answers in a recruitment examination when the governing rules contain no provision for such re-evaluation.
  2. Whether the Patna High Court erred in altering answer keys without independent expert input and in directing retention of already appointed candidates while accommodating newly qualified ones.
  3. What remedy best balances fairness to unsuccessful candidates, stability of public appointments, and the institutional limits of judicial review in academic matters.

Arguments of the Parties

BSSC (Appellant)

  • The High Court’s directions violate settled service-law principles by retaining existing appointees yet adding others, creating administrative chaos.
  • Implementing the impugned judgment would require creation of thousands of supernumerary posts across 21 services, spawning extensive litigation.
  • Relying on Ran Vijay Singh (2018) 2 SCC 357, courts should not interfere with exam results absent statutory provision for re-evaluation.

Aggrieved Candidates (Appellants)

  • The Division Bench confined relief to only four questions; more questions (e.g., 61, 62, 67, 82, 98, 107, 111, 124, 125, 148, 149) also contained errors and should be deleted or corrected.
  • A revised merit list based on all defective questions would place them within the zone of selection.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ran Vijay Singh v. State of U.P.
(2018) 2 SCC 357
Court should rarely order re-evaluation; benefit of doubt to examining authority; avoid disrupting completed selection processes. Relied upon to criticise High Court interference and to justify limited Supreme Court intervention.
Pramod Kumar Srivastava v. BPSC
(2004) 6 SCC 714
No candidate has a right to re-evaluation absent a rule permitting it. Cited to underscore narrow scope of judicial review in exam matters.
Khushboo Shrivastava v. CBSE
(2014) 14 SCC 523
Courts should not substitute their answers for examiners’ in academic assessments. Used to emphasise that High Court acted beyond its competence.
Maharashtra State Board v. Paritosh Bhupeshkumar Sheth
(1984) 4 SCC 27
Judicial deference to academic expertise; reluctance to interfere in educational matters. Formed part of the doctrinal foundation limiting judicial intervention.
Board of Secondary Education v. Pravas Ranjan Panda
(2004) 13 SCC 383
Directions for large-scale re-evaluation unsustainable without rule-based authority. Cited alongside Pramod Kumar Srivastava to show consistency of precedent.
Rajesh Kumar v. State of Bihar
(2013) 4 SCC 690
Equitable treatment where answer keys change post-selection. Referenced by High Court; Supreme Court noted but did not rely on it.
Vikas Pratap Singh v. State of Chhattisgarh
(2013) 14 SCC 494
Protection of candidates innocent of malpractice when keys are revised. High Court’s reliance acknowledged; ultimate decision overridden.
Pranav Verma v. High Court of Punjab & Haryana
(2020) 15 SCC 377
Supreme Court can accept expert committee report and direct revised results in exceptional situations. Cited to justify accepting the report of the Court-appointed committee here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. Scope of Review: The Court reiterated that, under Article 226, judicial scrutiny of examination results is “narrow,” citing a line of cases from 1984 to 2018 that discourage re-evaluation absent explicit statutory authority.

2. High Court Error: Both the Single Judge and Division Bench changed answer keys without independent expert verification, creating uncertainty and disrupting appointments. This contravened principles in Ran Vijay Singh and other precedents.

3. Expert Committee Approach: The Supreme Court had already, on 25-9-2019, appointed a neutral three-member committee. Its unanimous findings revealed inaccuracies in the High Court-imposed key, recommending deletion of two questions and revised answers for others. Accepting these findings aligns with the limited but exceptional power recognised in Pranav Verma.

4. Balancing Equity and Stability: While acknowledging candidate grievances, the Court prioritised stability of existing appointments. It invoked Article 142 to craft an equitable solution—re-evaluate using the committee’s key yet protect those already appointed, absorbing any additional successful candidates against future vacancies up to 31-12-2019.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The judgments of the Patna High Court—Single Judge (2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961) and Division Bench (2015 SCC OnLine Pat 4893)—are set aside. BSSC must recast and publish results based on the Supreme Court-appointed expert committee’s report, without disturbing existing appointees. Excess successful candidates are to be accommodated against vacancies arising until 31-12-2019.

