- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Daler Singh v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, Daler Singh, sought a direction to respondent Nos. 1 and 2 to issue him a passport which had been withheld on the complaint made by respondent No. 3. The petitioner states that he was married to Sandeep Kaur on 2.6.2009, has been living in Italy for over seven years and visits India often. On 23.3.2015 an argument occurred when he informed his wife that he intended to take her and their son to Italy; Sandeep Kaur left his house and took away his passport No. H-0805464 (issued from Milan). She made complaints to various police authorities and to the NRI Wing, Phase VII, Mohali, seeking an FIR on general allegations of dowry. The petitioner reported his passport as missing to the Punjab Police (Annexure P-1), applied for re-issue on 11.4.2015 (Annexure P-2) and filed an affidavit dated 7.4.2015 (Annexure P-3) stating the passport was lost in his house and requesting re-issue.
On 25.5.2015 the petitioner learned that respondent Nos. 1 and 2 had not re-issued his passport because respondent No. 3 had filed an application stating an inquiry was pending against the petitioner. In the respondents' reply it was stated that the petitioner had given inconsistent particulars in his application (naming his spouse as "Gurwinder Kaur" and stating marital status as "divorcee") and that adverse police verification from respondent No. 4 indicated he was married to Sandeep Kaur. The police verification further disclosed that FIR No. 27.5.2015 under Sections 406, 420, 494, 498-A read with Section 34 IPC was registered at Police Station NRI Patiala and that a clear police verification report was awaited before reconsideration. The Court heard counsel for the parties and disposed of the petition with directions (see Holding).
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the passport authorities were justified in withholding/re-fusing re-issue of the petitioner's passport merely because an FIR arising out of a matrimonial dispute was registered and the matter was at the stage of police investigation.
- What constitutes "proceedings in respect of an offence pending before a criminal court in India" under Section 6(2)(f) of the Passports Act, 1967 — specifically, whether the pendency at the investigation stage (before cognizance) attracts Section 6(2)(f) or whether cognizance by a court is required.
- Whether incorrect or inconsistent disclosures in the passport application (spouse's name, marital status) and an adverse police verification report can justify non-recommendation or withholding of passport re-issuance pending clarification.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner contended that merely because an FIR arising out of a matrimonial dispute was pending, the respondents were not justified in withholding his passport.
- The petitioner relied on precedent authorities (including Abhijit Sen, Tarsem Singh and Surinder Pal Singh) to support the contention that pendency of an FIR at the investigation stage is not an adequate ground for withholding a passport.
- The petitioner had applied for re-issue, filed an affidavit explaining the passport was lost, and sought re-issuance despite the complaint filed by respondent No. 3.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents stated that in the re-issue application the petitioner filled the spouse's name as "Gurwinder Kaur" and the marital status as "divorcee", whereas the police verification indicated he was married to Sandeep Kaur; in the absence of correct spouse details the passport facility was not recommended.
- The respondents asserted that an adverse police verification report had been received, and that a further police report revealed FIR No. 27.5.2015 registered under Sections 406, 420, 494, 498-A read with Section 34 IPC was pending against the petitioner at Police Station NRI Patiala.
