- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Jubeda Chitrakar @ Jaba @ Zubeda Chitrakar v. State Of West Bengal
Structured Summary of the Opinion delivered by Thottathil B. Radhakrishnan, C.J.
Factual and Procedural Background
Two appeals were filed by two of the five accused persons who were tried in Sessions Case No. 85(12)08, CIS No. 222 of 2009 arising from Kasba P.S. Case No. 271(08)08. The accused were charged under Sections 489B, 489C and 120B of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The trial court found that the charge under Section 120B was not established but held that, on circumstantial evidence, the accused shared a common intention and therefore Section 34 IPC applied. Consequently, the accused were convicted under Sections 489B and 489C read with Section 34 IPC.
Sentences imposed by the court below (as described in the opinion): for the offence under Section 489B — rigorous imprisonment for 8 years and a fine of Rs. 8,000 with default rigorous imprisonment for 3 months; for the offence under Section 489C — rigorous imprisonment for 6 years and a fine of Rs. 5,000 with default rigorous imprisonment for 2 months. The sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
The factual matrix leading to conviction: on secret source information received 30.08.2008, police (P.W.1 accompanied by P.W.2 and P.W.3) conducted a raid at Ruby Hospital bus-stand under Kasba P.S., intercepted and apprehended target persons with forged Indian currency notes (FICN). Seizures were witnessed by independent local witnesses (including P.W.4). Further raids on 03.09.2008 also resulted in seizures. Specific recoveries recorded in the opinion included: from Mokaram Mondal — 500 pieces of Rs.100 FICN, 7 pieces of Rs.1000 FICN and 9 pieces of Rs.500 FICN wrapped in newspaper and kept in a polly bag; from appellant Sunil Pramanick — 27 pieces of Rs.500 FICN; from appellant Jubeda Chitrakar (at her house) — 20 pieces of Rs.500 FICN and 5 pieces of Rs.1000 FICN. The seized articles were preserved, labelled and produced; an expert examination produced Exhibit B12.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the possession of forged or counterfeit currency notes (FICN) in the quantities recovered and concealed circumstances is sufficient to constitute the offence under Section 489B IPC (which criminalises "using as genuine" and "trafficking in" forged currency), or whether such possession only attracts Section 489C IPC (possession with intent to use as genuine).
- How the phrase "or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine" in Section 489B IPC should be interpreted—specifically, whether "traffics" must be read ejusdem generis with "sells to", "buys" and "receives from any other person", thereby requiring interaction with another person for Section 489B to apply.
- Whether the court below correctly appreciated the evidence (including secret-source based raid, seizure, documentary and expert evidence) and correctly concluded that mens rea was present such that convictions under Sections 489B and 489C read with Section 34 IPC were sustainable.
- Whether the sentence imposed by the court below for offences under Sections 489B and 489C was excessive or required interference.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The findings of the trial court on appreciation of evidence and resultant findings of guilt were impeached as unsustainable.
- Even if the legal evidence tended to inculpate the appellants, such evidence could only support conviction under Section 489C (possession with intent), and not under Section 489B (which, it was argued, requires selling, buying, receiving or trafficking involving another person).
- The conclusion of the court below convicting the accused on both counts (489B and 489C) was argued to be contrary to law and unsustainable on the reasons given by the trial court.
