Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Medical Council Of India v. Madem Apoorva And Others

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 8, 2016
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Supreme Court was seized of Writ Petition (Civil) No. 76 of 2015 and several connected Special Leave Petitions concerning unfilled postgraduate and super-specialty medical seats that had been reverted to various States after the all-India counselling process. An earlier order dated 28-7-2016 had recorded that out of 848 such seats, a substantial number remained vacant in five States—Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, Odisha—and in the University of Delhi.

The present orders deal with three separate situations:

  • University of Delhi (Order dated 1-9-2016): 99 postgraduate seats were still vacant. An interlocutory application (I.A. No. 20/2016) sought a direction for an additional round of counselling.
  • States of Andhra Pradesh & Telangana (Order dated 8-9-2016): In SLP(C) No. 19633/2016 the petitioners challenged a High Court order permitting a final counselling after the statutory deadline to fill 86 vacant seats in Andhra Pradesh and 32 in Telangana.
  • State of Odisha (Order dated 8-9-2016, I.A. No. 25/2016): Two super-specialty Cardiology seats had been released late; the State sought permission for an extra counselling round.

The Court heard the parties through their respective counsel, considered the urgency of utilising public medical infrastructure, and issued directions specific to each situation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, despite the Court-fixed admission schedule, an additional counselling round could be ordered to fill 99 vacant postgraduate seats in the University of Delhi.
  2. Whether the High Court of Hyderabad was justified in extending the counselling schedule for Andhra Pradesh and Telangana, and what relief—if any—should be granted in the resultant SLPs.
  3. Whether the Supreme Court should permit the State of Odisha to conduct an extra counselling to fill two late-released super-specialty Cardiology seats.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant-in-person / State Applicants

  • Emphasised the large number of vacant seats in government institutions and the resultant waste of public resources.
  • In the Odisha application, highlighted the acute need for cardiologists in the State and the belated release of the two seats.

Medical Council of India (MCI)

  • In the SLPs, argued that the High Court could not lawfully depart from the admission schedule finalised by the Supreme Court.
  • Conceded, however, that the peculiar facts of the Odisha case warranted Supreme Court intervention for an additional counselling.

Union of India / University Representatives

  • Did not oppose an extra counselling round for Delhi University, provided it adhered strictly to merit and excluded already-admitted candidates.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged that it had earlier laid down a strict admission timetable but considered the “larger public interest” in preventing valuable postgraduate and super-specialty seats—in government colleges—from going waste. The analysis proceeded on a case-by-case basis:

  • University of Delhi: Because 99 seats lay vacant, the Court directed one additional counselling within two weeks, with wide publicity and eligibility limited to candidates who had not already secured admission.
  • Andhra Pradesh & Telangana: While noting that the High Court should not have altered the Court-approved schedule, the Supreme Court recognised the exceptional circumstances (86 and 32 vacant seats respectively). It therefore ordered the universities that conducted the last counselling to hold one final round within two weeks, confined to government colleges and excluding already-admitted students, and cautioned that such directions were passed only due to the “special features” of the case.
  • Odisha Super-specialty Seats: Accepting that the seats were released late and specialists were urgently needed, the Court allowed a further counselling within one week, again stressing the exceptional nature of the relief.

Across all matters the Court reaffirmed the primacy of its earlier schedule, warning that lower courts should not extend deadlines in future, yet carved out narrow exceptions to avert public detriment.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING:

  • I.A. No. 20/2016 in WP(C) 76/2015: ALLOWED; Delhi University to conduct an extra counselling for 99 seats within two weeks.
  • SLP(C) Nos. 19549-51/2016 & 23707/2016: DISMISSED.
  • SLP(C) No. 19633/2016: DISPOSED OF; directed final counselling in Andhra Pradesh & Telangana within two weeks.
  • I.A. No. 25/2016 in WP(C) 76/2015 (Odisha): ALLOWED; one-week window for counselling of two Cardiology seats.

