- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bhupati Debnath v. State Of Tripura
Judgment Summary — Akil Kureshi, C.J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner is a retired Auditor of respondent No. 2, Tripura Handloom and Handicrafts Development Corporation Ltd., a Government of Tripura undertaking. He retired on superannuation effective 30.06.2018 after over 29 years' service. The petitioner was paid gratuity of Rs. 9,80,423 on or around 04.12.2018. He raised two grievances: (i) that payment of gratuity was delayed and interest should be awarded, and that the gratuity was computed applying a pre-revised ceiling of Rs. 10,00,000 instead of a revised ceiling of Rs. 20,00,000 notified by the Central Government on 29.03.2018; and (ii) that his sanctioned leave encashment for 300 days of accumulated earned leave has not been paid in full.
The corporation advanced three defenses: (i) the computation of gratuity payable is Rs. 9,80,423 and that amount has been paid, so the question of the revised ceiling does not arise; (ii) the Central Government's revised ceiling is not binding because it has not been adopted by the State Government, and the corporation is governed by the State Government's prescriptions; and (iii) financial constraints delayed payment of the leave encashment — Rs. 1,17,200 was paid on 27.12.2019 and the remaining amount would be paid when funds are available.
At hearing the court directed the petitioner to furnish a detailed breakup of his gratuity computation within two weeks so the corporation could verify whether the paid amount represented the full entitlement; if the total gratuity payable exceeded Rs. 10,00,000 the question of applying the revised limit would arise and be decided in the petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Central Government's notification dated 29.03.2018 specifying a revised ceiling of Rs. 20,00,000 under Sub-section (3) of Section 4 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 applies to employees of the respondent corporation, even though the corporation is governed by the State Government as the "appropriate Government".
- Whether the petitioner is entitled to interest for delayed payment of gratuity and leave encashment, and if so, the rate and period for which interest should run.
- Procedural: Whether the respondent corporation must verify the petitioner's computation and pay any shortfall in gratuity and the remaining leave encashment within specified time limits.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The gratuity payment was delayed and therefore interest should be awarded.
- The gratuity was calculated by reference to the pre-revised ceiling of Rs. 10,00,000; the petitioner contends the revised ceiling of Rs. 20,00,000 notified by the Central Government on 29.03.2018 should apply.
- The sanctioned leave encashment for 300 days remains unpaid and should be released.
Respondent Corporation's Arguments
- The correct computation of gratuity payable to the petitioner is Rs. 9,80,423 and that amount has been paid; therefore, there is no question of applying the revised ceiling.
- The Central Government's notification revising the ceiling has not been adopted by the State Government; as the corporation is governed by the State Government, the revised ceiling does not apply to its employees.
- Payment of leave encashment has been delayed due to severe financial constraints; a part payment of Rs. 1,17,200 was made on 27.12.2019 and the balance will be paid when funds are available.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the statutory scheme in the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 and the relationship between the concept of "appropriate Government" and the ceiling for gratuity payments under Section 4 of the Act. The analysis proceeded in the following steps, each grounded in the text of the opinion:
- Statutory framework: The court recited the statement of objects and reasons for the Act and summarized the Act's purpose — to provide a uniform Central law for payment of gratuity to employees in specified establishments and related matters.
- Definition of "appropriate Government": The court set out Clause (a) of Section 2 which defines "appropriate Government" (Central Government in relation to specified classes of establishments; State Government in other cases). The court noted that this distinction matters for administration (for example, appointment of Controlling Authority under Section 3, exemptions under Section 5, and insurance requirement under Section 4A).
- Distinction with Section 4(3): The court observed that Section 4(1) and (2) prescribe who is eligible for gratuity and the rate (15 days' wages for each completed year or part in excess of six months). Crucially, Section 4(3) provides that "The amount of gratuity payable to an employee shall not exceed such amount as may be notified by the Central Government from time to time."
- Effect of the 2018 amendment: The court noted that Act 12 of 2018 substituted the earlier fixed monetary ceiling (previously ten lakh rupees) by empowering the Central Government to notify the ceiling "from time to time". Thus the power to set the ceiling is a delegated legislative power exercisable by the Central Government.
