- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
KUTUBUDDIN RAJAKSAB KASABHAG v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
The appellant was the accused in the Court of the learned Special Judge/Prl.Sessions Judge, at Vijayapura (hereinafter for brevity referred to as Special Court) in Special (NDPS) Case No.1/2016 and was convicted by the judgment of conviction and order on sentence dated 25.11.2016, passed by the said Court for the offence under Section 8(c) which is punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (hereinafter for brevity referred to as `NDPS Act).
2. The summary of the case of the prosecution is that on 25.7.2015 at 3.30 p.m. in the house bearing No.C-5 of Mahatma Gandhi Ashraya Colony, Star Chowk, Crl.A.No.200183/2016 near Ambedkar Circle of Ward No.16 at Vijayapura, the accused was found in possession of 42 Kgs. of dried ganja without any permit or licence from the competent authority with an intention to sell the same and thereby has committed the offence in contravention of Section 8(c) punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of the NDPS Act.
3. Based upon the charge sheet filed against the accused, the learned Special Judge/Prl.Sessions Judge, framed charges against the accused for the offence under Section 8(c) punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of the NDPS Act. Since the accused pleaded not guilty, in order to prove the charge leveled against him, the prosecution examined nine witnesses from PWs.1 to 9 and got marked documents from Exs.P-1 to P-19. The material objects from MO-1 to MO-22 were marked from prosecution side. Accused did not examine any witnesses from his side. However, a copy of Niveshana Crl.A.No.200183/2016 Hakku Patra as Ex.D-1 and portion of statement of PW-3 as Ex.D-2 were marked from his side.
4. After hearing the arguments from both side, the Special Court by its impugned judgment of conviction and order on sentence dated 25.11.2016, convicted the accused for the alleged offence under Section 8(c) punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of the NDPS Act and sentenced him accordingly. It is against the said judgment of conviction and order on sentence, the accused has preferred this appeal.
5. The respondent State is being represented by learned High Court Government Pleader.
6. The records from the Special Court were called for and the same are placed before this Court.
7. Heard the arguments from both side and perused the materials placed before this Court, including Crl.A.No.200183/2016 the memorandum of appeal and the records from the Special Court.
8. For the sake of convenience, the parties would be referred to as per their ranks before the Special Court.
9. In view of the above, the point that arise for my consideration is :
Whether the prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that on 25.7.2015, at 3.30 p.m. in the House bearing No.C-5 of Mahatma Gandhi Awas Colony, Star Chowk, Near Ambedkar Circle of Ward No.16 at Vijayapura, within the limits of respondent-Police Station, the appellant/accused was found in possession of 42 Kgs. of dried ganja which was of commercial quantity without any permit or licence from the competent authority and with an intention to sell the same and thereby has committed an offence under Section 8(c), which is punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of NDPS Act?Crl.A.No.200183/2016
10. Among the nine witnesses examined by the prosecution, PW-1 (CW-1) Abubakar Mujawar, is the Excise Inspector in the office of the Deputy Commissioner of Excise at Vijayapura and also the complainant in this case. The said witness in his evidence has stated that, on 25.7.2015, at about 2.00 p.m., he received a credible information informing that in House No.C-5, in Ward No.16, near Star Chowk and Ambedkar Statue at Mahatma Gandhi Ashraya Colony in Vijayapura, one Kutubuddin Rajaksab Kasabhag, has illegally and unlawfully stored ganja which he had wrapped in brown papers and kept below the cot in the said house and he is about to transport the same to a different place at about 4.00 OClock on the same evening. PW-1 has further stated that he passed on the information to his higher officers who are Deputy Superintendent of Excise Sri Jagadish Inamdar in person Crl.A.No.200183/2016 and to the Deputy Commissioner of Excise Sri Venkatesh Padaki over the phone since Sri Venkatesh Padaki was at Bengaluru. The Deputy Commissioner permitted him over the phone to proceed further in conducting the raid under the guidance of Deputy Superintendent of Excise. Thereafter, he (the witness) formed a raiding team, which also included two panchas by name Rudrappa Kumbar and Vinod Shahapeti, to whom he briefed about the information received by him and also issued a notice in writing as per Exs.P-1 and P-2. The witness has further stated that the Deputy Superintendent of Excise, himself, the Sub-Inspector of Excise, panchas and other staff went near the place about which the details were given in the information, in two vehicles. When they went near the said house bearing No.C-5, a person standing in front of the house after seeing these people, by shock, rushed into the house. After getting suspicion about the same, a Search Crl.A.No.200183/2016 Related Report (zs av g) was prepared as per Ex.P-3 in the spot, which was signed by the Deputy Superintendent of Excise and panchas. The witness has further stated that after preparation of the said report, they entered the house, where they noticed the person who had run inside the house after seeing these people who is the accused in the Court. At enquiry, he identified himself as Kutubuddin Rajaksab Kasabhag, to whom these people informed about the purpose of their raid. The witness has also stated that when these people first inspected the kitchen, they did not find anything there. In the Hall leading to the front