Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Education Secretary,... v. L.B.S. B.Ed. College...

Rajasthan High Court
Jan 22, 2015
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Fifteen privately managed educational institutions applied to the National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) for recognition to conduct teacher education and to admit B.Ed. students for the 2014-15 academic year. They also applied for university affiliation and sought No Objection Certificates (NOCs) from the State Government of Rajasthan. The common entrance counselling was scheduled and, by the calendar, was closed on 08.09.2014. The State Government refused to grant NOCs on the ground that the State already had a large number of B.Ed. colleges and sanctioned seats (an annual intake of 91,690 students, 793 colleges statewide and 137 in Jaipur district), and that additional seats (an academic survey indicating 62,137 seats from 2009-10 to 2016-17) would exceed the actual demand for teacher trainees and risk student exploitation and unemployment.

The institutions challenged the refusal by way of writ petitions. Relying on the Supreme Court's decision in State of Maharashtra v. Sant Dnyaneshwar Shikshan Shastra Mahavidyalaya, the Single Judge allowed the writ petitions on 04.09.2014 and directed that the petitioner institutions could participate in counselling, that the respondent university would consider affiliation subject to requirements, and that the State would immediately issue NOCs in light of the Apex Court judgment.

On 24.11.2014 an interim order stayed the effect and operation of the Single Judge's 04.09.2014 judgment. The stay was granted on two principal grounds: (1) the Single Judge had issued blanket directions, and (2) the required minimum number of teaching days (200 days then, later discussed as 180 days under substituted regulations) could not be completed in the remaining part of the 2014-15 academic year if students were admitted at that late stage. The State-appellants then filed Special Leave Petitions; one college later did not press its SLP before the Supreme Court which dismissed it as not pressed. The High Court noted that the question whether excess capacity relative to demand could justify refusal of NOCs was not considered by the Single Judge and reserved that question for decision on merits after hearing the parties. Ultimately the High Court allowed the Special Appeals, set aside the Single Judge's orders, and held that the colleges may admit students for the 2015-16 academic year subject to the NCTE guidelines issued on 28.11.2014.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the State Government may refuse to grant a No Objection Certificate to private B.Ed. institutions on the basis that the existing capacity (number of sanctioned seats/colleges) in the State exceeds the actual demand for teacher trainees.
  2. Whether the Single Judge's directions to permit the petitioner institutions to participate in counselling and to require immediate issuance of NOCs by the State (in the light of Sant Dnyaneshwar) were appropriate, or whether such blanket directions should be stayed.
  3. Whether institutions that obtained NCTE recognition but did not obtain university affiliation and/or NOC before the prescribed cut-off date are entitled to be included in counselling held earlier and to admissions during the same academic session.
  4. Whether courts may direct admissions in mid-academic session when prescribed norms (minimum working days / practice teaching days) cannot reasonably be complied with, having regard to students' interests and quality of education.

Arguments of the Parties

State-Appellants' Arguments

  • The State refused to grant NOCs based on the NCTE academic survey and its own data showing an already large number of B.Ed. colleges and seats; granting more NOCs would create excess capacity relative to demand and lead to student exploitation and unemployment.
  • The Single Judge erred in issuing blanket directions relying on Sant Dnyaneshwar without considering the State's policy decision and the relevant data supporting refusal.
  • Ordinarily, the role of the State at the second stage (after NCTE recognition) is formal, but here the State relied on relevant data and took a policy decision not to grant NOCs to new private B.Ed. institutions until 2015; this was a legitimate consideration.
  • Practical and calendar constraints: by the time of the proceedings a large portion of the teaching calendar had passed (more than five months), so new admissions could not complete the required minimum teaching days for 2014-15.

