Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajendrakumar & Others v. State Of Maharashtra & Others

Bombay High Court
Feb 1, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

High Court Opinion — Indira Jain, J. (Oral) — Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicants filed applications under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure seeking quashing of the First Information Report registered as Crime No.562/2016 at Ballarsha Police Station, Chandrapur for offences punishable under Section 306 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.

Brief factual matrix as stated in the opinion:

  • Yogesh Kottawar, a salesman employed with M/s. GIMA Manufacturing Pvt. Ltd., allegedly consumed poison on 06/08/2016 and died on 08/08/2016.
  • The deceased's wife lodged the FIR, alleging that the applicants harassed the deceased for not recovering dues from customers and that for about 15 days prior to the incident the applicants repeatedly accused him of misappropriation, causing him tension that led to his suicide.
  • A chit (suicide note) was found in the deceased's pocket in which he disclosed that he was being harassed by the applicants and that this was the reason for his committing suicide.
  • The accused (applicants) sought quashing of the FIR before this Court. By order dated 28/09/2016 the Court issued notice and passed an ad interim order restraining filing of the charge-sheet until further orders. The State filed its reply resisting the quashing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the allegations in the FIR and the suicide note, taken prima facie, disclose the ingredients of "abetment" as defined by Section 107 IPC so as to sustain an offence under Section 306 IPC.
  2. Whether the First Information Report in Crime No.562/2016 should be quashed under Section 482 CrPC on the ground that the material is omnibus, vague and lacks specific instances or nexus between the alleged harassment and the suicide, thereby making continuation of criminal proceedings an abuse of process.
  3. Whether, in view of the settled legal principles relating to Section 306 IPC, the applicants can be compelled to face trial on the present allegations.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments (as advanced by Shri Anil S. Mardikar, Senior Counsel)

  • There is no specific allegation in either the suicide note or the FIR against one of the applicants in Criminal Application No.608/2016 showing any responsibility for the deceased's suicide.
  • Even the allegations against the applicants in the related application, if accepted at face value, do not amount to abetment so as to attract Section 306 IPC because the essential ingredients of abetment are absent.
  • The grievances recorded in the FIR and the suicide note are without substance and are omnibus; thus the State should not have registered the offence, particularly where the deceased's statement indicated tension due to heavy workload rather than deliberate instigation by the accused.
  • Reliance was placed on recent decisions of the Court (Dilip Ramrao Shirasao, Ramesh Someshwarrao Tayde, Sandkip Ajay Wadse) to support the contention that mere allegations of harassment are insufficient to sustain an offence under Section 306 IPC.

State's Arguments (as advanced by Shri M.K. Pathan, A.P.P.)