door of the house, they noticed the presence of a cot. A bedspread was spread on the cot up to the floor level. The articles beneath the cost were covered with the said bedspread. These people removed the said bedspread and noticed Crl.A.No.200183/2016 the stocking of some packets in the form of bundles covered with brown colour paper. There were twentyone such bundles. When opened, they noticed the presence of ganja in all the twentyone bundles. When they enquired the accused, he told to them that in order to sell them unauthorisedly, he has brought them from Hyderabad. The witness has stated that making use of the Balance which they had with them, they weighed each of the twentyone bundles and ascertained that each of the bundles were weighing about 2 Kgs. As such, there was about 42 Kgs. of dried ganja. From out of twentyone bundles from each of the bundle, about 50 grams of ganja was separated as a sample and they were kept in separate plastic pouches stappled and sealed with their office seal. The slips signed by him, as well the panchas were also pasted to those samples. Bundles and the samples were marked with Serial Numbers which the Crl.A.No.200183/2016 witness identified in the Court at MO-1 to MO-21. He also stated that sample seal was also prepared which he has identified at Ex.P-4. The witness further stated that on the side of the cot, there was a window, on which they noticed two documents, one was a copy of the application submitted by the accused for obtaining a new Ration Card and another was an electricity bill with respect to R.R.No.84783, which electric connection was pertaining to the said house. The witness has identified and marked the said Electricity Bill at Ex.P-5. He has identified and marked the copy of the application said to have been submitted to obtain Ration Card at Ex.P-6. The witness also stated that after coming outside of the house, he enquired two persons who were standing on the side of the house, who stated that it was the accused who was residing in the said house and Crl.A.No.200183/2016 doing business in ganja. However, they refused to give the said information in writing, so also, disclose their names and identity. The witness has stated that, in connection with the search and seizure, he drew a panchanama in the presence of panchas in the same place between 3.30 p.m. to 5.30 p.m., as per Ex.P-7, for which panchanama, apart from panchas, himself and Deputy Superintendent of Excise have all put their signatures. The witness has also stated that the ganja seized in the matter, excluding the samples, were produced before the learned III Addl. J.M.F.C., at Vijayapura, as per NDPS Act, who prepared an inventory and took out nearly 30 grams from each of the bundle as a sample and they were sealed separately with Seal No.540. A certificate was issued in that by the learned Magistrate as per Ex.P-8. The witness has identified all the twentyone such sealed bundles at MO-22. Crl.A.No.200183/2016 The witness has also stated that after the seizure panchanama, the accused and seized articles and samples were brought to the Excise Station, where he himself on behalf of the Government, lodged a complaint and registered in respondent-Station in Crime No.94/2015 and also prepared first information report and submitted the same to the Court along with complaint, panchanama and other documents. The witness has identified and marked the complaint at Ex.P-9 and his signature at Ex.P-9(a). He identified and marked the first information report at Ex.P-10. After complying rest of the formalities, he arrested the accused and along with remand application, he sent him to the Court. He subjected the seized articles to the Property Form as per Ex.P-11. He also prepared a report under Section 42(1)(2) of NDPS Act and submitted to his higher authorities on 25.7.2015 itself, which document he identified and marked at Ex.P-12. Crl.A.No.200183/2016 The witness also stated that on 13.8.2015, he wrote to the Corporation as per Ex.P-13 and to the Hubballi Electric Supply Company Limited (HESCOM) authorities as per Ex.P-15 for furnishing the house ownership documents. The reply received by the Corporation and HESCOM have been identified by the witness at Exs.P-14 and P-16 respectively. He has stated that the electricity connection as shown in Ex.P-16 stands in the name of Smt.Rajakbee Kasabhag. The further investigation was handed over to CW-13. The witness was subjected to a detailed cross- examination from the accused side, wherein he adhered to his original version. However, he stated that the site of the said house was allotted to one Sri Parashuram Raju Ballari. The photocopy of the said letter was marked at Ex.D-1. However, he denied that it was the said Sri Parashuram Raju Ballari who was the owner and in possession of the said house. Crl.A.No.200183/2016
11. PW-2 (CW-2) Rudrappa Kumbar has stated that, on 25.7.2015, at about 2.00 p.m., when he was having a cup of tea near Choudhary Hospital at Vijayapura, a Police Constable from Excise Police Station came to him and requested him to accompany him to go to his superior since his superior had asked him to bring panchayatdar. Similarly, the Police Constable also requested one more person, who was Vinod Shahapete, who was also found there. Both of them accompanied the said Police Constable to their station, where the Excise Inspector Sri Mujawar (PW-1) briefed them about the information received by them about illegal storage of ganja by Kutubudddin Rajaksab Kasabhag in his house at Mahatma Gandhi Ashraya Colony. He also requested them to be the panchas of the raid which was required to be conducted without any delay. These people agreed for the same. As such, forming a team, they went to the house informed in the information Crl.A.No.200183/2016 which was in Mahatma Gandhi Ashraya Colony at Vijayapura. There a Search Related Report was prepared, for which, these people have put their signature. The witness has also stated that, at that time, in front of the said house, the accused was standing. After seeing the Excise Authorities, he went inside the house, these people followed him. They did not notice anything in the kitchen, however, in the Hall of the house, they noticed a cot which was covered with a bedsheet. When the said bedsheet was removed, they noticed about storing of twentyone bundles covered with paper, which bundles when weighed, were found to be each weighing