Respondent-Institutions' (Colleges') Arguments

  • Once recognition is granted by the NCTE and affiliation is obtained, the State Government cannot refuse NOC merely on the ground that the overall capacity in the State is in excess of demand; capacity of new colleges taken together is not a valid ground for refusal.
  • The substituted Regulations provided for 180 working days (down from 200), and the colleges asserted they could complete the required days (including practice teaching) by teaching on Sundays and holidays and by carrying teaching from January to August 2015.

Coordinator, PTET (Intervenor/Registrar) Arguments

  • The fifteen institutions were required to fulfil all conditions (affiliation and NOC) before 04.07.2014 to be permitted to participate in counselling, which was scheduled to close on 02.09.2014 and actually concluded on 08.09.2014.
  • The appellant colleges obtained university affiliations only in October 2014, after the counselling deadline; therefore they did not meet the cut-off and were not entitled to participate in the counselling.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Maharashtra v. Sant Dnyaneshwar Shikshan Shastra Mahavidyalaya [(2006) 9 SCC 1] Established authority relied upon by the Single Judge to allow institutions to participate in counselling and obtain NOCs once recognition/affiliation processes are favorable. The Single Judge relied on this judgment to permit participation in counselling. The High Court observed the Single Judge had chosen to rely upon Sant Dnyaneshwar without considering the State's grounds and stayed that direction to consider the matter on merits.
Maa Vaishno Devi Mahila Mahavidyalaya v. State of Uttar Pradesh [(2013) 2 SCC 617] Explains the two-stage process: NCTE examines recognition applications and seeks State comments; normally the State's role is formal at the second stage once recognition is granted and affiliation is acceptable; authorities must adhere to prescribed schedules. The High Court cited and relied on paragraphs 79–81 to discuss the role of the State and the importance of adherence to the schedule, acknowledging both the limited role of the State in normal circumstances and the requirement that State comments be reasoned and timely. The decision was considered in assessing the State's conduct and the Single Judge's reliance on Sant Dnyaneshwar.
Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission v. Mukesh Thakur [(2010) 6 SCC 759] Courts should not direct admission in mid-academic session as such directions disturb other students and may prevent the late-admitted student from completing required attendance and practical classes; quality of education cannot be compromised. The High Court relied on this precedent to support the proposition that admission at a belated stage is generally impermissible and to justify refusing directions that would admit students mid-session for 2014-15.
Pramod Kumar Joshi v. Medical Council of India [(1991) 2 SCC 179] Referenced as authority underlying the rule against permitting admissions mid-academic session where required teaching/clinical/practical exposure cannot be ensured. Referenced by the High Court (through citation in Mukesh Thakur) to reinforce the general principle that courts should not order mid-session admissions that compromise educational standards.
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Dr. Anupam Gupta (AIR 1992 SC 932 / 1993 Supp (1) SCC 594) Referenced among authorities disfavoring mid-session admissions where attendance and course completion requirements cannot be met. Used as part of the batch of authorities (via Mukesh Thakur) to justify refusing to permit late admissions for the academic year 2014-15.
State of Punjab v. Renuka Singla [(1994) 1 SCC 175 : AIR 1994 SC 595] Another authority cited for the principle that late admission can disturb the course and affect quality of education; courts should avoid directing mid-session admissions. Referred to in support of the same principle that persuaded the High Court against permitting late admissions.
Medical Council of India v. Madhu Singh [(2002) 7 SCC 258] Part of the jurisprudence that disallows judicial directions for mid-session admission when it would compromise the course requirements and standards. Included among authorities relied upon in Mukesh Thakur and cited by the High Court to support refusal of mid-session admissions.
Mridul Dhar (Minor) v. Union of India [(2005) 2 SCC 65] Included in the line of cases limiting courts from issuing directions for admissions in the middle of an academic session. Referred to (via Mukesh Thakur) to reinforce the caution against mid-session admissions adopted by the High Court.
Bhartia Education Society (referenced in Maa Vaishno Devi) Authority cited for the view that the role of the State Government is limited to manner of admission and eligibility criteria and should not interfere with NCTE-prescribed recognition conditions. Cited in the High Court's discussion of Maa Vaishno Devi to explain the contours of the State's limited role; the High Court noted that State's role must be within the framework of the Act, Regulations and recognition conditions.
St. John Teachers Training Institute (referenced in Maa Vaishno Devi) Authority indicating the State Government must confine itself to NCTE guidelines when considering grant of NOC. Referred to in the High Court's exposition of Maa Vaishno Devi to show that the State must ordinarily follow NCTE guidelines in considering NOC applications.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court's analysis proceeded in several interrelated strands, based on the materials and arguments before it:

  1. Blanket Directions and Procedural Fairness: The Court observed that the Single Judge had issued blanket directions (allowing participation in counselling and immediate issuance of NOCs) primarily relying on Sant Dnyaneshwar without addressing the State's specific reasons for refusal. The High Court found that issuing such blanket directions could create practical difficulties for the State in balancing student supply with employment absorptive capacity and could lower educational standards if intake was increased indiscriminately.
  2. State's Concern About Excess Capacity: The High Court recognised prima facie the legitimacy of the State's concern that an excessively large number of B.Ed. seats would create unemployment and exploitation of students. The Court noted that the question whether excess capacity relative to demand is a valid ground for refusing NOCs had not been considered by the Single Judge and therefore the matter should be decided on merits after hearing the parties.
  3. Role of the State vis-à-vis NCTE and Adherence to Schedule: Relying on the principles explained in Maa Vaishno Devi, the Court acknowledged that normally the State's role at the post-recognition/affiliation stage is limited and procedural. However, the Court also stressed adherence to prescribed schedules under the Regulations (schedules that govern timelines for recognition, affiliation and admissions) and that exceptions to the schedule cannot be casually carved out. The State must provide reasoned comments within timelines; conversely, once recognition and valid affiliation are in place, the State ordinarily should not obstruct commencement of admissions unless there is a serious vitiating factor.
  4. Cut-off Dates and Factual Compliance: The Court accepted the Coordinator PTET's point that the colleges had to fulfil conditions (affiliation and NOC) by the cut-off date of 04.07.2014 to be included in counselling. The colleges obtained affiliations only in October 2014, after counselling had closed; therefore they did not meet the procedural cut-off that governed inclusion in the counselling process.
  5. Academic Calendar and Minimum Teaching Days: The Court placed paramount importance on students' interests and educational standards. It referenced the NCTE norms (para 2.2) prescribing a minimum number of working days and practice teaching days (quoted in the opinion as at least 180 working days under the substituted Regulations). Drawing on the Supreme Court's jurisprudence (Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission v. Mukesh Thakur and related authorities), the High Court reasoned that courts should not direct admissions mid-session when the requisite attendance and practical teaching cannot reasonably be met, because such directions would harm both existing students and those admitted late.
  6. Balance of Equities and Motive of Litigants: The Court noted that none of the individual students who had succeeded in PTET and missed admission filed writ petitions; rather, the colleges filed writ petitions primarily to protect their investments in infrastructure and faculty. The Court highlighted that equities must favour students (their training and subsequent competence), not colleges seeking to protect commercial investments.
  7. Interim Relief and Final Disposition: In view of the above considerations—the procedural default on cut-off dates, the State's policy and data-based concerns, the impracticability of conducting the requisite teaching days within the remaining academic year, and the risk to educational standards—the Court stayed the Single Judge's blanket directions and decided to allow the Special Appeals on merits, setting aside the Single Judge's orders. The Court permitted the colleges to admit students only for the next academic year (2015-16), subject to compliance with the NCTE guidelines issued on 28.11.2014.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The High Court allowed all the Special Appeals, set aside the orders passed by the learned Single Judge dated 04.09.2014, and held that the fifteen colleges would not be permitted to be admitted into counselling or to admit students for the academic year 2014-15. The Court directed that the colleges may admit students for the academic year 2015-16 only upon fulfillment of the new guidelines issued by the NCTE on 28.11.2014.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on parties: The colleges were denied relief to secure admissions for the 2014-15 academic year; they can seek to admit students only in the subsequent year (2015-16) subject to compliance with NCTE guidelines and other procedural requirements (affiliation, NOC, adherence to schedule).
  • Procedural and policy consequence: The decision underscores the importance of adherence to cut-off dates, timelines and prescribed schedules for recognition/affiliation/admissions and recognizes that the State may legitimately rely on data-based policy decisions (concerning capacity and demand) while exercising its limited role at the second stage—particularly where issues of employment absorption and educational standards arise.
  • On precedent and standards: The Court applied established authorities restricting judicially directed mid-session admissions to protect educational standards and student interests. The order did not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond applying existing case law and the NCTE norms; it confined its relief to setting aside the Single Judge's blanket directions and granting admission rights prospectively subject to compliance with regulatory requirements.