  • The material on record shows harassment of the deceased by the applicants to such an extent that he had no alternative but to end his life.
  • Perusal of the suicide note and the FIR discloses involvement of the applicants as abettors, and therefore the applications for quashing ought to be rejected.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dilip Ramrao Shirasao and others v. State of Maharashtra and another [2016 ALL MR (Cri) 4328] Affirmation that prosecution must at least prima facie establish that accused had intention to aid, instigate or abet the deceased to commit suicide; absence of such material precludes compelling the accused to face trial under Section 306 IPC. The Court relied on this decision as part of the settled law requiring prima facie material of intention/abetment and applied that standard to find that such material was absent in the present case.
Ramesh Someshwarrao Tayde and another v. State of Maharashtra and another [2016 ALL MR (Cri) 5049] Relied upon by applicants as recent authority supporting the proposition that mere allegations may not constitute abetment under Section 306 IPC. Referenced by the Court as part of the authorities demonstrating the settled position that abetment requires positive/material evidence of intention or instigation; used to support the conclusion that the present allegations are insufficient.
Sandkip Ajay Wadse and others v. State of Maharashtra and another (Criminal Application No.428/2016) Relied upon by applicants; cited as a contemporaneous decision of this Court addressing quashing in Section 306 cases. Noted by the Court among precedents demonstrating the settled approach; applied collectively with other authorities to assess sufficiency of material in the present matter.
Sanju alias Sanjay Singh Sengar v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2002 Cri.L.J. 2796) Holds that mere abusive words or statements in a quarrel are not prima facie enough to instigate a person to commit suicide; proximity and specific instigation are relevant. The Court reproduced and relied on the reasoning that abusive language or quarrel, without proximate instigation or specific acts, do not satisfy ingredients of abetment; applied to find lack of proximate causal nexus here.
Madan Mohan Singh v. State of Gujarat (cited as 2010 ALL MR (Cri) 3245 (S.C.) / (2010) 8 SCC 628) Holds that suicide notes may be rhetoric or departmental grievances and, unless there is allegation of instigation, conspiracy or aiding, such documents do not constitute abetment; intention to aid/instigate is necessary. The Court relied on this precedent to emphasize that the suicide note and FIR must show specific intention/abetment; finding the present suicide note rhetorical and omnibus, the Court concluded it did not disclose abetment.
S.S. Chheena v. Vijay Kumar Mahajan (2010 All MR (Cri) 3298 (S.C.)) Stated that abetment requires mens rea and a positive act of instigation or aiding; conviction under Section 306 IPC cannot be sustained without credible evidence or material showing such acts or intention. The Court cited this authority for the principle that abetment demands a clear mens rea and active conduct; applied this principle to find that there was no credible material against the applicants in the present case.
Swamy Prahaladdas v. State of M.P., 1995 Supp. (3) SCC 438 Established that mere words like "go and die" uttered in anger do not constitute instigation sufficient for Section 306 IPC. Used in the Court's exposition of settled law showing that mere expressions in anger are insufficient to constitute abetment; supported the conclusion that vague allegations here are not enough.
Mahendra Singh v. State of M.P., 1995 Supp. (3) SCC 731 Held that a charge/conviction under Section 306 IPC is not sustainable merely on allegations of harassment where ingredients of abetment are absent. Relied upon to reinforce that harassment alone, without ingredients of abetment, does not attract Section 306; applied to the facts where no specific instances were attributed to the accused.
Ramesh Kumar v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2001) 9 SCC 618 Held that words uttered in a fit of anger without intent cannot be equated with instigation; hypersensitivity of the victim may preclude finding of abetment. Cited to support the proposition that ordinary petulance or discord, not expected to induce a reasonable person to commit suicide, does not establish abetment; applied to characterize the deceased's complaints as insufficient.
Netai Duta v. State of W.B. (referenced) Referenced in the context that courts may quash proceedings where allegations under Section 306 IPC are absurd or irrelevant and no material of definite nature exists. Noted by the Court as an authority illustrating circumstances where proceedings were quashed for want of credible material; used in overall survey of precedents.
Chitresh Kumar Chopra v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), (2009) 16 SCC 605 Considered dictionary meanings of "instigation" and "goading"; emphasized that there must be intention to provoke/encourage the act — each case depends on its facts. Quoted in connection with the principle that abetment involves a mental process of intent and that there is no universal formula — applied to assess the specific facts and note the absence of intentional conduct here.
State of Kerala and others v. S. Unnikrishnan Nair and others, AIR 2015 SC 3351 : [2015 ALL SCR 2824] Held that a suicide note which is vague and does not show proximate instigation cannot support an offence under Section 306 IPC; inferior rank and vague allegations may render the allegation implausible. The Court relied on this Supreme Court decision to illustrate that vague allegations in a suicide note do not constitute abetment; applied that rationale to find the present suicide note omnibus and insufficient.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by reciting the settled law on the ingredients necessary to attract Section 306 IPC, drawing on a series of decisions (both of the Supreme Court and this Court) that consistently require at least prima facie material showing intention to instigate, aid or abet suicide.

The Court then examined the materials specific to this case (as recorded in the opinion):

  • The suicide note (a chit) found in the deceased's pocket was dated 03/08/2016. It referred to a dispute over supplied goods and a demand for discount involving Chandan Naik (applicant no.3) and stated that the writer could not decide the discount and was being harassed to recover dues; the writer described becoming "unwanted" in the office and expressed the decision to take an extreme step.
  • Although the deceased named the owner, other employees and Chandan Naik, the note and the FIR were omnibus in nature: no specific role was attributed to each accused and no specific instances of harassment were described against particular persons.
  • Timing: the note was written on 03/08/2016, the deceased consumed poison on 06/08/2016, died on 08/08/2016, and the FIR was lodged on 09/08/2016. The police also recorded a statement of the victim on 07/08/2016 in which he made only vague allegations of tension at the workplace.
  • Given the absence of specific instances or direct nexus between alleged ill-treatment and the suicide, the Court concluded the essential requirement to attract Section 306 IPC (as shaped by the precedents) was not present here.

