Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Daya Shanker (Dead) Through L.Rs. And Another v. Rajendra Kumar And Others

Allahabad High Court
May 30, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Plaintiff No.-1 executed a registered general power of attorney (GPA) dated 9.2.1988 in favour of defendant No.-1, Jitendra Kumar, authorizing him to deal with the plaintiff’s property. Defendant No.-1 executed a sale-deed of the disputed property on the basis of this GPA in favour of defendants No. 2, 3, and 4, who are closely related to defendant No.-1. The sale-deed was executed on 3.8.1991 but registered on 26.2.1992. Plaintiff sent a registered notice dated 3.10.1991 for cancellation of the GPA, which was served on defendant No.-1. Plaintiffs filed suit seeking cancellation of the sale-deed on grounds that it was executed without authority, without consideration, and as part of a conspiracy to prejudice plaintiffs’ rights.

The Trial Court decreed the suit on 7.2.2009, cancelling the sale-deed, finding that the notice of cancellation was served before execution of the sale-deed, invalidating it. The First Appellate Court allowed Civil Appeal No.-10/2009 on 7.11.2015, holding that a registered document can only be cancelled by a registered deed, that the notices were not legally proved served, and that the GPA had not been cancelled at the time of sale-deed execution. Consequently, the sale-deed was valid and the suit was dismissed. Plaintiffs filed the present second appeal against this judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the registered power of attorney (GPA) executed by plaintiff No.-1 in favour of defendant No.-1 was effectively cancelled by notices sent prior to execution of the sale-deed.
  2. Whether the sale-deed dated 3.8.1991 executed by defendant No.-1 under the authority of the GPA is liable to be cancelled.
  3. Whether a registered power of attorney can be cancelled by unregistered documents or by registered notice of cancellation, or only by a registered deed.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The cancellation of authority under the GPA was proved by notices sent under certificate of posting dated 8.7.1991 and registered post dated 9.10.1991.
  • Defendant No.-1 had no right to execute the sale-deed after knowledge of such cancellation.
  • The sale-deed was executed without consideration and as part of a conspiracy involving defendant No.-1 and his relatives.
  • The Trial Court’s judgment cancelling the sale-deed was correct and should be upheld.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The First Appellate Court correctly applied legal provisions, including sections 32 and 33 of the Indian Registration Act, and held that cancellation of a registered document cannot be effected by registered notice but only by registered deed under section 17(1) of the Act.
  • The alleged notice dated 8.7.1991 was not proved or on record and thus not valid service.
  • The burden was on the plaintiff to prove the grounds for cancellation, which was not met.
  • The sale-deed was executed under valid authority of the GPA and is not illegal despite the close relation of the vendees to defendant No.-1.
  • No substantial question of law arises; the matter involves factual findings based on evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Section 17, Indian Registration Act Mandates registration of non-testamentary instruments affecting immovable property and provides that cancellation of such registered documents can only be effected by registered deed. Court held that the GPA, being a registered document, could not be cancelled by unregistered notice or registered notice alone; cancellation requires a registered deed.
Sections 32 and 33, Indian Registration Act Legal provisions governing registration and cancellation of registered documents. Applied by the First Appellate Court to conclude that cancellation by notice was not legally effective.
Section 49, Indian Registration Act Provides that unregistered documents required to be registered shall not affect immovable property or confer power unless registered. Used to support the principle that cancellation of a registered GPA requires registration of the cancellation deed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the factual and legal aspects concerning the validity and cancellation of the registered GPA and subsequent sale-deed. It found the Trial Court’s conclusion that service of notice by certificate of posting constituted proof of service to be erroneous and perverse, as neither the notice nor its contents were proved. The First Appellate Court’s finding that cancellation of a registered power of attorney must be effected by a registered deed, not merely by notices, was accepted as legally sound and factually correct.

The Court observed that the burden of proof lay on the plaintiff to establish that the GPA holder acted beyond his authority or that the GPA was cancelled before execution of the sale-deed. Since the sale-deed was executed under the authority of the registered GPA and no valid cancellation was proved, the sale-deed was a valid and effective document. The Court emphasized that mere familial relations between the GPA holder and the vendees do not invalidate the sale-deed absent proof of fraud or violation of the GPA’s terms.

The Court further noted that the question whether the GPA was cancelled and whether the sale-deed was liable to be cancelled were questions of fact, properly decided by the lower courts on evidence. No perversity or legal infirmity was found in the First Appellate Court’s reasoning to justify interference in the second appeal.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The Court upheld the validity of the sale-deed executed under the registered GPA, confirming that a registered power of attorney cannot be cancelled by unregistered notices or registered notices alone, but only by a registered deed. This decision affirms the legal principle regarding cancellation of registered instruments under the Indian Registration Act and underscores the necessity of proper registration formalities to affect rights in immovable property. The direct effect is that the sale-deed remains valid and the plaintiffs’ suit for its cancellation is rejected. No new precedent was established beyond affirmation of existing legal principles.

Show all summary ...

Pramod Kumar Srivastava, J.:— Heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the records.

