Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Govinda Chandra Tiria v. Sibaji Charan Panda And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 5, 2020
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 1 was appointed as a Lower Division Clerk (LDC) in the Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF), New Delhi on 24-5-1993. Although his headquarters were in Delhi, the appointment letter imposed a liability to serve anywhere in India. Pursuant to a Ministry circular dated 24-11-1993, he sought and obtained a deputation to the Eastern Regional Office (ERO), Bhubaneswar, joining there on 10-5-1994. After exhausting the permissible three-year deputation period, Respondent 1 repeatedly requested permanent absorption at Bhubaneswar, citing family hardship.

On 13-11-1996 the competent authority approved his absorption on transfer basis subject to explicit conditions: (i) severance of lien with the Central Secretariat Clerical Service (CSCS); (ii) treatment as a fresh appointee ranking juniormost in the ERO LDC cadre; (iii) liability to serve anywhere in India; and (iv) no transfer benefits. Respondent 1 accepted these terms in writing, tendered a technical resignation from his Delhi post, and was relieved on 2-1-1997.

A provisional seniority list dated 8-3-2001 ranked Respondent 1 below the appellant. Respondent 1 objected, invoking Office Memorandum (OM) No. 22011/7/86-Estt(D) dated 29-5-1986 (as later modified by the Supreme Court in Rooplal). His objection was rejected on 22-6-2001, and the final seniority list issued on 3-7-2001.

Respondent 1 challenged the list before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Cuttack Bench (OA 584/2001). The CAT dismissed the application on 17-10-2003, holding that his absorption was not in public interest and hence the OM placed him below regular incumbents.

Respondent 1 then filed Writ Petition (C) 1645/2004 before the Orissa High Court. On 22-8-2008 the High Court allowed the petition, directed preparation of a fresh gradation list, and ordered consideration of his promotion to Upper Division Clerk (UDC). The appellant (whose seniority was thereby disturbed) appealed to the Supreme Court. Leave was granted on 16-4-2010; the present judgment resolves that appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Respondent 1, after accepting absorption as a “fresh appointee” with bottom seniority, could subsequently claim seniority from his original Delhi appointment/date of deputation.
  2. Whether Office Memorandum No. 22011/7/86-Estt(D) dated 29-5-1986 (as modified by Rooplal) entitled Respondent 1 to count past service when his transfer was not “strictly in public interest”.
  3. Whether the High Court erred in overriding the expressly accepted terms of absorption and in applying the OMs to elevate Respondent 1’s seniority.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Respondent 1 unequivocally accepted the absorption terms stipulating junior-most seniority; he is estopped from resiling and prejudicing others’ seniority.
  • The 29-5-1986 OM, read with its caveat for transfers “not strictly in public interest”, places Respondent 1 below regular incumbents; his absorption arose from his own request, not public interest.
  • The High Court misapplied the OMs and ignored binding conditions of absorption; precedent (Mrigank Johri v. Union of India) supports the validity of such conditions.

Respondent 1's Arguments

  • Invoked Rooplal v. State (NCT of Delhi) to contend that past regular service should be counted for seniority after absorption.
  • Asserted that nothing in the OMs mandates bottom seniority on permanent absorption; therefore, the condition imposed by MoEF was invalid.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rooplal v. State (NCT of Delhi), (2000) 1 SCC 644 Struck down “whichever is later” clause in OM 29-5-1986; substituted “whichever is earlier” for counting seniority of deputationists absorbed in public interest. Distinguished: present absorption was at employee’s request and not in public interest; thus the benefit in Rooplal does not apply.
Mrigank Johri v. Union of India, (2017) 8 SCC 256 Upholds contractual absorption terms treating the employee as a fresh recruit with no seniority benefit from past service. Applied: Court held that Respondent 1, having accepted identical terms, cannot later claim earlier seniority.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

1. The Court first examined the absorption memorandum dated 13-11-1996. It unequivocally required Respondent 1 to sever lien with CSCS and accept junior-most status in the ERO. Respondent 1 voluntarily accepted these terms and never challenged them until the seniority list was issued; hence, principles of estoppel and contractual acceptance apply.

2. Under OM 29-5-1986 the normal rule counts seniority from the date of absorption. An exception exists where absorption is in public interest; only then can past service count (now from the earlier of two dates, post-Rooplal). The Court found, on the record, that MoEF wanted Respondent 1 to return to his parent cadre; absorption occurred solely on his persistent request. Therefore, the transfer was not “strictly in public interest,” triggering the clause that places such transferees below all regular appointees.

