- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
India Vision Satellite Communication Ltd., In Re
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion addresses an ongoing execution proceeding against a judgement debtor company. The person in charge, Mr. Jamal Farooquee, appeared before the Tribunal and disclosed that the company currently has no employees, is non-functional, and has limited financial activity. The company has filed annual returns only for 2015-16. Tax dues relating to service tax amounting to approximately Rs. 3.74 crores have been settled, but payment must be made by March 2020 to release attached assets. The Tribunal seeks information regarding the valuation, location, and status of the company’s assets to facilitate execution of the decree.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the judgement debtor company can furnish the required particulars of its assets, including valuation, location, and current status, despite being non-functional and lacking employees.
- How to treat the assets attached by tax authorities in the context of the execution proceeding.
- Whether permission should be granted to the judgement debtor to liquidate or dilute investment in assets to satisfy the decree.
Arguments of the Parties
Judgement Debtor's Arguments
- The company currently has no employees and the office is non-functional, making it difficult to prepare and furnish particulars in the prescribed format.
- Annual returns have been filed only for the year 2015-16.
- Tax dues related to service tax have been settled by way of a payment arrangement of approximately Rs. 3.74 crores, with payment due by March 2020.
- The assets attached by tax authorities will be freed upon payment of tax dues, and proceeds from these assets can then be applied to satisfy the decree under execution.
- The value of fixed assets as per the affidavit dated 8.11.2019 is approximately Rs. 9.89 crores, including three main assets: land at Ambalapuzha, earth station equipment, and a residential flat at Edappally.
- The bank accounts are frozen with no significant balances, and the company is at a standstill.
- The company is not under liquidation and there is an intention to invite investors to restart business operations.
- Requests permission to liquidate or dilute investments in assets to pay dues and satisfy the decree, subject to Tribunal’s monitoring.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal accepted the judgement debtor’s plea regarding difficulty in furnishing required information due to lack of employees but emphasized the need for expeditious compliance. The in-charge was directed to file an affidavit with copies of documents relating to the title of the three main assets identified by their exact locations. The Tribunal clarified that all assets, including those attached by Service Tax Authorities, remain under attachment for the purpose of the execution proceeding, with prior attachment orders having precedence over proceeds. The court also indicated that if liquidation or dilution of assets is necessary to clear dues and satisfy the decree, an application seeking permission must be filed so that the Tribunal can monitor the disposal process to ensure the best value is obtained.
Holding and Implications
The Tribunal accepted the judgement debtor’s explanation regarding difficulties in furnishing information but imposed conditions to ensure transparency and progress in the execution proceeding. The judgement debtor is required to:
- File an affidavit with title documents of the main assets by the next hearing date.
- Take expeditious steps to clear outstanding service tax dues and report the amount raised.
- File an application if liquidation or dilution of assets is required, allowing the Tribunal to monitor the process.
The direct effect is continued judicial oversight to protect the decree holder’s interests while allowing the judgement debtor a regulated opportunity to manage its assets and liabilities. No new precedent was set by this order.
Shiva Kirti Singh, Chairperson:— Pursuantto the last order Mr. Jamal Farooquee, S/o Late T Abdulla, R/o Tharavattah, P O Farook College, Calicut, Kerala, Pin 673, 632 has appeared in person in the capacity of Incharge of the affairs of the judgement debtor company. - - In reply to the questions put by this Tribunal, he has stated that the company has no employees or staff at present and the office is non functional due to which all the required particulars could not be prepared and furnished in the prescribed format provided in the relevant provisions of CPC.- He also disclosed that annual returns have been filed with the Registrar of Companies only for the year 2015-16.- He has produced communications from tax authorities contained in six sheets to substantiate his stand that by way of settlement the tax dues relating to service tax matters-has been determined for an amount of approximately Rs. 3.74 crores.- His stand is that the amount has to be arranged from the assets of the company which have been attached by the tax authorities and is required to be paid by March 2020. -Thereafter, once payment is made, the assets will be free of attachment and the same or-proceeds from the assets can be applied to satisfy the decree under-execution in this proceeding.
2. In the last order, it was clearly indicated that the person Incharge of the Company, if the dues are not paid, shall be present alongwith relevant records to answer the queries in respect of valuation, location and current-status of its assets, both movable and immovable. -The valuation of the fixed assets disclosed in the affidavit as on 31.3.2016 was Rs. 9.89 crores approximately. -In the affidavit, on the basis of Annexures - A-3, and A-4 which includes the balance-sheet for March 2016 the value of fixed assets have been provided in paragraph-7. - That paragraph mentions the value of three assets including land at Ambalapuzha, Earth station equipment and a residential flat at Edappally P.O. -Kochi to be Rs. 9.89 crores.- In paragraph-8, it has been stated that those three assets have been attached by Service Tax Authorities and the documents pertaining to these assets are enclosed.- However, the affidavit does not contain - documents relating - to the assets but only an order showing attachment.
3. In paragraph-9, the balance amount of assets has been described as Rs. 2.04 crores covering other fixed assets-such as computer, generator, vehicle and other equipments whose current value has been described as less than Rs. 50 lakhs.
4. The bank accounts have also been frozen and the company's work is at stand still.- In reply to a question, -it has been disclosed that there was no significant amount of money in the bank accounts.- Mr. Farooquee has stated to clarify that all the bank accounts of the company, four in number, have been disclosed and the-balances in those accounts are reflected by the documents annexed with two affidavits.
5. It is not in dispute that the respondent company is not under liquidation.--Mr. Farooquee has supported the-statement in the affidavit that he wants to invite other investors so that the company may start its business again.
6. For the present, the main concern of the decree holder and of this Tribunal is to find out the exact location of the main assets said to be worth Rs. 9.89 crores in paragraph 7 of the affidavit filed on 8.11.2019.
7. The addresses or the exact location of the three assets described in paragraph-7 of the affidavit have-been furnished by Mr. Farooquee and is they are as follows:
1. Ambalapuzha Property
Under the survey no. 79/1-5 resurvey no. 293/2-3 in block 21 of Purakkad Panchayath, Thottappally-Ambalapuzha, Alleppy (Dist) Kerala
2. Equipments/Office address:
Indiavision Satellite Communication Ltd., Anjumana Road, Mamangalam, Edappally-P.O., Kochi-24, Kerala
3. Flat-Ist Floor-1A, Asset Enlive, V.P. Marakkar Road, Vattekkunnam 682024, Edappally Toll, Kochi, Kerala.
8. For the time being, plea of the judgement debtor that it has difficulty - in furnishing the required information for lack of employess is accepted.- But the Incharge Mr. Farooquee has to find out ways and means to produce through an affidavit to be filed by the next date, copies of documents relating to the title of the three properties indicated above.- It is also expected that the judgement debtor shall take expeditious steps to clear the service tax dues and inform this Tribunal as to how much money was raised for that purpose.- If it requires liquidation of all or any of the aforesaid three assets or dilution of investment as indicated in the balance-sheet of 2015-16, then an application should be filed on behalf of the judgement debtor seeking permission of this Tribunal so that, if required, -this Tribunal may monitor the process of disposal of the assets at the best value-available.- It is clarified that all the existing assets of the judgement debtor including those which are attached with the Service Tax Authorities shall be treated to be under attachment for the purpose of present execution proceeding also. - Of course, the earlier-attachment order shall have precedence over the proceeds-of the assets. - If required, judgement debtor may file an appropriate application in the meantime.
9. Post the matter under the same head on 3.4.2020.
Alert