Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bajaj Allainz Genera... v. B. Krishnappa Setty ...

Karnataka High Court
Jul 8, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (MACT Mangalore → High Court Appeal)

Factual and Procedural Background

On 24.4.2007 at about 5:30 p.m. a motorcycle bearing registration No. KA-19 V-7113 overturned at Mishamajalu in Jalsur Village. The deceased (referred to in the record variously as Avinash/Aravind Shetty), aged 22, was riding as a pillion on the motorcycle driven by his friend Kishore Kumar (the first respondent in the claim petition). The rider allegedly drove rashly and negligently, lost control and the vehicle capsized. The deceased sustained injuries, was taken to Rajeshwari Hospital, and died the same day. He was said to be working as a Recovery Agent and earning about Rs.8,000 per month according to the claimants.

The claim petition was filed before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (MACT), Mangalore (MVC No.658/2008). After service of notice the first respondent was absent and proceeded ex parte; the second and third respondents appeared and filed written statements. The Tribunal framed issues, heard evidence (claimants' PW.1 and documentary exhibits Ex.P1–P30; respondents' RWs.1–3 and Exs.R1–R2), and on 09.12.2009 awarded compensation of Rs.2,58,000 with interest at 6% p.a. from the date of petition till realization. The insurance company (appellant) appealed to the High Court challenging that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal was justified in holding that Kishore Kumar was the rider of the offending motorcycle and the deceased was the pillion rider, in view of alleged discrepancies (including the FIR) relied upon by the insurance company.
  2. Whether the Tribunal committed an error in the computation of compensation by adopting a multiplier of 10 for loss of dependency instead of a higher multiplier (contention that multiplier should be 7 by appellant; respondents sought multiplier 18).
  3. Whether the appellate court could modify or enhance compensation in favor of the claimants though the claimants/respondents had not filed a cross-objection (i.e., exercise of appellate powers under CPC and Motor Vehicles Act).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Insurance Company) - Contentions

  • The deceased (referred to in some documents as Arvind/Avinash Shetty) was actually the rider of the motorcycle and not a pillion rider; the claim petition is false on that point.
  • The FIR (recorded 24.4.2007; complainant Vasappa S/o Subbaiah Gowda) names the rider as Aravind/Avinash Shetty and thus contradicts the claimants' version. The Tribunal wrongly held that names were reversed in the FIR.
  • The complainant (author of FIR) was not examined to resolve discrepancies.
  • Hospital records of Kishore Kumar only state "history of road traffic accident" and do not explicitly indicate he was riding; the charge sheet was, according to the appellant, laid against Kishore Kumar but the petitioners did not produce it to establish their case.
  • The claim petition is alleged to be based on concocted documents intended to obtain an unjustifiable award.
  • The Tribunal did not assign valid or cogent reasons to discard the respondents' evidence, especially the investigator's evidence.
  • The Tribunal erred in adopting a multiplier of 10 for computation of dependency; the appellant contends the correct multiplier should have been 7.
  • On these grounds the appellant sought setting aside the Tribunal's judgment and award.

Respondents / Claimants - Contentions

  • The Tribunal correctly found (on appreciation of oral and documentary evidence) that Kishore Kumar was the rider and the deceased (Aravind/Avinash Shetty) was the pillion rider; rider sustained hand injury and pillion sustained head injury.
  • The accident was caused by rash and negligent riding of the motorcycle bearing No. KA-19/V-7113, and the deceased died due to injuries sustained.
  • The Tribunal's assessment of evidence was proper and should not be interfered with.
  • Respondents sought enhancement of compensation on the ground that the Tribunal wrongly adopted multiplier 10 instead of 18 (arguing the deceased was a bachelor and taking the age of the parents); they relied on case law including P.S. Somanathan and Ravinder Kumar Sharma to support the position that enhancement can be sought without filing a cross-objection.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
P.S. Somanathan and others vs. District Insurance Officers and another (2011 SAR (Civil) 286) The opinion references this decision as relied upon by counsel for the claimants; the provided text does not state a specific rule or principle from this authority. The record states counsel relied on this judgment in support of the claimants' contention for enhancement, but the court's text does not record any specific doctrinal application drawn from this precedent.
Ravinder Kumar Sharma vs. State of Assam, (1999) AIR SC 3571 It is recorded in the opinion that this case holds a respondent can question an adverse finding without filing a cross-objection; filing a cross-objection is optional and not mandatory. The High Court relied on the principle (as cited in the opinion) to justify considering enhancement in favour of the claimants despite the absence of a cross-objection by them.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The High Court reviewed the oral testimony and the documentary evidence placed on record by the parties. Key items of evidence considered and their import as stated in the opinion:

  • Ex.P1 (FIR): The FIR registered an offence against the rider of the motorcycle No.KA-19-V-7113 under Sections 279 and 338 IPC and recorded that the rider sustained hand injury while the pillion sustained head injury.
  • Ex.P2 (spot mahazar) and Ex.P3 (rough sketch): These were drawn at the scene by the investigating officer and supported the investigating officer's version of events.
  • Ex.P5 (post-mortem report): It disclosed that the deceased (Aravind/Avinash Shetty) sustained head injuries and died due to those injuries.
  • Ex.P6 (claim notice): Contained particulars of the vehicle, ownership, insurer and names of injured persons and indicated that the investigating officer filed a charge sheet against the first respondent (Kishore Kumar) as the rider on the date of the accident.
  • Ex.P25 (discharge summary): Confirmed the deceased sustained head injuries and died on the same day in hospital.
  • RW.2 (Kishore Kumar) was examined by the insurer and in his evidence he stated that on the date of accident he was riding the motorcycle bearing No.KA-19/V 7113 and that a charge sheet was filed against him after investigation.

On evaluating the totality of the oral and documentary evidence (including the FIR, spot mahazar, rough sketch, charge-sheeting activity by the investigating officer, PM report and RW.2's own testimony), the Tribunal's finding that Kishore Kumar was the rider and the deceased was the pillion rider was upheld. The High Court found no material to disbelieve the evidence of RW.2 and PW.1 and therefore saw no justifiable reason to interfere with the Tribunal's finding on causation — that the accident occurred solely due to the actionable negligence of the rider of motorcycle No.KA-19/V-7113.

On the quantum of compensation, the Court accepted the Tribunal's approach of assessing the deceased's income at Rs.4,000 per month (despite PW.1 stating an income of Rs.8,000) because there was no valid proof of income. The Tribunal deducted 50% towards the deceased's personal expenses. However, the Court found the Tribunal erred in adopting a multiplier of 10 for calculating loss of dependency. Given the deceased's age of 22 years, the High Court held that a multiplier of 18 should have been applied.

The Court therefore recalculated the loss of dependency strictly according to the formula and figures it accepted from the record:

Computation (as set out in the opinion): Rs.4,000 x 12 x 18 x 50% = Rs.4,32,000

The Court contrasted this figure with the Tribunal's award under the dependency head (Rs.2,40,000 as recorded in the opinion) and concluded that the dependency component required enhancement by Rs.1,92,000. The Court expressly stated that other heads of compensation awarded by the Tribunal appeared just and reasonable and did not call for interference.

The Court also discussed procedural powers: it referred to Order VII Rule 7 CPC (moulding of relief) and Order 41 Rule 33 CPC (appellate powers) and observed that the appellate court may exercise wide powers to grant relief in favour of parties even if they have not filed an appeal or cross-objection. It held that such provisions are available to the High Court in appeals under the Motor Vehicles Act and can be followed consistent with natural justice to do complete justice between the parties. The court relied on this principle to enhance compensation despite the absence of a cross-objection by the claimants.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The appeal is DISPOSED OF in part. The High Court modified the Tribunal's award by enhancing the compensation payable under the head of loss of dependency.

Core Ruling (as recorded):

  • The Tribunal's finding that Kishore Kumar was the rider and the deceased Aravind/Avinash Shetty was the pillion rider is upheld; the accident occurred due to reckless/negligent riding by the rider.
  • The Tribunal's computation of income (Rs.4,000 per month) and deduction of 50% for personal expenses is accepted.
  • The Tribunal erred in adopting multiplier 10; the correct multiplier for the deceased aged 22 years is 18. The dependency component is recalculated to Rs.4,32,000.
  • Accordingly, the compensation under the dependency head is enhanced by Rs.1,92,000 (from Rs.2,40,000 to Rs.4,32,000). Other heads remain undisturbed.