3. The High Court’s conclusion that no rule required bottom seniority was held erroneous because it ignored the “not in public interest” proviso and the binding absorption conditions.

4. Relying on Mrigank Johri, the Court reaffirmed that when an employee accepts absorption as a new recruitment with express waiver of seniority, past service cannot later be invoked to alter the cadre’s seniority.

5. Distinguishing Rooplal, the Court noted that case involved urgent public interest absorption without informed consent; here, the facts were the reverse—personal request, full disclosure, and explicit consent.

Holding and Implications

APPEALS ALLOWED; HIGH COURT JUDGMENT SET ASIDE.

The Supreme Court restored the original seniority list, confirming that Respondent 1 ranks below the appellant. However, recognising prolonged litigation and subsequent promotions, the Court directed MoEF to create an ex-cadre/supernumerary post so Respondent 1 can retain his current rank of Assistant without disturbing the corrected seniority list. No wider precedent is set beyond reaffirming that contractual absorption terms and the “not in public interest” proviso to OM 29-5-1986 govern seniority in comparable situations.

Show all summary ...

Sanjay Kishan Kaul, J.— On the recommendation of the Staff Selection Commission, Respondent 1 before us was so offered an appointment to the post of Lower Division Clerk (LDC) Group C in the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, New Delhi in the pay scale of Rs 950-1500 vide Letter dated 24-5-1993. In terms of this letter of appointment, the headquarters of the work was at New Delhi, but the appointment carried with it a liability to serve anywhere in India. On completion of the period of probation of two years, Respondent 1 made an application dated 22-7-1994 in pursuance to the Circular dated 24-11-1993, seeking options from the staff for the post of LDC on “transfer on deputation basis” initially for a period of one year, which was likely to be extended to a further period of maximum three years. The application of Respondent 1 was accepted and he joined the office of Deputy Conservator of Forests as LDC at Bhubaneshwar on 10-5-1994 in pursuance to his selection vide Letter dated 12-4-1994.

2. In terms of the Circular dated 24-11-1993, Respondent 1 was granted the maximum number of extensions, for a period of three years, periodically after obtaining the no-objection certificate from the Central office at Delhi.

3. In the course of the tenure of deputation, Respondent 1 made a request for transfer on a permanent basis to the regional office at Bhubaneshwar and vide Letter dated 21-11-1994, from the Central office to the Eastern Regional Office, MoEF, Bhubaneshwar, it was informed that no further extension could be given to Respondent 1 and calling upon the Bhubaneshwar office to make its own recruitments. Respondent 1, however, persisted with his request and then sent a letter on 22-9-1995, seeking the consideration of his case sympathetically. The relevant part of this letter is extracted as under:

“That I am the only earning member of my family. My family depends upon me both financially and physically. During posting at Delhi I had to send a major portion of my salary to my family. When I was far away from my home I was unable to attend the needs of my family members. So I had to work under great mental tension.
Therefore, I request you to kindly consider my case sympathetically and allow me no-objection certificate for my posting in any Central Government office located in Orissa.
In this connection, I request you to refer to my applications dated 30-1-1995 and 17-5-1995 and request you to take necessary action at any early date.”

4. On 5-9-1996, once again Respondent 1 made a representation to the Bhubaneshwar office for absorption on “compassionate grounds” as LDC (Hindi typist) on transfer basis. The endeavour of Respondent 1 finally succeeded when an office memorandum dated 13-11-1996 was issued intimating him about the approval of the competent authority for absorption on a transfer basis in the Eastern Regional Office and seeking his consent on the terms and conditions set out in the letter. The said conditions are under:

“(i) He should sever fully his link or lien with the CSCS cadre.
(ii) He will be treated as fresh appointee in the Eastern Regional Office, Ministry of Environment and Forests, Bhubaneshwar and he will be ranked juniormost in the cadre of LDC in ERO, MoEF, after his appointment in this office.
(iii) His present posting shall be at Bhubaneshwar (Orissa) but he is liable to be posted anywhere of India in this Ministry.
(iv) The transfer is at his own request and as such, he is not entitled to TTA/Joining time, etc.
In case he is willing to accept all the conditions stipulated above, in addition to all the rules and regulations applicable to his grade in Government of India, he may please get relieved of his duties from the Ministry of Environment and Forests, New Delhi after completing all the required formalities and thereafter report for duty in the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Eastern Regional Office, Bhubaneshwar.”