A copy of the High Court's order was directed to be placed in all connected files.

Show all summary ...

1. We have heard learned counsel appearing for the parties.

2. Fifteen Educational Institutions under private management applied for recognition to the National Council for Teachers Education, Delhi (for short, ‘the NCTE’) for conducting education research and training in teacher education, and to admit the students for B.Ed. Courses for the year 2014-15. They also applied for affiliation to the Universities in the State of Rajasthan, and for Objection Certificate from the State Government. After the Common Entrance Examination, in which these institutions were not included the counselling was closed on 08.09.2014. Before the counselling could be closed for the academic session 2014-15, the State Government refused to grant No Objection Certificate to these institutions on the ground that there are total number of 793 B.Ed. Colleges in Rajasthan, which are quite adequate. The number of the candidates, who are pursuing B.Ed. Course, are far in excess to the total number of new teachers required in the State of Rajasthan. The State Government was of the view that with an annual intake of 91690 students in the B.Ed. Colleges in the State of Rajasthan, in accordance with the academic survey conducted by the NCTE, the State of Rajasthan will have 62137 students between the academic sessions 2009-10 to 2016-17, which would be in excess of the actual demand of teacher trainees in the State of Rajasthan. The letter dated 13.05.2011 sent by the Joint Secretary, Higher Education, Government of Rajasthan to the Regional Director (NRC, NCTE), Jaipur, and the consequent refusal to issue a No Objection Certificate was challenged by the appellants in a writ petition before learned Single Judge.

3. Relying upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra v. Sant Dnyaneshwar Shikshan Shastra Mahavidyalaya, [(2006) 9 SCC 1], the writ petitions were allowed on 04.09.2014 with directions to the effect that the petitioner institutions would be entitled to participate in the counselling for admitting the students. The respondent-University will consider the petitioner institutions for affiliation, subject to fulfillment of all requirements and the State of Rajasthan would immediately issue No Objection Certificate in favour of the petitioners in the light of the judgment of the Apex Court.

4. On 24.11.2014, by an interim order, the effect and operation of the judgment dated 04.09.2014 was stayed on the ground that the Court could not have given blanked directions and further that the compulsory lectures of 200 days will not be completed in the remaining part of the academic year in pursuance to the norms and standards for Bachelor of Education programme leading to B.Ed., Degree for the academic year 2014-15. The interim order, dated 24.11.2014 is quoted as below:

“We have heard learned counsel appearing for the State-appellants and learned counsel for the respondents.

The delay of 5 days in filing the Special Appeal has been explained with good and sufficient grounds. The delay Is condoned.

The reply would be filed to the Special Appeal within two weeks.

List for hearing in the second week of January, 2015.

The State of Rajasthan is aggrieved by the directions issued by learned Single Judge that the petitioner-lnstitutions would be entitled to participate in the counselling for admission of the students, and that the respondent-University will consider the petitioner-Institutions for affiliation, subject to fulfillment of requirements, and that the State of Rajasthan would immediately issue No Objection Certificate in favour of the petitioner-lnstitutions, in the light of the judgment of the Apex Court.