On this basis and applying the cited authorities, the Court held that prima facie material to proceed against the applicants for abetment was lacking and that compelling the applicants to face trial would be an abuse of process of law.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The Court allowed the applicants' petitions. Specifically, Criminal Applications Nos.593/2016 and 608/2016 were allowed, the rule was made absolute in terms of the prayer clause (I), and there was no order as to costs.

Direct implications (as stated or evident from the opinion):

  • The FIR registered as Crime No.562/2016 (under Section 306 read with Section 34 IPC) will not result in the applicants being compelled to face trial on that charge pursuant to these applications; the criminal proceedings against them in respect of these applications have been quashed.
  • The Court treated continuation of criminal proceedings on the present material as an abuse of the process of law because the suicide note, the statement of the deceased and the FIR were omnibus and lacked specific allegations necessary to establish abetment under Section 306 IPC.
  • The opinion applies settled legal principles and does not purport to lay down a new legal principle or broader precedent beyond the application of established authorities to the facts of this case.

Order as recorded in the opinion:

  • (i) Criminal Applications Nos.593/2016 and 608/2016 are allowed.
  • (ii) Rule is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (I).
  • (iii) No order as to costs.
Show all summary ...

Indira Jain, J. (Oral)

1. By these applications under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, applicants are seeking quashing of F.I.R. in Crime No.562/2016 registered at Ballarsha Police Station, Chandrapur for the offences punishable under Section 306 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code.

2. The facts giving rise to the applications may be stated in brief as under :

(I) Yogesh Kottawar was working as salesman in M/s. GIMA Manufacturing Pvt. Ltd., Ballarsha. On 06/08/2016, he consumed poison and died on 08/08/2016. Wife of Yogesh is the first informant. She lodged report with Police Station Ballarsha alleging therein that the applicants harassed the deceased for not recovering the dues from the customers. Before the incident, for about 15 days, applicants continuously made allegations against Yogesh that he misappropriated the amount received from the customers. Due to such remarks, Yogesh was tense and took an extreme step to end his life.

(II) On receiving report, above said crime came to be registered. After Yogesh consumed poison, his wife Seema alias Sonu found a chit in the pocket of his pant. In the said chit, Yogesh disclosed that he was being harassed by the applicants and, therefore, he was committing suicide.

(III) In the above background, applicants, who have been arrayed as accused, have approached this Court for quashing of F.I.R.

(IV) Vide order dated 28/09/2016, this Court issued notice to non-applicants and by way of an ad interim order, directed not to file charge-sheet until further orders. In pursuance to notice, nonapplicant no.1 - State of Maharashtra filed its reply and resisted the challenge to F.I.R.

3. Shri Anil S. Mardikar, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of applicants submits that there is no whisper either in suicide note or F.I.R. against applicant in Criminal Application No.608/2016 showing that he was responsible in any way for alleged suicide committed by victim. So far as applicants in another application are concerned, submission is that allegations, even if taken at their face value, would not constitute an abetment so as to attract the provisions of Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code. According to applicants, grievances made in F.I.R. and suicide note are without substance. It is submitted that non-applicant no.1 should not have registered the crime in view of the statement of deceased clearly indicating that victim was tense as due to heavy workload, he was not in a position to perform his work within time.

4. Per contra, Shri M.K. Pathan, learned A.P.P. for non-applicant no.1-State submits that material placed on record would show harassment by applicants to such an extent that deceased had no other alternative but to end his life. He submits that from perusal of suicide note and F.I.R., involvement of applicants as abettors is apparent and seeks rejection of both the applications.

