Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mandeep Kaur v. Dharam Lingam

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Oct 5, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal arises from a judgment dated 17.03.2015 in HMA No. 22 of 11.03.2014, in which the appellant-wife, Mandeep Kaur, sought dissolution of marriage under Section 13B-1(ia)(1b) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 against respondent-husband Dharam Lingam. The learned Additional District Judge, Ludhiana dismissed the petition on the ground that the Hindu Marriage Act would not extend to the respondent because he is a citizen of Canada. The appellant challenged that dismissal by filing the present appeal.

At trial the respondent initially appeared through counsel on notice, but when the case was fixed for filing of written statement he absented and the trial court proceeded ex parte. During the appeal, notice to the respondent was first returned “unclaimed”; a later registered notice was not returned, and the appellate court assumed the registered AD had reached its destination after more than 30 days. The appellant asserted the marriage had been solemnized at Village Gorsian Makhan, Tehsil Jagraon, District Ludhiana, and that the parties cohabited for about one and a half months before the respondent returned to Canada.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the extent and applicability of the Hindu Marriage Act under Section 1(2) of the Act — i.e., whether the Act applies to a respondent who is a foreign citizen but may be domiciled in India?
  2. To which court may a petition under the Hindu Marriage Act be presented — in particular, whether the District Court in Ludhiana had jurisdiction to entertain the wife's petition?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The marriage between appellant and respondent was solemnized in Village Gorsian Makhan, Tehsil Jagraon, District Ludhiana under Hindu rites and customs.
  • After marriage the parties cohabited for about one and a half months; the respondent returned to Canada on the pretext of completing immigration formalities.
  • The appellant filed the petition for dissolution under the Hindu Marriage Act in the appropriate District Court (Ludhiana) and relied on the Act's provisions (including Section 19) to establish jurisdiction.

Respondent's Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The respondent is described in the record as a citizen of Canada.
  • On notice of the petition the respondent appeared before the trial court but did not file a written statement, did not plead that he was not domiciled in India, and did not raise any specific jurisdictional objection before absconding from further proceedings; therefore there were no pleaded facts by the respondent denying Indian domicile or contesting the trial court’s jurisdiction.
  • The trial court nevertheless dismissed the petition on the short ground that the Hindu Marriage Act would not extend to the respondent because of his Canadian citizenship.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shashi Leekha v. Sheila Shashi Leekha, AIR 2013 Bom 86 Interprets Section 1(2): the Act "extends to the whole of India except the State of Jammu and Kashmir, and applies also to Hindus domiciled in the territories to which this Act extends, who are outside the said territories." The court cited this decision to support the view that Section 1(2) contemplates application of the Act to Hindus domiciled in India even if they reside outside India.
Sondur Gopal v. Sondur Rajini, (2013) 7 SCC 426 Affirms that Section 1(2) gives the Act an extra‑territorial operation limited to Hindus domiciled in India; stresses that domicile in India is the saving nexus for extraterritorial operation. The court relied on this Supreme Court ruling to hold that the Act applies to Hindus domiciled in India even if they reside abroad, and that absence of a respondent's specific pleading on domicile precludes assuming he is not domiciled in India.
R. Sridharan v. The Presiding Officer, 2010 (8) MLJ 438 (Madras High Court Division Bench) Interprets Section 19 and recognizes the wife's right to present a petition in the District Court where she resides; foreign citizenship of husband cannot defeat that right by a technical plea. The court cited this authority to reinforce that Section 19(iii‑a) must be given effect so that a wife may file where she actually resides and that such jurisdiction cannot be defeated by the husband's foreign citizenship.
Y. Narasimha Rao v. Y. Venkata Lakshmi, (1991) 3 SCC 451 Holds that a foreign court (Missouri in that case) had no jurisdiction under the Hindu Marriage Act and that marriages performed under the Act can be dissolved only under the Act. The court relied on this Supreme Court authority to conclude that foreign courts lack jurisdiction to dissolve marriages governed by the Hindu Marriage Act, thereby supporting the conclusion on jurisdiction under Section 19.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate court conducted a textual and precedential analysis focused on two issues: the territorial extent of the Hindu Marriage Act under Section 1(2), and the proper forum for presentation of petitions under the Act (Section 19).