IMPLICATIONS: The orders permit limited departures from the Supreme Court’s fixed admission timetable to avoid wastage of government medical seats, but expressly caution that such relief is confined to the unique circumstances at hand and should not be treated as a standing precedent for future deadline extensions.

Show all summary ...

(2017) 14 SCC 155

Order dated 1-9-2016

(Before Dipak Misra and Chockalingam Nagappan, JJ.)

Special Leave Petitions (C) No. 19633 of 2016 with Nos. 23707, 19549-51 of 2016, WP (C) No. 76 of 2015

Writ Petition (C) No. 76 of 2015

1. This Court on 28-7-2016 IA No. 9 in WP (C) No. 76 of 2015, had passed the following order:

“In course of hearing, we have been apprised that once 848 postgraduate seats were reverted to the States. In the present application, we are concerned only with five States, namely, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Himachal Pradesh, Odisha and the University of Delhi.
We have been apprised that in the States of Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Himachal Pradesh, Odisha and Delhi University, the seats vacated are 31, 15, 9, 80 and 99 respectively. As far as the State of Madhya Pradesh is concerned, Mr Saurav Mishra, learned counsel appearing for the State of Madhya Pradesh, shall take instructions with regard to the seats which are still vacant. Regard being had to the aforesaid, we would require the Union of India to apprise us whether as a matter of policy, the seats that have remained vacant should be allowed to remain vacant or they should be allowed to be filled up.
The learned counsel for the States shall prepare a memorandum about the nature of seats available in praesenti to the learned counsel for the petitioner.
Let the matter be listed on 9-8-2016.”

2. Though, this Court had passed the aforesaid order, as advised at present, we are not inclined to extend the date as far as the States are concerned. We shall only deal with the interlocutory application filed against the University of Delhi and, accordingly, we proceed.

IA No. 20 of 2016 in WP (C) No. 76 of 2015

3. IA No. 20 of 2016 for intervention has been filed by Mrs Rajni Nijhavan, the applicant-in-person.

4. Having heard the applicant-in-person, Ms Pinky Anand, learned Additional Solicitor General appearing for the Union of India, Mr Gaurav Sharma, learned counsel for MCI and Mr Mohinder J.S. Rupal, learned counsel for the University of Delhi, we direct the University of Delhi to conduct one more counselling for 99 seats that are lying vacant, within two weeks hence. Wide publicity shall be given within a week from today so that all the students can be made aware of the same. If any student, who has already taken admission, he/she shall not be allowed to participate in the counselling. Needless to say, the counselling shall be done regard being had to the merit.

5. The interlocutory application stands disposed of accordingly.

6. Let a copy of the order passed today be handed over to Mr Mohinder J.S. Rupal, learned counsel appearing for the University of Delhi.

IA No. 25 of 2016 and IAs Nos. 13-19 of 2016

7. Let IA No. 25 of 2016 be taken up in course of next week and IAs Nos. 13-19 of 2016 filed in WP (C) No. 76 of 2015 be taken up in the third week of September, 2016.

SLPs (C) Nos. 19633, 23707 and 19549-51 of 2016

8. List these special leave petitions on 7-9-2016.

9. Let a copy of the petitions be served on the learned Standing Counsel for the State of Andhra Pradesh and State of Telangana. A copy of the petitions be also served on the learned counsel for the respondent Universities.

(2017) 14 SCC 157

Order dated 8-9-2016

(Before Dipak Misra and Chockalingam Nagappan, JJ.)

Special Leave Petitions (C) No. 19633 of 2016 with Nos. 23707, 19549-51 of 2016, WP (C) No. 76 of 2015

SLPs (C) Nos. 19549-51 and 23707 of 2016

10. Heard Mr V.V.S. Rao, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners and Mr Gaurav Sharma, learned counsel for the Medical Council of India.