The State of Rajasthan has refused to issue No Objection Certificate to the respondent-Colleges, for admission in the B.Ed. Course for the year 2014-15. The grounds, for refusing to issue No Objection Certificate for the year 2014-15, are based upon the survey conducted by the National Council for Teacher Education, Delhi (for short, ‘the NCTE). In the letter dated 13.05.2014 sent by the Joint Secretary, Higher Education, Government of Rajasthan to the Regional Director (NRC, NCTE), National Council for Teacher Education, Jaipur, it is stated:—

“With reference to your above mentioned letter as directed it is submitted that the application of L.B.S.B.Ed. College Jaipur for grant of No Objection Certificate for recognition for B.Ed. Course has been considered by the State Government in the light of direction of the Jaipur Bench of Rajasthan High Court in Civil Writ Petition no. 3654/2014, dated 04.04.2014.

It has been observed that:

(1) B.Ed. Colleges are already running in Jaipur district with an annual intake of 15600 Students.

(2) B.Ed. Colleges are already running in the State of Rajasthan with an annual intake of 91,690 Students.

(3) The academic survey conducted by the NCTE, Delhi points out that for the State of Rajasthan from 2009-10 to 2016-17, 62,137 seats would be far in excess of the actual demand for teacher trainees.

Keeping in view the above mentioned position, the State Government is of the view that the number of existing 137 Colleges in Jaipur District is quite adequate. Also, the total number of existing 793 Colleges in the State of Rajasthan is quite adequate and the number of candidates who are completing their B.Ed. Course each year from these Colleges is far in excess of the total number of new teachers required in the State of Rajasthan.

Permitting new private B.Ed. Colleges in the State would lead to exploitation of students. They will pay high fees but not get employment, since the job opportunities are less than the number of trained teachers already passing out each year from the B.Ed. Seats already sanctioned in the existing institutions.

Therefore, the State Government is of the considered view that No Objection Certificate should not be granted to L.B.S.B.Ed. College Jaipur Rajasthan for setting up a B.Ed. Education institution.

Moreover, looking to the overall position of seats already sanctioned in the State for B.Ed. Course, which is already in excess, as pointed out above, it is further stated that the refusal to grant No Objection Certificate is not restricted to this institution only. The State Government has taken a policy decision not to grant No Objection Certificate to any new private B.Ed. Institution in the State till 2015.”

Learned Single Judge has noted the grounds, on which the No Objection Certificate was refused, he has not considered the validity of the grounds, and has rather chosen the rely upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra v. Sant Dnyaneshwar Shikshan Shastra Mahavidyalaya, [(2006) 9 SCC 1].

It is submitted by learned counsel appearing for the State-appellants that the question as to whether the excess capacity, in any particular State of the actual demand of teacher trainees, could be a ground to refuse the No Objection Certificate, was not considered by the Apex Court, nor learned Single Judge has considered the grounds of refusal to be untenable. He submits that an annual intake capacity of 91,690 students in B.Ed. colleges in the State of Rajasthan and the excess capacity created in the new colleges of 62,137 seats would be far in excess of the actual demand of teacher trainees.

Learned counsel appearing for the respondent-Institutions has submitted that one the recognition is granted by NCTE, and that affiliation is obtained from the University, the State Government cannot deny No Objection Certificate on the ground that the overall capacity of the students in the State of Rajasthan, or Jaipur is in excess of the demand of teacher trainees, he submits that the capacity of the new Colleges, taken together in the State of Rajasthan, is not a ground, on which No Objection Certificate could be refused by the State Government.