Implications: The decision restores certainty to a decade-long recruitment process, reaffirms judicial restraint in academic matters, and provides a pragmatic mechanism—via Article 142—to reconcile accuracy of results with stability of public employment. It sets no new doctrinal precedent but reinforces existing jurisprudence limiting court-mandated re-evaluation.

Show all summary ...

S. Ravindra Bhat, J.— Special leave granted. The parties were heard, with consent of their counsel.

2. These appeals are directed against a common judgment in Kumod Kumar v. Bihar Staff Selection Commission 2015 SCC OnLine Pat 4893, (2015) 3 PLJR 693 of the Patna High Court, dated 24-6-2015.

3. One set of appeals [arising from SLPs (C) Nos. 23202-204 of 2015] has been preferred by the Bihar Staff Selection Commission (hereafter “BSSC”) and the other set (referred to as “the aggrieved party appellants”) by several aggrieved parties, who were appellants before the Division Bench of the High Court, in four intra-court appeals, which had questioned the judgment and order 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169 of a learned Single Judge. The Single Judge set aside the results of the main examination, with consequential directions to BSSC to prepare fresh results of the Graduate Level Combined Examination 2010, in accordance with the directions of the Court in relation to deletion/modification of questions and answer as stipulated in the judgment. The aggrieved party appellants were not party to the writ proceedings, but had been declared selected in terms of the results first published, and subsequently were shown as not qualified under the revised results pursuant to the directions of the Court issued by the learned Single Judge. Three appeals to the Division Bench were by candidates who were writ petitioners and had impugned the judgment of the Single Judge in not granting them full relief in respect of all questions that were challenged. These parties were not selected in the final results declared.

4. The brief facts of the case are that on 18-6-2010, BSSC issued an advertisement calling for applications for selection of candidates to 1569 vacancies in Class III posts, in various departments of the Government of Bihar. Examinations were conducted on 12-4-2012, results of the preliminary examination were declared; this became the subject-matter of challenge before the Patna High Court. The High Court, after calling for evaluation of the questions and the results published by experts, directed fresh declaration of results. Resultantly, the fresh declaration of results was made on 29-12-2012. 27,289 candidates qualified in the examination. Meanwhile the number of vacancies increased to 3285 (from the original number of 1569).

5. On 27-10-2013, the main written examination (for selection), as part of the second phase, was held; those who had been declared successful in the preliminary examination were allowed to compete. On 28-1-2013, the model answer to the main examinations were published; BSSC elicited comments and objections to the model answer.

6. BSSC constituted a Committee of Experts to examine the objections; their report suggested changes with respect to 13 questions. The acceptance of the report meant consequential revision of the result. This led to the filing of five writ petitions before the Patna High Court. The results declared by BSSC were impugned on diverse grounds, including that the original number of vacancies could not have been increased; that the increase in the number of candidates was arbitrary and that the final results were based on answer to various questions, which were wrong.

7. The Single Judge, after considering the contentions of the parties on merits, held 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169 that the increase in the number of vacancies to be considered for selection and appointment beyond the initially advertised number, was valid and in consonance with the law declared by this Court; it was further held that the increase in the number of candidates allowed to compete for the post (i.e. 27,289 instead of the original 16,425 declared successful in the preliminary test) was justified, despite that number exceeding the ratio (of consideration of five candidates for one post) because of the revision in the results. The change in the result as a consequence of the Expert Committee's Report adversely impacted 915 candidates who had been previously declared successful in the result of the preliminary test declared on 12-4-2012.

8. By an order of the Patna High Court in Manoj Kumar v. State of Bihar 2012 SCC OnLine Pat 1250, (2012) 1 PLJR 542, it was held that these candidates should not be disturbed by the change in result. BSSC, therefore, retained these 915 candidates on the list of successful candidates. Further, the change in answer caused the inclusion of several others who now obtained the same marks as these 915 candidates. This resultant increase in the number of successful candidates from 16,425 to 27,289 was held to be permissible by the Single Judge 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169. After examining the merits of the answer accepted by BSSC, the Single Judge 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169 was of the opinion that Questions 82, 147, 148 and 149 were incorrect; the writ petitions were allowed, with a direction to BSSC to re-evaluate the answer sheets of the candidates after deleting the said four questions.

