- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mritunjay Singh v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The writ petitioner, a sailor employed under a contract from February 12, 2020, sought to leave India to board a merchant vessel as part of his livelihood. However, he was prevented from departing by immigration authorities due to a Look Out Circular (LOC) issued against him at the request of respondent no. 3 Bank. The petitioner was implicated in a criminal case registered by the CBI related to alleged loan default by a company where he was a director. The petitioner was discharged from the criminal charges, and this discharge was affirmed on revision. Separately, a case under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act led to an attachment order of Rs. 50 lakh against the petitioner’s account. The petitioner challenged this order and was permitted by the Division Bench of this Court to open a separate salary account for livelihood purposes. The petitioner contends that his fundamental rights to personal liberty and to carry on his profession are being infringed by the travel restriction imposed via the LOC.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the issuance of a Look Out Circular on the basis of financial default, without a pending criminal offence under the Penal Code or penal statutes, justifies preventing the petitioner from leaving the country.
- Whether the petitioner’s fundamental rights to personal liberty and to practice his profession are violated by the travel restrictions imposed.
- Whether the Bank’s financial claims and attachment order provide sufficient legal ground to restrict the petitioner’s travel abroad.
- Whether the petitioner can be permitted to travel abroad subject to conditions despite the LOC.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The petitioner is a sailor with a valid contract of employment requiring travel abroad for livelihood, not pleasure.
- The petitioner was discharged from the criminal case by the CBI, and the discharge was upheld on revision, negating any criminal offence basis for the LOC.
- The attachment order and legal remedies pursued by the Bank suffice as security; financial default alone is insufficient to restrict travel.
- The petitioner has traveled abroad multiple times during the pendency of the criminal case, demonstrating bona fide intentions to return.
- Restricting travel infringes fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution of India.
Respondent No. 3 Bank’s Arguments
- Financial defaults fall within the scope of Look Out Circular issuance under amended guidelines.
- Permitting the petitioner to leave would risk the Bank’s recovery as there is no assurance the petitioner would return.
- The dues owed by the petitioner exceed the amount attached, justifying travel restriction.
Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 (Immigration Authorities) Arguments
- They acted on the Bank’s request in issuing the LOC and preventing travel.
- Their stance is neutral regarding the validity of the LOC and the request underlying it.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bank of Baroda v. Nimish Kalyabhai Vasa | This unreported judgment was cited in support of the petitioner’s contention against travel restrictions. | The Court considered it as part of the petitioner’s legal support but did not elaborate on its application. |
| Dr. Shrikant Bhasi v. Bureau of Immigration | Unreported judgment cited regarding travel restrictions and LOC issuance. | Referenced by petitioner’s counsel; no detailed analysis provided in the opinion. |
| Priya Parameswaran Pillai v. Union of India | Unreported judgment cited in petitioner’s favor concerning fundamental rights and travel. | Not further elaborated upon in the Court’s reasoning. |
| SMT. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, (1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 (S.C) 597 | Fundamental rights relating to personal liberty and freedom of movement. | Used to underscore the petitioner’s right to travel and personal liberty. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the petitioner’s contract of employment and noted the limited period of absence from India (maximum five months), indicating no risk of indefinite stay abroad. It acknowledged that the petitioner’s travel is for livelihood, not luxury, and that the petitioner was discharged from criminal charges, with no pending offence under the Penal Code or other penal statutes warranting travel restriction. The Court observed that financial default alone does not justify issuance of an LOC or travel restriction, especially since the Bank has already secured an attachment order. The Court rejected the argument that any financial default could trigger a travel ban, emphasizing that only offences seriously affecting the economic stability of the country or banking system would merit such measures. The Court found no evidence that the petitioner’s travel would threaten the country’s economic interest or banking system. To address the Bank’s concern about the petitioner’s return, the Court proposed a conditional undertaking by the petitioner to return within five months and to provide contact details during travel. Thus, the Court balanced the petitioner’s constitutional rights with the Bank’s interests, allowing travel subject to safeguards. The Court also noted that the respondents must file affidavits in opposition before final disposal, but interim relief was granted to the petitioner.