11. We find no merit in the special leave petitions. The special leave petitions stand dismissed.

SLP (C) No. 19633 of 2016

12. The present special leave petition has been preferred against the judgment and order dated 13-7-2016 Writ Appeal No. 405 of 2016 passed by the High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh in a batch of writ petitions whereby the High Court has directed as follows:

“Today, we are confronted with a situation where about 86 seats in government medical colleges have gone waste in the State of Andhra Pradesh and 32 seats have gone waste in the State of Telangana. All these seats are for postgraduate degrees or diplomas both on clinical and non-clinical sides. The last date on which the 5th counselling was held, was 30-5-2016. As per the government orders, the private colleges were entitled to convert these merit quota seats into management quota seats. This could have happened only after 30-5-2016. Today, we are on 13-7-2016. Therefore, the breaking of the deadline, just for the purpose of ensuring that the vacant seats are filled up, will be in larger public interest. We make it clear that we are not merely taking note of the plight of the writ petitioners, but the very plight of the government institutions, where the investment in the form of resources cannot be utilised to the full potential, if some of the seats go waste in postgraduate courses.
Though the learned counsel for the Medical Council of India submitted that any violation of the deadline, has always been taken adverse notice of by the Supreme Court, the courts have not so far been confronted with a situation of this nature where so many seats go waste not due to the fault committed by anyone of the stakeholders. Therefore, the peculiar circumstances of the case warrant us to issue interim directions not necessarily in the interest of some individuals but also in the larger public interest and the interest of the universities and the educational institutions themselves.
In view of the above, an interim direction is issued to the respondents to open up one last counselling to be conducted on 23-7-2016 for filling up of seats that are remaining vacant, either due to non-allotment or due to allotment not being taken by the allotted candidate or due to the allotted candidate taking the seat and not reporting or due to the allotted candidate joining and leaving by this time for better prospects or better course. There shall be one counselling conducted by Dr NTR University of Health Sciences for filling up these seats. An advertisement, in this regard, shall be published in the same manner as they have done in the past in newspapers and also in the websites of the Universities.”

13. It is submitted by Mr Gaurav Sharma that the High Court could not have passed the aforesaid order. It needs to be stated that this Court has determined a schedule after hearing the learned counsel for the Union of India and the Medical Council of India. Therefore, the High Court should not have issued the above directions. We are sure, in future, the same shall not be done.

14. Despite our saying so, we cannot be oblivious of the plight that the two States have faced and the in-service and the direct applicants are facing in praesenti. Various grievances have been raised. We take note of the fact that 86 seats in the State of Andhra Pradesh and 32 seats in the State of Telangana are available in the government colleges in both the States. Having regard to the facts and circumstances of the case, we direct that the University(ies) that conducted the last counselling shall conduct a counselling within two weeks hence after giving due publicity. A student who has already taken admission will not be eligible to participate in this counselling. Needless to say, the University shall follow the procedure as provided in the admission brochure/prospectus. We further say that the vacant seats are meant only for government colleges and universities. We repeat at the cost of repetition that we have passed this order in the special features of the case.

15. The special leave petition is accordingly disposed of.

IA No. 25 in WP (C) No. 76 of 2016

16. Heard Ms Sharmila Upadhyaya, learned counsel for the applicants and Mr Gaurav Sharma, learned counsel for the Medical Council of India.

17. It is submitted by Ms Upadhyaya, learned counsel for the State of Odisha that two superspecialty seats in Cardiology were released belatedly and there is need for Cardiology doctors in the State of Odisha. The learned counsel would submit that these seats were to be filled up by 31st August but it could not be done due to belated receipt of communication from the Central Government.

18. Mr Gaurav Sharma, learned counsel for the Medical Council of India submits that present case is one where this Court may intervene and accord the permission to the State to go ahead with another counselling to fill up the extended benefit of admission of students in two superspecialty seats in Cardiology.

19. In view of the aforesaid, the prayer stands allowed. Counselling be effected within a week hence and seats be filled up accordingly. Needless to say, this order is passed in special features of the case.

20. The IA stands disposed of.

Court Masters