- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Triveni Prasad And Others v. Union Of India Through Secy., Ministry Of Surface Transport
Factual and Procedural Background
Seven petitioners filed a writ petition claiming they were the recorded tenure-holders of plot No. 696 and that the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI) had unlawfully occupied that plot to widen the road and construct a toll plaza. Directions to obtain instructions were issued on 24 April 2014. Because instructions were not forthcoming, a Division Bench of this Court on 18 July 2014 passed an interim order restraining the respondents from interfering with the petitioners' possession of plot No. 696 at village Dakhina Sheikhpur, Tehsil Mohanlalganj, District Lucknow, until further orders.
The NHAI applied to vacate the interim order and filed a counter-affidavit dated 24 September 2015 stating that a notification for acquisition under the National Highways Act, 1956 had been issued, objections invited and considered, compensation determined and an award delivered on 25 July 2015. The counter-affidavit stated that acquisition covered 0.3110 hectare and compensation had been awarded and notice given to petitioners for disbursement. The petitioners disputed the quantum of compensation and invoked provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (the 2013 Act).
The petitioners also sought by an amendment application to challenge a communication dated 22 November 2014 rejecting a representation for acquiring alternative plot No. 807 (belonging to Gaon Sabha), and prayed to quash notifications dated 16 February 2015 and 8 September 2014 under the 1956 Act. The NHAI opposed the amendment, contending compensation had already been dispensed and that the decision to acquire the disputed land was approved by a competent committee in public interest; it also argued the alternative land proposed by petitioners was unacceptable.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the interim order dated 18 July 2014 restraining the respondents from interfering with possession of plot No. 696 should be vacated in view of acquisition proceedings and payment of compensation under the National Highways Act, 1956.
- Whether the choice of plot No. 696 for acquisition (as opposed to an alternative plot No. 807 suggested by the petitioners) was arbitrary or amenable to judicial review.
- Whether the petitioners are entitled to challenge the acquisition notifications and, separately, to claim enhancement of or entitlement to compensation in accordance with the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (and related ordinances and notifications), i.e., the applicability of the 2013 Act to acquisition under the National Highways Act, 1956 and the petitioners' right to fair compensation and rehabilitation/resettlement benefits.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- They are the recorded tenure-holders of plot No. 696 and that it was unlawfully occupied by NHAI for widening the road and constructing a toll plaza.
- They disputed the quantum of compensation awarded and sought assessment/quantification under the 2013 Act.
- They contended that an alternative nearby land (plot No. 807) was available and acquiring the roadside portion (plot No. 696) caused considerable loss and deprived them of roadside access to their remaining land.
- They alleged the acquisition of their plot was not required for road alignment but for constructing a toll plaza.
Respondents' (NHAI's) Arguments
- A notification for acquisition under the National Highways Act, 1956 was issued; objections were considered; compensation was determined and the award delivered on 25 July 2015 for 0.3110 hectare; petitioners have been given notice for disbursement.
- The policy decision and choice of land were approved by the competent committee based on feasibility and location and taken in public interest without intention to prejudice petitioners.
- The alternative land suggested by petitioners was unacceptable and therefore the acquisition choice cannot be set aside by the Court.
- The amendment seeking to challenge notifications cannot now be permitted because compensation has already been dispensed with and acquisition proceedings are complete in relation to the plot in question.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the affidavits, rejoinders and heard counsel for both sides. Its analysis proceeded along two main strands: (A) the validity of the acquisition and the choice of land, and (B) the petitioners' right to claim compensation under the statutory framework of the 1956 Act read with the 2013 Act and subsequent ordinances/notification.
A. Choice of land and challenge to acquisition:
- The Court observed that the interim order of 18 July 2014 had prevented the road-widening and construction of a toll plaza.
- On the factual material (notably the revenue map annexed to the petitioners' rejoinder and the appraisal committee's report relied upon by respondents), plot No. 806 is the existing national highway, sought to be aligned with plot No. 686 by widening, and plot No. 696 lies on the north-eastern side where the highway is slightly narrow.
- The Court accepted the Authority's explanation that plot No. 696 was chosen for widening based on the appraisal committee's report and locational considerations; it held the choice was not shown to be arbitrary on the material before it.
- The Court explained that the selection of land for highway alignment and widening is a matter for the expert authority (NHAI) and is not ordinarily amenable to judicial review in the absence of material showing arbitrariness; consequently, the petitioners' contention that plot No. 807 should have been acquired could not be converted into a matter of judicial choice by the Court.
- Because acquisition was for a public purpose and no material contradicted that, the challenge raised by amendment to the acquisition notifications was deemed unsustainable; the amendment application was rejected insofar as it challenged the acquisition process and choice of land.
