- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
ASSOTECH LIMITED v. MEERUTI
CUSTOMS, EXCISE & SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL
ALLAHABAD
REGIONAL BENCH - COURT NO.I
Service Tax Appeal No.50213 of 2015
(Arising out of Order-in-Original No.21/Commr./MRT-I/2014 dated 16/06/2014 passed by Commissioner, Central Excise, Meerut-I)
M/s Assotech Limited …..Appellant
(148F, Pocket-IV, Mayur Vihar Phase-I, New Delhi)
VERSUS
Commissioner of Central Excise, & Service Tax, Meerut-I …..Respondent
(Opp. CCS University, Mangal Pandey Nagar, Meerut--250005)
APPEARANCE:
Shri Abhinav Kalra, Chartered Accountant for Appellant Shri Rajeev Ranjan, Authorized Representative for Respondent
CORAM :
Hon'ble Mrs. ARCHANA WADHWA, MEMBER (JUDICIAL) Hon'ble Mr. ANIL G. SHAKKARWAR, MEMBER (TECHNICAL)
FINAL ORDER NO.70100 / 2020
DATE OF HEARING: 14 January, 2020
DATE OF DECISION: 14 January, 2020
PER: ARCHANA WADHWA
The appellant M/s Assotech Limited is engaged in providing 'commercial or industrial construction service', 'construction of residential complex services', 'works contract service' and 'site formation service' to various clients.
2. The dispute in the present appeal relates to one contract given to them by M/s Arrow Infra Limited for supply of mud and spreading and dumping of earth on agricultural land. The said services were provided by the appellant during the period 01 October, 2007 to 31 March, 2008. Inasmuch the definition of 'site formation and clearance service, excavation, earth moving and demolition service does not include the service provided in relation to agriculture, irrigation etc., the appellant
1
did not pay any service tax on the said services so provided by them to M/s Arrow Infra Limited. There is no dispute about the said fact, which is also accepted by the Revenue in the show cause notice as also in the order.
3. Subsequent to the completion of the said work, M/s Arrow Infra Limited got the land use changed from agriculture use to construction of residential complexes etc. in the year 2009-2010. Certificate to that effect was issued by Uttarakhand Development Authority vide their Notification dated 13 January, 2009 and 29 March, 2010. Thereafter construction activity took place on the said land and buildings were constructed.
4. In the above background Revenue entertained a view that since the land now stands used for construction activities and not for agricultural purpose, the services provided by the appellant during the period prior to land use change would fall under 'site formation and clearance service and excavation, earth moving and demolition services'. As a result appellant was liable to pay service tax in respect of the same. Accordingly, a show cause notice dated 22 April, 2013 was issued raising the demand of service tax to the tune of Rs.2.47 crores (approx) in respect of the services provided by the appellant during the period 01 October, 2007 to 31 March, 2008. The said show cause notice stands culminated into an impugned order passed by the Commissioner of Service Tax, Meerut.
5. Learned Chartered Accountant Shri Abhinav Kalra appearing for the appellants assails the impugned order on merits as also on limitation. It is his contention that admittedly the services were provided during the period 01 October, 2007 to 31 March, 2008, when the land in question was an agricultural land. The activities undertaken by them were supply of mud and spreading and dumping the same in the agricultural land. The said activities were completed by them by March 2008 and as such their tax liability has to be assessed accordingly. There is no dispute that the land was agricultural land during the period of the service and was changed to industrial and commercial use only in 2009 onwards. As such it cannot be said that the services
2
provided by them were in respect of land which was for commercial purpose during the relevant time. He also assails the impugned order on the point of limitation by submitting that the show cause notice issued on 22 April, 2013 is admittedly barred by limitation. He submits that the Adjudicating Authority has invoked the longer period on the ground that M/s Arrow Infra Limited have connived with the appellant to get the work of spreading and dumping of earth by declaring the land as agriculture land and thereafter getting the same converted from Agricultural land to Commercial. As such he said that there is mala fide intention on the part of the assessee requiring invocation of extended period. The said finding of Commissioner is being assailed by the learned advocate on the ground that the Adjudicating Authority has gone by his whims and fancies and there is nothing on record to suggest that the said agricultural land was subsequently got converted so as not to pay the tax. As such, he submits that invocation of longer period is not justified.
6. Learned A.R. appearing for the Revenue reiterates the findings of the Adjudicating Authority. As regards the factual position that the land was admittedly agricultural land at the time of providing of services, he fairly agrees to that fact but submits that subsequent conversion of land into commercial use was with a mala fide intention of M/s Arrow Infra Limited.
7. After considering the submissions from both the sides and after going through the impugned order, we note that the services of providing mud and spreading the same was undertaken by the appellant during the period 01 October, 2007 to 31 March, 2008. As per the contract entered by the appellants with M/s Arrow Infra Limited the land in question upon which the mud was to be spread was admittedly agricultural land. Revenue has also not disputed the said fact. As per the definition of site formation and clearance etc, any activity done in relation to agriculture is excluded. Inasmuch as the services in the present
3
case were provided in relation to agriculture, the same has to be held as exempted. Subsequent action by the owner of the land has got no relation to the activities done by the appellant prior to the said conversion. As such, we do not agree with the findings of the Adjudicating Authority that since the agricultural land was subsequently converted into commercial land, the activity undertaken by the appellant prior to the said conversion would become taxable subsequent to conversion of the land. The taxability of the service is required to be examined at the time when the same were provided. Admittedly, the same were provided in respect of the agricultural land. As such, we find not justifiable reason to uphold the impugned order.
8. Apart from the merit of the case, we also agree with the learned chartered accountant that the demand raised on 22 April, 2013 is barred by limitation. At the time when the appellant provided services, the same were exempted and as such the appellant's plea that no service tax is required to be paid cannot be doubted. There is no evidence on record to establish that the appellant at the time of providing the services knew that the said land is going to be converted. In such a scenario, the invocation of longer period cannot be upheld.
9. In view of the forgoing, we set aside the impugned order and allow the appeal with consequential relief to the appellants.
(Dictated and Pronounced in open Court)
Sd/-
(Archana Wadhwa) Member (Judicial)
Sd/-
(Anil G. Shakkarwar) Member (Technical)
Nihal
4
Alert