2 Kgs. The accused was also present at that time in the house. When enquired by the Excise Authorities, he stated that he had stored the ganja for sale. The witness has further stated that the Excise Authorities took about 50 grams of ganja from each of Crl.A.No.200183/2016 the bundle as sample, upon which also, the slips bearing the signatures of panchas were pasted. In the said process, these people noticed a copy of an application submitted for obtaining a Ration Card and also an Electricity Bill as per Ex.P-6 and Ex.P-5 respectively. A seizure panchanama was made in the house as per Ex.P-7, which was signed by him. The witness has identified the alleged sample packets of ganja taken out from twentyone bundles, at MO-1 to MO-21. The sample seal impression was also taken as per Ex.P-4. The witness has stated that at the time of raid and drawing the panchanama, neighbours were standing at some distance. Though Excise Inspector requested them to sign the panchanama, they refused to sign it. Even this witness was subjected to a detailed cross-examination, wherein he adhered to his original version. Crl.A.No.200183/2016
12. PW-3 (CW-5) Raju Gonde, is the Sub-Inspector in Excise Department. While corroborating the evidence of PW-1, he has stated that, on 25.7.2015, at about 2.00 p.m., while he was in office, PW-1 summoned him to the office of the Deputy Superintendent and stated to him about the credible information received by them, which revealed that the accused has illegally stored ganja in his house at Ward No.16. At their request, he also joined them for a raid. Accordingly, when they went to the house of the accused, after seeing these people in Uniform, the accused was shocked and went inside his house. On getting suspicion about the same, these people prepared a Search Related Report as per Ex.P-3, which was signed by PW-1, himself and panchas. The witness has identified the accused in the Court as the one who was found at his house during the time of raid. Crl.A.No.200183/2016 The witness has further stated that, first they searched the kitchen, but, could not notice anything. However, in the Hall of the said house, they noticed a cot covered with a bedspread. When the said bedspread was removed, they noticed twentyone bundles packed with brown colour paper and stored beneath the cost. When examined, they noticed that all the twnetyone bundles were containing dried ganja in it. Each of the bundles were weighed and they were weighing 2 Kgs. each. The sample of about 50 grams was taken from each of the bundle for further opinion in the matter. The samples collected were properly sealed and the signature of PW-1 and panchas were pasted to those samples. The witness has identified those samples at MO-1 to MO-21. He also stated that in the window by the side of the cot, these people noticed a copy of the application applied for obtaining a Ration Card as per Ex.P-6 and also an Electricity Bill. He stated that the Crl.A.No.200183/2016 neighbours refused to give their names, address and their statements. When accused was enquired on the spot, he stated that he had brought the said ganja from Hyderabad for their sale in Vijayapura. A seizure panchanama as per Ex.P-7 was drawn in the spot and along with the seized goods and the accused, they returned to their Station, where PW-1 lodged the complaint. The witness adhered to his original version even in his cross-examination also.
13. PW-4 (CW-4) Jagadish Inamdar, the Deputy Superintendent, Sub-Division, Excise Department, Vijayapura, has stated that on 25.7.2015, in the afternoon, while he was in the office, he received an information from PW-1 Mujawar, the Excise Inspector, about he receiving an information that accused has stored large quantity of ganja in his house at Ward Crl.A.No.200183/2016 No.16 of Vijayapura. At the request of said Excise Inspector, he led the team of raid joined by other raiding team members, including panchas and other members and went to the house of the accused. Seeing these people, accused who was standing outside the house, went inside. Thus, a Search Related Report was prepared on the spot. After entering the house, these people searched the house only to notice that beneath the cot in the Hall, twentyone bundles of ganja covered with brown colour paper were kept. When enquired, the accused has stated that he has brought the same from Hyderabad to sell at Vijayapura for profit. Each of the bundle were weighed and ascertained that they were weighing 2 Kgs. each. About 50 grams of ganja from each of the packet was taken out and sealed separately and retained as a sample. The witness has also stated that when the Hall was examined carefully, they noticed a copy of the Crl.A.No.200183/2016 application for the Ration Card and an Electricity bill with R.R.No.84783 kept in the window. They collected those two documents and noticed that electricity meter of that house also bears the number as No.84783. When the neighbours were enquired, they stated that the accused was residing in the said house and has been selling ganja, but, they refused to give their names and identity. The witness has identified the panchanama at Ex.P-7 and sample of the seized articles at MO-1 to MO-21. After returning to the Station, PW-1 lodged a complaint. The witness adhered to his original version in his cross-examination also.