- Central notification of 29.03.2018: The court quoted the Central Government notification (S.O. 1420 (E)) issued in exercise of Sub-section (3) of Section 4, which specified that the amount of gratuity payable shall not exceed twenty lakh rupees.
- Legal conclusion on applicability: From the text of Section 4 and the amendment, the court concluded that the ceiling specified by the Central Government applies to gratuity payable under Section 4 irrespective of which Government is the "appropriate Government" for administrative purposes. Therefore the respondents' contention that the revised ceiling would apply only if adopted by the State Government was rejected.
- Relief and practical directions: The court directed a procedural step — the petitioner to submit his detailed gratuity computation; the corporation to verify whether Rs. 9,80,423 represents full entitlement; if a shortfall exists, it must be paid applying the revised ceiling of Rs. 20,00,000 and within specified timelines with interest. The court also rejected the defense of indefinite delay due to financial constraints, emphasizing the pensionless status of the petitioner and his reliance on post-retiral payments.
Holding and Implications
Petition disposed of.
Direct holdings and consequences on the parties (as ordered by the court):
- The petitioner must submit his detailed calculation of payable gratuity to respondent No. 2 within two weeks from the date of the order; the respondent shall verify and communicate whether the previously paid Rs. 9,80,423 represents full entitlement.
- While calculating gratuity, the revised ceiling of Rs. 20,00,000 (as specified by the Central Government notification dated 29.03.2018) shall be applicable.
- If there is any shortfall in payment of gratuity, the shortfall shall be paid within four months from the date of the order with simple interest at 7.5% per annum running from one month after the date of superannuation until actual payment.
- The remaining amount of sanctioned leave encashment shall be released within four months from the date of the order and shall carry simple interest at 7.5% per annum from one month after the date of retirement until actual payment.
- The gratuity already paid shall also carry simple interest at 7.5% per annum from one month after the date of retirement until actual payment.
- All pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
Broader implications: The opinion holds, as a matter of statutory construction within the text of this judgment, that the Central Government's power under Section 4(3) to notify the ceiling for gratuity applies to gratuity payments across establishments irrespective of which Government is the "appropriate Government" for administrative purposes. The opinion does not purport to create any further precedent beyond this decision in the present petition.
Akil Kureshi, C.J.:— Heard learned counsel for the parties for final disposal of the petition.
2. Petitioner is a retired employee of respondent No. 2, Tripura Handloom and Handicrafts Development Corporation Ltd., a Government of Tripura undertaking (hereinafter to be referred to as the said corporation). He retired on superannuation w.e.f. 30.06.2018 as an Auditor after putting in more than 29 years of service. He has been paid gratuity of Rs. 9,80,423 on or around 04.12.2018. He has two grievances. Firstly, that the payment of gratuity is delayed for which interest should be awarded, further that such gratuity is paid by taking into consideration a pre-revised limit of Rs. 10,00,000 (rupees ten lakhs) for payment of gratuity without applying the fresh ceiling of Rs. 20,00,000 (rupees twenty lakhs) as per the Government of India notification dated, 29.03.2018. His second grievance is that his leave encashment of accumulated unused Earned Leave of 300 days is not paid though sanctioned.
3. The said corporation has taken three defences:
(i) Firstly, the computation of gratuity payable to the petitioner comes to Rs. 9,80,423 which has already been paid. The question of applying revised ceiling limit, therefore, would not arise;
(ii) Secondly, that in any case the revised limit is prescribed by the Government of India in its notification which is not adopted by the State Government. The corporation is governed by the State Government's prescription. Unless and until such revised limit is adopted by the State Government, it would not apply to the employees of the said corporation;
(iii) Lastly, that on account of severe financial constraints the leave encashment has not been paid immediately. A sum of Rs. 1,17,200 has been paid on 27.12.2019. The remaining amount would be paid as soon as the funds are available.
