Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bajrangi Tiwari v. Commissioner Devi Patan Mandal Gonda And Another

Allahabad High Court
Mar 5, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Ritu Raj Awasthi, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged two impugned orders dated 27.7.2011 and 30.7.2013 which cancelled the petitioner's fair price shop licence and rejected his appeal respectively.

The licence had previously been suspended on 18.11.2010; the petitioner successfully appealed under Clause 28(3) of the U.P. Essential Commodities Distribution Order, 2004 and the licence was restored on 21.12.2010. A fresh complaint dated 3.5.2011 alleged non-distribution of essential commodities by the petitioner for the period December 2009 to March 2011. The complainant had earlier lodged a criminal FIR (registered as Crime No. 267 of 2011) alleging multiple offences (Sections 147, 148, 149, 504, 352, 324, 307 IPC and Section 3(2)(v) SC/ST Act).

The petitioner's licence was suspended on 14.6.2011 and cancelled by order dated 29.7.2011. An appeal to the Divisional Commissioner was dismissed by order dated 30.7.2011. This writ petition followed challenging the cancellation and the appellate rejection.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the fair price shop licence can be cancelled merely on lodging of a criminal case against the licencee?
  2. Whether, while passing any such order, the Government Order dated 17.8.2002, particularly paragraph 10, would be applicable/considered or not?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The cancellation was effected without any enquiry or opportunity and merely because a criminal case was lodged against the petitioner; such cancellation is unsustainable.
  • The petitioner had earlier been suspended and then restored after an appeal; the new complaint was made by persons with whom the petitioner had enmity and who had lodged a false FIR (Crime No. 267 of 2011).
  • The Government Order dated 17.8.2002 relates only to allotment/conditions for grant of fair price shop licences and does not govern suspension or cancellation.
  • Suspension and cancellation are governed by the Government Order dated 29.7.2004 and the U.P. Essential Commodities Distribution Order, 2004; neither permit cancellation merely on lodging of a criminal case.
  • The petitioner relied on several earlier judgments (e.g., Jagdish Narian Mishra; Raj Kumari Singh; Harpal; Gopi; Lalta Prasad) to support the proposition that mere lodging of an FIR cannot justify cancellation and to contend that Ranjit Singh was wrongly decided or per incuriam.
  • The appellate authority failed to consider the aforesaid judgments and legal position when deciding the appeal.