Prima facie, we find that it is a concern of the State Government to ensure that there are sufficient number of colleges for B.Ed. Course, so that there is no shortage of teachers in the State of Rajasthan. In case, the number of colleges and the intake is extremely high, the State Government can justifiably refuse the admission on the ground that the number of trainee teachers will be far and excess of the actual demand of teacher trainees, to avoid the issue of unemployment in future: The mushroom growth of Colleges offering B.Ed. Courses in the State of Rajasthan, has compounded the problem.

Prima facie, we find that since this question has not been considered by learned Single Judge, it would be appropriate to decide the matter on merits after hearing the parties at an early date.

We are of the view that in the meantime, the blanked directions issued by learned Single Judge, would create a difficulty for the State Government in adjusting the number of students with B.Ed. Degrees, for the purposes of giving employment, and further that high intake will also lower down the standards of education.

Learned counsel appearing for the State-appellants also informs the Court that by this time, more than five months of the calender, for teaching, is over, and that the respondent would not be able to complete the compulsory 200 days of lectures, in the remaining part of the academic year in pursuance to the norms and standards for Bachelor of Education programme leading to B.Ed. Degree for the year 2014-15. The counselling has also been closed, according to the calender, on 08.09.2014.

For the aforesaid reasons, until further orders, the effect and operation of the impugned judgment dated 04.09.2014 shall remain stayed.”

5. Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the L.B.S. B.Ed College had filed Petition for Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No(s). 35259-35260/2014, in which on 18.12.2014, the Supreme Court passed the following orders:

‘Taken on board.

The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the Petitioner states that as the Petition has been set out for hearing before the Division Bench of High Court on 9th January, 2015, he does not with to press the Special Leave Petitions. The petitions are dismissed as not pressed.”

6. It is submitted by learned counsel appearing for the State-appellants that after the judgment in Sant Dnyaneshwar Shikshan Shastra Mahavidyalaya (supra), the Supreme Court has rendered on 13.12.2012 a judgment in Maa Vaishno Devi Mahila Mahavidyalaya v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [(2013) 2 SCC 617], in which it was held in paragraph Nos. 79, 80 & 81 as follows:

79. It is on record and the Regulations framed under the Act clearly show that upon receiving an application for recommendation, the NCTE shall send a copy of the application with its letter inviting recommendations/comments of the State Government on all aspects within a period of 30 days. To such, application, the State is expected to respond with its complete comments within a period of 60 days. In other words, the opinion of the State on all matters that may concern it in any of the specified fields a recalled for. This is the stage where the State and its Department should play a vital role. They must take all precautions to offer proper comments supported by due reasoning. Once these comments are sent and the State Government gives its opinion which is considered by the NCTE and examined in conjunction with the report of the experts, it may grant or refuse recognition. Once it grants recognition, then such grant attains supremacy viz-a-viz the State Government as well as the affiliating body. Normally, these questions cannot be re-agitated at the time of grant of affiliation. Once the University conducts inspection in terms of its Statutes or Act, without offending the provisions of the Act and conditions of recognition, then the opinion of the State Government at the second stage is a mere formality unless there was a drastic and unacceptable mistake or the entire process was vitiated by fraud or there was patently eminent danger to life of the students working in the school because of non-compliance of a substantive condition imposed by either of the bodies, in the normal circumstances, the role of the State is a very formal one and the State is not expected to obstruct the commencement of admission process and academic courses once recognition is granted and affiliation is found to be acceptable.

80. In Sant Dnyaneshwar Shikshan Shastra Mahavidyalaya (supra), the view of this Court was that the State Government has not role whatsoever. However, in the case of Bhartia Education Society (supra), it was stated that the role of the State Government was limited to the manner of admission, eligibility criteria, etc. without interfering with the conditions of recognition prescribed by the NCTE. the exercise of discretion by the State Government and affiliating body has to be within the framework of the Act, the Regulations and conditions of recognition. Even in St. John Teachers Training Institute (supra), the Court stated that the State Government or the Union Territory has to necessarily confine itself to the guidelines issued by the NCTE while considering application for grant of ‘No Objection Certificate’. Minimization of the role of the State at the second stage can also be justified on the ground that affiliation primarily is a subject matter of the University which is responsible for admission of the students laying down the criteria thereof, holding of examinations and implementation of the prescribed courses while maintaining the standards of education as prescribed.

