Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Duncans Industries Limited And Another v. Union Of India And Others

Calcutta High Court
Sep 20, 2016

1. These appeals are directed against an order dated March 15, 2016 passed by a learned single Judge dismissing the writ petition.

2. The dispute commenced with a notification dated January 28, 2016 issued by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Government of India by which the following order was passed:—

“Now, therefore, in exercise of powers conferred by subsection (1) of section 16E of the Tea Act, 1953 (29 of 1953), the Central Government hereby authorises the Tea Board to take immediate steps to take over the management or the control of the above seven tea estates as per the provisions of Chapter IA of the Tea Act, 1953 (29 of 1953).”

3. The aforesaid order was passed on the grounds that “and whereas, the Central Government is of the considered opinion that the tea gardens as listed below are being managed in a manner highly detrimental to the tea industry and to public interest:

(i) Birpara Tea Estate

(i) Garganda Tea Estate

(i) Lankapara Tea Estate

(i) Tulsipara Tea Estate

(i) Huntapara Tea Estate

(i) Dhumchipara Tea Estate

(i) Demdima Tea Estate”

4. We find some force in the submission advanced by Mr. Mitra, learned senior advocate appearing for the appellants, that the allegation that the seven tea gardens were managed in a manner highly detrimental to the tea industry and to public interest could have attracted an order under section 16B or under section 16D of the Tea Act, 1953. But it could not have justified an order under section 16E of the Act as the Central Government purported to do. It was, therefore, submitted that the notification is bad.

5. The other aspect of the matter is that by virtue of the said notification, dated January 28, 2016 issued, under section 16E of the said Act and by operation of sub-section (2) of section 16E of the said Act, the provisions contained in sections 16A and 16B of the Industrial Development Regulation Act, 1951 became operative. In consequence whereof the persons in management of the tea gardens are deemed to have vacated office. Therefore, the appellants who were running the aforesaid seven tea gardens are no longer in possession thereof; whereas Mr. Bose, learned senior advocate appearing for the Tea Board, submitted that his client does not have requisite expertise to run the tea gardens. His client, he added, does that by appointing entrepreneurs and for that purpose tenders were invited four times.

6. Mr. Chanda, learned Additional Solicitor-General of India, submitted that the tenders have now been finalised, and managers for four gardens have been approved. As regards the balance three, steps have to be taken by the Central Government.

7. The picture which emerges is that the appellants, in lawful possession of the gardens, were removed without any adequate arrangement for taking over the day-to-day management thereof either by Tea Board or any other independent agency. Consequence is that the situation is worse than what it was on the day when the notification January 28, 2016 was issued.

8. In that view of the matter, subject to result of the appeals, the following interim arrangement has been made by us after hearing the learned advocates for the parties:—

(a) the appellants-writ petitioners shall take over management of all the seven tea gardens;

(b) the appellants-writ petitioners shall pay both the current and arrear dues of the workers;

(c) the appellants-writ petitioners shall run the gardens in a prudent businessman like manner; and

(d) the appellants-writ petitioners shall keep the Tea Board informed by fortnightly returns as to the steps taken by them.

9. It is clarified that the interim order has been passed only for the purpose of improving lot of the workers as also that of the gardens. The appellants shall not be entitled to alienate or encumber any of the fixed assets except in the usual course of business. Liberty to mention.

10. Certified photostat copy of this order, if applied for, shall be given to the parties.