B. Compensation and statutory applicability:
- The Court noted on record that acquisition proceedings had been conducted and compensation awarded. It then turned to the question of the petitioners' entitlement to claim compensation and its quantum.
- The Court considered Section 105 of the 2013 Act (which governs the applicability of the 2013 Act's provisions to enactments listed in the Fourth Schedule) and observed that the National Highways Act, 1956 is included in the Fourth Schedule to the 2013 Act.
- The Court reviewed subsequent executive instruments: Ordinance No. 9 of 2014 (amending section 105 to make 2013 Act provisions relating to compensation and rehabilitation/resettlement apply to enactments in the Fourth Schedule with effect from 1 January 2015), Ordinance No. 4 of 2015 and Ordinance No. 5 of 2015 (which contained similar amendments), and the Central Government's notification dated 28 August 2015 (Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Removal of Difficulties) Order, 2015) which came into force on 1 September 2015 and applied the 2013 Act's provisions on compensation, rehabilitation/resettlement and infrastructure amenities to cases of acquisition under enactments specified in the Fourth Schedule.
- On this statutory and executive framework, the Court held that petitioners have the right to contest entitlement to "free and fair compensation" in accordance with the 2013 Act (and the referenced ordinances/notification) and that it is open to petitioners to raise such claims before the competent authority or court where enhancement or fair compensation issues are pending or may be raised.
- Accordingly, while the Court refused to interfere with the acquisition itself, it preserved the petitioners' statutory remedies and rights to pursue compensation-related claims before the appropriate forum.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is disposed of; the interim order dated 18 July 2014 is vacated; and the amendment application insofar as it challenged the acquisition proceedings is rejected.
Implications:
- Direct effect on parties: The Court declined to interfere with the acquisition of plot No. 696 and allowed the NHAI to proceed subject to the rights preserved below. The interim restraint on interference with possession was vacated.
- Preservation of compensation remedies: The petitioners retain the right to contest the quantum and entitlement to compensation — specifically, to raise claims for enhancement or fair compensation under the provisions of the 2013 Act (as affected by the ordinances and the 28 August 2015 notification) before the competent authority or court. The Court noted petitioners have a full right to pursue such claims and that the competent forum is obliged to decide those claims in law.
- Precedential impact: The opinion does not purport to lay down any new legal principle or to set a broader precedent beyond the adjudication of the petition before it; the Court expressly declined to entertain the amendment challenge to acquisition on the facts and statutory context presented.
Disposition: "Petition Disposed Of." (as recorded in the opinion)
Amreshwar Pratap Sahi and Attau Rahman Masoodi, JJ.:— This writ petition by seven petitioners was filed claiming relief over plot No. 696 contending that they are the recorded tenure holders of the said plot which has been unlawfully occupied by the National Highways Authority of India to widen the road and to raise a Toll Plaza. Directions were issued on 24.4.2014 to obtain instructions but since instructions were not coming forward a Division Bench of this Court on 18.7.2014 passed an interim order restraining the respondents from interfering with the possession of the disputed land being plot No. 696 at village Dakhina Sheikhpur, Tehsil Mohanlalganj, District Lucknow till further orders.
2. The National Highways Authority of India moved an application for vacating the said order alongwith a counter-affidavit dated 24.9.2015 wherein it has been stated that a notification for acquisition was issued under the National Highways Act, 1956 inviting objections and pursuant thereto reports were obtained on the objections so filed, whereafter, on opportunity being provided the compensation was determined and the award was delivered on 25.7.2015. The counter-affidavit categorically states that the notification was issued for acquisition of the disputed plot to the extent of 0.3110 Hect. only for which compensation has been awarded and the petitioners have been put to notice for disbursement of such compensation. A dispute has been raised with regard to the quantum of the same as the petitioners' are claiming assessment and quantification in terms of the Right to fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. The petitioners also urge that an alternative nearby land was available and, therefore, acquiring the roadside land of the petitioner has put them to considerable loss and they would also be deprived of any access to their remaining land from the roadside. These facts have been said in the rejoinder sworn by Sri Narmada Prasad dated 8.10.2015. An amendment application has been filed by the petitioners wherein they allege that they had moved a representation for acquiring plot No. 807 belonging to the Gaon Sabha but the same was rejected by the communication dated 22.11.2014 which is subject-matter of challenge in the said application with a prayer to quash the notification dated 16.2.2015 and the notification dated 8.9.2014 issued under the 1956 Act. Objection to the said amendment application has been filed and we have heard Ms. Samidha for the National Highways Authority of India who has pointed out that this cannot now be permitted inasmuch as the compensation has already been dispensed with and the policy decision which was taken to assess the feasibility of the acquisition of the disputed land, had been approved by the competent committee, which was done completely in public interest without any intention of causing any prejudice to the petitioners. The Authority has taken a conscious decision keeping in view the location of the land and the alternative land suggested by the petitioner was unacceptable. A rejoinder affidavit to the said objection has been filed by the learned Counsel for the petitioners where it has been asserted that the petitioner cannot use their property appropriately as they have been deprived of the roadside facing area of their land. It has also been alleged that the acquisition of the petitioners plot is not required for alignment of the road but for constructing a toll plaza.