14. PW-5 (CW-8) Ningaiah, an Excise Guard in the office of the Deputy Commissioner of Excise has stated that, at the instruction of PW-1, his superior, he secured two panchas i.e., Rudrappa Kumbar and Vinod Crl.A.No.200183/2016 Shahapeti and produced them before PW-1. Those two panchas have agreed to be panchas in the raid. The witness has also stated that, thereafter he joined PWs.1, 3, 4, 6 and other staff in the raid. All of them went to the house of the accused, where a Search Related Report was written as the accused did not cooperate for the search. The accused got himself identified as Kutubuddin Rajaksab Kasabhag. When the house was searched, they did not notice anything in the kitchen, however, in the Hall beneath the cot, they noticed twentyone bundles wrapped in brown colour paper and containing ganja in it. In the said house, near the window, a copy of the application filed by the accused for a Ration Card and an electricity bill were also noticed and they were seized, which documents, the witness has identified at Exs.P-6 and P-5. The witness has also stated that twentyone bundles found in the house of the accused were weighed Crl.A.No.200183/2016 and each was weighing 2 Kgs. From each of the bundle, about 50 grams of ganja was taken out as sample and they were sealed separately. The witness has identified those samples at MO-1 to MO-21. He has identified the accused in the Court. The witness also stated that there were neighbours at the time of drawing panchanama, but, none of them have agreed to sign panchanama. The witness was adhered to his original version in his cross-examination.
15. PW-6 (CW-10) Anand is another Excise Guard in the Excise Department, who has stated that, based on the instruction by Sub-Inspector of Excise, he carried twentyone sample packets of ganja along with the covering letter to the Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL) at Bengaluru for getting them chemically examined. He has identified the covering letter at Ex.P-17. Crl.A.No.200183/2016 The witness has also stated that on 10.9.2015, once again with the instruction of his superior, he went to Forensic Science Laboratory at Bengaluru and collected the samples along with their report at Ex.P-18. He has identified the sample articles at MO-1 to MO-21. The denial suggestions made to him in his cross- examination were not admitted as true by the witness.
16. PW-7 (CW-11) Smt.Rajakbee Kasabhag, in her evidence has stated that accused is her son. She also stated that she has no house at Mahatma Gandhi Ashraya Colony. She also stated that she has not obtained any electrical connection with R.R.No.84783. She pleaded her ignorance about the said incident of illegally storing of ganja. She was treated as hostile and prosecution was permitted to cross-examine her. However, prosecution could not get any support in her cross-examination. Crl.A.No.200183/2016
17. PW-8 (CW-12) Savita Koliwad, the Driver in the office of the Deputy Commissioner of Excise at Vijayapura has stated that, on the date of the raid, she was also there in the team as a driver. She came to know that the said house stands in the name of Rajakbee, the mother of the accused/appellant. She was residing separately on the ground of her alleged ill-health. The witness has stated that mother of the accused has stated that in the house under the raid, it was the accused who was residing and she was residing separately. The denial suggestions made to her in her cross- examination were not admitted as true.
18. PW-9 (CW-13) Jamal Ahamed, the Sub- Inspector in the office of the Deputy Commissioner, Excise Department at Vijayapura, has stated that, after taking further investigation from PW-1 on 16.8.2015, he sent twnetyone sample packets seized in this matter for Crl.A.No.200183/2016 their chemical examination to Forensic Science Laboratory at Bengaluru. He has also sent a request letter as per Ex.P-17 to Forensic Science Laboratory. On 29.8.2015, his staff Anand Nagur (PW-6) submitted a request at Forensic Science Laboratory and produced the acknowledgement before him. On 29.8.2015, the KEB, Vijayapura, confirmed that the electrical connection of the said house stands in the name of Rajakbee Kasabhag, which the witness has identified at Ex.P-16. He has also stated that on 10.9.2015, he sent PW-6 Anand Nagur to collect FSL report and samples, which the said witness did and gave his statement. The witness also stated that, by his enquiry, he noticed that the said house though stands in the name of the mother of the accused, but, it was the accused who was residing in the said house. During the course of investigation, he collected the details from Municipal Corporation, Vijayapura, about the ownership of the house and also Crl.A.No.200183/2016 recorded the statement of the mother of the accused and after completing the investigation, on 11.12.2015, has filed the charge sheet against the accused. The denial suggestions made to him in his cross-examination were not admitted as true by this witness.
19. Two interlocutory applications are pending in this appeal, one is IA.No.2/2019 filed under Section 389(1) of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter for brevity referred to as `Cr.P.C.), seeking suspension of sentence and enlarging the appellant/accused on bail. The second application is IA.No.1/2020 filed under Section 482 of Cr.P.C., seeking consideration of Paragraph Nos.9 and 10 of memorandum of appeal as not part of the appeal. In view of the fact that the matter was taken up for its final disposal and final argument on the main appeal itself is heard, learned Crl.A.No.200183/2016 counsel for the appellant has not pressed these two applications.