9. Two appeals were preferred against that decision of the Single Judge. It was contended that BSSC had wrongly assessed Questions 61, 62, 67, 82, 98, 107, 111, 124, 125, 148 and 149. By the impugned judgment 2015 SCC OnLine Pat 4893, (2015) 3 PLJR 693, the Division Bench partly allowed the appeals. The operative directions in the impugned judgment are extracted below : (Kumod Kumar case 2015 SCC OnLine Pat 4893, (2015) 3 PLJR 693, SCC OnLine Pat paras 25-29)

“25. Thus, the only change we find is with regard to Question 69 where the correct answer is option (A). In respect of Question 98, the correct answer is option (D). The correct answer to Question 107 is not available and has to be deleted. In respect of Question 111, we hold that it should not be deleted and the correct answer is option (C).
26. Thus, we are inclined to interfere with the judgment 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169 of the learned Single Judge only to the extent of these four questions in the manner indicated hereinabove.
27. Thus, the inevitable result would be, in order to ensure fairness of procedure of selection, the results which were revised and published pursuant to orders of the learned Single Judge would call for a further revision in respect of the four questions as noted in the preceding paragraphs but it would not follow that as per the fresh revised results of persons who had already been selected and appointed and have been working but who do not make the mark this time would be disqualified and dismissed. We hold that this would be highly iniquitous inasmuch as they are not guilty of any fraud, malpractice but are mere victims of mistake committed not by them. We have already noted judgments of the Supreme Court in Rajesh Kumar (2013) 4 SCC 690 and Vikas Pratap Singh (2013) 14 SCC 494 in these regards but again that does not end the matter. By change of answer of these four questions, as noted above, there may be some persons, who are now found to have made to the final merit list but, were not selected earlier leaving them out would be injustice. There would not be many such persons.
28. Having considered the matter, we would accordingly order that such persons who now come into the merit list would have to be adjusted, if vacancies were there were (sic) or there are vacancies available in cadre, for which examination were held. Their inter se seniority in the cadre to which they are allotted would be determined by inter se merit position, irrespective of their date of appointment. We order accordingly.
29. With these observations and directions, these letters patent appeals are, accordingly, disposed of.”

10. The appellants in civil appeals arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 29764-65 of 2015 are aggrieved by the impugned judgment 2015 SCC OnLine Pat 4893, (2015) 3 PLJR 693; their complaint is that the Division Bench confined the relief in respect of only four wrong answer; according to them, there were other defective questions or wrong answer : they argue that Questions 61, 62, 67, 82, 98, 107, 111, 124, 125, 148 and 149 should be deleted altogether (as against the interference with respect to four Questions i.e. 69, 98, 107 and 111). The appellants in civil appeals arising out of SLP (C) No. 30109 of 2016, on the other hand, urge that answer to Questions 61, 82, 119, 124, 125 and 135 have to be corrected, and the revised merit list should be published on the basis of such corrected result. BSSC, in its appeal arising out of SLPs (C) Nos. 23202-04 of 2015, on the other hand, urges that after the judgment 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169 of the learned Single Judge, appointments were made since the grievance of the writ petitioners had been substantially mitigated. It was in the context of appeals preferred by private respondents (some of whom are before this Court) who found that their names were out of zone of consideration, that the Division Bench delivered the impugned judgment 2015 SCC OnLine Pat 4893, (2015) 3 PLJR 693.

11. It is submitted that the directions in the impugned judgment, which include those requiring the accommodation of candidates who were to come in the merit list as against the vacancies available in the cadre without disturbing appointments already made, is violative of well-established and settled principles of service law. It is highlighted that if the impugned directions are to be complied with, there would be several complications inasmuch as the recommendations for 3285 vacancies were against 21 different categories of posts many of which require additional qualifications. This, it is urged would also include creation of supernumerary post.

12. After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, this Court had issued notice on 30-10-2015 2015 SCC OnLine SC 1868. In the meanwhile, on 28-9-2015 2015 SCC OnLine SC 1867 BSSC was asked to work out the judgment in terms of the directions contained to show the likely results.