81. Lastly, the question which is required to be discussed in light of the facts of the present cases is adherence to the Schedule. Once the relevant Schedules have been prescribed under the Regulations or under the Judge made law, none, whosoever it be, is entitled to carve out exceptions to the prescribed Schedule. Adherence to the Schedule is the essence of granting admission in a fair and transparent manner as well as to maintain the standards of education. The purpose of providing a time schedule is to ensure that all concerned authorities act within the stipulated time. Where, on he one hand, it places an obligation upon the authorities to act according to the Schedule, there it also provides complete clarity to other stakeholders as to when their application would either be accepted and/or rejected and what will be the time duration for it to be processed at different quarter. It also gives clear understanding to the students for whose benefit the entire process is set up as to when their examinations would be held, when results would be declared and when they are expected to take admission to different colleges in order of merit obtained by them in the entrance examinations or other processes for the purposes of subject and college preference.”

7. It is submitted by the Additional Advocate General that the State Government was conscious of a large number of students completing B.Ed. Course in the State, which will cause unemployment and a problem for the State of Rajasthan to accommodate them in the schools, and consequently a policy decision was taken not to grant No Objection Certificate to the appellants. It is submitted that ordinarily, as held in Maa Vaishno Devi Mahila Mahavidyalaya v. State of Uttar Pradesh (supra), the role of the State is very formal, and the State is not expected to obstruct the commencement of admission process and academic courses recognition is granted and affiliation is found to be acceptable; the State Government, having considered the data collected by the NCTE itself took a decision not to issue No Objection Certificate to any more colleges. In the present case, it is submitted that the appellant-Institutions were not issued No Objection Certificate on the ground that the number of persons, who will complete B.Ed. Course will be far in excess to be accommodated, which is a relevant consideration for the State Government for refusing the No Objection Certificate.

8. Mr. Kapil Choudhary, learned counsel appearing for the co-ordinator, Pre-Teachers Education Test (in short, ‘PTET’) informs the Court that the fifteen Institutions were required to fulfil all necessary conditions namely, the affiliations with the Universities and the No Objection Certificate to be issued by the State Government before 04.07.2014, as he counselling was scheduled to be closed on 02.09.2014, and was actually concluded on 08.09.2014. The appellant colleges got the affiliations from the Universities in the month of October, 2014 much after the counselling was closed. They did not fulfil the conditions for allowing the participation in the counselling upto 08.09.2014 when the counselling was actually closed. The refusal for No Objection Certificate by the State Government, was additional ground on which they were not allowed to take part in counselling.

9. We are faced with a piquant situation in these Special Appeals, inasmuch as, any relief to be granted to the appellant-lnstitutions on the ground that they have also developed infrastructure, for which they have invested huge amount, will not leave sufficient time, for the students at this stage, if they are permitted to be admitted after counselling, to complete the minimum of 180 days lectures of B.Ed. Programme recommended by the NCTE in its Regulations. Para 3(2.2) of the Norms and Standards for Secondary Teacher Education Programme leading to Bachelor of Education (B.Ed.) Degree is quoted as below:

“2.2 Working Days

(a) There shall be at least 180 working days exclusive of period of examination and admission etc., out of which at least 40 days shall be for practice teaching in about ten schools at upper primary/secondary/senior secondary level.

(b) A working day shall be of a minimum of 6 hours in a six-day week, during which physical presence in the institution of teachers and students-teachers is necessary to ensure their availability for individual advice, guidance, dialogues and consultation as and when needed.”