5. The crucial aspect is that Respondent 1 was to be treated as a “fresh appointee” in the Regional Eastern Office and rank juniormost in the cadre after his appointment to that office. He was called upon to give his willingness to all the conditions, which were duly accepted by Respondent 1. He gave his technical resignation thereafter (Annexure P-9) and consequently the office order dated 2-1-1997 was issued, relieving him. He also addressed a letter on 31-1-1997 giving his willingness in writing to transfer, on permanent absorption basis, on the terms and conditions specified under OM No. 2-56/FCE dated 13-11-1996, and accordingly joined.

6. On 8-3-2001, the provisional seniority list was circulated by an office order of the even date, in terms whereof Respondent 1 was shown at Sl. No. 3, while the appellant was shown at Sl. No. 2. Respondent 1 filed objections dated 12-3-2001 seeking to rely on OM No. AB-140171/89-Est(RR) dated 3-10-1989. This was despite his consent as according to him the said OM would govern the terms of absorption and not his consent. The representation was rejected on 22-6-2001. The rejection takes note of the interim developments during this period of time i.e. issuance of an office memorandum dated 27-3-2001 arising from a judgment of this Court in Rooplal v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2000) 1 SCC 644, in terms whereof the terms and conditions of OM No. 20020/7/80-Esst(D), dated 29-5-1986, were struck down to the extent it provided as under:

“20. … ‘… —the date he has been holding the post on deputation
or
—the date from which he has been appointed on a regular basis in the same or equivalent grade in his parent department, whichever is later.’”
(emphasised matter struck down in Rooplal case (2000) 1 SCC 644)

7. The instructions were to take effect from 14-12-1999, which was the date of the judgment of the Supreme Court (the latter part is not an aspect which we are examining). The final seniority list was published on 3-7-2001, maintaining the provisional seniority list and thus Respondent 1 filed Original Application No. 584/2001 before the Central Administrative Tribunal, Cuttack Bench challenging the seniority list on the ground that his seniority had been calculated in violation of the Government of India circulars and guidelines issued from time to time, and his name had been placed below two persons (including the appellant). This original application was, however, dismissed by Order dated 17-10-2003 based on the counter-affidavit filed by the Central Government to the effect that the latter part of OM No. 22011/7/86-Est.(D) would govern the present case as the absorption of Respondent 1 was not in public interest. The relevant clauses of OA No. 20020/7/80-ESTT(D) dated 29-5-1986 are being extracted hereunder:

“no. 20020/7/80-estt(d)
government of india/bharat sarkar,
ministry of personnel, public grievance and pensions
department of personnel & training
new delhi, the 29-5-1986
office memorandum
Subject: Seniority of persons absorbed after being on deputation.
The undersigned is directed to say that the existing instructions on seniority instructions on seniority of transferees contained in Para 7 of the Annexure to this Department's OM No. 9/11/-55-RPS dated 22-12-1959 (copy enclosed) mainly deal with cases where persons are straightaway appointed on transfer. It is, however, observed that most of the cases of permanent absorption are those where the officers were taken on deputation initially under the method of transfer on deputation/transfer contained in the relevant recruitment rules. The OM is intended to fill this gap in the existing instructions.
2. Even in the type of cases mentioned above, that is, where an officer initially comes on deputation and is subsequently absorbed, the normal principle that the seniority should be counted from the date of such absorption, should mainly apply. Where, however, the officer has already been holding on the date of absorption in the same or equivalent on grade on regular basis in his parent department, it would be equitable and appropriate that such regular service in the grade should also be taken into account in determining his seniority subject only to the condition that at the most it would be only from the date of deputation to the grade in which absorption is being made, it has also be ensured chart the fixation of seniority of a transfer in accordance with the above principle will not affect any regular promotions made prior to the date of absorption. Accordingly, it has been decided to add the following sub-para (iv) to Para 7 of general principles communicated vide OM dated 22-12-1959.
“(iv) In the case of a person who is initially taken on deputation and absorbed later i.e. where the relevant recruitment rules provide for transfer on deputation/transfer, his seniority in this grade in which he be absorbed will normally be counted from the date of absorption. If he has, however, been holding already from the date of absorption, the same is equivalents grade on regular basis in parent department, such regular services in the grade shall also be taken into account in fixing his seniority, subject to the condition that he will be given seniority from
– the date he has been holding the post on deputation.
OR
– the date from which he has been appointed on a regular basis in the same or equivalent grade in his parent department.
Whichever is later.
The fixation of seniority of transferee in accordance with the above principle will not, however, affect any regular promotions to the next higher grade, made prior to the date of such absorption. In other words, it will be operative only in filling up of vacancies in higher grade taking places after such absorption.
In cases in which transfers are not strictly in public interest, the transferred officers will be placed below all officers appointed regularly to the grade on the date of absorption.”
(emphasis supplied)