Practical Consequences / Orders:

  • The respondents/claimants are entitled to enhanced compensation of Rs.1,92,000 with interest at 6% p.a. from the date of petition till realization; the Tribunal's judgment and award in MVC No.658/2008 is modified to that extent.
  • The appellant-insurer is directed to deposit the enhanced compensation with interest before the Tribunal within six weeks from receipt of the High Court's judgment, after which the amount shall be released to the claimants upon proper identification.
  • The impugned judgment and award remains unaltered insofar as apportionment and deposit directions are concerned; any amount already deposited shall be transmitted to the concerned Tribunal and the office is to draw the decree accordingly.
  • No new legal doctrine beyond the application of existing appellate powers and the established method for computing dependency was created; the decision modifies quantum on the facts of this case.

Additional Notes from the Opinion

  • The opinion explicitly cites and relies on procedural provisions: Order VII Rule 7 of the Civil Procedure Code and Order 41 Rule 33 of the Civil Procedure Code, and refers to their applicability in appeals under the Motor Vehicles Act to enable the court to do complete justice.
  • The opinion records certain inconsistencies in naming (Avinash/Aravind) in documents and arguments, and it addresses these by reference to the body of oral and documentary evidence rather than by privileging any single document in isolation.
Show all summary ...

1. This appeal is directed against the judgment and award dated 09.12.2009 rendered by the MACT, Mangalore, D.K., in MVC No.658/2008 awarding compensation of Rs.2,58,000/- with interest @ 6% p.a. from the date of petition till realisation.

2. The factual matrix of the appeal is that on 24.4.2007 at about 5.30 p.m., one Avinash Shetty, son of the claimants was proceeding in a motor cycle bearing Regn.No.KA-19 V-7113 as a pillion rider and it was ridden by his friend Kishore Kumar who was respondent no.1 in the claim petition. When they reached a place called Mishamajalu in Jalsur Village, at that time, the rider of the motor cycle drove the same in rash and negligent manner, as a result, he lost control over the vehicle and it was capsized. Due to the said impact, the said Avinash Shetty sustained injuries. Immediately, he was taken to Rajeshwari Hospital at Mangalore and took treatment as inpatient and later on died in the hospital same day due to the injuries sustained by him in the accident and the dead body was taken to Government Wenlock Hospital for postmortem. As on the date of accident, the deceased was aged 22 years and was working as Recovery Agent and earning about Rs.8,000/- p.m. Due to the untimely death of the deceased, the petitioners suffered loss in all respects. They have spent huge amount towards hospitalization, transportation, funeral and obsequies ceremony. Since the accident occurred due to the negligent riding of the motor cycle by its rider, the claimants filed the claim petition before the Tribunal seeking compensation.

3. After service of notice, first respondent remained absent throughout the proceedings and he was placed exparte. Second and third respondents entered appearance through their counsel and filed separate written statement denying the entire petition averments and sought for dismissal of the claim petition.

4. Based upon the pleadings of the parties, the Tribunal framed the issues for its consideration. In order to prove their case, first petitioner was examined as PW.1 and documents as per Exs.P1 to P30 were got marked. On behalf of respondents, RWs.1 to RW.3 were examined and Exs.R1 and R2 were got marked. After hearing the arguments of learned counsel for the parties and on evaluation of oral and documentary evidence available on record, the Tribunal passed the impugned judgment, awarding compensation of Rs.2,58,000/- with interest @ 6% p.a. from the date of petition till the date of realisation. It is this judgment which is under challenge in this appeal by the insurance company.

5. Learned counsel for the appellant/insurance company contends that deceased Arvind Shetty was not the pillion rider of the motorcycle bearing regn.No.KA-19 V-7113 but the said motorcycle was driven by himself and not by Kishore Kumar and that the claimants have filed the false claim petition stating that deceased Arvind Shetty was the pillion rider. The said defense taken by the insurance company has not been considered by the Tribunal. Further, it is contended that claimants in order to prove their claim have relied on the FIR. In the FIR it is stated that in the accident the rider of the Motorcycle is Arvind Shetty - the deceased. But the Tribunal committed an error in holding that the names of the rider and the pillion rider have been reversed in the FIR. Further, the FIR was recorded on 24.4.2007 and the complainant is one Vasappa and it clearly states the name of the accused as the rider of the motorcycle Avinash Shetty and in the complaint it is stated that the rider Arvind Shetty has driven the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner. Hence, the finding of the Tribunal that Kishore Kumar was riding the motor cycle is unsustainable as against the documentary evidence placed on record.