On Section 1(2), the court examined the statute's language: "It extends to the whole of India except the State of Jammu and Kashmir, and applies also to Hindus domiciles in the territories to which this Act extends who are outside the said territories." From a plain reading the court concluded that the Act applies to Hindus domiciled in India even if they reside outside India. The court reinforced this textual interpretation by citing Shashi Leekha and the Supreme Court decision in Sondur Gopal v. Sondur Rajini, both of which affirm that the Act has extraterritorial operation only insofar as it applies to Hindus domiciled in India.

The court then applied that legal framework to the facts. Although the respondent is described as a Canadian citizen, he had appeared initially in the trial court and did not file a written statement nor plead that he was not domiciled in India. Given the absence of any pleading from the respondent negating Indian domicile or contesting jurisdiction, the appellate court held that one cannot assume the respondent was not a Hindu domiciled in India by origin and residing abroad. Consequently, the court answered Issue (i) in favour of the proposition that the Act could apply to the respondent unless and until facts were pleaded and proved to show otherwise.

On jurisdiction under Section 19, the court reproduced the statutory provisions that prescribe the district courts before which petitions may be presented, including sub‑clause (iii‑a) (inserted by Act 50 of 2003) that gives the wife the right to present the petition before the district court in whose jurisdiction she is residing. The court explained the legislative aim of sub‑clause (iii‑a) as a corrective measure to avoid prejudice to women arising from the earlier wording of Section 19.

The court relied on R. Sridharan to emphasize that the statutory right granted to the wife to file in her local district cannot be defeated by a technical plea about the husband's foreign citizenship. It also cited Y. Narasimha Rao to underline that foreign courts do not have jurisdiction to dissolve marriages governed by the Hindu Marriage Act. Given these legal positions and the factual finding that the marriage was solemnized in Ludhiana and the appellant was residing in the territorial jurisdiction where she filed, the appellate court held that the trial court erred in dismissing the petition solely because the respondent was a Canadian citizen.

Finally, the appellate court observed that because the respondent had appeared before the trial court and raised no jurisdictional objections before absconding, he had submitted to the jurisdiction of the Ludhiana court. On this basis the trial court's dismissal on the ground of non‑extension of the Act to the respondent was held to be incorrect.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The appellate court set aside the judgment dated 17.03.2015 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Ludhiana, which had dismissed the petition on the ground that the Hindu Marriage Act would not extend to the respondent by reason of his Canadian citizenship.

Consequent directions and direct effect:

  • The matter is remitted to the trial court (Additional District Judge, Ludhiana) with a direction to proceed in accordance with law.
  • The trial court is permitted to issue fresh notice to the respondent and to give both parties fresh opportunity to adduce evidence.

Broader implications: The opinion reaffirms established principles (as reflected in cited authorities) that the Hindu Marriage Act applies extraterritorially only to Hindus domiciled in India and that a wife has a statutory right under Section 19(iii‑a) to file in the district where she resides; it does not purport to establish new precedent beyond applying those principles to the facts at hand. The immediate consequence is a retrial/rehearing at the trial court level; no novel legal doctrine is announced in this judgment.

Show all summary ...

Sneh Prashar, J.:— Assailing the judgment dated 17.03.2015 vide which HMA case No. 22 of 11.03.2014 filed by appellant-wife Mandeep Kaur against respondent-husband Dharam Lingam under Section 13B-1(ia)(1b) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (for short ‘the Act’) for dissolution of their marriage was dismissed by learned Additional District Judge, Ludhiana, the appellant-wife preferred the instant appeal.

2. As indicated in the impugned judgment by learned Additional District Judge, Ludhiana, on notice of the petition, the respondent-husband had appeared through counsel but when the case was fixed for filing written statement, he absented from hearing and was proceeded against ex-parte.

3. During the instant appeal proceedings, notice of motion was issued to the respondent. At the first instance, notice issued was received back unserved with the report “unclaimed”. Subsequently, the notice sent through registered cover was not received back served or otherwise. Since more than 30 days had passed after the registered notice was issued, it is assumed that the registered AD had reached its destination.

4. Otherwise also as already observed above, the respondent was ex-parte when the impugned judgment was passed by learned trial Court on 17.3.2015. The petition was dismissed on the short ground that the Act would not extend in the case of respondent-husband since he is a citizen of Canada.

5. We have have heard learned counsel for the appellant and have scrutinized the impugned judgment passed by learned trial Court.