We may repeat here that the expression whichever is later as appearing in the Circular stood modified in pursuance to the judgment of this Court in Rooplal (2000) 1 SCC 644.

8. Respondent 1, aggrieved by the order of the Central Administrative Tribunal filed a writ petition before the Orissa High Court under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India, being Writ Petition No. 1645 of 2004, which was allowed vide judgment dated 22-8-2008 WP (C) No. 1645 of 2004, directing a fresh gradation list of LDC to be drawn and to consider the case of Respondent 1 for promotion to the post of UDC, if he is so entitled. The judgment took note of the opinion of this Court in Rooplal (2000) 1 SCC 644 and simultaneously also took note of the conditions imposed at the time of absorption of Respondent 1, which had been accepted by Respondent 1 as “the only hurdle”. Thereafter, it proceeded to record its reasons in Para 11:

“The learned Assistant Solicitor General has not been able to place any rule/circular/office memorandum to show that if an employee is to be permanently absorbed in the borrowing department he has to accept the bottom most seniority in the cadre. In absence of anything in support of such condition, we are of the view that imposition of such condition on contrary to the office memorandums dated 29-5-1986 and 27-3-2001 and, therefore, the petitioner cannot be bound by that. Since we are of the view that the seniority of the petitioner in the cadre of LDC in the Eastern Regional Office is to be reckoned from the date he joined on deputation in the office of Opposite Party 2, the gradation list prepared for LDC is liable to be set aside and, therefore, a fresh gradation list is required to be drawn.”

9. The appellant, his seniority being disturbed thus, approached this Court, though the Union of India did not approach this Court. Leave was granted on 16-4-2010 2010 SCC OnLine SC 76, and the matter is listed before us, unfortunately, after almost a decade.

10. We have heard the learned counsel for parties.

11. In sum and substance, there are really two submissions on behalf of the appellant — (a) the terms of the absorption of Respondent 1 itself stipulated that his seniority would rank below the others, and having accepted the terms and conditions of absorption, he cannot be permitted to resile from the same, and consequently affect the seniority of the appellant, (b) the High Court fell into error while observing in para 11 that the office memorandums dated 29-5-1986 and 27-3-2001 will prevail, and that in those memorandums, there was nothing which could affect the seniority of Respondent 1 from his initial date of appointment at Delhi.

12. The second aspect is assailed on the basis that the crucial aspect of extracted OM dated 29-5-1986 has not been considered i.e. that such seniority would not be available in cases in which transfers are “not strictly in public interest”. This was a precondition. The fact that the department wanted Respondent 1 to go back to his parent cadre, the communication substantiated the same. It was the insistence of Respondent 1, by way of repeated representations, which resulted in the office order for his absorption on the terms and conditions set out in the said office order dated 13-11-1996. Thus, such an observation can hardly be stated to be “strictly in public interest”, much less in public interest. This is also the stand of the Union of India taken in the counter-affidavit filed in the court below.

13. The learned counsel for Respondent 1 endeavoured to persuade us to the contrary by referring to the judgment of this Court in Rooplal (2000) 1 SCC 644. We may note that all principles of law arise in the given factual situation. If we consider the factual situation of that case, which had quashed a part of OM No. 20020/7/80-ESTT (D) dated 29-5-1986 insofar as it provided for “whichever is later”, and replaced it with “whichever is earlier”, we are faced with a scenario where the police authorities, with a view to strengthen their existing security system in the capital, had created 12 new police stations in Delhi, and the posts were required to be filled in the shortest possible time so that there was an immediate impact on the law and order situation in Delhi. As the normal course of recruitment would take a longer period of time, in view of the urgent need of the hour, a decision was taken for suitable persons to be deployed on deputation basis to the ranks of Inspector, Sub-Inspector, Assistant Sub-Inspector, Head Constable, Constable and Driver. The request letter also stated that those officials taken on deputation were likely to be considered for permanent absorption after one year, if found suitable.