Prosecution's Arguments
- The prosecution supported the trial court's findings and verdict and contended that the necessary ingredients of Section 489B were established in addition to those of Section 489C, and therefore the appeals should be rejected.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Parakh Foods Limited vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and Anr., (2008) 4 SCC 584 | Relied upon by appellants to argue that the term "traffics" in Section 489B must be read ejusdem generis with "sells to", "buys" and "receives from any other person", implying the necessity of another person's involvement. | The court considered this authority but rejected the ejusdem generis reading in the present context. The opinion explains why "or otherwise traffics in" should not be confined to activities necessarily involving another person and held that "traffics" covers actions of dealing or trading in forged notes even otherwise than by selling/buying/receiving. |
| Rayab Jusab Sama vs. State of Gujarat, 1998 CriLJ 942 (Gujarat High Court) | Held that possession of a large number of fake currency notes can constitute active transportation of such notes and thus fall within Section 489B (trafficking). | The bench in the present opinion followed this decision as applicable on the facts, agreeing that concealed possession of a sizeable quantity may amount to active transportation and thus to trafficking under Section 489B. |
| Shabbir Sheikh vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh, Crl. Appl. Nos. 162, 452 and 453/2015 (Jabalpur Bench) decided 10.02.2018 | Held that carrying a sizeable quantity of fake currency notes in a concealed manner on public road/otherwise amounts to active transportation and not mere dormant possession; absence of explanation under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and application of Section 106 Evidence Act where facts are within accused's knowledge. | The court expressly agreed with and followed this precedent: applied the reasoning that concealed, sizeable possession amounts to trafficking; noted that appellants gave no explanation under Section 313 Cr.P.C. and therefore did not discharge their burden under Section 106 of the Evidence Act. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's analysis proceeded in a stepwise manner, applying evidentiary and interpretive principles to the facts before it:
- Appreciation of evidence: The court found that the raid, interception and seizure were based on secret source information and that testimony of police witnesses (P.W.1, P.W.2, P.W.3) and local witnesses (including P.W.4) proved the raid, search and seizure. The seized articles were produced, preserved, labelled, sealed and subjected to expert examination, resulting in Exhibit B12, which the court accepted as having evidentiary value. The court found no material contradiction in oral evidence and no interest or hostility on part of police witnesses to displace credibility.
- Mens rea and Section 313 Cr.P.C.: The court noted that none of the accused made specific statements under Section 313 Cr.P.C. nor adduced defence evidence. The court treated the absence of explanation as significant to mens rea: the components of mens rea for offences under Sections 489B/489C are knowledge or having reason to believe that the notes are forged/counterfeit and an intention to use them as genuine (or to allow them to be so used). The court held mens rea was clearly established on these facts.
- Interpretation of Section 489B—meaning of "traffics": The court examined the statutory text and context. It observed that Section 489B lists activities ("sells to", "buys", "receives from") that require at least two persons, but also includes the phrase "or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine." The court considered the argument (based on Parakh Foods) that "traffics" must be read ejusdem generis with the specified activities and thus require another person's involvement. After analyzing the use and ordinary meaning of the word "otherwise" (including reference to a dictionary meaning cited in the opinion) and the common understanding of "traffics/trafficking" as dealing or trading in illicit items, the court rejected an ejusdem generis restriction. It held that "or otherwise traffics in" was meant to sweep within Section 489B activities of dealing or trading in forged notes even when not effected strictly by selling/buying/receiving—for example, active transportation or concealed, sizable possession amounting to dealing/trafficking.
- Reliance on precedents concerning active transportation: The court followed the precedents of Rayab Jusab Sama (Gujarat High Court) and Shabbir Sheikh (Madhya Pradesh High Court, Jabalpur Bench) which treated concealed possession of sizeable quantities of fake notes as active transportation (trafficking) and not mere dormant possession. The court applied these authorities to the facts of the present appeals.
- Application of evidential burden (Section 106 Evidence Act): The court applied Section 106 of the Evidence Act (placing burden on a person to prove facts especially within his knowledge) to the appellants' failure to explain their possession. Since the appellants did not provide an explanation under Section 313 Cr.P.C. or present defence evidence, they did not discharge the burden to show the nature of their possession was innocent; this supported the conclusion that their possession was active trafficking.
- Conclusion on offences: On the cumulative application of the above, the court concluded that the recovered quantities and the manner of concealment amounted to active transportation/trafficking, and the elements of both Sections 489B and 489C (including mens rea) stood established. The court therefore affirmed the trial court's conviction under Sections 489B and 489C read with Section 34 IPC.