6. It is further contended that the complainant has not been examined to clarify the discrepancies. The hospital records of Kishore Kumar shows history of road traffic accident and it does not indicate that Kishore Kumar was riding the vehicle and his evidence that he was riding the vehicle is contrary to the statement in the FIR. Though the FIR has been recorded by the police and proceeded with the case for investigation, but the charge sheet was laid against the rider of the motor cycle namely Kishore Kumar and the same has not been produced by the petitioners in order to establish their case. The claim petition is filed based on the concocted documents with an intention of obtaining false and unjustifiable award. Further, the Tribunal has not assigned any valid or cogent reasons to discard the evidence of the respondents in particular the evidence of investigator. Further, the multiplier of 10 adopted by the Tribunal is erroneous and the same should have been 7. On all these grounds, he seeks for setting aside the judgment and award passed by the Tribunal by allowing the present appeal.

7. Per contra, learned counsel for respondent - claimants while taking me through the evidence of PW.1 contends that the Tribunal has rightly held that in the accident the rider of the motor cycle has sustained hand injury and the pillion rider sustained injuries to his head. The Tribunal on appreciation of both oral and documentary evidence available on record has rightly held that the accident occurred only due to the rash and negligent riding of the motor cycle bearing No.KA-19/V 7113 and the son of petitioners by name Aravind Setty died on account of the accidental injuries sustained in the road traffic accident.

8. He further contends that the Tribunal while awarding compensation under the head loss of dependency, has wrongly adopted multiplier of 10 instead of 18 by taking the age of the parents as the deceased was a Bachelor. In support of this contention, he has relied on a judgment of the Apex Court in P.S.Somanathan and others vs. District Insurance Officers and another,2011 SAR(Civil) 286 and Ravinder Kumar Sharma vs. State of Assam, (1999) AIR SC 3571. On all these grounds he seeks for enhancement of compensation by modifying the judgment and award passed by the Tribunal.

9. Having regard to these strenuous contentions as taken by learned counsel for the appellant and so also, learned counsel for respondents, it is relevant to state that PW.1 - Krishnappa Shetty being the father of deceased has stated in his evidence about the accident that occurred on 24.4.2007 and his son Aravind Shetty succumbed to the accidental injuries. In support of their contention, the claimants relied upon documents such as Ex.P1 - FIR, Ex.P2 - spot mahazar, Ex.P3 - rough sketch, Ex.P4 - IMV report, Ex.P5 - post-mortem report, Ex.P6 - claim notice, Ex.P7 - I.D.Card, Ex.P8- driving license, Ex.P25- discharge summary. On perusal of Ex.P1 - FIR, it could be seen that the police have registered case against the rider of the motor cycle bearing No.KA-19- V-7113 for the offence punishable under Sections 279 and 338 of IPC. In FIR it is mentioned that in the accident the rider of the motor cycle has sustained hand injury and the pillion rider sustained injuries to his head. Ex.P5 - P.M. report discloses that deceased Aravind Shetty sustained head injuries and died due to the accidental injuries sustained in the road traffic accident. It is the contention of the appellant - insurance company that a false case has been filed by the claimants stating that the vehicle was driven by Kishore Kumar and the deceased Arvind Shetty was a pillion rider. It is further contended that in the FIR the complainant is one Vasappa S/o Subbaiah Gowda and it clearly states the name of the accused as the rider of the motorcycle Avinash Shetty and in the complaint it is stated that the rider Arvind Shetty has driven the vehicle in a rash and negligent manner. But it is relevant to note here that in Ex.P2 - spot mahazar and Ex.P3-rough sketch are drawn on the scene of occurrence by the investigating officer. Ex.P6 - claim notice contains the particulars relating to the vehicle involved in the accident, its ownership, insurer and the name of the injured persons and it clearly discloses that the concerned investigating officer after investigation has filed a charge sheet against the first respondent - Kishore Kumar who was riding the motor cycle as on the date of accident. Ex.P25 - discharge summary clearly discloses that deceased Aravind Shetty sustained injuries to his head and later on he died on the same day in the Hospital. The contention of the petitioners is clearly supported by these documentary evidence available on record. Even the insurance company has examined the said Kishore Kumar as RW.2 and in his evidence the said Kishore Kumar has stated that on the date of accident, he was riding the motor cycle bearing No.KA-19/V 7113 and the police after thorough investigation have filed the charge sheet against him. The Tribunal, on appreciation of these oral and documentary evidence has rightly held that first respondent - Kishore Kumar was riding the offending motor cycle as on the date of accident and the deceased Aravind Shetty was proceeding in that motor cycle as a pillion rider and there is no material on record to disbelieve the evidence of RW.2 and PW.1. The accident occurred solely due to the actionable negligence on the part of the rider of the motor cycle bearing No.KA- 19/V-7113 due to which the son of claimants namely Aravind Shetty succumbed to the injuries. This finding of the Tribunal is based on the appreciation of entire oral and documentary evidence on record and I find no justifiable reason to interfere with the same, as there is no substance in the contentions taken by learned counsel for the appellant - insurance company.

