- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Surinder Kumar v. State Of Punjab .
Factual and Procedural Background
On 12 September 1996 a police patrol comprising Head Constable Devi Lal, Sub-Inspector Darbara Singh and other officials was travelling from Dalbir Khera towards Waryam Khera. Near the Canal Minor bridge they spotted the appellant, Surinder Kumar, carrying a bag. When approached he moved towards the canal bank but was apprehended. The Additional Superintendent of Police (ASP), Abohar, was called to the spot and a search of the bag yielded 1 kg 750 g of opium. Two 10-gram samples were taken, sealed, and an FIR was registered the same day.
The appellant was tried before the Special Judge, Ferozepur, who on 20 May 1999 convicted him under Section 18 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act) and sentenced him to 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹1,00,000, with one year’s additional imprisonment in default. His appeal (Crl. A. No. 706-SB/1999) was dismissed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana on 22 April 2008. The present criminal appeal before the Supreme Court challenged those concurrent findings.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether failure to examine Joginder Singh, ASI—who transported the sealed contraband to the court—broke the chain of custody and vitiated the prosecution case.
- Whether non-examination of the ASP who was present at the search constituted a breach of Section 50 of the NDPS Act.
- Whether the conviction was unsustainable because no independent witnesses were examined.
- Whether the investigation was invalid because the informant and investigator were allegedly the same person, in light of Mohan Lal v. State of Punjab.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- Link evidence was incomplete because Joginder Singh, ASI, who handled the seized material, was not examined.
- Non-examination of the ASP, in whose presence the search allegedly occurred, violated Section 50 NDPS Act.
- Lack of independent witnesses rendered the prosecution version unreliable; reliance solely on police witnesses was improper.
- The investigator and informant being the same person offended the rule subsequently laid down in Mohan Lal v. State of Punjab.
- Relied on decisions in Trimukh Maroti Kirkan, Noor Aga and Mohan Lal to seek acquittal.
Respondent State's Arguments
- Chain of custody remained intact; the seals were verified by the Magistrate, and the Chemical Examiner received samples with seals tallied.
- Official witnesses’ testimony is sufficient; absence of independent witnesses is not fatal, as recognised in Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab.
- Non-examination of the ASP was due to service difficulties; his absence did not prejudice the defence and Section 50 was complied with.
- Varinder Kumar v. State of Himachal Pradesh confines the ratio of Mohan Lal to future cases; hence it does not apply to this pre-2018 prosecution.
- Urged affirmance of concurrent findings of fact by both courts below.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra, (2006) 10 SCC 681 | Relied on by appellant; specific principle not elaborated in the opinion. | The Court did not specifically analyse this decision. |
| Noor Aga v. State of Punjab, (2008) 16 SCC 417 | Relied on by appellant; principle not detailed in the text. | Not expressly discussed in the judgment. |
| Mohan Lal v. State of Punjab, (2018) 17 SCC 627 | Informant and investigator cannot be the same. | Distinguished; Court held, following Varinder Kumar, that prosecutions prior to Mohan Lal remain governed by their own facts. |
| Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab, (2011) 3 SCC 521 | Absence of independent witnesses does not automatically render prosecution doubtful. | Cited to reject appellant’s contention regarding non-examination of independent witnesses. |
| State (NCT of Delhi) v. Sunil, (2001) 1 SCC 652 | Presumption that official acts of police are regularly performed; police evidence not to be approached with inherent distrust. | Quoted approvingly to support reliance on police witnesses. |
| Varinder Kumar v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (2020) 3 SCC 321 | Held that Mohan Lal doctrine is prospective; earlier prosecutions unaffected. | Applied to hold that the appellant could not derive benefit from Mohan Lal. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined each objection raised by the appellant:
- Chain of custody: The sealed contraband was handed to Joginder Singh, ASI, solely for production before the Magistrate. He did not possess the investigating officer’s seal, and the Magistrate found the seals intact (Exts. P-13 & P-14). The Chemical Examiner also confirmed intact seals (Ext. P-10). Therefore, non-examination of the ASI did not break the link evidence.
- Presence of ASP and Section 50 compliance: Records showed the ASP was summoned repeatedly but could not attend due to service issues. Nonetheless, evidence established that the search was conducted in his presence; hence Section 50 was not violated. The Court held that his non-examination was not fatal.