- Sentence analysis: The court reflected on the social gravity of offences relating to currency (Chapter XVIII of IPC) and the need to balance deterrence, societal interests and proportionate punishment. Having regard to the quantity of FICN recovered and the concealed, trafficked nature, the court found no legal infirmity in the sentences imposed by the trial court and declined to interfere.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeals are dismissed; the convictions and sentences imposed by the court below under Sections 489B and 489C read with Section 34 IPC are affirmed.
Immediate consequences for the parties:
- The appellants' convictions under Sections 489B and 489C of the IPC (read with Section 34) are confirmed.
- The sentences imposed by the trial court are affirmed: rigorous imprisonment for 8 years and fine of Rs. 8,000 (default 3 months) for Section 489B; rigorous imprisonment for 6 years and fine of Rs. 5,000 (default 2 months) for Section 489C; sentences to run concurrently.
Broader legal consequence explicitly articulated in the opinion:
The court adopted an interpretation of Section 489B that the phrase "or otherwise traffics in" is not confined to acts necessarily involving another person (such as selling, buying or receiving) and can encompass active transportation or concealed possession of a sizeable quantity of forged currency notes. The court followed prior High Court authorities to treat such concealed, sizable possession as active trafficking under Section 489B, and applied Section 106 of the Evidence Act to the accused's failure to explain their possession.
The opinion does not state that a new legal precedent was created beyond the interpretive conclusions reached and the affirmance of existing High Court authorities; the direct effect is confirmation of conviction and sentence in these appeals.
Certified copy supply direction: The opinion directs that an urgent photostat certified copy of the judgment/order, if applied for, be supplied to the parties on compliance with requisite formalities.
Thottathil B. Radhakrishnan, C.J. - These two appeals are by two out of the five accused persons who stood trial in Sessions Case No. 85(12)08, CIS No. 222 of 2009 in Kasba P.S. Case No. 271(08)08. They stand convicted and sentenced for committing offences found to be punishable under Sections 489B and 489C of the Indian Penal Code; for short, IPC; read with Section 34 of the IPC.
2. Charges were framed alleging commission of offences punishable under Sections 489B/489C and 120B of the IPC against all the accused persons. The court below found that the charge under Section 120B has not been established and in lieu of that, there are sufficient evidence, circumstantially, that the accused persons had the common intention and acted accordingly; and hence, Section 34 IPC is applicable. On such basis, they were found guilty of having committed offences punishable under Sections 489B/489C read with Section 34 of the IPC and were convicted. They were sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 8 years and to pay a fine of Rs. 8,000/- with default sentence of rigorous imprisonment for 3 months, for the offence found to be punishable under Section 489B of the IPC. They were sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for 6 years for offence found to be punishable under Section 489C of the IPC and to pay fine of Rs. 5,000/- with default sentence of rigorous imprisonment for 2 months. The sentences were ordered to run concurrently.
3. Heard the Learned Advocate appearing for the appellant in CRA 562 of 2018 and the Learned Advocate appearing for the appellant in CRA 592 of 2018. We have also heard the Learned Public Prosecutor and the Learned Additional Public Prosecutor.
4. The learned advocates appearing for the appellants impeached the findings of the court below on appreciation of evidence and resultant findings as to guilt. They further argued that, even assuming that the legal evidence on record inculpate the appellants, that could be only to the extent of the charge against them under Section 489C and not under Section 489B of the IPC. The conclusion of the court below leading to the conviction of the accused persons on both the counts are contrary to law and the reasons stated by the court below to hand down such order of conviction is unsustainable, it was argued.
5. The learned prosecutors supported the findings and verdict handed down by the court below and argued that necessary ingredients of section 489B have been established over and above the ingredients of section 489C and hence, the appeals be rejected.