Respondent's (State) Arguments — as advanced by Standing Counsel

  • The petitioner did not possess the requisite "good reputation" as a criminal case (Crime No. 267 of 2011 under multiple IPC sections and the SC/ST Act) was registered against him.
  • Paragraph 10 of Government Order dated 17.8.2002 prescribes essential requirements for grant of a fair price shop licence, including that a person should have good reputation, not have been involved in criminal cases, and not have been convicted.
  • The Division Bench decision in Ranjit Singh supported cancellation/suspension where a licencee is involved in criminal acts after allotment; accordingly, the impugned orders were lawful and did not warrant interference.
  • Other decisions (e.g., Awadhesh Kumar following Ranjit Singh) upheld application of the Government Order dated 17.8.2002; and in cases where a preliminary enquiry had taken place (Harpal; Brij Lal) different procedural conclusions were reached about notice/opportunity at the preliminary stage.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jagdish Narian Mishra Vs. State of U.P. and others Relied on by petitioner to support that a fair price shop licence cannot be cancelled merely on lodging of a criminal case. The petitioner relied on this decision; the Court noted it among earlier judgments favouring the petitioner's position and observed that the Larger Bench's answers are consistent with the principle that cancellation cannot be effected merely on lodging of an FIR.
Smt. Raj Kumari Singh Vs. State of U.P. and others Relied on by petitioner for the proposition that cancellation cannot follow solely from the lodging of a criminal complaint. The Court recorded that the petitioner relied on this judgment and treated it as part of the body of precedent supporting the need for enquiry/procedure before cancellation; the Larger Bench ruling aligned with this view.
Harpal Vs. State of U.P. and others Decision relating to a case where suspension order was passed on the basis of a preliminary enquiry. The opinion noted Harpal concerned a preliminary enquiry situation; the Court distinguished it from the present case where no preliminary enquiry or opportunity was shown to have been held prior to cancellation.
Ranjit Singh Vs. State of U.P. and others Relied upon by the State to uphold cancellation/suspension where licencee's criminal involvement undermines required reputation; observed policy favouring persons of clean image and operation of para 10 of Government Order 17.8.2002. The Court recorded that Ranjit Singh supported the State's position, but also noted that there were conflicting judgments on the point; the matter was referred to a Larger Bench which answered the questions contrary to the view that cancellation may follow merely on lodging FIR.
Tuples Educational Society and another Vs. State of U.P. and another (Full Bench) Invoked by petitioner to argue that Ranjit Singh does not lay down a correct precedent and is per incuriam (petitioner relied on paragraphs 126 and 128 of this Full Bench judgment). The petitioner relied on this Full Bench authority to challenge the precedential value of Ranjit Singh; the Court recorded this contention in recounting the competing authorities and the reasons for referring the issue to a Larger Bench.
Gopi Vs. State of U.P. and others Relied on by petitioner to emphasize that Ranjit Singh is per incuriam and not binding. The Court noted the petitioner's reliance on Gopi as part of his submissions seeking to displace Ranjit Singh; the Court ultimately applied the Larger Bench's determinations which supported the petitioner's principal contention on cancellation solely on lodging of FIR.
Lalta Prasad Vs. State of U.P. and others Relied on by petitioner for the proposition that mere lodging of an FIR does not automatically demonstrate lack of good reputation. The Court recorded the petitioner's reliance on this decision in support of his submission that lodging of an FIR does not, by itself, justify cancellation; the Court's final decision reflected the Larger Bench's answer consistent with that principle.
Awadhesh Kumar Vs. State of U.P. and others Division Bench decision (vide order dated 29.11.2016) that upheld Government Order dated 17.8.2002, relying on Ranjit Singh. The Court noted Awadhesh Kumar as an example of a later Division Bench following Ranjit Singh; this contributed to the identification of conflicting decisions which warranted reference to the Larger Bench.
Brij Lal V. State of U.P. and others Division Bench judgment (25.3.2015) holding that at the stage of preliminary enquiry no opportunity is required to be given to a delinquent licencee. The opinion observed Brij Lal as addressing the stage of preliminary enquiry and clarifying procedural expectations; the Court distinguished the present case where no preliminary enquiry was shown to have been conducted prior to cancellation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's reasoning proceeded in the following sequence, based solely on the materials and submissions recorded in the opinion:

  1. Examination of the impugned order dated 27.7.2011 showed the petitioner's licence was cancelled "merely on lodging of a criminal case" (Crime No. 267 of 2011). The impugned order did not indicate any opportunity was given to the petitioner nor that any enquiry was held prior to cancellation.
  2. The court identified the applicable administrative framework: Government Order dated 29.7.2004 prescribes the procedure for complaints against a licencee. That procedure requires a preliminary enquiry where prima facie serious irregularities are found, issuance of a show-cause notice, suspension by a speaking order if necessary, followed by a detailed enquiry and an opportunity of hearing before passing final cancellation orders.
  3. The court recorded that there were conflicting judicial precedents on whether mere lodging of an FIR suffices for cancellation. For that reason the matter had earlier been referred to a Larger Bench with two formulated questions (whether cancellation can be based merely on lodging of a criminal case; and whether Government Order 17.8.2002, especially para 10, is applicable to suspension/cancellation).
  4. The Larger Bench (headed by the Chief Justice) answered both questions: (i) a licence cannot be cancelled merely on lodging of an FIR; and (ii) the Government Order dated 17.8.2002 pertains to allotment and not to suspension/cancellation, which is governed by the Government Order dated 29.7.2004 (the Larger Bench's order referred to 29.7.2014 as a typographical error for 29.7.2004).
  5. Applying the Larger Bench's conclusions to the present case, the court found the cancellation order was not sustainable: the cancellation was effected without following the mandatory/required procedure laid down in Government Order dated 29.7.2004 and was grounded only on the lodging of a criminal complaint.
  6. The appellate authority (Divisional Commissioner) had failed to consider the aforesaid legal position and had wrongly concluded that no interference was necessary. Given the lack of procedural fairness and the Larger Bench's answers, both the cancellation order (27.7.2011) and the appellate order (30.7.2013) were unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