14. The opinion of this Court was that such deputationists were permanently absorbed but were not being given the benefit of service of equivalent post, and that they should have been so conveyed in order to make an informed choice of whether to seek or not to seek permanent absorption i.e. there had to be full disclosure and transparency in respect of the terms and conditions of the absorption. It was not a case of request for absorption, but, the exigencies of service, and that too, without putting them to notice of this fact.

15. The facts of the present case are completely to the contrary. Despite departmental communications wanting Respondent 1 to go back to the parent cadre it is Respondent 1's insistence and persuasion which prevailed, with the department absorbing Respondent 1 with the terms and conditions aforementioned. One of the terms and conditions was that seniority would be counted from the date of absorption and Respondent 1 accepted the same. That absorption was never challenged in any proceeding, nor the terms thereof, when he was treated as a fresh appointee. It is only when the seniority list was circulated that the challenge was sought to be made to the seniority list, in an oblique manner, and the terms and conditions of the absorption were sought to be assailed. This is not permissible.

16. The learned counsel for the appellant has also drawn our attention to the judgment of this Court in Mrigank Johri v. Union of India (2017) 8 SCC 256, wherein it has been held that benefit of past service rendered in a cadre is usually reckoned for the purpose of seniority. In the instant case, where the conditions were categorically stated that the absorption would be “deemed to be new recruitment” and the previous service would be counted for all purposes “except his or her seniority in the cadre”, the appellant having accepted it without any demur, the seniority list prepared as a sequitur to the terms and conditions of the absorption could not be faulted with.

17. This principle applies on all fours to the facts of the present case. The learned counsel for the appellant has also rightly contended that the plea based on the fact that the appointment of Respondent 1 was with a provision for transfer would not assist the said respondent as the present case is not one of transfer but of deputation, in pursuance to an OM and thus, the principle of a person moving to another cadre would squarely apply. Such depute would also, thus, have to be governed by the terms and conditions of such absorption.

18. In this behalf we may note OM No. 20020/7/80-ESTT(D), which, in Para 2 sets out that when an officer initially comes on deputation, and is subsequently absorbed, the normal principle that seniority should be counted from the date of such absorption, should mainly apply. This was, however, subject to the caveat of the OM dated 22-12-1959, which states that if such a person is absorbed in an equivalent grade on a regular basis in the parent department, such regular services in the grade should also be taken into account in fixing his seniority subject to the condition that it would be from the date he had been holding the post on deputation or from the date he had been appointed on regular basis in the same or equivalent grade in his parent department “whichever is later”, which was amended to make it “whichever is earlier”.

19. Thus, normally the deputation would be counted, but this was further made subject to the caveat that in case the transfers are not strictly in public interest, the transferred officers will be placed below all appointed regularly to the grade on the date of absorption. It is the latter clause which will apply as this was not a case “strictly in public interest”.

20. We are thus, of the view that the impugned judgment WP (C) No. 1645 of 2004 cannot be sustained and has to be set aside.

21. We must note with some regret that the Union of India, having taken a categorical stand before the Central Administrative Tribunal, endeavoured to possibly help Respondent 1 by filing a counter-affidavit before this Court, endeavouring to take a slightly different position by observing “however, it is true that the MoEF objected to his continuance in the office of the Res-3 many times but extension was granted based on the request from office of the Res-3”. To say the least, the Union of India should be conscious while preferring affidavits, and if they want to change the stand, they must give reasons for the same. The manner of wording the affidavit seems to be an oblique attempt and we are of the view that a closer scrutiny is necessary by the Department as to how such a counter-affidavit was placed before us.

22. We are, however, faced with a situation that in the meantime, Respondent 1 has earned promotions, and is now deployed to the post of Assistant. The long pendency of litigation has resulted in a scenario where the effect of the aforesaid order would be possibly to demote him. We are conscious that the promotions given to him were subject to the result of the proceedings, as intimated to him by the department. This would be rather harsh. Thus, while the seniority list would be maintained, we are of the view that Respondent 1 may not be demoted, and an ex-cadre/supernumerary post should be created to keep him in the same post without affecting the seniority list.

23. The appeals are accordingly allowed leaving the parties to bear their own costs.