6. On the basis of secret source information received on 30.08.2008, P.W. 1, the Sub-inspector made requisite diary entry to the effect that one Mokaram of Bongaon area, accompanied by two or three others, would come to Ruby Hospital at bus-stand in front of ECTP under Kasba P.S. for delivering Forged Indian Currency Notes (''''FICN'''' in short) to his agents. P.W. 1, accompanied by P.W. 2 and P.W. 3, raided and apprehended the target persons with FICN. The seizures were witnessed by two independent persons in the locality, including P.W. 4. On the basis of the testimony of the witnesses, the raid, search and seizure were proved to the satisfaction of the court below. It was also supported by the evidence of the local witnesses regarding seizure. The articles which were seized and produced were proved. The court below rightly acted upon such evidence. P.W. 1 gave details about getting the source of information, the raid, recovery of FICN and attendant factors. He stated that he received information from a secret source. Corroborating materials, in the form of testimony of the policemen, are trustworthy. Having gone through the oral evidence, we do not see any material contradiction among any of the witnesses in relation to the information, raid and recovery of FICN. That search and seizure was followed by another raid on 03.09.2008. FICN were seized. The numbers and other details of the FICN are delineated in the judgment of the court below.
7. The material evidence on record in the form of depositions regarding the raid, search and seizure and the documentary evidence as well as the recovered articles are proved through cogent evidence. They correlate and connect the material particulars regarding the commission of the crimes charged. The seizures were followed by appropriate preservation, labelling, sealing and other due processes which enabled the recovered articles being preserved tamper-proof and made available for examination by expert. Such examination led to Exhibit B12 report of the expert, which has been admitted in evidence and its contents believed and acted upon, on due examination by the court below. There is no reason to denounce the evidentiary value of the expert''''s report. In so far as the material witnesses are concerned, there is adequate corroboration and there is no contradiction worthy enough to dislodge the credibility of the testimony of the witnesses. Not only that, the police officials who were involved in the process are not shown to have had any particular interest, hostile to the accused persons. It is only the call of duty that prompted the police officials to raid, search and seize the materials which were brought on record after ensuring their due scientific examination by the expert. The testimony of the witnesses correlate and connect the material particulars regarding the raid, search and seizure as well as the arrest of the accused persons and recovery and preservation of the recovered articles in terms of law. We do not find any legal infirmity or error in the appreciation of the evidence by the court below in that regard.
8. The court below held that this is not a case where the accused persons could plead that they did not have the mens rea to commit the offences. The non-examination of any defence witness and the fact that no specific statement was made by any of the accused persons, when questioned under Section 313 of Cr.P.C., were factors which weighed with the court below to hold that the accused persons, including the appellants, possessed the FICN being aware of the fact that they were not genuine. Thus mens rea was clearly established. This is not one of those cases where the court would assume the absence of mens rea on the premise that the possession of FICN by the accused persons was innocent, accidental or in any other such manner which would lead the court to hold that the actus reus of possession of FICN was not coupled with mens rea. The component of mens rea for offence falling under Section 489B and/or 489C is the knowledge or having reason to believe that the currency note or bank note is forged or counterfeit, coupled with the intention to use the same as genuine or the knowledge that it may be used as genuine.
9. The question that would, however, arise for decision is as to whether possession of any forged or counterfeit currency note is sufficient to inculpate the accused for offence punishable under Section 489B. The argument advanced on behalf of the appellants is that possession by itself does not amount to the activities which fall under Section 489B of the IPC.
10. Sections 489B and 489C are among those provisions which were added to the Penal Code by Act 12 of 1899, in a bunch, under a new sub heading "Of Currency-Notes and Bank-Notes" in Chapter XVIII. Section 489B was further amended through act 26 of 1965 with effect from 01.01.1956 whereby punishment of transportation for life which was earlier prescribed was substituted with the punishment of imprisonment for life.
Sections 489B and 489C as they stand after the aforesaid, read as follows:-
Section 489B:
Using as genuine, forged or counterfeit currency-notes or banknotes- Whoever sells to, or buys or receives from, any other person, or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine, any forged or counterfeit currency-note or bank-note, knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit, shall be punished with imprisonment for life, or with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to ten years, and shall also be liable to fine.