2. It is admitted case between the parties that plaintiff No.-1 had executed a registered general power of attorney (GPA) dated 9.2.1988 of his properly in favour of defendant No.-1 Jitendra Kumar (son of Laxman Prasad). Then defendant No.-1 had executed sale-deed of disputed property on the basis of said power of attorney in favour of defendants No. 2, 3 and 4. Admittedly, defendants No. 2 and 3 are sons of Laxman Prasad and real brother of defendant No.-1 Jitendra Kumar. It is also admitted that defendant No.-4 Sharda Dutt is real father-in-law of defendant No.-1 Jitendra Kumar. It is also admitted that on the basis of power of attorney, the sale-deed was executed on 3.8.1991, but it was not registered that day, and its registration proceeding was performed and completed on 26.2.1992. It is proved from the evidences, although it was not admitted by defendants, that plaintiff has sent registered notice dated 3.10.1991 to defendant No.-1 for cancellation of registered power of attorney, which was served on him. Plaintiffs had filed suit for cancellation of sale-deed dated 3.8.1991 executed by defendant No.-1 (the power of attorney holder) in favour of defendants No. 2, 3 and 4 on the ground that this was executed without authority and without any consideration, as a result of conspiracy committed by defendant No.-1 with his brothers defendants No. 2 and 3 and father-in-law defendant No.-4. This ground was also taken that this sale-deed was executed without any bona fide or good faith, and was got executed for prejudicing the rights of plaintiff and defendant No.-5 over disputed property.

3. Aftei affording opportunity of hearing to parties and accepting their evidences, the Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Fatehpur had passed judgment dated 7.2.2009, by which original suit was decreed and sale-deed dated 3.8.1991, registered on 26.2.1992, was cancelled. In this judgment, Trial Court had given finding to the effect that plaintiff had sent first notice of cancellation of sale-deed by post under certificate of posting dated 8.7.1991 and held that sending of this notice under certificate of posting is proof of its service on defendant No.-1. Trial Court had also given finding that after service of notice of cancellation of power of attorney, the sale-deed in question was executed, therefore it is liable to be cancelled, as defendant No.-1 had no right to execute sale-deed after such knowledge of power of attorney.

4. Against the judgment of Trial Court, Civil Appeal No.-10/2009 was preferred, which was heard and allowed by the judgment dated 7.11.2015 of Additional District Judge, Court No.-9, Fatehpur. In this judgment, First Appellate Court had held that registered document can be cancelled in accordance with law by registered deed only. It was also held that service of notice under certificate of posting dated 8.7.1991 and registered notice dated 9.10.1991 is legally not proved. First Appellate Court also held that in power of attorney, plaintiff No.-1 had authorized power of attorney holder defendant No.-1 to execute sale-deed, gift deed, mortgage deed or other transfer deed of disputed property and got it registered and received payment. With these findings First Appellate Court had held that till execution of sale-deed in question, the power of attorney executed by plaintiff No.-1 in favour of defendant No.-1 was not cancelled, and the power of attorney holder (defendant No.-1) had executed sale-deed in question under authority obtained from the owner of property that is plaintiff No.-1. Therefore, said grounds for cancellation of sale-deed are not proved. On the basis of these findings, First Appellate Court had allowed the appeal and dismissed the original suit.

5. Aggrieved by the impugned judgment of First Appellate Court, present second appeal has been preferred by plaintiffs of the original suit.

6. Learned Counsel for the appellant contended that the cancellation of authority under power of attorney by notice under certificate of posting dated 8.7.1991 and by registered post dated 9.10.1991 is proved; therefore, after knowledge of such notice the defendant No.-1 had no right to execute sale-deed, and the said sale-deed was unauthorizedly executed by him which is liable to be cancelled. He further contended that defendant No.-1 is real brother of defendants No. 2 and 3 and is son-in-law of defendant No. 4. He had connived with these defendants and executed sale-deed in question without any payment of consideration because it is not proved that what happened to alleged consideration, therefore the judgment of Trial Court was correct and appeal should be admitted for being allowed.

7. These contentions of learned Counsel for the appellants were refuted by learned Counsel for the respondents, who contended that First Appellate Court had rightly discussed legal provisions including provisions of sections 32 and 33 of Indian Registration Act and held that any document for the value of more than 100/- rupees cannot be cancelled under section 17(1) of this Act by registered notice. Such registration can be cancelled only by the registered deed. He further contended that Trial Court had erroneously considered the service of notice allegedly sent on 8.7.1991, because this notice is not proved, nor was available on record before the Court. He further submitted that other grounds mentioned in plaint for cancellation of sale-deed were not proved. It was burden of plaintiff to prove those grounds, which he failed to do so, therefore there is no error in judgment of lower Appellate Court. He further contended that dispute relates to finding of fact that could be decided on the basis of evidences and no substantial question of law arises in this matter; therefore, this appeal should be dismissed.