5. Before considering the prayer for quashing of FIR under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, we find it appropriate to keep in mind essential ingredients necessary to attract the provisions of Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code and the settled law in that regard. The learned Senior Counsel for applicants pressed into service recent decisions of this Court in (i) Dilip Ramrao Shirasao and others v. State of Maharashtra and another [2016 ALL MR (Cri) 4328], (ii) Ramesh Someshwarrao Tayde and another v. State of Maharashtra and another [2016 ALL MR (Cri) 5049 and (iii) Sandkip Ajay Wadse and others v. State of Maharashtra and another in Criminal Application No.428/2016, to substantiate his submissions.

6. In Dilip Ramrao Shirasao and others (supra), this Court, relying upon the catena of decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, held that it is necessary for the prosecution to at least prima facie establish that accused had an intention to aid or instigate or abet the deceased to commit suicide and in the absence of availability of such material, accused cannot be compelled to face trial for the offence punishable under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code. It would be appropriate to reproduce paragraphs 11 to 18 of the said decision here for ready reference :

"11. The law as to what are the requirements to constitute an offence punishable under Section 306 of the IPC is no more res integra. The law is very well crystalized by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the catena of cases including in the cases of Sanju alias Sanjay Singh Sengar v. State of Madhya Pradesh, reported in 2002 Cri.L.J. 2796; Madan Mohan Singh v. State of Gujrat and another, reported in (2010) 8 SCC 628; and in the case of S.S. Chheena v. Vijay Kumar Mahajan reported in 2010 All MR (Cri) 3298 (S.C.).

12. In the case of Sanju @ Sanjay Sengar cited supra, the appellant before the Apex Court was the brother of Neelam wife of deceased Chander Bhushan @ Babloo. It was the prosecution case that after marriage of Neelam with the deceased, there was continuous ill-treatment by the deceased and his family members to Neelam. As such she had gone to her parents house and started living with her brother, the appellant before the Apex Court. About two months prior to the incident, the appellant advised the deceased to take his sister back to her matrimonial house and treat her properly. It was the prosecution case that on 25th July, 1998, the appellant visited the place of the parents of the deceased and pleaded with them that his sister should be rehabilitated in the matrimonial home and should not be physically ill-treated or harassed. It was also the prosecution case that on that day the appellant also said to have threatened the parents of the deceased that if they do not mend their behaviour towards his sister, he would be compelled to resort to filing a complaint under Section 498-A of the Indian Penal Code. On this, the parents of the deceased expressed helplessness. It was the further prosecution case that the parents of the deceased informed the deceased about the same. He went to the house of parents of the appellant, where quarrel took place between them. Therefore, the deceased returned alone and told his brothers and other acquaintances that the appellant had threatened and abused him by using filthy words. On the next date i.e. on 27th July, 1998, the deceased was found hanging with a rope by neck on the raft of his house and he was found dead. A suicide note was left by the deceased. On the basis of the said suicide note, the charge-sheet was filed against said Sanju alias Sanjay Sengar. A petition challenging filing of charge-sheet was filed before the High Court under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The same was rejected. Hence, said Sanju alias Sanjay Sengar approached the Hon'ble Apex Court.

13. The Apex Court in Sanju @ Sanjay Sengar's case considered the earlier judgments in paragraphs 9 to 12 of the said judgment. It would be appropriate to refer to the same -

"9. In Swamy Prahaladdas v. State of M.P. & Anr., 1995 Supp. (3) SCC 438, the appellant was charged for an offence under Section 306 I.P.C. on the ground that the appellant during the quarrel is said to have remarked the deceased 'to go and die' . This Court was of the view that mere words uttered by the accused to the deceased 'to go and die' were not even prima facie enough to instigate the deceased to commit suicide.

10. In Mahendra Singh v. State of M.P., 1995 Supp.(3) SCC 731, the appellant was charged for an offence under Section 306 I.P.C basically based upon the dying declaration of the deceased, which reads as under:

"My mother-in-law and husband and sister-in-law (husband's elder brother's wife) harassed me. They beat me and abused me. My husband Mahendra wants to marry a second time. He has illicit connections with my sister-in-law. Because of those reasons and being harassed I want to die by burning."

11. This Court, considering the definition of 'abetment' under Section 107 I.P.C., found that the charge and conviction of the appellant for an offence under Section 306 is not sustainable merely on the allegation of harassment to the deceased. This Court further held that neither of the ingredients of abetment are attracted on the statement of the deceased.