Holding and Implications
The Court granted interim relief permitting the petitioner to travel abroad subject to filing an undertaking to return within five months and providing contact details.
The respondents are restrained from preventing the petitioner’s travel until the next hearing, provided the petitioner complies with the conditions. The petition remains pending with directions for the respondents to file affidavits in opposition within four weeks. The decision directly affects the petitioner’s right to travel for livelihood and does not establish a new precedent beyond the case’s facts and interim nature.
Sabyasachi Bhattacharyya, J.:— The Court: The grievance of the writ petitioner is that despite the writ petitioner being a sailor in merchant vessel and having a contract for 4 (+/- 1) months from February 12, 2020 to board a merchant vessel, which contract is annexed at page 29 of the instant writ petition. The petitioner was prevented by the immigration authorities when he sought to leave India on the ground of a Look Out Circular (LOC) having been issued against the petitioner. Although the petitioner has no direct knowledge about the LOC, the petitioner has learnt that the same was issued on the request of the respondent no. 3 Bank.
2. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that there was a criminal case registered by the CBI against the petitioner, as a director of a company against which there were certain allegations of default of a loan given by the respondent no. 3 Bank. The investigation of the CBI in such matter ended in a charge sheet being filed, wherein the present petitioner was discharged on the finding that the present petitioner was not liable for the said default. Upon the said order being passed on the basis of the acceptance of the charge sheet, the CBI challenged the same in revision; however, the revision was itself rejected, thereby affirming the order of discharge of the petitioner.
3. That apart, it is submitted, a case under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act was initiated, in connection with which the adjudicating authority passed an order of attachment of an account of the petitioner to the extent of Rs. 50 lakh. The petitioner having challenged such order before the Division Bench of this Court, the Division Bench disposed of the appeal by granting the petitioner the liberty to open a separate salary account for the purpose of getting his livelihood.
4. In such circumstances, it is submitted that the personal liberty of the petitioner, which is granted by the fundamental rights under the Constitution of India, and his right to carry on any profession of his choice, as enshrined in the Constitution of India, cannot be curtailed by preventing the petitioner from leaving the country.
5. It is further submitted that the petitioner is not seeking to leave the country for pleasure but for his livelihood, as is apparent from the contract of employment as annexed at page 29 of the writ petition. Learned Counsel for the petitioner further argues that the petitioner has travelled abroad several times during the pendency of the criminal case itself and has come back to contest the case, which ex facie is sufficient to show the bona fides of the petitioner in that regard.
6. Learned Counsel for the petitioner sites certain unreported judgments of different High Courts in support of his contention, being as follows:
1. Bank of Baroda v. Nimish Kalyabhai Vasa,
2. Dr. Shrikant Bhasi v. Bureau of Immigration,
3. Priya Parameswaran Pillai v. Union of India,
4. SMT. Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India, reported in (1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 (S.C) 597
7. Learned Counsel for the respondent no. 3 Bank submits that financial defaults are included within the purview of issuance of Look Out Circulars after the latest amendments to the concerned Guidelines. As such, preventing the petitioner from leaving the country was wholly within the periphery of legal process as sanctioned by the LOC itself.
8. Learned Counsel for the petitioner Banks submits that the dues from the petitioner are much more than the worth of the account attached and, as such, it is submitted that permitting the petitioner to leave the country would put the Bank at risk inasmuch as, there would not any assurance that the petitioner would return later to India to face trial.
9. Learned Counsel appearing for the respondent no. 1 and 2 submits that the said respondents acted on the request of the Bank in issuance of the LOC and, pursuant to the LOC, the petitioner was prevented from travelling abroad. In his usual fairness, learned Counsel for the respondents no. 1 and 2 takes a neutral stand so far as the LOC as well as the veracity of the request giving rise to such Circular being concerned.