20. The first point of argument of learned counsel for the appellant is that the prosecution has failed to prove that the alleged seized goods of 21 bundles of alleged ganja was in possession of the accused. In the absence of proof of any such possession, no presumption under Section 35 of NDPS Act regarding the culpable mental state of an accused can be presumed. In his support, learned counsel relied upon two judgments of Honble Apex Court. The first judgment is in Bhola Singh vs- State of Punjab, in Criminal Appeal No.448/2006, disposed of on 8.2.2011. In the said case, the Honble Apex Court was pleased to observe that, Section
35 of NDPS Act imposes a heavy reverse burden on an accused, the condition for the applicability of this and other related Sections would have to be spelt out on Crl.A.No.200183/2016 facts and it was only after the prosecution had discharged the initial burden to prove the foundational of facts that Section 35 would come into play. The second judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the appellant is that in Mohan Lal vs- State of Rajasthan, in Criminal Appeal No.1393/2010, disposed of on 17.4.2015, in Paragraph-16 of its judgment, the Honble Apex Court was pleased to observe as below : The term possession for the purpose of Section 18 of the NDPS Act could mean physical possession with animus, custody or dominion over the prohibited substance with animus or even exercise of dominion and control as a result of concealment. The animus and the mental intent which is the primary and significant element to show and establish possession. Further, personal knowledge as to the existence of the chattel i.e. the illegal substance at a particular location or site, at a relevant time and the intention based upon the Crl.A.No.200183/2016 knowledge, would constitute the unique relationship and manifest possession. In such a situation, presence and existence of possession could be justified, for the intention is to exercise right over the substance or the chattel and to act as the owner to the exclusion of others.
21. Learned High Court Government Pleader in his argument on the point of possession, relied upon a judgment of Honble Apex Court in Bahadur Singh vs- State of Haryana, reported in [(2010) 4 SCC 445], wherein with respect to the concept of `conscious possession under NDPS Act, the Honble Apex Court was pleased to observe about the facts in the case before it that six bags, each containing 32 Kgs. Of popply husk was recovered from the premises of the petitioner which was opened by him with a key in his possession. Thus, it was held that conscious possession of contraband was proved. Crl.A.No.200183/2016
22. In the instant case, as observed above, PW-1 the Excise Inspector, PW-2 the pancha in the raiding team, PW-3 another Excise Inspector, PW-4 the Deputy Superintendent of Excise and PW-5 the Excise Guard, have all uniformly stated that when they raided the house of the accused, the accused was present in the house. Initially the accused who was standing outside his house, after seeing these people in Uniform approaching his house, went inside his house. These witnesses have further stated that, at the enquiry of the raiding team, he disclosed his identity and after knowing the identity and purpose of visit of the raiding team, he allowed them to conduct search in the house. No where any of the witnesses have stated that at the enquiry of the officers of the raiding team, the accused informed them that he is not the occupant of the said house. Had really the accused was not the occupant of the said house and not in the possession of the seized goods, Crl.A.No.200183/2016 he should have definitely told the raiding team on the spot itself that the said house is no where related or connected to him and that he is not the occupant of the said house. Therefore, these facts go to show that accused was the occupant and in possession of the said house and he was the possessor of the seized goods.
23. In addition to the above, all the material witnesses have also stated that the raiding team during the search have noticed the presence of an Electricity bill and a copy of application submitted to the concerned Department asking for issuance of a Ration Card. Among them, PW-1 and PW-4 have further in clear terms stated that the said Electricity bill was with respect to R.R.No.84783. The very same R.R. number was mentioned on the Electricity Meter installed in the said house. Further, these witnesses have also stated that the application for sanction of Ration Card was made by the accused himself and in his name. Further Crl.A.No.200183/2016 the reply issued by HESCOM, Vijayapura, as per Ex.P-16 would go to show that electricity connection to the said house was standing in the name of Smt.B.R.Kasabhag. The said Smt.Kasabhag is PW-11 Rajakbee Kasabhag. Though she has stated that she has not obtained any electricity connection in her name to the house from where the alleged goods were seized, but, the accused being her son, it cannot be expected that she supports the case of the prosecution. On the other hand, PW-8 has stated that the said house was standing in the name of the mother of the accused. As such, the Corporation authorities vide their reply at Ex.P-14 have stated that the said house does not stand in the name of the accused. PW-9, the Investigating Officer has stated that his investigation revealed that the said house was standing in the name of the mother of the accused. He has stated that mother of the accused had taken the said house under lease from one Sri Parashuram Raju Crl.A.No.200183/2016 Ballari, who was the original allottee of the site. Though the Investigating Officer has not recorded the statement of said original allottee Sri Parashuram Raju Ballari, still, the evidence of the material witnesses, more particularly, PWs.1, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 9 and the document at Exs.P-5 and P-6 go to prove that it was the accused who was residing in the said house and was in actual possession of the twentyone bundles of contraband goods. Therefore, the argument of learned counsel for the appellant that the prosecution has failed to prove the factual possession of the contraband goods by the accused is not acceptable.
24. The second argument of learned counsel for the appellant was that the material seized was not proved to be ganja. PW-2, the pancha in his cross- examination has stated that, in the seized goods, fruits and flowers were not there, but, dried ganja leaves were there. However, in the cross-examination, the very Crl.A.No.200183/2016 same witness has stated that apart from the leaves, the powder of the seeds which was ganja were also there. However, he further stated that since the Excise Inspector told him that contents of twentyone seized bundles were ganja, he came to know that they were ganja. As such, when he himself has no specific knowledge as to what is ganja, his statement that the seized goods were containing only leaves of ganja, is not safe to believe upon.