13. The Court had on 25-9-2019 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1802 passed the following order : (Bihar Staff Selection Commission case 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1802, SCC OnLine SC, paras 1 and 2)

“1. Having heard the learned Senior Counsel for the parties, we are of the view that the Bihar Public Service Commission should appoint an Expert Committee consisting of three members in order to determine what is the correct answer to the questions which are appended as part of this order. The Expert Committee to be appointed within a period of two weeks from today. The Expert Committee will then submit its report in a sealed cover to this Court within a period of four weeks from the date on which the Committee is formed.
2. The Expert Committee is left with the discretion to co-opt persons of their choice in assisting them. Representations of parties to be submitted within a period of two weeks from today so that the Committee may consider them as and when it is constituted. List after six weeks.”

14. The questions which were referred to the Committee of Experts, extracted in a tabular form as part of the order of 25-9-2019 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1802 is set out below:

Sl. No. QUESTIONS WITH FOUR OPTIONS 1. 61. The Primary Product of Photosynthesis is: (A) Citric Acid (B) Glucose (C) Starch (D) Maltose 2. 69. Which technique has been possible only after development of recombinant DNA Technology: (A) DNA Fingerprinting (B) Monoclonal antibody production (C) Fermentation (D) Vaccination 3. 82. The largest beach in India is in (A) Kerala (B) Goa (C) Tamil Nadu (D) West Bengal 4. 98. 2 × (3+4) is equal to: (A) (3 × 4) +2 (B) (2 × 4) + 3 (C) (3 × 2) + 4 (D) (2 × 3) + (2 × 4) Sl. No. QUESTIONS WITH FOUR OPTIONS 5. 107. Which term comes next in the series YEB, WFD, UHG, SKL? (A) QGL (B) TOL (C) QNL (D) QOL 6. 111. If dust is called air, air is called fire, fire is called water, water is called colour, colour is called rain and rain is called dust, then where do fish live? (A) Fire (B) Water (C) Colour (D) Dust 7. 119. Arrange in the logical sequence 1) Butterfly 2) Cocoon 3) Egg 4) Worm (A) 1,3,4,2 (B) 1,4,3,2 (C) 2,4,1,3 (D) 3,4,2,1 8. 124. Given the statements — “No fruit is tree. All flowers are trees”, which one of the following is correct? (A) No fruit is flower (B) Some trees are flowers (C) All flowers are fruits (D) None of these
9. 125. Given the statements : All windows are doors and no door is wall. (A) No window is wall (B) No wall is door (C) Some windows are walls (D) None of these. 10. 135. How many minimum steps are necessary to change the word ‘Sleep’ into ‘Dream’? You have to change one letter at a time and all changes should result in a meaningful word. (A) 5 (B) 4 (C) 6 (D) 7

15. The report of the Committee of four Experts — Dr S.K. Srivastava, Professor (Retired), PG Deptt. of Zoology, Patna University, Patna and former Vice-Chancellor, Patna University, Patna; Dr L.N. Ram, Professor (Retired) PG Deptt. of Geography, Patna University, Patna and former Vice-Chancellor, Patna University, Patna; Dr Binod Kumar Pandey, Professor and Head, PG Deptt. of Statistics, Patna University, Patna and Dr Balgangadhar Prasad, Professor (Retired), PG Deptt. of Mathematics, Patna University, Patna and Co-opted Member, was set out in the common report dated 4-11-2019. The summary of the extract (of the answers to the questions) is set out below:

“The answer to the question by the Expert Committee against the order dated 25-9-2019 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1802 passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in SLPs (C) Nos. 23202-204 of 2015 with SLPs (C) Nos. 29764-65 of 2015, SLP (C) No. 30109 of 2016 is below:
Sl. No. Q. No. Correct Answer 1. 61 B 2. 69 A 3. 82 C 4. 98 D 5. 107 No option is correct 6. 111 D 7. 119 D 8. 124 A 9. 125 Two options are correct 10. 135 C
The explanation is given on separate pages.”

16. The report also contains detailed reasoning in justification of the answer, determined to be correct according to the experts. The detailed reasoning too is in a common document, prepared unanimously by four experts.