3. We have gone through the contents of the respective affidavits and we have heard Sri Tiwari for the petitioners and Ms. Samidha for the respondents.
4. It is evident from the aforesaid facts on record that the interim order dated 18.7.2014 has not allowed the construction of the toll plaza to proceed and the road to be accordingly widened. The revenue map is Annexure-R.A.-1 to the rejoinder filed by the learned Counsel for the petitioners which indicates that plot No. 806 is the existing national highway which is sought to be aligned with plot No. 686 by widening. Plot No. 696 lies on the north-eastern side of the road where plot No. 806 is slightly narrow and it appears that for the said reason that plot No. 696 was chosen for widening as has been asserted in the affidavit filed on behalf of respondents based on a report of the appraisal committee. The choice of the said land, therefore, cannot be contested as an arbitrary exercise nor can be a matter of judicial review by us as it is the expert body of the National Highways Authority which is best suited to choose the land. The contention of the petitioners, therefore, that plot No. 807 ought to have been acquired as an alternative, therefore, can not be a matter of judicial choice by us as there is no material to draw an adverse conclusion so far as the choice of land is concerned. The area of plot No. 696 as occupied and acquired appears to be in alignment with the directional proximity required for widening.
5. Coming to the issue of compensation it is also now on record that the land was subjected to proper acquisition proceedings whereafter compensation has been awarded. The acquisition is for a public purpose. That being clearly fulfilled and there being no material to controvert the same, the challenge raised through the amendment application, therefore, does not deserve to be entertained by us in these proceedings. In the event any separate challenge has been raised to the same the same would not be affected by our order on the amendment application on this count. The challenge to the notification on our assessment through the amendment is unsubstantiated and when a clear public purpose is deciphered and the choice of the land does not appear to be an arbitrary exercise of discretion, we see no reason to interfere with the acquisition proceedings at the instance of the petitioners. The amendment application is, therefore, rejected as the challenge raised to that extent is unsustainable in law.
6. There is, however, one aspect which we find necessary to mention which is the right of the petitioners to claim compensation and its quantum. This claim is subject to the applicability of the provisions of the 1956 Act which has to be read alongwith the Land, Acquisition Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013. Section 105 of the Act which is as follows:
“105. Provisions of this Act not to apply in certain cases or to apply with certain modifications.—(1) Subject to sub-section (3), the provisions of this Act shall not apply to the enactments relating to land acquisition specified in the Fourth Schedule.
(2) Subject to sub-section (2) of section 106, the Central Government may, by notification, omit or add to any of the enactments specified in the Fourth Schedule.
(3) the Central Government shall, by notification, within one year from the ate of commencement of this Act, direct that any of the provisions of this act relating to the determination of compensation in accordance with the First Schedule and rehabilitation and resettlement specified in the Second and Third Schedules, being beneficial to the affected families, shall apply to the cases of land acquisition under the enactments specified in the Fourth Schedule or shall apply with such exceptions or modifica tions that do not reduce the compensation or dilute the provisions of this Act relating to compensation or rehabilitation and resettlement as may be specified in the notification, as the case may be.
(4) A copy of every notification proposed to be issued under sub-section (3), shall be laid in draft before each House of Parliament, while it is in Session, for a total period of thirty days which may be comprised in one session or in two or more successive Sessions, and if, before the expiry of the Session immediately following the Session or the successive Sessions aforesaid, both Houses agree in disapproving the issue of the notification or both Houses agree in making any modification in the notification, the notification shall not be issued or, as the case may be, shall be issued only in such modified form as may be agreed upon by both the Houses of Parliament.”