10. We are informed by learned counsel appearing for the respondents that in the substituted Regulations of 2009, which are applicable now, the period of 200 days has been substituted by 180 days, and that the respondents will be able to complete 180 days of teaching, if they are allowed to teach on Sundays and on holidays. According to the respondent-Colleges, the period of teaching from January, 2015 to August, 2015 on normal days will be 201 days, and if 35 sundays followed by 7 holidays they will get 243 days available from 1st January, 2015 till August, 2015 to complete the course.

11. We are unable to appreciate, nor inclined to permit the colleges to rush up the students of B.Ed., which are proposed to be admitted through counselling in the last week of January, 2015, to complete the Course, which includes at least 40 days of practical teaching.

12. In Himachal Pradesh Public Service Commission v. Mukesh Thakur[(2010) 6 SCC 759], it was held by the Supreme Court in para 23 as follows:

“23. The situation will be entirely different where the court deals with the issue of admission in mid-academic session. This court has time and again said that it is not permissible for the Courts to issue direction for admission in mid-academic session. The reason for it has been that admission to a student at a belated stage disturbs other students, who have already been pursuing the course and such a student would not be able to complete the required attendance in theory as well as in practical classes. Quality of education cannot be compromised. The students taking admission at a belated stage may not be able to complete the courses in the limited period. In this connection reference may be made to the decisions of this Court in Dr. Pramod Kumar Joshi v. Medical Council of India, (1991) 2 SCC 179; State of Uttar Pradesh v. Dr. Anupam Gupta etc., 1993 Supp (1) SCC 594 : AIR 1992 SC 932; State of Punjab v. Renuka Singla, (1994) 1 SCC 175 : AIR 1994 SC 595; Medical Council of India v. Madhu Singh, (2002) 7 SCC 258; and Mridul Dhar (Minor) v. Union of India, (2005) 2 SCC 65.”

13. We also find substance in the objections raised by learned counsel appearing for the Co-ordinator, PTET that the colleges did not have affiliation from the University, and thus, they did not fulfil all conditions for admitting them, for allowing to be included in the counselling upto the last date fixed by the Co-ordinator, PTET upto 04.07.2014. The affiliations from the University were given after the cut-off of the date fixed for all the colleges for counselling by the Co-ordinator, PTET. The respondent-institutions are thus not entitled to the benefit of the principles of law laid down in State of Maharashtra v. Sant Dnyaneshwar Shikshan Shastra Mahavidyalaya (supra), and Maa Vaishno Devi Mahila Mahavidyalaya v. State of Uttar Pradesh (supra).

14. We may observe here that even if, we accept the suggestions of learned counsel appearing for the respondents, that will squeeze and complete the course upto the August, 2015, we are of the view that any directions issued by us in this regard will be detrimental to the interest of students, and their proficiency to teach, which Is of paramount consideration by the Court in making such orders. The equities in such cases have to be taken into consideration, keeping in mind the interest of the students, and not the colleges, which have started these courses, as commercial activities. We may also observe that no individual, who had succeeded in the PTET Examination, and was not admitted to B.Ed. Course in the counselling, had filed a writ petition for seeking admission to any of these fifteen colleges. It is only the colleges, which had filed writ petition for seeking admission to any of these fifteen colleges. It is only the colleges, which had filed writ petitions in order to protect the investments made by them, in engaging the faculty and creating infrastructure to run colleges. The recognition given by NCTE, in the absence of the No Objection Certificate given by the State Government, and the delayed affiliations does not give any indefeasible rights to the respondent colleges to seek a writ of mandamus to hold the counselling, which was closed on 8th September, 2014, to admit students for benefit of colleges above this stage. For the aforesaid reasons, all the Special Appeals are allowed. All the orders passed by learned Single Judge are set aside. The Colleges may be allowed to admit the students for the academic year 2015-16, subject to fulfillment of the new guidelines issued by the NCTE on 28.11.2014.

15. A copy of this order will be placed in all connected files.