8. So far finding of Trial Court regarding service of notice dated 8.7.1991 under certificate of posting is concerned, it is altogether erroneous and perverse. Neither that notice nor its contents were proved. Apart from mere sending of a notice under certificate of posting may be the proof of its sending, but it cannot be proof of its service as held by Trial Court. The sending of information of the cancellation of authority under power of attorney by notice under certificate of posting dated 8.7.1991 is not proved. The finding of the First Appellate Court in this regard is found factually correct and acceptable.

9. This contention of learned Counsel for the appellants is also unacceptable that burden of proof lies on defendant, who had failed to prove by suppressing evidence of defendant No.-1 Jitendra Kumar, the earlier power of attorney holder. Admittedly, the defendant No.-1 Jitendra Kumar was agent of plaintiff No.-1, who had been authorized by plaintiff to execute sale-deed or other document of transfer to anyone and receive consideration in the way he likes. The sale-deed dated 3.8.1991 executed by defendant No.-1, the power of attorney holder, is not in violation of any of the terms of power of attorney dated 9.2.1988. Since defendant No.-1 was power of attorney holder and agent of plaintiff, so burden was on plaintiff to prove that his power of attorney holder had acted against the terms of power of attorney given to him. The rights of vendees of sale-deed in question cannot be denied merely on the ground that they are near relative of power of attorney holder, especially when no act appears to have been committed against the authority given to power of attorney holder (defendant No.-1) under said registered power of attorney. The burden was not on defendants/vendees to prove that what happened to the consideration of sale-deed given by them to power of attorney holder of plaintiff. There can be no presumption that sale-deed would become illegal or void, if it is executed by power of attorney holder in favour of his near relatives. In this matter, it is immaterial as to whether defendant No.-1 had given notice of sale-deed in question to plaintiffs or not. Trial Court had rightly held that it was moral duty of defendant No.-1 power of attorney holder to inform this fact to plaintiffs, but such duty was not legal. If power of attorney holder or agent of plaintiffs had not given notice of the acts performed by him under authority of power of attorney, then mere non-information cannot be the proof of act of fraud or illegality.

10. This fact is not disputed that if power of attorney holder had acted in accordance with authority under power of attorney without any knowledge of cancellation of such authority on 3.8.1981, and said sale-deed was registered on 26.2.1992, therefore it would be a valid and effective document unless it is proved that power of attorney had already been legally cancelled at the time of execution of sale-deed under its authority.

11. the only point in this matter has been as to whether registered power of attorney can be cancelled by unregistered document or by registered notice of cancellation.

12. Section 17 of Registration Act directs mandatory registration of “non-testamentary instruments which purport or operate to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish, whether in present or in future, any right, title or interest, whether vested or contingent, to or in immovable property’. Section 49 of this Act provides that “No document required by section 17 or by any provision of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (4 of 1882), to be registered shall-- (a) affect any immovable property comprised therein, or (b) confer any power to adopt, or (c) be received as evidence of any transaction affecting such property or conferring such power, unless it has been registered.”

13. Registered power of attorney creates a legal right of GPA holder in immoveable property to transfer it, in accordance with the terms mentioned in it. This right in such immoveable property can be limited or extinguished only through the registered document, and not otherwise.

14. In present matter plaintiff No.-1 had executed a registered power of attorney (GPA) dated 9.2.1988 of his property in favour of defendant No.-1. Then defendant No.-1 had executed sale-deed of disputed property on the basis of said power of attorney in favour of defendants No. 2, 3 and 4. From the time of execution of registered GPA till now, said authority under GPA was never withdrawn, cancelled or limited by plaintiff, the executor of said GPA. Therefore the sale-deed was executed on 3.8.1991 under the authority of said GPA was a valid document which could not be cancelled by registered notice dated 3.10.1991 to defendant No.-1 for cancellation of registered power of attorney, which was served on him.

15. If the plaint case on its facts, are taken to be true, in that situation also, the sale-deed dated 3.8.1991/registered on 26.2.1992 was a valid and legal document, creating the ownership rights of purchasers (defendants No. 2, 3 and 4) in disputed property. This finding of lower Appellate Court through impugned judgment is found correct that said registered GPA dated 9.2.1988 was never cancelled.

16. The only points to be determined in this appeal before this Court was as to whether the plaintiff-appellant had cancelled the GPA granted by him to defendant No.-1 (GPA holder), and as to whether the sale-deed dated 3.8.1991/registered on 26.2.1992 is liable to be cancelled. These are not the question of law, but are questions of fact that could be decided on basis of evidences, as had been done by the Lower Court. The impugned judgment in present case is based on appreciation of all the available evidences, and findings are apparently acceptable. Such findings cannot be interfered in second appeal.

17. On examination of the reasoning recorded by the learned First Appellate Court in first appeal, I am of the view that judgment in civil appeal was well reasoned, and was based on proper appreciation of entire evidences on record. No perversity or infirmity is found in finding re corded by the First Appellate Court to warrant interference through this appeal. No substantial question of law was involved before this Court. None of the contentions of the learned Counsel for the appellant can be sustained. In view of the above, this appeal is dismissed.

18. Appeal Dismissed.