Section 489C:
Possession of forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notesWhoever has in his possession any forged or counterfeit currencynote or bank-note, knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit and intending to use the same as genuine or that it may be used as genuine, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to seven years, or with fine, or with both.
Those provisions were brought in simultaneously and punishments, which can be differentiated in terms of types and terms have been prescribed under those two sections. That being so, clear distinction has to be maintained regarding the ingredients of the offence which is to be treated as a larger count and it has to be decided whether an accused has committed such offence, to inculpate that person with such higher offence.
11. Section 489B uses the phrase "or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine". This phrase assumes importance in the context of the fact that the term "traffics" is not defined for the purpose of Section 489B or for the IPC generally. The phrase "or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine" is added on to a string of phrases which results in the sentence that delineates the ingredients of the offence as defined in Section 489B; the punishment for which is prescribed in that section. The activities which would amount to an offence punishable under Section 489B of the IPC are firstly, selling, buying or receiving. The provision to this effect in the section is "whoever sells to, or buys or receives from, any other person". Therefore, the involvement of at least two persons is necessary for performing the activity of selling, buying or receiving which would amount to an offence for the purpose of Section 489B. If that be so, an important issue for consideration would be as to whether any activity which falls into the concept "or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine" could be anything that could be treated differently from selling, buying or receiving or whether the term "traffics" has to be read ejusdem generis with "sells", "buys" or "receives". It was argued on behalf of the appellant on the basis of the decision of the Apex Court in Parakh Foods Limited vs. State of Andhra Pradesh and Anr., (2008) 4 SCC 584 that the term "traffics" has to be read ejusdem generis with the phrases "sells to", "buys" and "receives from any other person" and that the junction of another person is necessary to accomplish such acts. It is here that use of the word "otherwise" gains critical importance. The word "otherwise" is used to indicate the opposite of, or contrast to, something already stated when used as part of a phrase as "or otherwise" (see Oxford Dictionary of English-3rd Edition). Even when the word "otherwise" is used not as part of a phrase as "or otherwise", but as an adverb or an adjective, such usages are also resorted to, to draw a contrast or distinction. The word "traffics" as well as the word "trafficking" and "trafficked" are used to describe the action of dealing or trading in something illegal. The activity or activities which would amount to "sells to", "buys" or "receives from" any other person, may require the participation of two persons to complete any such transaction. However, any activity which would fall within the phrase "otherwise traffics in" does not indispensably require active participation of more than one person if noticeably sizable quantity of FICN is found to be in the possession of that person and such concealed possession cannot be treated as dormant possession. It is active transportation which amounts to trafficking. Any other mode of interpreting the phrase "or otherwise traffics" would dilute the rigour of law. A strict and literal interpretation of the penal provision contained in Section 489B of the IPC does not lead us to any other conclusion. Thus, the phrase "or otherwise traffics" in Section 489B of the IPC would take within its sweep, the action of dealing or trading in forged counterfeit currency note or bank note even otherwise than by selling, buying (purchase) or receiving. Therefore, the word "traffics" and the phrase "or otherwise traffics in" in Section 489B of the IPC are not to be read ejusdem generis with the words "sells", "buys" or "receives"; but ought to be read to understand that activities other than selling, buying or receiving would also fall into the basket of the incriminating factors which constitute the ingredients of the acts and omissions which is an offence as per that Section.
12. The Division Bench of the Gujarat High Court in Rayab Jusab Sama vs. State of Gujarat, 1998 CriLJ 942 , held the possession of large number of fake currency notes to be a case of active transportation of such notes. That precedent was followed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh(Jabalpur Bench) in Shabbir Sheikh vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh Crl. Appl. Nos. 162, 452 and 453/2015 decided on 10.02.2018, holding that such cases cannot be treated as those of mere dormant possession but are of active transportation of fake currency notes which would fall within the sweep of Section 489B of the IPC. In holding so, it was stated that when the accused person is found carrying sizeable quantity of fake currency notes on a public road, or otherwise, in a concealed manner, it would amount to active transportation of such currency notes at the time when the accused person is apprehended. No explanation being offered by the accused person when questioned under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. regarding the possession of the counterfeit currency, the burden of proof of facts within the knowledge of such person was held as not discharged by that person in terms of Section 106 of the Evidence Act. We completely agree with those judicial precedents and follow them, they being applicable on the facts of these appeals, as we would elaborate hereunder.