12. In Ramesh Kumar v. State Of Chhattisgarh . (2001) 9 SCC 618, this Court while considering the charge framed and the conviction for an offence under Section 306 I.P.C. on the basis of dying declaration recorded by an Executive Magistrate, in which she had stated that previously there had been quarrel between the deceased and her husband and on the day of occurrence she had a quarrel with her husband who had said that she could go wherever she wanted to go and that thereafter she had poured kerosene on herself and had set fire. Acquitting the accused this Court said :

"A word uttered in a fit of anger or emotion without intending the consequences to actually follow cannot be said to be instigation. If it transpires to the court that a victim committing suicide was hypersensitive to ordinary petulance, discord and difference in domestic life quite common to the society to which the victim belonged and such petulance, discord and difference were not expected to induce a similarly circumstanced individual in a given society to commit suicide, the conscience of the court should not be satisfied for basing a finding that the accused charged for abetting the offence of suicide should be found guilty."

14. After considering the earlier judgments, Their Lordships observed thus at paragraph 13 -

"13. …....... It is in a fit of anger and emotional. Secondly, the alleged abusive words, said to have been told to the deceased were on 25th July, 1998 ensued by quarrel. The deceased was found hanging on 27th July, 1998. Assuming that the deceased had taken the abusive language seriously, he had enough time in between to think over and reflect and, therefore, it cannot be said that the abusive language, which had been used by the appellant on 25th July, 1998 drived the deceased to commit suicide. Suicide by the deceased on 27th July, 1998 is not proximate to the abusive language uttered by the appellant on 25th July, 1998. The fact that the deceased committed suicide on 27th July, 1998 would itself clearly pointed out that it is not the direct result of the quarrel taken place on 25th July, 1998 when it is alleged that the appellant had used the abusive language and also told the deceased to go and die. This fact had escaped notice of the courts below.

15. Their Lordships of the Apex Court further have reproduced the suicide note in the said case in paragraph 14 of the judgment, wherein Sanjay Sengar was directly implicated to be the person responsible for suicide of the deceased. After reproducing the said suicide note, Their Lordships observed thus at paragraph 15 -

"15. …....... The prosecution story, if believed, shows that the quarrel between the deceased and the appellant had taken place on 25th July, 1998 and if the deceased came back to the house again on 26th July, 1998, it cannot be said that the suicide by the deceased was the direct result of the quarrel that had taken pace on 25th July, 1998. Viewed from the aforesaid circumstances independently, we are clearly of the view that the ingredients of 'abetment' are totally absent in the instant case for an offence under Section 306 I.P.C. …...."

After these observations, Their Lordships allowed the appeal and quashed and set aside the charge sheet.

16. In the case of Madan Mohan Singh [2010 ALL MR (Cri) 3245 (S.C.)] (cited supra), the petitioner was working as a DET in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. The deceased i.e. Deepakbhai Krishnalal Joshi has committed suicide. On the basis of complaint filed by his wife, an FIR came to be registered. The petitioner had applied for discharge. The trial Court rejected it. The Gujarat High Court upheld the order of the trial Judge. Being aggrieved thereby the petitioner has approached the Apex Court. The prosecution heavily relied on the suicide note of the deceased wherein it was stated that the petitioner was responsible for his death. The Apex Court negating the contention on behalf of prosecution observed thus :-

"10. We are convinced that there is absolutely nothing in this suicide note or the FIR which would even distantly be viewed as an offence much less under Section 306 IPC. We could not find anything in the FIR or in the so-called suicide note which could be suggested as abetment to commit suicide. In such matters there must be an allegation that the accused had instigated the deceased to commit suicide or secondly, had engaged with some other person in a conspiracy and lastly, that the accused had in any way aided any act or illegal omission to bring about the suicide.