17. It is argued on behalf of BSSC that the process of selection in the present case is very complex as altogether 3285 vacancies in 21 posts requiring different qualifications under various departments were notified, and recommendations had been sent by the Commission long ago in the year 2013, in compliance with the judgment passed in the writ petition. The recommendations were made on the basis of merit-cum-choice and suitability of a candidate for a particular post.

18. It is thus argued that any modification in the result, in compliance with the order passed in the impugned judgment or in terms of the report of the committee, would result in administrative chaos as well as in “a tsunami of litigation”. The exercise would drastically alter the final result, and not only a large number of candidates recommended, selected and appointed would be ousted but it would also result in alteration in service and inter se seniority position of a large number of candidates already appointed and working for the past six years. It is stated that even confining the result to the candidates who were in litigation before the High Court or this Court will not help, as candidates who had not claimed revision of result will, on the principles of parity, claim appointment and those already appointed will claim change in services as per their revised merit position and/or inter se seniority in the services.

19. It is submitted that initially this Court by order dated 28-9-2015 2015 SCC OnLine SC 1867 directed BSSC to work out the impugned judgment and show the likely result therein. Pursuant to that order, BSSC filed additional affidavits dated 24-9-2015 and 28-10-2015. After considering them, this Court by its order dated 30-10-2015 2015 SCC OnLine SC 1868 issued notice and stayed the impugned judgment. The effect of change of result could well be anticipated from the following data indicated in the two additional affidavits (with regard to only four questions):

(a) 249 candidates will have to be removed from service and similar number of candidates will be eligible for appointment.
(b) If 249 candidates are to be retained, as directed by the High Court, then to give appointment to 249 new candidates and to maintain reservation roster, 688 additional posts will be required.
(c) It is submitted that this will further result in change of posts/services of 1162 candidates already appointed and if they have to be retained at their old posts, then a total of 3362 posts will be required.

20. It is argued that now if the recommendation of the Committee of Experts is implemented, then around 3000 to 6000 additional posts, in addition to those already advertised, would be required to be created to absorb the effect of alteration of result. It is urged that to avoid litigation and administrative chaos, in the light of the judgment of this Court in Ran Vijay Singh v. State of U.P. (2018) 2 SCC 357, it may be directed that the result published, recommendation sent and appointments made on the basis of the judgment 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169 of the learned Single Judge should not be interfered with. In Ran Vijay Singh (2018) 2 SCC 357, this Court held that : (Ran Vijay Singh case (2018) 2 SCC 357)

“31. On our part we may add that sympathy or compassion does not play any role in the matter of directing or not directing re-evaluation of an answer sheet. If an error is committed by the examination authority, the complete body of candidates suffers. The entire examination process does not deserve to be derailed only because some candidates are disappointed or dissatisfied or perceive some injustice having been caused to them by an erroneous question or an erroneous answer. All candidates suffer equally, though some might suffer more but that cannot be helped since mathematical precision is not always possible. This Court has shown one way out of an impasse—exclude the suspect or offending question.”

21. The tabular comparative statement for the answer according to the experts appointed under directions of this Court, and the relative claim of the candidates, is extracted below:

Tabular comparative statement of the results of disputed questions

Sl. No. Questions which are in issue BSSC's opinion SJ DB SC experts Candidates claim 1. 61. The primary product of Photosynthesis is (A) Citric Acid (B) Glucose (C) Starch (D) Maltose (B) (B) (Pg. 255) (B) (Pg. 42) (B) (C) 2. 69. Which technique has been possible only after development of recombinant DNA technology: (A) DNA Fingerprinting (B) Monoclonal antibody production (C) Fermentation (D) Vaccination (D) (D) (Pg. 190) (A) (Pg. 43) (A) (A) 3. 82. The largest beach in India is in (A) Kerala (B) Goa (C) Tamil Nadu (D) West Bengal Delete Delete (Pg. 248) Delete (Pg. 44) (C) (C) 4. 98. 2 × (3+4) is equal to: (A) (3×4)+2 (B) (2×4)+3 (C) (3×2)+4 (D) (2×3)+(2×4) (A&D) (A&D) (Pg. 190 & 242) (D) (Pg. 45) (D) (A&D)
5. 107. Which term comes next in the series YEB, WFD, UHG, SKL? (A) QGL (B) TOL (C) QNL (D) QOL (D) (D) (Pg. 257) Delete (Pg. 46) Delete Delete 6. 111. If dust is called air, air is called fire, fire is called water, water is called colour, colour is called rain and rain is called dust, then where do fish live? (A) Fire (B) Water (C) Colour (D) Dust Delete Delete (Pg. 194, 243 & 256) (C) (Pg. 47) (D) (C) 7. 119. Arrange in logical sequence : 1) Butterfly 2) Cocoon 3) Egg 4) Worm (A) 1, 3, 4, 2 (B) 1, 4, 3, 2 (C) 2, 4, 1, 3 (D) 3, 4, 2, 1 (A&D) A&D (Pg. 242) Not pressed (D) (A&D) (Pg. 95 Gr.I) 8. 124. Given the statements — “No fruit is tree. All flowers are trees”, which one of the following is correct? (A) No fruit is flower (B) Some trees are flowers (C) All flowers are fruits (D) None of these. (A) (A) (Pg. 257) (A) (Pg. 47) (A) (A&B) (Pg. 95 Gr. J) 9. 125. Given the statements : All windows are doors and no door is wall. (A) No window is wall (B) No wall is door (C) Some windows are walls (D) None of these. (A) (A) (Pg. 257) (A) (Pg. 48) (A&B) Delete (A&B) (Pg. 96 Gr.K) 10. 135. How many minimum steps are necessary to change the word ‘Sleep’ into ‘Dream’? You have to change one letter at a time and all changes should result in a meaningful word. (A) 5 (B) 4 (C) 6 (D) 7 (A) Not pressed Not pressed (C) (B)

22. It is evident that the experts appointed by this Court have recommended that two questions (at Sl. Nos. 5 and 9) should be deleted for the purpose of evaluation, because of defective or ambiguous (i.e. more than one) answer. It is a matter of record that one set of petitioners approached the High Court, complaining of arbitrariness in the declaration of results, as a consequence of defective evaluation. Before they had approached the Court, BSSC had undertaken the exercise of submitting the results to expert evaluation, and then revised the key answer, deleting (from consideration) certain questions. The exercise was undertaken again by BSSC, which complied with the Single Judge's directions. As a result of that exercise, several candidates were appointed. The Division Bench, regrettably, in the context of appeals by candidates who had been originally selected, who questioned the decision of the Board to have the re-evaluation, questioned the revised merit list. Others who had approached the Division Bench were those who were excluded from selection, after the Single Judge's decision.

23. This Court reiterates that the scope of judicial review under Article 226 in matters concerning evaluation of candidates—particularly, for purpose of recruitment to public services is narrow. The previous decisions of the Court (1984) 4 SCC 27, (2004) 6 SCC 714, (2004) 13 SCC 383, (2010) 6 SCC 759, (2011) 4 SCC 602, (2014) 14 SCC 523, (2018) 2 SCC 357; have constantly underscored that in the absence of any provision for re-evaluation of answer sheets, judicial review should be rarely exercised — preferably under exceptional circumstances. A three-Judge Bench of this Court, in Pramod Kumar Srivastava (2004) 6 SCC 714 held as follows : (Pramod Kumar Srivastava case (2004) 6 SCC 714)

“7. … Under the relevant rules of the Commission, there is no provision wherein a candidate may be entitled to ask for re-evaluation of his answer book. There is a provision for scrutiny only wherein the answer books are seen for the purpose of checking whether all the answer given by a candidate have been examined and whether there has been any mistake in the totalling of marks of each question and noting them correctly on the first cover page of the answer book. There is no dispute that after scrutiny no mistake was found in the marks awarded to the appellant in the General Science paper. In the absence of any provision for re-evaluation of answer books in the relevant rules, no candidate in an examination has got any right whatsoever to claim or ask for re-evaluation of his marks.”