7. The aforesaid information has been promptly tendered to us by Sri Abhinav Trivedi learned Counsel for the State and has been ably explained by him who has invited the attention of the Court towards the Fourth Schedule appended to the 2013 Act indicating the list of enactments as mentioned in section 105(3) aforesaid. The Fourth Schedule is extracted here under:
“THE FOURTH SCHEDULE
(See section 105)
LIST OF ENACTMENTS REGULATING LAND ACQUISITION AND REHABILITATION AND RESETTLEMENT
1. The Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958 (24 of 1958).
2. The Atomic Energy Act, 1962 (33 of 1962).
3. The Damodar Valley Corporation Act, 1948 (14 of 1948).
4. The Indian Tramways Act, 1886 (11 of 1886).
5. The Land Acquisition (Mines) Act, 1885 (18 of 1885).
6. The Metro Railways (Construction of Works) Act, 1978 (33 of 1978).
7. The National Highways Act, 1956 (48 of 1956).
8. The Petroleum and Minerals Pipelines (Acquisition of Right of User in Land) Act, 1962 (50 of 1962).
9. The Requisitioning and Acquisition of Immovable Property Act, 1952 (30 of 1952).
10. The Resettlement of Displaced Persons (Land Acquisition) Act, 1948 (60 of 1948).
11. The Coal Bearing Areas Acquisition and Development Act, 1957 (20 of 1957).
12. The Electricity Act, 2003 (36 of 2003).
13. The Railways Act, 1989 (24 of 1989).”
He has also invited the attention of the Court towards Ordinance No. 9 of 2014 and Clause 10 thereof which is extracted herein under:
“The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Amendment) Ordinance, 2014
[No. 9 of 2014]
10. Amendment of section 105.— in the principal Act, in section 105,— (i) for sub-section (3), the following sub-section shall be substituted, namely—
“(3) the provisions of this Act relating to the determination of compensation in accordance with the First Schedule, rehabilitation and resettlement in accordance with the Second Schedule and infrastructure amenities in accordance with the ‘Third Schedule shall apply to the enactments relating to land acquisition specified in the Fourth Schedule with effect from 1st January, 2015.”;
(ii) sub-section (4) shall be omitted.”
This was followed by Ordinance No. 4 of 2015 wherein Clause 12 provides as under:
“The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Ameridment) Ordinance, 2015
[No. 4 of 2015]
12. Amendment of section 105.- in the principal Act, in section 105,— (i) for sub-section (3), the following sub-section shall be substituted, namely—
(3) the provisions of this Act relating to the determination of compensation in accordance with the First Schedule, rehabilitation and resettlement in accordance with the Second Schedule and infrastructure amenities in accordance with the Third Schedule shall apply to the enactments relating to land acquisition specified in the Fourth Schedule with effect from 1st January, 2015.”;
(ii) sub-section (4) shall be omitted.”
This was again followed by Ordinance No. 5 of 2015 wherein Clause 12 reads as under:
“The Fight to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Amendment) Second Ordinance, 2015
[No. 5 of 2015]
12. Amendment of section 105.- in the principal Act, in section 105,— (i) for sub-section (3), the following sub-section shall be substantiated, namely—
“(3) the provisions of this Act relating to the determination of compensation in accordance with the First Schedule, rehabilitation and resettlement in accordance with the Second Schedule and infrastructure amenities in accordance with the Third Schedule shall apply to the enactments relating to land acquisition specified in the Fourth Schedule with effect from 1st January, 2015.”;
(ii) sub-section (4) shall be omitted.”
The aforesaid ordinances have been followed by a notification dated 28.8.2015 of the Central Government through the Ministry of Rural Development mat is extracted hereunder:
“MINISTRY OF RURAL DEVELOPMENT
New Delhi, the 28th August, 2015
Now, therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1) of section 113 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (30 of 2013), the Central Government hereby makes the following Order to remove the aforesaid difficulties, namely:
1.(1) This order may be called the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement (Removal of Difficulties) Order, 2015.
(2) It shall come into force with effect from the 1st day of September, 2015.
2. The provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, relating to the determination of compensation in are ordance with the First Schedule, rehabilitation and resettlement in accordance with the Second Schedule and infrastructure amenities in record” with the Third Schedule shall apply to all cases of land acquisition under the enactments specified in the Fourth Schedule to the said Act.”
8. The petitioners, therefore, have a full right to contest their claim with regard to their entitlement of a free and fair compensation in accordance with the provisions of 2013 Act keeping in view the ordinances and the notifications referred to herein above. It is open to the petitioners, therefore, to raise their plea with regard to any such claim which may be admissible and permissible under the aforesaid provisions before the competent authority or the Court where any such issue of enhancement of compensation or claim of fair compensation has been raised or is pending consideration in relation to the acquisition of the land of the petitioners. This issue, therefore, will have to be decided by the appropriate-forum and the petitioners will have full right to raise this issue appropriately which the competent forum is obliged to decide in law. Consequently, for all the aforesaid reasons we decline to interfere with the acquisition part of the land and we consequently vacate the interim order dated 18.7.2014 but at the same time we dispose of the writ petition without prejudice to the rights of the petitioners to contest their claim with regard to the quantum of compensation and their right to claim a fair compensation be fore the appropriate forum in accordance with law and in view of observations made herein above.
9. Petition Disposed Of.
Alert