4. The petitioner has not given the breakup of his computation of gratuity on the basis of which he contends that the amount of Rs. 9,80,423 does not represent the full entitlement of the petitioner. He would, therefore, file such calculation before the employer within a period of 2(two) weeks from today. The corporation shall verify the details provided by the petitioner and communicate to him whether the amount of Rs. 9,80,423 already paid represents the full gratuity entitlement of the petitioner. If there is any short payment so that the total payable gratuity (inclusive of what is already paid over to the petitioner) exceeds Rs. 10,00,000 (rupees ten lakhs), the question of applying revised limit would arise. In this context, therefore, it would be necessary to decide this issue in the present petition.
5. The statement of objects and reasons for enactment of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (the Act, for short) reads as under:
“STATEMENT OF OBJECTS AND REASONS:
There is at present no Central Act to regulate the payment of gratuity to industrial workers, except the Working Journalists (Conditions of Service) and Miscellaneous Provisions Act. 1995. The Government of Kerala enacted legislation last year for payment of gratuity to workers employed in factories, plantations, shops and establishments. The West Bengal Governor Promulgated an Ordinance on the 3 June, 1971 prescribing a similar scheme of gratuity. This Ordinance has since been replaced by the West Bengal Employees' Payment of Compulsory Gratuity Act, 1971, enacted by the President on 28 August, 1971. Gratuity is also being paid by some employers to their workers under Awards and Agreements.
Since the enactment of the Kerala and the West Bengal Acts, some other State Governments have also voiced their intention of enacting similar measures in their respective States. It has become necessary, therefore, to have a Central law on the subject so as to ensure a uniform pattern of payment of gratuity to the employees throughout the country. The enactment of a Central law would also avoid different treatment to the employees of establishments having branches in more than one State when, under the conditions of their service, the employees are liable to transfer from one State to another.
The proposal for Central legislation on gratuity was discussed in the Labour Ministers' Conference held at New Delhi on 24 and 25 August, 1971 and also in the Indian Labour Conference at its session held on the 22 and 23 October, 1971. There was general agreement at the Labour Ministers' Conference and the Indian Labour Conference that Central legislation on payment of gratuity might be undertaken as early as possible. It is accordingly proposed to undertake such legislation.
In enacting the President's Act for West Bengal in August, 1971, care has been taken to so design its provisions that they could serve as far as possible as norms for the Central law. The Bill has, therefore, been drafted on the lines of the West Bengal Employees' Payment of Compulsory Gratuity Act, 1971 with some modifications which have been made in the light of the views expressed at the Indian Labour Conference relating to forfeiture of gratuity in cases of dismissal for gross misconduct.
The Bill provides for gratuity to employees drawing wages up to Rs. 270 per month in factories, plantations, shops, establishments and mines, in the event of superannuation, retirement, resignation and death or total disablement due to accident or disease. The quantum of gratuity payable will be 15 days' wages based on the rate of wages last drawn by the employees concerned for every completed year of service or part thereof in excess of six months subject to a maximum of 15 months' wages. The term “wages” will mean “basic wage plus dearness allowance”.
It is proposed that the appropriate Government for administering the Act in relation to establishment belonging to or under the control of the Central Government or a railway company, or mine, a major port and oilfield or in relation to establishments having departments or branches in more than one State, will be the Central Government, and, in relation to other establishments, the State Government.
The Bill seeks to give effect to the above proposals.”
6. With these objects in mind to provide for a scheme for the payment of gratuity to employees engaged in factories, mines, oilfields, plantations, ports, railway companies, shops or other establishments and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto the said Act was enacted.
7. Clause (a) of Section 2 of the Act defines the term “appropriate Government” as under:
“2. (a) “appropriate Government” means,-
(i) in relation to an establishment-
(a) belonging to, or under the control of, the Central Government,
(b) having branches in more than one State,
(c) of a factory belonging to, or under the control of, the Central Government,
(d) of a major port, mine, oilfield or railway company, the Central Government,
(ii) in any other case, the State Government.”
8. This distinction between the State or the Central Government being an appropriate Government in relation to different classes of establishments, manifests itself in various sections contained in the said Act. For example, under Section 3 the appropriate Government may, by notification, appoint an officer to be a Controlling Authority who shall be responsible for the administration of the Act. Different Authorities may be appointed for different areas. Under Section 4A the appropriate Government may notify date with effect from which every employer other than an establishment belonging to or under the control of the Central or the State Government would have to obtain an insurance for liability for payment of gratuity. Under sub-section (1) of Section 5 the appropriate Government may by notification exempt any establishment, factory, mine or oilfield etc. from the operation of the provisions of the Act. Under sub-section (2) of Section 5 similarly the appropriate Government may notify exemption of any employee or class of employees from the operation of the provisions of the said Act.