11. In spite of our best efforts and microscopic examination of the suicide note and the FIR, all that we find is that the suicide note is a rhetoric document in the nature of a departmental complaint. It also suggests some mental imbalance on the part of the deceased which he himself describes as depression. In the so- called suicide note, it cannot be said that the accused even intended that the driver under him should commit suicide or should end his life and did anything in that behalf. Even if it is accepted that the accused changed the duty of the driver or that the accused asked him not to take the keys of the car and to keep the keys of the car in the office itself, it does not mean that the accused intended or knew that the driver should commit suicide because of this.

12. In order to bring out an offence under Section 306 IPC specific abetment as contemplated by Section 107 IPC on the part of the accused with an intention to bring about the suicide of the person concerned as a result of that abetment is required. The intention of the accused to aid or to instigate or to abet the deceased to commit suicide is a must for this particular offence under Section 306 IPC. We are of the clear opinion that there is no question of there being any material for offence under Section 306 IPC either in the FIR or in the so called suicide note.

13. It is absurd to even think that a superior officer like the appellant would intend to bring about suicide of his driver and, therefore, abet the offence. In fact, there is no nexus between the so-called suicide (if at all it is one for which also there is no material on record) and any of the alleged acts on the part of the appellant. There is no proximity either. In the prosecution under Section 306 IPC, much more material is required. The courts have to be extremely careful as the main person is not available for cross-examination by the appellant-accused. Unless, therefore, there is specific allegation and material of definite nature (not imaginary or inferential one), it would be hazardous to ask the appellant-accused to face the trial. A criminal trial is not exactly a pleasant experience. The person like the appellant in the present case who is serving in a responsible post would certainly suffer great prejudice, were he to face prosecution on absurd allegations of irrelevant nature. In the similar circumstances, as reported in Netai Duta v. State of W.B., this Court had quashed the proceedings initiated against the accused.

14. As regards the suicide note, which is a document of about 15 pages, all that we can say is that it is an anguish expressed by the driver who felt that his boss (the accused) had wronged him. The suicide note and the FIR do not impress us at all. They cannot be depicted as expressing anything intentional on the part of the accused that the deceased might commit suicide. If the prosecutions are allowed to continue on such basis, it will be difficult for every superior officer even to work." (emphasis supplied)

17. In case of S.S.Cheena (cited supra), there was a dispute between one Saurav Mahajan, who was a final year student of Law Department and Harminder Singh, a fellow student of the same class with regard to the theft of a mobile phone. This came to the notice of M.D. Singh, the then Head of the Law Department who asked both the students to submit their versions of the incident in writing. The deceased and Harminder gave their versions and, thereafter, M.D.Singh forwarded their versions to the University authorities for taking necessary action. An inquiry was conducted on 13th October 2003 by the Security Officer of the University Shri S.S. Chheena. During the course of inquiry, on 17th October 2003, Saurav Mahajan committed suicide by jumping in front of the train. A suicide note was seized from the pocket of the deceased. On the complaint of father of the deceased, an offence under section 306 of I.P.C. was registered against Harminder Singh. During the course of trial, S.S. Cheena was also impleaded as accused. Being aggrieved by the framing of charge, S.S. Cheena approached the High Court. The High Court refused to interfere. Being aggrieved thereby, said S.S. Cheena approached the Supreme Court. The Apex Court observed thus:

"27. This Court in Chitresh Kumar Chopra v. State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi) (2009) 16 SCC 605 had an occasion to deal with this aspect of abetment. The Court dealt with the dictionary meaning of the words "instigation" and "goading". The Court opined that there should be intention to provoke, incite or encourage the doing of an act by the latter. Each person's suicidability pattern is different from the other. Each person has his own idea of self-esteem and self-respect. Therefore, it is impossible to lay down any straitjacket formula in dealing with such cases. Each case has to be decided on the basis of its own facts and circumstances.

28. Abetment involves a mental process of instigating a person or intentionally aiding a person in doing of a thing. Without a positive act on the part of the accused to instigate or aid in committing suicide, conviction cannot be sustained. The intention of the legislature and the ratio of the cases decided by this Court is clear that in order to convict a person under Section 306 IPC there has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence. It also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide seeing no option and that act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that he committed suicide.

29. In the instant case, the deceased was undoubtedly hypersensitive to ordinary petulance, discord and differences which happen in our day-to-day life. Human sensitivity of each individual differs from the other. Different people behave differently in the same situation.