The impugned orders dated 27.7.2011 and 30.7.2013 are set aside and the writ petition is allowed.

Direct effects and consequences:

  • The court set aside the cancellation of the petitioner's fair price shop licence dated 27.7.2011 and the appellate order dated 30.7.2013 that upheld that cancellation.
  • The writ petition has been allowed; the opinion records the concluding phrase, "Consequences shall follow." The opinion does not specify the detailed administrative steps to be taken following the setting aside of the orders.

The Court's decision in this single-judge opinion follows and applies the Larger Bench's answers that a licence cannot be cancelled merely on lodging of an FIR and that suspension/cancellation is governed by the Government Order dated 29.7.2004 rather than the allotment-focused Government Order dated 17.8.2002. The opinion does not purport to announce a novel precedent beyond applying the Larger Bench's determinations.

Show all summary ...

Ritu Raj Awasthi, J—Heard Mr. Vijay Kumar Tiwari, learned counsel for the petitioner as well as Mr. Kuldeep Singh, learned Standing Counsel and perused the records.

2. The writ petition has been filed challenging the orders dated 27.7.2011 as well as 30.7.2013, whereby the fair price shop licence of petitioner has been cancelled and the appeal preferred against the said order has been rejected.

3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the fair price shop licence of petitioner was earlier suspended on 18.11.2010. The petitioner feeling aggrieved preferred appeal under Clause 28 (3) U.P. Essential Commodities Distribution Order, 2004 which was allowed vide order dated 21.12.2010 and the fair price shop license was restored. Now, on the same allegations another complaint was made on 3.5.2011. In this complaint allegations were made regarding non-distribution of essential commodities by the petitioner during the period December, 2009 to March, 2011. The complainant had earlier lodged FIR against the petitioner under Section 307 IPC. In fact, the petitioner has enmity with the complainant, namely, Nanbabu Gautam and Munna Lal Gautam. They had lodged false case registered as case Crime No. 267 of 2011, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 504, 352, 324, 307 IPC and Section 3 (2) (v) SC/ST Act. The fair price shop licence of petitioner was suspended vide order dated 14.6.2011 and thereafter vide order dated 29.7.2011 the fair price shop licence of petitioner was cancelled. The appeal preferred thereafter before the Divisional Commissioner was dismissed vide judgment and order dated 30.7.2011.

4. The contention of learned counsel for petitioner is that the licence of fair price shop cannot be cancelled merely on lodging of a criminal case against him. The order impugned dated 29.7.2011 is, therefore, not sustainable in the eyes of law. In support of his submissions, learned counsel for petitioner relies on the judgment dated 30.10.2009 of this Court in the case of Jagdish Narian Mishra Vs. State of U.P. and others1 and Smt. Raj Kumari Singh Vs. State of U.P. and others2.

5. It is submitted that the petitioner had taken specific ground in this regard in his appeal, however, the appellate court has failed to take into consideration the aforesaid judgments and has not properly decided the said issue.

6. It is also contended that the fair price shop licence of petitioner cannot be cancelled taking into consideration the Government Order dated 17.8.2002 as it relates to the procedure prescribed for allotment of fair price shop licence and it does not deal with the suspension or cancellation of fair price shop licence.