- The respondents took the position that once a clear police verification report was received from respondent No. 4, the petitioner's case would be reconsidered; the respondents also alleged the petitioner had given false explanations about his marital status.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Abhijit Sen v. Superintendent (Regional Passport Officer), Kolkata (2004 CriLJ 1281 / 2004 (2) All Cri LR 893) | The Division Bench held that the presentation of a charge-sheet does not itself initiate criminal proceedings for the purposes of the Passports Act; proceedings before a Magistrate commence when cognizance is taken. The case involved impoundment under Section 10(2)(e) of the Passports Act. | The Court relied on this authority to support the proposition that proceedings are "pending before a criminal court" only when the court has taken cognizance; thus investigation-stage complaints without cognizance do not attract Section 6(2)(f) or justify impounding under Section 10. |
| Venkatesh Kandasamy v. Government of India, Ministry of External Affairs, Chennai, AIR 2015 Mad 3 | Addressed the question when proceedings can be said to be pending before a Criminal Court for purposes of Section 6(2)(f); noted the scheme of the Passports Act and considered Section 10(3)(e). | The Court referenced this decision to interpret Section 6(2)(f) and to emphasize that a "pending" proceeding requires more than an investigation — the jurisprudence requires court cognizance or similar initiation before deeming proceedings to be pending before a criminal court. |
| Suresh Nanda v. C.B.I., (2008) 3 SCC 674 : AIR 2008 SC 1414 | Discussed Section 10(3)(e) of the Passports Act and, after referencing Constitution Bench decisions (Satwant Singh Sawhney and Menaka Gandhi), explained that the Passports Act being a special Act prevails over Section 104 CrPC; distinguished seizure from impounding and required police to forward seized passports to the Passport Authority with reasons. | The Court relied on the principles expressed in this judgment to underscore that impounding/retention of passports must conform to the Passports Act and that the Passport Authority, after offering an opportunity of hearing, must decide whether to impound — police retention alone is insufficient. |
| Satwant Singh Sawhney v. D. Ramarathnam, Assistant Passport Officer (1967 (3) SCR 525 : AIR 1967 SC 1836) | Constitution Bench authority cited for foundational principles about passports and the law; used in analysis of the Passports Act as a special statute. | Cited (via Suresh Nanda) to support the view that the Passports Act's scheme governs impounding/seizure and that such matters are to be decided under the Act's provisions. |
| Menaka Gandhi v. Union of India ((1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 SC 597) | Constitution Bench authority regarding fundamental rights and limits on administrative action; referenced in interpreting the Passports Act as a special statute within constitutional jurisprudence. | Referred (via Suresh Nanda) to underline that the Passports Act governs restrictions on travel and passport impoundment, reinforcing procedural safeguards such as hearing before impoundment. |
| Tarsem Singh v. Union of India (CWP No. 8902 of 2012, decided 15.01.2014) | Dealt with re-issue of passport where petitioner had been convicted but sentence suspended on appeal; explained circumstances where passport was directed to be issued subject to permission from the criminal court. | The Court cited Tarsem Singh to illustrate that passports may be issued subject to conditions and that travel abroad can be subject to the criminal court's permission; used as precedent for conditional relief where criminal proceedings or convictions are involved. |
| Surinder Pal Singh v. Union of India (CWP No. 24358 of 2014, decided 13.08.2015) | Involved a case where charges were framed and prosecution evidence was pending; the Court disposed of the petition granting liberty to the petitioner to apply to the concerned criminal court for permission to apply for re-issuance of passport. | Referred to show that where criminal proceedings are at a later stage (charges framed), the appropriate course is to seek permission from the criminal court; used to justify directing the petitioner to approach the criminal court for permission to travel abroad. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first identified the statutory scheme: Section 6(2)(f) of the Passports Act allows refusal of a passport where "proceedings in respect of an offence alleged to have been committed by the applicant are pending before a criminal court in India." The Court emphasized the distinction between police investigation and proceedings pending before a criminal court.
Relying on authorities (notably Abhijit Sen and the decisions discussed in Venkatesh Kandasamy and Suresh Nanda), the Court explained that a mere investigation or the presentation of a charge-sheet does not automatically amount to proceedings pending before a criminal court. The Court noted the Division Bench view in Abhijit Sen that initiation of proceedings before a Magistrate for the purposes of the Passports Act occurs only when the Magistrate takes cognizance. The Court also drew on Suresh Nanda (and the underlying Constitution Bench authorities) to stress procedural safeguards: the Passports Act governs impounding/retention and the passport authority must consider reasons and give an opportunity of hearing; police cannot unilaterally retain/impound without following the Act's scheme.
Applying these principles to the present matter, the Court observed that all criminal complaints against the petitioner were only at the stage of investigation. The respondents did not contend that final reports had been filed or that the Criminal Court had taken cognizance or framed charges such that Section 6(2)(f) would apply. Given that the matters remained at the investigation stage and cognizance had not been taken, the Court concluded that the passport authority's non-reissuance amounted to non-application of mind and was vitiated.
The Court therefore directed re-issuance of the passport subject to any other legal impediment. However, the Court qualified that the petitioner's manner of use of the passport for travel outside India would be subject to the orders of the appropriate criminal court in respect of the FIR; the petitioner would have to approach the concerned criminal court to seek leave or permission to travel abroad if he intended to use the passport for that purpose. This approach aligns with prior decisions (e.g., Tarsem Singh and Surinder Pal Singh) permitting conditional issuance or requiring court permission where criminal proceedings are involved.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The petition is disposed of and respondent No. 2 is directed to re-issue the passport to the petitioner, provided there is no other legal impediment, except the registration of the aforesaid case.