25. PW-1, the Excise Inspector who was part of the raiding team has stated that when they opened all the twentyone bundles seized in the house of the accused, they noticed that they were containing dried ganja in them. The said witness in his cross-examination has further stated that he has undergone the training with respect to narcotic drug from Narcotic Drugs Control Bureau at Bengaluru. He denied the suggestion that the seized articles did not possess flowering and fruiting Crl.A.No.200183/2016 tops in it. When a specific question was put to the witness as to whether he has separated flowering and fruiting tops in the seized articles, he replied stating that the seized articles were containing only flowering and fruiting tops, as such, the question of bifurcating them did not arise. With the said detailed answer, the witness has made it clear that he is an expert in identifying the ganja and that the seized articles of the ganja containing flowering and fruiting tops in them. Section 2(iii) (b) of NDPS Act defines ganja as cannabis (hemp) means, ganja, that is, the flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis plant (excluding the seeds and leaves when not accompanied by the tops) by whatever name they may be known or designated. The answer given by PW-1, the Excise Inspector that the entire seized goods were containing flowering and fruiting tops only and that he had undergone the training in Narcotic Drugs would go to show that the Crl.A.No.200183/2016 witness is able to make out the difference between the ganja as defined under the NDPS Act with other articles, including rest of the part of the ganja plant. As such, he has identified the entire goods as ganja only. PW-3 though has stated in his examination-in-chief that when they opened twentyone seized bundles, they noticed the dried ganja in them, but, in his cross-examination he has stated that he noticed mixture of the dried ganja leaves and powder and seeds. However, to a specific question as to whether the small stems with flowers and fruits were there, the witness has answered in the negative. Relying upon the said statement, learned counsel submitted that one of the raiding team member has stated that there were no fruits and flowers, as such, the seized goods was not ganja. However, a careful reading of the evidence of PW-3, more particularly, the question put to him and the Crl.A.No.200183/2016 answer given by him which is mentioned above clearly go to show that the question that was put to the witness is not about the presence of flowers and fruits of ganja, but, it was about the presence of small stems containing the flowers and fruits in them. For the said question, it was more concentrated on the presence of the stems, as such, the witness has stated that they were not. By the said answer, since it cannot be inferred that there were no flowering or fruiting tops of ganja in the seized goods, the said interpretation as attempted to be canvassed by the learned counsel for the appellant in the statement of PW-3 in his cross- examination, is not acceptable.
26. Thirdly, the samples collected from the seized goods from each of the bundles were sent to their chemical examination to the Forensic Science Laboratory. The report of the said Laboratory is at Ex.P-18. The said report while describing the article Crl.A.No.200183/2016 examined by it, has mentioned about its microscopic characteristic in the following manner :
Small quantity of the grinded sample is treated with alcoholic potassium hydroxide and observed under stereo microscope. Non glandular hair (trichomes), numerous, unicellular, rigid, curved with a slender pointed apex and an enlarged base containing crystolithic hairs are observed. These microscopic features found on the surface of the fruiting and flowering tops are the characteristic features of cannabis in Sl.No.1.In its opinion in the same report, the Laboratory has opined that the samples found in the plastic packets have responded positive for ganja (cannabis) and cannabis contain psychoactive constituents. Thus, the Forensic Science Laboratory in its report has clearly found the presence of microscopic features which can be found on the surface of the flowering and fruiting tops. Thus, the chemical test has responded positive about Crl.A.No.200183/2016 the presence of ganja. Had there not been presence of flowering or fruiting tops of the cannabis plant, the samples of the seized articles would not have responded in positive in the test. Therefore, the argument of learned counsel for the appellant that the seized articles did not answer the definition of ganja, is also not acceptable.