6. The operating paragraph in the judgment of learned trial Court leading to dismissal of the petition is reproduced hereunder:-

“It is the case of petitioner that respondent is citizen of Canada. As per Section-1 sub-section-2 of The Hindu Marriage Act, the Act extends to the whole of India except the State of Jammu and Kashmir and applies also to Hindus domiciled in the territories to which this Act extends who are outside the said territories. As stated above, respondent is citizen of Canada. There is nothing on record which would show that respondent comes within meaning of Hindu domiciled in India, having place of abode in India, even if he resides outside India. Thus, Hindu Marriage Act would not extend in case of respondent.”

7. The contentious issues that necessitate examination are:

(i) extent and applicability of the Act as per Section 1(2) of the Act;

(ii) the court to which a petition under the Act can be presented.

8. Section 1(2) of the Act provides for extent of the Act and the same reads as follows:-

“1. Short title and extent.-(1) xxx xxx xx

(2) It extends to the whole of India except the State of Jammu and Kashmir, and applies also to Hindus domiciles in the territories to which this Act extends who are outside the said territories.”

9. From a plain reading of Section 1(2) of the Act, it is evident that the Act extends to the Hindus of the whole of India except the State of Jammu and Kahmir and also applies to Hindus domiciled in India, who are outside the said territories. In short, the Act, in our considered opinion, will apply to Hindus domiciled in India even if they reside outside India.

10. In Shashi Leekha… v. Sheila Shashi Leekha…. AIR 2013 Bom 86, a Division Bench of Bombay High Court held as under:-

“12. Section 1(2) predicates that the Act extends to the whole of India except the State of Jammu and Kashmir, and applies also to Hindus domiciled in the territories to which this Act extends, who are outside the said territories.”

11. In Sondur Gopal v. Sondur Rajini. (2013) 7 SCC 426, the parties were originally citizens of India but acquired citizenship of Sweden and as citizens of Sweden claimed domicile in Australia. The plea of the appellant-husband that he was a Swedish citizen domiciled in Australia, hence, Australian Courts shall have jurisdiction, was rejected by Hon'ble the Supreme Court. Examining the extent and applicability of the Act, it was observed that a plain reading of Section 1(2) of the Act, which provides for ‘extent of the Act’, shows that it has extra-territorial operation and it was held as under:-

“21. Bearing in mind the principle aforesaid, when we consider Section 1(2) of the Act, it is evident that the Act extends to the Hindus of whole of India except the State of Jammu and Kashmir and also applies to Hindus domiciled in India who are outside the said territory. In short, the Act, in our opinion, will apply to Hindus domiciled in India even if they reside outside India. If the requirement of domicile in India is omitted altogether, the Act shall have no nexus with India which shall render the Act vulnerable on the ground that extra-territorial operation has no nexus with India. In our opinion, this extra-territorial operation of law is saved not because of nexus with Hindus but Hindus domiciled in India.

22. to 26. x x x x

27. Section 2(1) provides for the application of the Act. The same reads as follows:

2. Application of Act.- (1) This Act applies -

(a) to any person who is a Hindu by religion in any of its forms or developments, including a Virashaiva, a Lingayat or a follower of the Brahmo, Prarthana or Arya Samaj,

(b) to any person who is a Buddhist, Jaina or Sikh by religion, and

(c) to any other person domiciled in the territories to which this Act extends who is not a Muslim, Christian, Parsi or Jew by religion, unless it is proved that any such person would not have been governed by the Hindu law or by any custom or usage as part of that law in respect of any of the matters dealt with herein if this Act had not been passed.

This section contemplates application of the Act to Hindu by religion in any of its forms or Hindu within the extended meaning i.e. Buddhist, Jaina or Sikh and, in fact, applies to all such persons domiciled in the country who are not Muslims, Christians, Parsi or Jew, unless it is proved that such persons are not governed by the Act under any custom or usage. Therefore, we are of the opinion that Section 2 will apply to Hindus when the Act extends to that area in terms of Section 1 of the Act. Therefore, in our considered opinion, the Act will apply to Hindu outside the territory of India only if such a Hindu is domiciled in the territory of India.”

12. In the case in hand, the respondent was stated to be citizen of Canada. On notice of the petition, he had appeared before learned trial Court but without filing written reply to the petition and raising any objection/pleading relating to his status as domicile of India or jurisdiction of the Court, had walked out of the proceedings. In the absence of pleading on his part, it cannot be assumed that he was not a Hindu domiciled in India by origin and residing outside the territory of India. Issue No. (i) is answered accordingly.