13. Adverting to the material evidence on record and the findings of the court below, it can be seen that the raid, interception and recovery were on the basis of secret information, the reception of which, and the modality of the raid and recovery have been noticed by us. 500 pieces of 100 rupees denomination FICN, 7 pieces of 1000 rupees denomination FICN and 9 pieces of 500 rupees denomination FICN wrapped in a newspaper and kept in a polly bag were recovered from Mokaram Mondal (one of the accused). Sunil Pramanick (one of the appellants) was also searched and 27 pieces of 500 rupees denomination FICN were recovered. Jubeda Chitrakar (one of the appellants) whose house was also raided led to recovery of 20 pieces of 500 rupees denomination FICN and 5 pieces of 1000 rupees denomination FICN. Thereupon, Jubeda was arrested. Again search and seizure was conducted leading to recovery of FICN from different other accused persons who are not amongst the appellants. They were also convicted. The appellants did not offer any explanation when questioned under Section 313 Cr.P.C. regarding the possession of FICN. Nor was any evidence adduced in defense to explain the possession of FICN. Section 106 of the Evidence Act enjoins that when any fact is especially within the knowledge of any person, the burden of proving the fact is upon him. In terms of Section 106 of the Evidence Act the burden of proof of facts within the knowledge of the appellants regarding the nature of possession of FICN was not discharged. Hence, the possession of such large quantity of FICN in concealed manner is not dormant possession but active transportation amounting to trafficking. It amounts to commission of offences punishable under Section 489B of the IPC. The possession of FICN of such quantity is trafficking, and, therefore, falling under the incriminating activity which made the accused/appellants offenders punishable under Section 489B as well, apart from the liability for committing offences punishable under Section 489C. For the aforesaid reasons the conviction of the appellants under Sections 489B as well as 489C stands. We approve the findings of the court below on the issue that the accused persons are liable to be convicted under Sections 489B and 489C of the IPC. Accordingly, we affirm the finding of guilt and the conviction of the appellants by the court below.
14. Now, we come to the question of sentence. The court below has imposed rigorous imprisonment of eight years and fine of Rs. 8,000/- in default rigorous imprisonment for three months under Section 489B of the IPC and rigorous imprisonment of six years with a fine of Rs. 5,000/- in default rigorous imprisonment for two months under Section 489C of the IPC. All the sentences are ordered to run concurrently.
15. The offences which are described and punishment prescribed in the sections which are grouped under the Heading "Of CurrencyNotes and Bank Notes" in Chapter XVIII of IPC are those, the commission of which would impact the authority of the State or Sovereign Power as well as the economic well being of the society. It is the solemn duty of the court to strike a proper balance while awarding sentence because awarding lesser sentence encourages any criminal and, as a result of the same, the society suffers. Imposition of sentence must be commensurate with the gravity of the offence. The court must keep in view rights and needs of the society at large while considering the imposition of appropriate punishment. One should keep in mind the social interest and conscience of the society while considering the determinative factors to decide on the sentence qua the gravity of the crime found to have been committed. Bearing these principles in mind, and having regard to the quantity of FICN which has been recovered upon it being found to have been concealed and trafficked, we do not find any legal infirmity in the sentence imposed by the court below. We also do not see that the sentence by court below to the accused persons is one which can be termed as wrong or excessive, warranting interference to modify and taper it down. Taking into consideration the totality of the facts and circumstances, we are satisfied that different sentences of imprisonment and fine as well as default sentences imposed on the appellants do not call for interference.
16. In the result, the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellants under the different counts are confirmed and the appeals are dismissed.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment/order, if applied for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all requisite formalities.
Alert