27. Fourthly, it was the argument of learned counsel for the appellant that the prosecution has not established that the officer who has received the information has not sent a copy thereof to his immediate superior officer, as such, Section 42(2) of NDPS Act is not complied. In his support, he relied upon two judgments of Honble Apex Court. Firstly, in Abdul Rashid Ibrahim Mansuri vs- State of Gujarat, in Appeal (Criminal) No.78/1992, disposed of on 01.02.2000. In the said judgment, the Honble Apex Court was pleased to Crl.A.No.200183/2016 observe that under Section 42(2), such empowered officer who takes down any information in writing or records the grounds under proviso to Section 42(1) should forthwith send a copy thereof to his immediate official superior. If there is total non-compliance of this provision, the same affects the prosecution case. In Karnail Singh vs- State of Haryana, in Criminal Appeal No.36/2003, disposed of on 29.07.2009, the Honble Apex Court, in Paragaraph-17 of the judgment, inter alia has observed as below :
17. In conclusion, what is to be noticed is Abdul Rashid did not require literal compliance with the requirements of Sections 42(1) and 42(2) nor did Sajan Abraham hold that the requirements of Section 42(1) and 42(2) need not be fulfilled at all. The effect of the two decisions was as follows : (a) The officer on receiving the information (of the nature referred to in Sub-section (1) of section 42) from any person had to record it in Crl.A.No.200183/2016 writing in the concerned Register and forthwith send a copy to his immediate official superior, before proceeding to take action in terms of clauses (a) to (d) of section 42(1). (b) But if the information was received when the officer was not in the police station, but while he was on the move either on patrol duty or otherwise, either by mobile phone, or other means, and the information calls for immediate action and any delay would have resulted in the goods or evidence being removed or destroyed, it would not be feasible or practical to take down in writing the information given to him, in such a situation, he could take action as per clauses (a) to (d) of section 42(1) and thereafter, as soon as it is practical, record the information in writing and forthwith inform the same to the official superior . (c) In other words, the compliance with the requirements of Sections 42 (1) and 42(2) in regard to writing down the information received and sending a copy thereof to the superior officer, should normally precede the entry, search and seizure by the officer. But in special circumstances involving emergent Crl.A.No.200183/2016 situations, the recording of the information in writing and sending a copy thereof to the official superior may get postponed by a reasonable period, that is after the search, entry and seizure. The question is one of urgency and expediency. (d) While total non-compliance of requirements of sub-sections (1) and (2) of section 42 is impermissible, delayed compliance with satisfactory explanation about the delay will be acceptable compliance of section 42. To illustrate, if any delay may result in the accused escaping or the goods or evidence being destroyed or removed, not recording in writing the information received, before initiating action, or non-sending a copy of such information to the official superior forthwith, may not be treated as violation of section 42. But if the information was received when the police officer was in the police station with sufficient time to take action, and if the police officer fails to record in writing the information received, or fails to send a copy thereof, to the official superior, then it will be a suspicious circumstance being a clear violation of section42 of the Act. Similarly, where the police Crl.A.No.200183/2016 officer does not record the information at all, and does not inform the official superior at all, then also it will be a clear violation of section
42 of the Act. Whether there is adequate or substantial compliance with section 42 or not is a question of fact to be decided in each case. The above position got strengthened with the amendment to section 42 by Act 9 of 2001.
28. Section 42(2) of NDPS Act reads as below :
Section 42(2) Where an officer takes down any information in writing under sub-section (1) or records grounds for his belief under the proviso thereto, he shall within seventy-two hours send a copy thereof to his immediate official superior.PW-1, the Excise Inspector in his examination-in- chief has stated that he has passed on the credible information received by him on 25.7.2015 about the accused illegally possessing the ganja, to his superiors. He has stated that he met the Deputy Superintendent of Excise Sri Jagadish Inamdar in person at his office and Crl.A.No.200183/2016 informed him about the credible information. Since Deputy Commissioner of Excise Sri Venkatesh Padaki had been to Bengaluru at that time, he passed on the information to him over the telephone and the said Deputy Commissioner granted him the permission over the phone to conduct a raid under the guidance of Deputy Superintendent of Excise. Further the very same witness has also stated that, after going to the house of the accused, since the accused after seeing the raiding team, went inside his house, he prepared a Search Related Report as per Ex.P-3. In the said report, he has mentioned it that he has drawn the said report in compliance of Section 42 of NDPS Act. Further, he has also stated that he submitted a report under Section 42(1) and Section 42(2) of NDPS Act to his superior on the same day as per Ex.P-12. The said exhibit clearly go to show that PW-1 has passed on the information in the form of his report in writing to the Deputy Crl.A.No.200183/2016 Commissioner of Excise on 25.7.2015 itself, which was received in the office of the addressee on the very same day. Thus, there is all the evidence to hold that there is no non-compliance of mandate under Section 42(2) of NDPS Act in the case. As such, the argument of learned counsel for the appellant on this point is also not acceptable. The learned counsel for the appellant further submitted that seized goods were not handled properly as it was sent for its chemical examination with the delay of nearly a month, as such, the case of the prosecution is doubtful.
28. Per contra, learned High Court Government Pleader in his argument submitted that, mere delay in sending the seized articles to Forensic Science Laboratory would not vitiate the case of the prosecution. In his support, he relied upon three reported judgments of Honble Apex Court as below : Crl.A.No.200183/2016
(i) In Mohan Lal vs- State of Rajasthan, reported in [(2015) 6 SCC 222], wherein also a contention was taken up by the appellant that there was delay in sending the seized contraband articles for its chemical examination. The Honble Apex Court observed that the seal being intact, the description of the case number and the impression of the seal having been fixed on memo of recovery, there is no reason or justification to discard the prosecution case on the ground of delay on the said scope.
(ii) In Ashok Kumar vs- State of Haryana, reported in [(2000) 2 SCC 592], with respect to the identification of the alleged charas said to have been recovered from the possession of the accused which were found faint on the packets produced before the Court, the Honble Apex Court has observed that, Chemical Analysers Report clearly established that the article examined by him were the articles connected with Crl.A.No.200183/2016 the accused. Further the accused neither having challenged the Chemical Analysers Report nor having pleaded for Chemical Analyser as a witness to establish that the seal and samples received by him were faint and unidentifiable. In such circumstances, doubts raised by the accused as to whether the sample seized were the same as examined by the Chemical Analyser, repel.