13. Another important factum in the instant case is that the marriage of the appellant was solemnized with the respondent at Village Gorsian Makhan, Tehsil Jagraon, District Ludhiana. The appellant submitted that after the marriage, they lived and cohabited as husband and wife for about 1½ months, before the respondent returned to Canada on the pretext of completing formalities of immigration department to call her to Canada.

14. Section 19 of the Act deals with jurisdiction and procedure, which reads as under:

“19. Court to which petition shall be presented.-Every petition under this Act shall be presented to the district court within the local limits of whose ordinary original civil jurisdiction-

(i) the marriage was solemnised, or

(ii) the respondent, at the time of the presentation of the petition, resides, or

(iii) the parties to the marriage last resided together, or

(iiia) in case the wife is the petitioner, where she is residing on the date of presentation of the petition, or

(iv) the petitioner is residing at the time of the presentation of the petition, in a case where the respondent is, at that time, residing outside the territories to which this Act extends, or has not been heard of as being alive for a period of seven years or more by those persons who would naturally have heard of him if he were alive.”

15. Sub-clause (iii-a) was inserted by Act 50 of 2003. As it was found that the provision regarding jurisdiction caused serious prejudice to the cause of women and the jurisdiction clause as it stood originally, was unfair to the women, necessary amendment was made in Section 19 of the Act for the purpose of incorporating a provision to enable the wife to file a petition before the District Court in whose jurisdiction she is actually residing. Accordingly, the wife is now entitled to file a matrimonial petition before the District Court in whose territorial jurisdiction she is residing.

16. In R.Sridharan v. The Presiding Officer 106, reported as 2010 (8) MLJ 438, a Division Bench of Madras High Court held as under:-

“19. The Hindu Marriage Act applies to all Hindus domiciled in the territory to which the act extends. Section 19 gives a right to the wife to present the petition to the District Court within whose jurisdiction she is residing.

20. When the wife was given the right to initiate the proceedings before the local District Court where she is actually residing, such a provision cannot be defeated by taking a technical plea that no such proceeding would lie on account of Foreign Citizenship of the husband or his domicile in another country.”

17. It has already been observed above that the respondent did not opt to counter the plea of the appellant that the marriage between the parties was solemnized in accordance with the Hindu rites and customs at Village Gorsian Makhan, Tehsil Jagraon, District Ludhiana and that they are governed by the provisions of the Act. When the marriage was solemnized under the Hindu law, the proceedings for divorce by the appellant had also to be preferred under the said Act. The respondent cannot take any exception to the proceedings in India under the provisions of the Act, merely on account of his citizenship of Canada, especially when the marriage was solemnized in India.

18. The provision of Section 19 (iii-a) of the Act gives a right to the wife to initiate the proceedings before the local District Court where she is actually residing and such a provision cannot be defeated on a technical plea that such proceeding would not lie on account of foreign citizenship of the husband. The objects and reasons which prompted the Parliament to incorporate such a provision have to be interpreted in letter and spirit.

19. In Y. Narasimha Rao v. Y. Venkata Lakshmi (1991) 3 SCC 451, the issue before Hon'ble the Supreme Court was regarding recognition of foreign judgment on matrimonial dispute passed by a Foreign Court. In the said case, the marriage was as per the provisions of the Act, however, the decree of divorce was granted by the Court of Missouri. It was held by Hon'ble the Supreme Court that the Court at Missouri had no jurisdiction to entertain a petition under the Hindu Marriage Act. It was categorically stated that marriages performed under the Hindu Marriage Act can be dissolved only under the said Act. With the above decision issue No. (ii) is set at rest.

20. By appearing before learned trial Court on notice and then raising no objection with regard to the jurisdiction of the said Court at Ludhiana before leaving the proceedings to proceed ex-parte against him, the respondent had submitted to the jurisdiction of the said Court, therefore, learned trial court wrongly dismissed the petition of the appellant on the ground that the provisions of the Act would not extend in the case of the respondent.

21. The genesis of the above discussion is that we set aside the judgment dated 17.03.2015 passed by learned Additional District Judge, Ludhiana. The matter is remitted back to the said Court with the direction to proceed as per law. It shall be open to learned trial Court to issue fresh notice to the respondent and also give fresh opportunity to both the parties to adduce evidence.

22. The appeal stands disposed of accordingly.