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the petitioner's passport is to be re-issued unless there exists some other legal bar not discussed in the petition.
- The re-issued passport's use for travel outside India is subject to any orders or restrictions imposed by the appropriate criminal court in relation to the FIR registered against the petitioner; the petitioner must apply to the concerned criminal court for permission to travel abroad if he intends to do so.
- The Court's decision rests on interpretation of the Passports Act and established precedent that mere registration of an FIR or police investigation (without cognizance by a criminal court) does not by itself justify refusal or impounding under the Act. The order does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying existing authorities to the facts of this petition.
Order accordingly.
1. By filing the present petition, Daler Singh - petitioner has sought direction to respondent Nos. 1 and 2 to issue him a passport, which has been withheld on the complaint made by respondent No. 3.
2. The brief facts, as put forth by the petitioner, are that he was married with one Sandeep Kaur on 2.6.2009. He has been living in Italy for the last more than seven years and had been visiting India very often. On 23.3.2015, when he came to India and informed his wife that he has come to take her and their son to Italy, an argument took place between them. Sandeep Kaur left the house of the petitioner and also took away his passport bearing No. H-0805464, which was issued to him from Milan (Italy). She also made complaints to different police authorities as also to the NRI Wing, Phase VII, Mohali to lodge an FIR against the petitioner on general allegations of dowry. Despite best efforts on the part of the petitioner, the matter could not be resolved amicably. The petitioner gave information to the Punjab Police about his missing passport (Annexure P-1) and also applied for re-issue of the same before respondent Nos. 1 and 2 on 11.4.2015 (Annexure P-2). He also filed the requisite affidavit dated 7.4.2015 (Annexure P-3) regarding his missing passport, wherein, he mentioned that it was issued from Italy and has been lost in his house on 7.4.2015. He requested the authorities to reissue the passport.
3. On 25.5.2015, on enquiry, the petitioner came to know that respondent Nos. 1 and 2 have not re-issued his passport because of the application made by respondent No. 3 stating that an inquiry is pending against the petitioner on the complaint of his wife.
4. In the reply filed on behalf of respondent Nos. 1 to 3, it has been stated that while applying for re-issue of the passport, in the column of spouse, the petitioner has filled the name of ‘Gurwinder Kaur’, while marital status was filled up as ‘divorcee’. It is further stated that adverse police verification report has been received from respondent No. 4, wherein, it is mentioned that the petitioner is married to Sandeep Kaur and in the absence of a correct mention of the spouse name passport facility was not recommended. The reply further states that a false explanation has been given by the petitioner that he had been living with Sandeep Kaur, but not legally divorced from the earlier wife. The second police verification report received from respondent No. 4 further revealed that court case FIR No. 27.5.2015 under Sections 406, 420, 494, 498-A read with Section 34 of the Penal Code, 1860, registered at Police Station NRI Patiala is pending against the petitioner. It has been stated that as and when a clear police verification report is received from respondent No. 4, the case of the petitioner would be reconsidered.
5. I have heard Learned counsel for the parties.
6. The contention on behalf of the petitioner is that merely on account of pendency of an FIR in a matrimonial dispute, the respondents are not justified to withheld his passport. Reliance has been placed on Abhijit Sen v. Superintendent (Administration) Regional Passport Officer, Kolkata, 2004 (2) All Cri LR 893 : (2004 Cri LJ 1281 (Cat)) CWP No. 890 2 of 2012 tided Tarsem Singh v. Union of India, decided on 15.01.2014 and CWP No. 24358 of 2014 titled Surinder Pal Singh v. Union of India decided on 13.08.2015.
7. The right to travel abroad has been recognized as a fundamental right by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Accordingly only such restrictions can be imposed thereon as are authorized by law.
8. The grounds for refusal of passports and travel documents are specified in the Passports Act, 1967. The relevant Sections 6(2) and 10(3) thereof are reproduced below:
“6. Refusal of passports, travel documents, etc.—
(2) Subject to the other provisions of this Act, the passport authority shall refuse to issue a passport or travel document for visiting any foreign country under clause (c) of sub-section (2) of section 5 on any one or more of the following grounds, and on no other ground, namely:
(a) that the applicant is not a citizen of India.,
(b) that the applicant may, or is likely to, engage outside India in activities prejudicial to the sovereignty and integrity of India.