24. In Khushboo Shrivastava (2014) 14 SCC 523 too, a similar view was echoed :

“9. We find that a three-Judge Bench of this Court in Pramod Kumar Srivastava v. Bihar Public Service Commission (2004) 6 SCC 714 has clearly held relying on Maharashtra State Board of Secondary & Higher Secondary Education v. Paritosh Bhupeshkumar Sheth (1984) 4 SCC 27 that in the absence of any provision for the re-evaluation of answer books in the relevant rules, no candidate in an examination has any right to claim or ask for re-evaluation of his marks. The decision in Pramod Kumar Srivastava v. Bihar Public Service Commission (2004) 6 SCC 714 was followed by another three-Judge Bench of this Court in Board of Secondary Education v. Pravas Ranjan Panda (2004) 13 SCC 383 in which the direction WP (C) No. 7056 of 2003 of the High Court for re-evaluation of answer books of all the examinees securing 90% or above marks was held to be unsustainable in law because the regulations of the Board of Secondary Education, Orissa, which conducted the examination, did not make any provision for re-evaluation of answer books in the rules.
10. In the present case, the bye-laws of the All India Pre-Medical/Pre-Dental Entrance Examination, 2007 conducted by the CBSE did not provide for re-examination or re-evaluation of answer sheets. Hence, the appellants could not have allowed such re-examination or re-evaluation on the representation of Respondent 1 and accordingly rejected the representation of Respondent 1 for re-examination/re-evaluation of her answer sheets. Respondent 1, however, approached the High Court and the learned Single Judge of the High Court directed 2008 SCC OnLine Pat 1553 production of answer sheets on Respondent 1 depositing a sum of Rs 25,000 and when the answer sheets were produced, the learned Single Judge himself compared the answer of Respondent 1 with the model answer produced by the CBSE and awarded two marks for answer given by Respondent 1 in the Chemistry and Botany papers, but declined to grant any relief to Respondent 1. When Respondent 1 filed the LPA before the Division Bench of the High Court, the Division Bench 2009 SCC OnLine Pat 1054, (2009) 1 PLJR 867 also examined the two answers of Respondent 1 in Chemistry and Botany and agreed with the findings of the learned Single Judge that Respondent 1 deserved two additional marks for the two answers.
11. In our considered opinion, neither the learned Single Judge nor the Division Bench of the High Court could have substituted his/its own views for that of the examiners and awarded two additional marks to Respondent 1 for the two answers in exercise of powers of judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution as these are purely academic matters. This Court in Maharashtra State Board of Secondary & Higher Secondary Education v. Paritosh Bhupeshkumar Sheth (1984) 4 SCC 27 has observed :
‘29. … As has been repeatedly pointed out by this Court, the Court should be extremely reluctant to substitute its own views as to what is wise, prudent and proper in relation to academic matters in preference to those formulated by professional men possessing technical expertise and rich experience of actual day-to-day working of educational institutions and the departments controlling them. It will be wholly wrong for the Court to make a pedantic and purely idealistic approach to the problems of this nature, isolated from the actual realities and grassroot problems involved in the working of the system and unmindful of the consequences which would emanate if a purely idealistic view as opposed to a pragmatic one were to be propounded.’
12. We, therefore, allow the appeal, set aside the impugned judgment 2008 SCC OnLine Pat 1553 of the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench 2009 SCC OnLine Pat 1054, (2009) 1 PLJR 867 of the High Court and dismiss the writ petition. There shall be no order as to costs. We are informed that the first respondent was admitted to the MBBS course subsequently. If so, her admission in the MBBS course will not be affected.”