9. However, when it comes to Section 4 of the said Act which pertains to payment of gratuity, this distinction of the appropriate Government being Central or the State Government, has no effect. Sub-section (1) of Section 4 provides that the gratuity shall be payable to an employee on termination of his employment after he has rendered continuous service for not less than five years, on his superannuation or retirement or resignation or death or disablement due to accident or disease. Sub-section (2) of Section 4 provides that for every completed year of service or part thereof in excess of six months the employer shall pay gratuity to an employee at the rate of 15 (fifteen) days wages based on the rate of wages last drawn by the concerned employee. Sub-section (3) of Section 4 which is of importance reads as under:
“(3) The amount of gratuity payable to an employee shall not exceed such amount as may be notified by the Central Government from time to time.”
10. As per this provision thus the amount of gratuity payable to an employee would not exceed such amount as may be notified by the Central Government from time to time. The group of words “such amount as may be notified by the Central Government from time to time” was substituted by Act 12 of 2018 for the group of words “ten lakh rupees”. This limit of ten lakhs of rupees was self in substitution of earlier limits of lesser amounts.
11. It can thus be seen that insofar as the payment of gratuity, its computation and the ceiling up to which such amount can be paid as referred to in Section 4 of the said Act, the term “appropriate Government” has no bearing. This distinction is also apparent from the statement of objects and reasons which provides that for the purpose of uniformity, the Central Act was envisaged. At the same time, appropriate Government is for the purpose of administering the Act. The ceiling limit for payment of gratuity is provided in Sub-section (3) of Section 4. Previously, such ceilings were contained in the sub-section itself. Pursuant to amendment by virtue of Act 12 of 2018 the power to prescribe such ceiling has been vested in the Central Government to be exercised by issuing notification in this regard. It is in exercise of such delegated powers of legislation that the Central Government has issued a notification dated 29.03.2018 which reads as under:
“S.O. 1420 (E).-In exercise of the powers conferred by Sub-section (3) of Section 4 of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 (39 of 1972), the Central Government hereby specifies that the amount of gratuity payable to an employee under the said Act shall not exceed twenty lakh rupees.”
12. This revised ceiling thus would apply to all establishments irrespective of whether they are controlled or governed by the State or the Central Government as the appropriate Government. The stand of the respondents, therefore, that unless and until such revised ceiling of payment of gratuity is adopted by the State Government, the employees of the said corporation cannot claim benefit of such revised limit cannot be accepted. Revised ceiling limit of Rs. 20,00,000 (rupees twenty lakhs) would be applicable to the petitioner.
13. The corporation cannot cite the reason of financial constraints indefinitely for paying post retiral benefits of its employees. The petitioner has put in more than 29 years of service. His service is not governed by the pension scheme. After his retirement, therefore, he would have only savings in the form of gratuity, provident fund accumulated in his account and leave encashment, if any, to fall back upon in his old age. Such amount must, therefore, be paid over to him as soon as possible.
14. Under the circumstances, petition is disposed of with following directions:
(i) As provided earlier, the petitioner shall apply to the respondent No. 2 stating his calculation of payable gratuity. The respondent No. 2 shall examine the petitioner's calculation and convey to him if any gratuity remains still payable;
(ii) While calculating such gratuity, revised limit of Rs. 20,00,000 (rupees twenty lakhs) shall be applicable;
(iii) If there is any shortfall in payment of gratuity, the same shall be paid within a period of 4(four) months from today with simple interest @ 7.5% per annum from one month after the date of superannuation till actual payments;
(iv) The remaining amount of leave encashment shall be released within a period of 4(four) months from today. The entire leave encashment payment shall carry simple interest @ 7.5% per annum from one month after the date of retirement till actual payments;
(v) The gratuity already paid shall also carry simple interest @ 7.5% per annum from one month after the date of retirement till actual payments.
15. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
Alert