(c) that the departure of the applicant from India may, or is likely to, be detrimental to the security of India;
(d) that the presence of the applicant outside India may, or is likely to, prejudice the friendly relations of India with any foreign country;
(e) that the applicant has, at any time during the period of five years immediately preceding the date of his application, been convicted by a court in India for any offence involving moral turpitude and sentenced in respect thereof to imprisonment for not less than two years;
(f) that proceedings in respect of an offence alleged to have been committed by the applicant are pending before a criminal court in India;
(g) that a warrant or summons for the appearance, or a warrant for the arrest, of the applicant has been issued by a court under any law for the time being in force or that an order prohibiting the departure from India of the applicant has been made by any such court;
(h) that the applicant has been repatriated and has not reimbursed the expenditure incurred in connection with such repatriation;
(i) that in the opinion of the Central Government the issue of a passport or travel document to the applicant will not be in the public interest.
9. Variation, impounding and revocation of passports and travel documents.—
(3) The passport authority may impound or cause to be impounded or revoke a passport or travel document,—
(a) if the passport authority is satisfied that the holder of the passport or travel document is in wrongful possession thereof;
(b) if the passport or travel document was obtained by the suppression of material information or on the basis of wrong information provided by the holder of the passport or travel document or any other person on his behalf; [Provided that if the holder of such passport obtains another passport the passport authority shall also impound or cause to be impounded or revoke such other passport]
(c) if the passport authority deems it necessary so to do in the interests of the sovereignty and integrity of India, the security of India, friendly relations of India with any foreign country, or in the interests of the general public;
(d) if the holder of the passport or travel document has, at any time after the issue of the passport or travel document, been convicted by a court in India for any offence involving moral turpitude and sentenced in respect thereof to imprisonment for not less than two years;
(e) if proceedings in respect of an offence alleged to have been committed by the holder of the passport or travel document are pending before a criminal court in India.
(f) if any of the conditions of the passport or travel document has been contravened;
(g) if the holder of the passport or travel document has failed to comply with a notice under sub-section (1) requiring him to deliver up the same;
(h) if it is brought to the notice of the passport authority that a warrant or summons for the appearance, or a warrant for the arrest, of the holder of the passport or travel document has been issued by a court under any law for the time being in force or if an order prohibiting the departure from India of the holder of the passport or other travel document has been made by any such court and the passport authority is satisfied that a warrant or summons has been so issued or an order has been so made.”
10. Clearly, as per Section 6(2)(f) the issuance of a passport can be refused if proceedings in respect of a criminal offence alleged to have been committed by the applicant are pending before a criminal court in India.
11. In Abhijit Sen's case, (2004 CriLJ 1281) (Cal)) (supra), the passport of the appellant/petitioner (therein) had been impounded under Section 10(2)(e) of the Passports Act, 1967 on the allegation that a criminal case is pending against him before a Criminal Court in India, at the instance of his wife. The Division Bench of Calcutta High Court after taking into consideration various decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and the High Courts on the issue, held as under:—
“16. The above observations of the Apex Court makes it clear that submission of the charge sheet is a matter culminating after the investigation by the Police is over and over which the Court has no control and therefore, the presentation of a charge sheet cannot be said to initiate the criminal proceedings until cognizance is taken by the Magistrate to place the accused on trial.”
12. In Venkatesh Kandasamy v. Government of India, Ministry of External Affairs, Chennai, AIR 2015 Mad 3, the Court was concerned with the question as to when can the proceedings be said to be pending before the Criminal Court.
“19. Having taken note of the scheme of the Passports Act, if we now go back to Section 6(2)(f) of the Act, it is seen that after invoking the said provision the first requisite is that proceedings in respect of an offence should be pending before a Criminal Court in India. The question as to what tantamount to proceedings pending before the Criminal Court, had come up for consideration earlier.
20. In Suresh Nanda v. C.B.I. [Appeal (Cri.) No. 179 of 2008 dated 24.1.2008: ((2008) 3 SCC 674 : AIR 2008 SC 1414) by the Supreme Court], the passport of a non resident Indian settled in the United Kingdom, was seized by the Police, when they conducted a search. A first information report was registered on the basis of a sting operation carried out by a news portal. The passport seized during the search was retained by the Central Bureau of Investigation. The Special Judge of the CBI Court directed the release of the passport. On a criminal revision filed by the Central Bureau of Investigation, the High Court reversed the order of the Special Court. Therefore, the individual filed a special leave petition before the Supreme Court.
