Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anun Dhawan And Others v. Union Of India And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Feb 10, 2020
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Court heard counsel for the parties in a matter in which notice had previously been issued on 2-9-2019 (reported at 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1757). Despite the passage of considerable time after issuance of notice, most States and Union Territories had not filed counter-affidavits/documents. The Court recorded that only the following had filed: (i) Union Territory of Andaman & Nicobar, (ii) the State of Punjab, (iii) Karnataka, (iv) Uttarakhand, (v) Jharkhand, (vi) Nagaland, and (vii) Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir. The present order addresses non-compliance by the remaining States/Union Territories and fixes costs and timelines for filing.

Legal Issues Presented

The opinion addresses a procedural matter and does not frame distinct legal issues.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
2-9-2019 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1757 Issuance of notice in the matter The Court referenced the prior notice order to highlight that, despite notice having been issued earlier, most States/Union Territories had still not filed counter-affidavits/documents.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court noted that, although notice had been issued earlier, most States and Union Territories had failed to file counter-affidavits/documents, with only a limited set of jurisdictions having complied. The Court characterized the continued lack of response as “unfortunate” given the lapse of a considerable period of time. To address this non-compliance, the Court imposed monetary costs on each State/Union Territory for failure to file counter-affidavits and structured a differential cost regime: a reduced cost for those ready to file by the next evening, and the higher cost for the remaining jurisdictions. The order also directed that the collected costs be deposited with the Registrar (Judl.) and maintained under a separate head, and it granted one week’s time to the remaining States/Union Territories to file.

Holding and Implications

COSTS IMPOSED AND TIME GRANTED FOR FILING.

  • Costs of Rs 5,00,000 were imposed on each State and Union Territory for not filing counter-affidavits in the matter.
  • States/Union Territories that file their counter-affidavits by “tomorrow evening” were directed to pay reduced costs of Rs 1,00,000.
  • The remaining States/Union Territories were directed to pay Rs 5,00,000 and were granted one week to file their counter-affidavits.
  • The costs were to be deposited with the Registrar (Judl.) of the Court, to be kept under a separate head.
  • The matter was directed to be listed on Monday, 17-2-2020.

The direct implication is to compel procedural compliance (filing of counter-affidavits) through financial sanctions and strict timelines. The order, as provided, does not indicate any broader legal implications or the setting of any new precedent beyond these directions in the present matter.

Show all summary ...

Order

1. Heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties.

2. Even though notice was issued in the matter on 2-9-2019 2019 SCC OnLine SC 1757, no counter-affidavits/documents are filed by the States except : (i) Union Territory of Andaman & Nicobar, (ii) the States of Punjab, (iii) Karnataka, (iv) Uttarakhand, (v) Jharkhand, (vi) Nagaland, and (vii) Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir.

3. It is unfortunate to note that even after lapse of considerable period of time, there is no proper response from the State Governments. In view of the above, we impose costs of Rs 5,00,000 (Rupees five lakhs only) on each State and Union Territory for not filing counter-affidavits in the matter.

4. We are informed by some of the learned counsel appearing for the States/Union Territories that they are ready with their counter-affidavits. In view of the above, those States'/Union Territories' counsel, who file their counter-affidavits by tomorrow evening, shall have to pay a costs of Rs 1,00,000 (Rupees one lakh only) and rest of the States/Union Territories shall have to pay a costs of Rs 5,00,000 as stated hereinabove and one week's time is granted to them for the purpose.

5. The costs shall be deposited with the Registrar (Judl.) of this Court who shall keep the same in a separate head.

6. List matter on Monday, 17-2-2020.

Court Masters