7. Submission is that suspension and cancellation of fair price shop license is governed by the Government Order 29.7.2004 and U.P. Essential Commodities Distribution Order, 2004. Neither the Government Order dated 29.7.2004 nor the U.P. Essential Commodities Distribution Order, 2004 provides that on lodging of a criminal case fair price shop licence can be cancelled. It is contended that the Division Bench of this Court in the case of Harpal Vs. State of U.P. and others3 has considered the import of Government Order dated 29.7.2004 and has held that the procedure prescribed in the said Government Order is mandatory in nature and requires to be followed while passing the cancellation order. As per Government Order dated 29.7.2004 a fair price shop licence can be cancelled only on the basis of an enquiry held against the licencee.

8. The contention is that the impugned order has been passed without holding any enquiry and merely on lodging of a criminal case against the petitioner and, as such, the procedure prescribed under the Government Order dated 29.7.2004 has not been followed, hence the cancellation order is not sustainable in the eyes of law.

9. It is also submitted that the judgment of this Court in the case of Ranjit Singh Vs. State of U.P. and others4 does not lay down the correct law as the Court while delivering the judgment in the case of Ranjit Singh has not considered the import of Government Order dated 29.7.2004 and has also not considered the earlier judgments of this Court including the judgment in the cases of Jagdish Narian Mishra , Rajkumari Singh and all other judgments which have been passed relying on the aforesaid judgments.

10. Contention is that in view of the law laid down by Full Bench of this Court in the case of Tuples Educational Society and another Vs. State of U.P. and another5 the judgment in the case of Ranjit Singh does not lay down any precedent and it is per incuriam. In this regard paragraphs 126 and 128 of Full Bench judgment has been relied by learned counsel for the petitioner.

11. In this regard, learned counsel for the petitioner has also placed reliance on the Division Bench judgment of this Court in the case of Gopi Vs. State of U.P. and others6 while emphasizing that the judgment passed by this Court in the case of Ranjit Singh is per incuriam and not binding on this Court and need not to be followed.

12. Learned counsel for petitioner emphasized that mere lodging of a first information report does not mean that the fair price shop licencee was not having a good reputation. In this regard, learned counsel for the petitioner has relied on the judgment dated 10.8.2016 of this Court in the case of Lalta Prasad Vs. State of U.P. and others7.

13. Mr. Kuldeep Singh, learned Standing Counsel, on the other hand, while defending the orders impugned, has submitted that the petitioner was not having a good reputation as criminal case was filed against him which was registered as case Crime No. 267 of 2011, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 504, 352, 324, 307 IPC read with Section 3 (ii) (V) SC/ST Act.

14. Submission is that it is the basic requirement for grant of fair price shop licence that a person should have a good reputation. Para 10 of Government Order dated 17.8.2002 provides the essential requirements and conditions for grant of fair price shop licence. It provides that a person must have good reputation and should not have been involved in any criminal case. No criminal case should have been lodged against him and he should not have been convicted by any criminal Court.

15. It is further submitted that in the case of Ranjit Singh the Division Bench of this Court while considering the suspension of a fair price shop licence has specifically observed that the policy of the Government appears to be that people of clean image and good character may run fair price shops for the reason that if the shops are allotted to the criminals, it will result in its misuse and the poor public at large would be deprived of the beneficial scheme. It has also been observed that any allottee of a fair price shop who is granted licence for running such shop has to conduct himself in a selfless manner throughout the period of licence is in force; in case an allottee indulges into a criminal act or criminal case is registered against him or punished for a criminal offence, even after the allotment of the shop, the provision of Section 10 of the Government Order dated 17.8.2002 would be applicable.

16. Submission is that in view of law laid down by Division Bench of this Court in the case of Ranjit Singh there is no infirmity or illegality in the order impugned and it does not require any indulgence by this Court.

17. It is also pointed out that relying on the judgment in the case of Ranjit Singh Division Bench of this Court in the case of Awadhesh Kumar Vs. State of U.P. and others8 vide judgment and order dated 29.11.2016 has upheld the Government order dated 17.8.2002.