21. After taking note of the provisions of Section 10(3)(e) of the Passports Act, 1967 and after taking note of the decisions of two Constitution Benches, one in Satwant Singh Sawhney v. D. Ramarathnam, Assistant Passport Officer, [1967 (3) SCR 525] : (AIR 1967 SC 1836) and Menaka Gandhi v. Union of India [(1978) 1 SCC 248] : ((1978) 1 SCC 248 : AIR 1978 SC 597), the Supreme Court held that the Passports Act, 1967 being a Special Act, the provisions therein would prevail over Section 104 of the Cri PC, which confers general power upon the Court to impound any document. The Court also pointed out the distinction between the mere seizure of a passport and the impounding of the same. A seizure is made at a particular moment, when somebody takes into possession of some property. However, if the seized property is retained for some period of time, the retention amounts to impounding. Therefore, the Supreme Court pointed out that while the Police may have the power to seize a passport under Section 102 of the Code, if it is permissible within the authority given therein, it does not have the power to retain or impound the same. The Court also indicated that the moment the Police seizes a passport under Section 102 of the Cri PC, they must send it along with a letter to the Passport Authority clearly stating that the seized passport deserves to be impounded for want of reasons mentioned in Section 10(3). It is thereafter for the Passport Authority to decide what to do. Even while taking a decision, the Passport Authority is to give an opportunity of hearing. What is important in the aforesaid decision is that in paragraph 15, the Court indicated that even the Court cannot impound a passport despite the enabling provision in Section 104 of the Code.
22. In Abhijit Sen v. Superintendent, [2004 CriLJ 1281], a Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court was concerned with a case where the Passport Authority impounded the passport under Section 10(2)(e), on the ground that a criminal case was pending against the passport holder. The Calcutta High Court held that there are two processes for initiation of a proceeding before a Criminal Court. While the first part is the investigation by the Police, the other part is the direction by the Court. Therefore, after pointing out the condition prescribed in Section 190 of the Cri PC for initiation of proceedings, the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court opined that the proceedings before a Magistrate is initiated when cognizance is taken. The Court held that no proceeding can be said to have been initiated under Clause (a) of Section 190 within the meaning of Section 10(2)(3) of the Passports Act.
23. Insofar as the case on hand is concerned, all the criminal complaints as against the petitioner are only at the stage of investigation. It is not a case of the Respondent that final reports have been filed in the criminal Courts in any of the criminal complaints, so as to make the case come within the four comers of Section 6(2)(f). Therefore, the impugned order is vitiated by non-application of mind and hence it is liable to be set aside.”
13. Thus, it has been held that proceedings can be said to be pending before a criminal court only when a cognizance has been taken by the Court.
14. In Tarsem Singh's case (supra), this Court dealt with a matter of re-issue of passport to the petitioner, who was convicted and sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for 5 years by the Trial Court. Appeal against conviction and sentence filed by him was pending, wherein, his sentence was suspended. The objection of the respondent was that the petitioner had not disclosed about his conviction in a criminal case at the time of police verification. Later on, the petitioner filed affidavit mentioning these facts. In these circumstances, this Court directed the Passport Officer to issue the passport to the petitioner, subject to the conditions that the petitioner shall take necessary permission by filing application before the Court to go abroad.
15. In Surinder Pal Singh's case (supra), a case under Sections 427/506/148/149, IPC and Section 25 of the Arms Act was registered against the petitioner. Report under Section 173 of the Cri PC had been filed and even the charge was also framed against him and the case was pending for prosecution evidence. This Court disposed of the petition granting liberty to the petitioner to apply to the concerned criminal court and seek its permission to apply for re-issuance of passport.
16. Coming to the facts of the case in hand, a criminal case arising out of the strained matrimonial ties has been registered against the petitioner at the instance of his alleged wife. As per the documents available on record and the version of the parties, the Criminal Court has not taken cognizance of it and charge against the petitioner has not been framed.
17. In view of above, this petition is disposed of with a direction to respondent No. 2 to re-issue the passport to the petitioner, if there is no other legal impediment, except the registration of the aforesaid case. However, it is directed that the manner of the use of the passport for travel outside will be subject to the orders of the appropriate criminal court of competent jurisdiction in respect of the FIR registered against the petitioner. The petitioner will himself approach the concerned Court, and seek appropriate directions to travel abroad, if he intends to use the passport for such a purpose. The petition is disposed of with the above directions.
18. Order accordingly.
Alert