10. Learned counsel for the respondent/claimants in this appeal though he has not filed any cross-objections, seeks for enhancement of compensation contending that the Tribunal has erred in adopting multiplier of 10 instead of 18 by taking the age of the parents, as the deceased was a Bachelor. In support of his claim he has relied on a judgment of the Hon ble Supreme Court reported in Ravinder Kumar Sharma vs. State of Assam, (1999) AIR SC 3571 wherein it is held that respondent can question adverse finding without filing cross objection and filing of crossobjection is optional and not mandatory.

11. In this background, it is relevant to refer Order VII Rule 7 of CPC which reads as under:

Relief to be specifically stated - Every plaint shall state specifically the relief which the plaintiff claims either simply or in the alternative, and it shall not be necessary to ask for general or other relief which may always be given as the Court may think just to the same extent as if it had been asked for. and the same rule shall apply to any relief claimed by the defendant in his written statement.

12. The instant appeal is filed by the appellant/insurance company challenging the impugned judgment and award rendered by the Tribunal in MVC No.658/2008 contending that the deceased who was the rider of the offending motor cycle is shown as pillion rider in the charge sheet so as to make false claim. But the Tribunal by taking into the totality of the facts and circumstances of the case and so also the oral and documentary evidence on record has addressed this issue by giving just and appropriate reasons and findings. The same reveals in the judgment rendered by the Tribunal. But keeping in view the scope and object of Order VII Rule 7 of CPC as stated supra relating to moulding of relief, even though certain reliefs are not asked for they can be granted by the Court under the above provision when the Court considers it just and proper to do so. Even Order 41 Rule 33 of CPC contemplates the power of court of appeal. The appellate court may exercise its wide power in favour of all or any of the respondents or parties, although such respondents or parties may not have filed any appeal or objection. The High Court in deciding an appeal under the Motor Vehicles Act can follow the principles laid down in Order 41 Rule 33 of CPC as they are in conformity with the rules of natural justice. Further, the provisions of CPC are also applicable in the proceedings under the Motor Vehicles Act. The object is to enable the Court to do complete justice between the parties. The method adopted by the Tribunal for computation of compensation in fatal accident action cannot be said to be in accordance with the settled principles governing the matter, the method adopted by the Tribunal for computation of compensation both for arriving at proper figure of multiplicand as well as the multiplier. Since the Tribunal has not applied proper multiplier, the same needs to be considered in this appeal.

13. Pw.1 in his evidence has stated that deceased was working as Recovery Agent and earning about Rs.8,000/- p.m. But there being no valid proof of income, the Tribunal rightly assessed the income of the deceased at Rs.4,000/- p.m. and deducted 50% towards his personal expenses, but erred in adopting multiplier of 10 by taking the age of the second petitioner. Since, the age of deceased Arvind Shetty was aged 22 years, the multiplier of 18 has to be taken and accordingly, the compensation towards loss of dependency is reworked out as under:

Rs.4,000 x 12 x 18 x 50% = Rs.4,32,000/-

Thus, the claimants are entitled for Rs.4,32,000/- as against Rs.2,40,000/- awarded by the Tribunal. The compensation enhanced under this head would be Rs.1,92,000/-. However, the compensation awarded under other heads appears to be just and reasonable and the same does not call for interference of this Court.

For the reasons and findings stated above, I proceed to pass the following:

ORDER

Appeal is disposed of. The respondents/claimants are entitled for enhanced compensation of Rs.1,92,000/- with interest @ 6% p.a. from the date petition till realisation. The judgment and award passed by the Tribunal in MVC No.658/2008 is modified accordingly.

The appellant-insurer shall deposit the enhanced compensation with interest before the Tribunal within six weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this judgment and on such deposit, the same shall be released to the claimants, on proper identification. However, the impugned judgment and award, in so far as it relates to the apportionment and deposit is concerned, shall remain unaltered.

The amount in deposit, if any, shall be transmitted to the concerned Tribunal.

Office to draw the decree accordingly.