10. A bare perusal of the contract of employment of the petitioner, annexed as annexure P2 at page 29, shows that the outer limit within which the petitioner has to returned in India is 5 months from the commencement of the date of his voyage. As such, in the present case there is little or no scope for the petitioner to remain out of India after the said period.
11. That apart, in the present case, the travels sought by the petitioner are not even for luxury but to maintain his livelihood, since he is a sailor by occupation and in the event he does not honour the contract of employment, he may also face financial consequences for that and lose his regular income.
12. It is further seen from the above-referred order of the Division Bench of this Court that the petitioner was permitted to open a separate salary account which would be beyond the pale of the order of attachment. The said direction would be rendered meaningless in the event the petitioner is not allowed to earn such salary by travelling abroad.
13. That apart, in view of the CBI itself having discharged the petitioner from the criminal case initiated against the petitioner along with others, and such order being affirmed in revision, there is no pending allegation of “offence” under the Penal Code, 1860 or any penal statue, as contemplated in the Guidelines regarding issuance of Look Out Circulars, which can prevent the petitioner from travelling abroad.
14. The financial default which has been alleged by the Bank, ipso facto, is not a good ground for issuance of look out notice or at least preventing the petitioner from leaving the country. Since the Bank has already taken steps as per the appropriate law governing such loans and defaults relating thereto and already an existing attachment order is there, such order operates as sufficient security for the Bank for the time being. Moreover, although by virtue of the current amendments to the Guidelines, offences which affect adversely THE economic interest of the country as a whole would be the closest charge which could be attracted in the present case for restraining the petitioner from his travels. However, such logic is inappropriate since there is remedy for recovery of such amount, which has been exhausted by the Bank and culminated in order of attachment.
15. If such logic is extended to its logical conclusion, even the default of a single rupee would be sufficient to restrict the personal liberty of a citizen to leave the country, because the loss of a single rupee also affects the economy of the country and no cut-off line on financial loans can be drawn for the purpose of constituting an economic offence which jeopardizes the interest of the country.
16. To affect the economy interest of the country as a whole as envisaged under the guidelines, the said offence should be of a much greater magnitude, which shakes the economic stability of the country or the finance market of the country or is of such a nature that the banking system of the country is under threat in the event the petitioner leaves the country. In the present case, however, no such high ground has been made out by the Bank for the respondent nos. 1 and 2 to prevent the petitioner from travelling abroad.
17. Despite the apprehension of the bank that the petitioner would not return to India, the same could be alleviated by directing the petitioner to file an undertaking during the course of the day stating that the petitioner would return to India on or before the expiry 5 months from his commencement of travelling. Such affidavit should also disclose the contact details of the petitioner, on which he would be accessible during the period of his travels.
18. Accordingly, since extensive arguments were extended at this stage of deciding interim prayers, such arguments had to be dealt with and this elaborate order had to be passed. However, the writ petition cannot be disposed of at this juncture in view of the respondents praying for opportunity to file their affidavit in opposition. Yet, subject to filing of the undertaking, the petitioner's right to travel abroad has to be opened up.
19. Accordingly, the respondents are directed to file their affidavit in opposition within four weeks from date. Affidavit in reply, if any, shall be filed by the petitioner within four weeks thereafter, if necessary, by affirming such affidavit in reply and notarizing the same in some foreign country and transmitting the same to India to be endorsed by the Commissioner of oaths of this court, which provision is existing within the framework of the rules framed by this Court both in respect of Original Side and Appellate Side writ matters.
20. However, in the meantime, the respondents are restrained from preventing the petitioner from travelling abroad with effect from tomorrow, subject to the petitioner filing an undertaking to the effect that the petitioner shall be returning on or before the expiry of 5 months from the date of commencement of his voyage to India and disclosing the contact numbers of the petitioner where the petitioner would be accessible during the period of his travel. A copy of such undertaking shall be served on the learned Advocate on record for the respondents as well. Let the writ petition being WP 105 of 2020 next appear for hearing in the Combined Monthly List of May, 2020.
21. Let a signed copy be given to the parties upon compliance of necessary formalities.
Alert