- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mukul Agrawal And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellants challenged a High Court order dated 21-5-2019 dismissing their application under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC) seeking quashing of criminal proceedings in Complaint Case No. 2705 of 2003 filed by Respondent 2 under Sections 420, 467, 468, and 471 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC).
Respondent 2 had earlier filed Original Suit No. 12 of 1996 asserting tenancy rights in a disputed shop and seeking injunction reliefs against alleged attempts to evict him and discontinue amenities. The appellant relied on an agreement dated 30-3-1988 to contend that Respondent 2 was merely working in the shop and was not a tenant.
During pendency of the civil suit, Respondent 2 filed the criminal complaint alleging that the 30-3-1988 agreement produced in the civil suit was false and fabricated and that Respondent 2 had never signed it, relying on a handwriting expert opinion submitted in the civil court.
The civil suit was decided on 13-5-2015 holding that Respondent 2’s signature on the agreement was forged and that the document was fabricated. The appellant then filed Civil Appeal No. 17 of 2015, which was allowed, setting aside the trial court’s findings and holding that the agreement was not false or fabricated.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the criminal proceedings in Complaint Case No. 2705 of 2003 alleging use of a forged/fabricated agreement should be quashed under Section 482 CrPC in light of the civil appellate court’s conclusive finding that the agreement dated 30-3-1988 was not forged or fabricated.
- Whether the High Court’s order dismissing the Section 482 CrPC application was vitiated for being non-reasoned and non-speaking, thereby impairing effective judicial review.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court found that the High Court’s order was deficient because it merely discussed general principles for quashing “laid down in judicial precedents” and then abruptly declined interference without reflecting consideration of facts or materials. The Court emphasized that an order amenable to challenge must be reasoned and speaking to facilitate meaningful judicial review.
On the merits, the Court treated the civil appellate court’s determination in Civil Appeal No. 17 of 2015—holding that the agreement dated 30-3-1988 was not false or fabricated—as conclusive for the purpose of assessing the criminal complaint’s foundation. Since the criminal complaint was premised on the allegation that the agreement was forged and fabricated (supported originally by handwriting expert opinion and the trial court’s civil finding), the appellate civil court’s contrary finding removed the “substratum” of the criminal case.
Accordingly, the Court held that permitting prosecution to continue despite the civil appellate finding would amount to a complete abuse of the process of law, justifying quashing of the complaint proceedings.
Holding and Implications
ALLOWED; PROCEEDINGS QUASHED. The Court quashed the proceedings in Complaint Case No. 2705 of 2003 and allowed the appeal.
The direct implication is that the appellants will not face prosecution in the said complaint case because the criminal allegation depended on the agreement being forged, a premise negated by the civil appellate court’s finding. The opinion does not discuss broader implications beyond this case and does not indicate that any new precedent was set.
Navin Sinha, J.— Leave granted. The appellants are aggrieved by order dated 21-5-2019 2019 SCC OnLine All 5765 dismissing their application under Section 482 CrPC, 1973 declining to quash the entire proceedings against them in Complaint Case No. 2705 of 2003 filed by Respondent 2 under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 IPC, 1860.
2. The order of the High Court unfortunately only discusses the principles for quashing laid down in judicial precedents and abruptly concludes to decline interference. The order does not reflect any consideration of the facts, the materials and the reasons why the High Court was not persuaded to entertain the application. We are therefore deprived of the understanding for the reasons why the High Court did not consider it a fit case for interference. Needless to state, any order which is amenable to challenge in a superior court, has to be reasoned and speaking to facilitate better understanding of the order making judicial review an effective exercise.
3. The respondent filed Original Suit No. 12 of 1996 stating that he was a tenant in the disputed shop and was wrongly being asked to vacate, declining to accept rent, seeking a permanent injunction restraining the appellant from evicting him, disconnecting the telephone and water connection, etc. The appellant relied on an agreement dated 30-3-1988 to submit that the respondent was working in the disputed shop and that he was not a tenant.
4. Even while the suit was pending, the present complaint came to be filed alleging that the agreement dated 30-3-1988 produced by the appellant in the suit was a false and fabricated document and that the respondent had never signed such an agreement. The basis for the complaint was the opinion of the handwriting expert submitted in the civil court.
5. The civil suit came to be decided on 13-5-2015 holding that the signature of Respondent 2 on the agreement dated 30-3-1988 was forged and that it was a fabricated document.
6. The aggrieved appellant, preferred Civil Appeal No. 17 of 2015 which has been allowed setting aside the findings in the suit holding that the agreement was not a false and fabricated document.
7. In view of the conclusive opinion of the appellate court that the agreement dated 30-3-1988 was not a forged document, the very substratum of the criminal complaint vanishes. In the circumstances to allow the appellants to be prosecuted will only be a complete abuse of the process of law. The proceedings in Complaint Case No. 2705 of 2003 are therefore quashed and the appeal is allowed.
Alert