(iii) In Mohinder vs- State of Haryana, reported in [(2014) 15 SCC 641], with respect to Section 43 of NDPS Act and in which case also, delay in sending the contraband for examination by Forensic Science Laboratory was contended, the Honble Apex Court on considering the facts of the case, held that PW-2 who carried samples from Police Station to Laboratory was not asked any question in his cross-examination though opportunity was given to defence. The FSL report was showing that the sample was received at FSL intact with Crl.A.No.200183/2016 seal which tallied with specimen seals forwarded. Hence, the petition was held liable to be rejected.
29. In the instant case, even though the alleged contraband was seized on 25.7.2015, but, the Investigating Officer i.e., PW-9 sent it for its chemical examination to Forensic Science Laboratory only on 27.8.2015, thus, after a month of its seizure. The FSL repot which is at Ex.P-18 go to show that those goods were received by the said Laboratory on 28.8.2015 and the seals corresponds with the samples sent and the description tallied. Thus, the seals which were put by PW-1 on the spot when the samples were taken from the seized articles were found un-tampered and they corresponded with the sample sent to the Laboratory. Further, the carrier of the articles to the Forensic Science Laboratory though was examined as PW-2, but, nothing was elicited from his cross-examination from the accused side regarding the alleged delay in submitting Crl.A.No.200183/2016 the articles to Forensic Science Laboratory. Similarly, no relevant questions were put to PW-9, the Investigating Officer also in that regard by the accused. As such, in the light of the above judgments relied upon by the learned High Court Government Pleader, the mere alleged delay in sending of samples of alleged articles since has not proved to be led to any tampering of the article or meddling with the article, the alleged delay itself will not vitiate the case of the prosecution.
30. Lastly, learned counsel for the appellant in his argument submitted that PW-1 himself being the complainant, has also conducted the investigation to some extent, as such, the investigation is vitiated. In the instant case, PW-1 is the complainant and he is also an Excise Inspector. Apart from conducting the raid and seizing the article, the said witness has submitted FIR in the case and has written letters to the Electric Supply Company and the Municipality seeking clarification about Crl.A.No.200183/2016 the name of the person holding the electricity connection to the said premises and the ownership of the said premises. Except this, he has not done any activity in the process of investigation of the case. He has handed over further investigation to CW-13 (PW-9) who has continued the investigation, including receiving the replies from Electricity Company and Municipality, sending the samples of seized articles to Forensic Science Laboratory and collecting the report from the said Laboratory, recording the statements of the witnesses and filing charge sheet etc., No where it was shown from the accused side that the said act of PW-1 has resulted in mis-conducting any investigation in this case or the activities of PW-1 causing any prejudice to the interest of the accused.
31. Our Honble Apex Court in Mohan Lal vs- State of Punjab, reported in [(2018) 17 SCC 627], while dealing with Article 21 of the Constitution of India and Crl.A.No.200183/2016 the right of the accused to fair investigation and trial, had an occasion to make an observation about the informant himself investigating the case and its permissibility. The Honble Apex Court observed in the said case that, the appellants were found guilty of the offence under Section 8(c) read with Section 20(b)(ii) of NDPS Act. They were found in possession of narcotic drug (heroin). The case was registered against the appellants on the basis of the statement of PW-8 (Inspector) who had conducted the search. Before the Honble Apex Court, it was argued that PW-8 was the complainant and he himself conducted the investigation and hence the entire investigation of the case was vitiated. Noticing that nothing was pointed out to show that the said investigation has caused prejudice or was biased against the accused, the Honble Apex Court was pleased to dismiss the appeal. Crl.A.No.200183/2016
32. In the instant case, as already observed, merely because PW-1 complainant is said to have conducted the search and written letters to Electricity and Municipal authorities, by that itself, it cannot be held that he has conducted an important part of the investigation in the matter. Further, nothing has been shown from the accused side that the said acts of PW-1 has in any manner caused prejudice or was biased against him. As such, the contention of the appellant that the investigation conducted in the case is bad in the eye of law, is not acceptable.
33. Nothing more worth to be considered was addressed in the argument of learned counsel for the appellant. As already observed above, the prosecution through PWs-1 to 6 and 8 and 9 has beyond reasonable doubt established that the present accused was found in possession of 42 Kgs. of ganja in his house without any licence or permit to deal with it. The evidence of the Crl.A.No.200183/2016 prosecution witnesses also have proved that he has stored them illegally with an intention to sell them and make profit. Thus, the said proven act of the appellant/accused has constituted an offence under Section 8(c) of the NDPS Act, which is punishable under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) of NDPS Act. Thus, the judgment of conviction under appeal passed by the Special Court since based upon proper analysis of the evidence placed before it, I do not find any infirmity or error in the said judgment of conviction.
34. The Special Court has sentenced the accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of ten years and to pay fine of `1 lakh and in default of payment of fine, to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of one year for the proven offence. The said punishment being the minimum punishment and proportionate to the gravity of the proven guilt of the Crl.A.No.200183/2016 accused, I do not find any reason to interfere in the order on sentence passed by the Special Court.
Alert