30. When we carefully scrutinize and critically examine the facts of this case in the light of the settled legal position the conclusion becomes obvious that no conviction can be legally sustained without any credible evidence or material on record against the appellant. The order of framing a charge under section 306 IPC against the appellant is palpably erroneous and unsustainable. It would be travesty of justice to compel the appellant to face a criminal trial without any credible material whatsoever. Consequently, the order of framing charge under section 306 IPC against the appellant is quashed and all proceedings pending against him are also set aside."

(emphasis supplied)

18. Recently, in the case of State of Kerala and others v. S. Unnikrishnan Nair and others, reported in AIR 2015 Supreme Court 3351 : [2015 ALL SCR 2824], Their Lordships had an occasion to consider a similar case. In the said case, the Chief Investigating Officer had committed suicide pending investigation in a murder case. In the suicide note, it was alleged that two of his subordinates were responsible for his this situation. There were some allegations against one Advocate and the Chief Judicial Magistrate. The First Information Report came to be lodged against the subordinate officers. They filed a petition under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code. The Kerala High Court quashed the First Information Report. Being aggrieved thereby, the State went in appeal before the Hon'ble Apex Court. While dismissing the appeal, the Their Lordships of the Apex Court observed thus :

"13. As we find from the narration of facts and the material brought on record in the case at hand, it is the suicide note which forms the fulcrum of the allegations and for proper appreciation of the same, we have reproduced it herein-before. On a plain reading of the same, it is difficult to hold that there has been any abetment by the respondents. The note, except saying that the respondents compelled him to do everything and cheated him and put him in deep trouble, contains nothing else. The respondents were inferior in rank and it is surprising that such a thing could happen. That apart, the allegation is really vague. It also baffles reasons, for the department had made him the head of the investigating team and the High Court had reposed complete faith in him and granted him the liberty to move the court, in such a situation, there was no warrant to feel cheated and to be put in trouble by the officers belonging to the lower rank. That apart, he has also put the blame on the Chief Judicial Magistrate by stating that he had put pressure on him. He has also made the allegation against the Advocate."

7. From the above, it is apparent that law as to what are the requirements to constitute an offence punishable under Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code is well crystallized in the above referred decisions. In the case on hand, disclosures by the victim to his wife, as narrated in F.I.R. and the suicide note found in the pocket of his pant, are the basis to set criminal law into motion. Perusal of copy of suicide note shows that the same was written on 03/08/2016. Some goods were supplied to Chandan Naik (applicant no.3 in Criminal Application No.593/2016). A dispute arose regarding payment as Chandan Naik was insisting for discount. He further states in the chit that regarding discount, he could not take decision and the decision was to be taken by the owner. For non-payment, he was not responsible, but he was being harassed for the recovery of dues. Then, he proceeds and writes that he has become unwanted in the office and, therefore, he is taking this extreme step.

8. Though, the victim holds the owner of the company, other employees and Chandan Naik responsible, it can be seen from the allegations in suicide note that they are omnibus and no specific role is attributed to each of them. No specific instances have been mentioned in suicide note or in the F.I.R. In the absence of specific instances, it is not possible to find out nexus between alleged ill-treatment and suicide. Therefore, the most important requirement to attract the provisions of Section 306 of the Indian Penal Code is absent in the present case.

9. It is also significant to note that suicide note was written on 03/08/2016. Victim consumed poison on 06/08/2016 and died on 08/08/2016. F.I.R. was lodged on 09/08/2016. Police recorded statement of victim on 07/08/2016. Even in the statement, he makes vague allegations that he had tension at his workplace. The dispute was between Chandan Naik and the company regarding discount on payment. Prima facie, on the face value, statement of the deceased, suicide note and allegations in F.I.R., if taken as they are, would not amount to abetment as defined under Section 107 of the Indian Penal Code.

10. In this view of the matter, applicants can not be compelled to face trial for the said offence as allowing the continuance of criminal action would amount to abuse of process of law. We are, therefore, inclined to allow the applications. Hence, the order :

(i). Criminal Applications Nos.593/2016 and 608/2016 are allowed.

(ii). Rule is made absolute in terms of prayer clause (I).

(iii). No order as to costs.