25. The decision in Ran Vijay Singh (2018) 2 SCC 357, after a review of all previous decisions, held as follows :

“30. The law on the subject is therefore, quite clear and we only propose to highlight a few significant conclusions. They are:
30.1. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination permits the re-evaluation of an answer sheet or scrutiny of an answer sheet as a matter of right, then the authority conducting the examination may permit it;
30.2. If a statute, Rule or Regulation governing an examination does not permit re-evaluation or scrutiny of an answer sheet (as distinct from prohibiting it) then the Court may permit re-evaluation or scrutiny only if it is demonstrated very clearly, without any “inferential process of reasoning or by a process of rationalisation” and only in rare or exceptional cases that a material error has been committed;
30.3. The Court should not at all re-evaluate or scrutinise the answer sheets of a candidate—it has no expertise in the matter and academic matters are best left to academics;
30.4. The Court should presume the correctness of the key answer and proceed on that assumption; and
30.5. In the event of a doubt, the benefit should go to the examination authority rather than to the candidate.
***
32. It is rather unfortunate that despite several decisions of this Court, some of which have been discussed above, there is interference by the courts in the result of examinations. This places the examination authorities in an unenviable position where they are under scrutiny and not the candidates. Additionally, a massive and sometimes prolonged examination exercise concludes with an air of uncertainty. While there is no doubt that candidates put in a tremendous effort in preparing for an examination, it must not be forgotten that even the examination authorities put in equally great efforts to successfully conduct an examination. The enormity of the task might reveal some lapse at a later stage, but the court must consider the internal checks and balances put in place by the examination authorities before interfering with the efforts put in by the candidates who have successfully participated in the examination and the examination authorities. The present appeals are a classic example of the consequence of such interference where there is no finality to the result of the examinations even after a lapse of eight years. Apart from the examination authorities even the candidates are left wondering about the certainty or otherwise of the result of the examination—whether they have passed or not; whether their result will be approved or disapproved by the court; whether they will get admission in a college or university or not; and whether they will get recruited or not. This unsatisfactory situation does not work to anybody's advantage and such a state of uncertainty results in confusion being worse confounded. The overall and larger impact of all this is that public interest suffers.”

26. Given the clear declaration of law in the judgments of this Court, we are of the opinion that the unilateral exercise of re-valuation undertaken by the High Court (both by the Single Judge 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169 and the Division Bench 2015 SCC OnLine Pat 4893, (2015) 3 PLJR 693) has not solved, but rather contributed to the chaos. No rule or regulation was shown by any party during the hearing, which justified the approach that was adopted. BSSC, in our opinion, acted correctly in the first instance, in referring the answer to a panel of experts. If there were justifiable doubts about the recommendations of that panel, the least that should have been done, was to require BSSC to refer the disputed or doubtful questions to another expert panel. That was not done; the “corrections” indicated by the Single Judge 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169 were accepted by BSSC; several candidates who made it to the select list freshly drawn up pursuant to his directions, were appointed. The Division Bench, thereafter undertook the entire exercise afresh, compounding the matter further by not referring the disputed questions to any panel of experts. We are left reiterating the lament, (made in Ran Vijay (2018) 2 SCC 357) that the High Court's interference has not resulted in finality “to the result of the examinations” despite a long lapse of time. There is an air of uncertainty about the entire selection — nay, the entire cadre, because the inter se seniority of selected (and appointed) candidates is in a state of flux.

27. As noticed earlier, the Committee of Experts appointed by this Court has made its recommendations. Since the exercise indicates that the previous re-evaluations (by the Single Judge and the Division Bench—both made in the absence of expert recommendations) are not correct or accurate, as an exceptional case, we propose to accept them. This approach of ours is in tune with a recent judgment of this Court in Pranav Verma v. High Court of Punjab & Haryana (2020) 15 SCC 377, 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1610, where the Court accepted the recommendations of a single member committee and directed revision of results in a public examination, relating to recruitment of candidates to judicial service.

28. As a result of the above discussion, BSSC is directed to evaluate and publish the results afresh, in the light of the recommendations and report of the experts (constituted by this Court) subject to care being taken by BSSC and the Government of Bihar, not to disturb appointments made previously pursuant to the directions of the Single Judge. In case the number of selected candidates (on the basis of the revised result) exceeds the vacancies available as on the last date indicated for consideration (in the recruitment or recruitments concerned), the State of Bihar would accommodate the excess numbers in the relevant cadres as against future vacancies arising till 31-12-2019. This Court is hereby making these directions to put a quietus on the dispute, in exercise of its extraordinary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India.

29. For the foregoing reasons, the impugned judgment 2015 SCC OnLine Pat 4893, (2015) 3 PLJR 693 of the Patna High Court, as well as the judgment 2013 SCC OnLine Pat 961, (2013) 4 PLJR 169 of the Single Judge are hereby set aside; the appeals are disposed of in the above terms without order on costs.