18. It is also submitted that so far as the judgment in the case of Harpal Singh is concerned that relates to a case where on the basis of preliminary enquiry suspension order was passed. The Division Bench of this Court in the case of Brij Lal V. State of U.P. and others9 vide judgment and order dated 25.3.2015 has held that at the stage of preliminary enquiry no opportunity is required to be given to a delinquent licencee. The judgment in the case of Harpal Singh and has clarified the position in this regard.

19. It is to be noted that considering the aforesaid submissions this Court vide order dated 8.2.2017 had noted that there are conflicting judgments on the point as to whether licence can be suspended/cancelled merely on lodging of a first information report against a licencee or not and referred the matter to be considered and decided by the Larger Bench. This Court formulated following questions for consideration by the Larger Bench:

"1. Whether the fair price shop licence can be cancelled merely on lodging of a criminal case against the licencee?; and

2. Whether, while passing any such order the Government Order dated 17.8.2002, particularly para-10 of said Government Order would be applicable/considered or not?"

20. The Larger Bench headed by Hon''''ble the Chief Justice vide order dated 26.10.2017 has answered the referred questions and has held that licence of fair price shop cannot be cancelled merely on lodging of FIR against the licencee. It has also been held that the Government Order dated 17.8.2002 relates to allotment of a fair price shop and hence the same cannot be referred to in suspension/cancellation of licence. It is the Government Order dated 29.7.2004 (wrongly typed as 29.7.2014) according to which the suspension/cancellation of fair price shop licence can take place. Relevant paragraphs of the judgment is reproduced below:

"14. Looking into the meaning of word, ''''discretion'''', as explained, above, and also looking to the fact that the Government order dated 29.7.2014, as a policy, requires such a discretion to be exercised in suspension/ cancellation of a licence. The answer to the two questions referred to this Court are answered as follows:-

(i) The answer is no. Licence of a fair price shop cannot be cancelled merely on lodging of FIR against the licencee.

(ii) The answer is no. The Government order dated 17.8.2002 relates to allotment of a fair price shop and hence the same cannot be referred to in suspension/cancellation of licence. It is the Government order dated 29.7.2014 according to which the suspension/cancellation of a fair price shop licence can take place. "

21. In the present case, perusal of the impugned order dated 27.7.2011 clearly indicates that the fair price shop licence of petitioner has been cancelled merely on lodging of a criminal case registered as case Crime No. 267 of 2011, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 504, 352, 324, 307 IPC read with Section 3 (ii) (V) SC/ST Act. It does not indicate that any opportunity whatsoever was provided to petitioner or any enquiry was held prior to passing of the impugned order.

22. The Government Order dated 29.7.2004 clearly provides the procedure according to which in case any complaint is received against a licencee a preliminary enquiry shall be held. In case in the preliminary enquiry some serious irregularities prima facie are found which may require cancellation of fair price shop; then, a show cause notice as to why fair price shop licence shall not be cancelled shall be issued to the licencee requiring him to submit his explanation. Thereafter, the licence of fair price shop may be suspended by passing a speaking order. The detailed enquiry thereafter shall be held and after giving opportunity of hearing to the licencee necessary orders for cancellation of fair price shop licence may be passed.

23. In the present case, no such procedure as prescribed under the Government Order dated 29.7.2004 was followed.

24. In view of above, I am of the considered view that the fair price shop licence of petitioner could not have been cancelled merely on lodging of a criminal case. Moreover, the cancellation of fair price shop licence of petitoiner is not sustainable in the eyes of law as it has been done without following the due procedure as prescribed under the Government Order dated 29.7.2004. The appellate Court has not considered the above legal position while deciding the appeal preferred by the petitioner and has wrongly come to conclusion that no interference is required in the impugned order dated 27.7.2011, as such, the impugned order dated 30.7.2013 is also not sustainable in the eyes of law.

25. In this view of the matter, the orders impugned dated 27.7.2011 and 30.7.2013 are hereby set-aside.

26. The writ petition is allowed. Consequences shall follow.