- Independent witnesses: Police witnesses testified that efforts were made to secure civilians but none were available. Relying on Jarnail Singh and State v. Sunil, the Court reaffirmed that the testimony of official witnesses, if credible, suffices.
- Investigator and informant identity: The appellant’s reliance on Mohan Lal was rejected because Varinder Kumar limits Mohan Lal to cases instituted after that ruling.
- Overall assessment: Both trial court and High Court findings were concurred with; evidence proved possession of 1 kg 750 g opium beyond reasonable doubt. Sentence of 10 years RI and ₹1 lakh fine was consistent with Section 18 NDPS Act.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED. The Supreme Court upheld the conviction and sentence imposed by the Special Judge and affirmed by the High Court.
Immediate consequence: the appellant’s bail bonds were cancelled, and he was directed to surrender within four weeks to serve the remaining sentence; failing that, the Chief Judicial Magistrate is to procure his custody. The judgment does not set out any new legal precedent but reinforces existing principles regarding chain of custody, reliance on police testimony, and the prospective operation of Mohan Lal.
R. Subhash Reddy, J.— This criminal appeal is filed by the sole accused, aggrieved by the judgment dated 22-4-2008 passed in Surinder Kumar v. State of Punjab Criminal Appeal No. 706-SB of 1999 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh.
2. The appellant herein was convicted for the offence punishable under Section 18 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (for short “the NDPS Act, 1985”), vide the judgment dated 20-5-1999, passed by the Special Judge, Ferozepur, for offence under Section 18 of the NDPS Act, 1985 and was sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of 10 years and to pay a fine of Rs 1,00,000 (Rupees one lakh) in default of payment of the same, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for another period of one year.
3. The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that on 12-9-1996, Devi Lal, HC (PW 1), Darbara Singh, SI (PW 2), along with other police officials were going from Dalbir Khera towards Waryam Khera, in a private jeep, on patrol duty, and when they reached near the bridge of Canal Minor, the appellant-accused was seen coming from the opposite direction, carrying a bag in his right hand. On seeing the police party, the appellant-accused turned towards the southern banks of the canal, but was apprehended on suspicion. The search of the bag, carried by the accused, in the presence of ASP, Abohar, who was called to the spot, in accordance with the provisions of the law, resulted into recovery of 1 kg 750 g of opium. Upon seizure, 2 samples of 10 g each, were separated and the remaining opium was put into the same bag. The samples were duly sealed and taken into possession. Thereafter, ruqa was sent to the police station, on the basis whereof an FIR was registered. The accused was arrested and after completion of the investigation, he was challaned. On appearance in the court, the documents relied upon by the prosecution were supplied to the accused. A charge under Section 18 of the Act was framed against him, to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed the trial.
4. To prove the charge against the appellant on behalf of the prosecution, four witnesses were examined i.e. Devi Lal, HC (PW 1), Darbara Singh, SI (PW 2), SI (PW 3) and Sham Lal, Constable (PW 4). After closure of evidence, the statement of the accused under Section 313 CrPC was recorded and he was explained of all incriminating circumstances appeared against him, in the prosecution evidence. He pleaded false implication, however, he did not lead any evidence in his defence. After appreciating the oral and documentary evidence on record, the learned Special Judge, Ferozepur, vide his judgment dated 20-5-1999, in Sessions Trial No. 17 of 1999, by recording a finding that prosecution has proved the guilt of the accused for offence under Section 18 of the Act, in keeping in his possession 1 kg 750 g of opium in the area of Village Dalmir Khera, convicted the appellant, he was sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for 10 years and to pay a fine of Rs 1,00,000 (Rupees one lakh) in default, to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one year.
5. Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment of the trial court, the appellant herein has filed Criminal Appeal No. 706-SB before the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh. The High Court by the impugned judgment dated 22-4-2008 Criminal Appeal No. 706-SB of 1999, dismissed the appeal filed by the appellant herein and confirmed the judgment and order of sentence dated 20-5-1999, passed by the Special Judge, Ferozepur.
6. We have heard Sri Mahabir Singh, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant assisted by Mr D. Mahesh Babu, Advocate-on-Record and Ms Ranjeeta Rohatgi, learned counsel appearing for the respondent State.
7. In this appeal, it is mainly contended by the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant that Shri Joginder Singh, ASI to whom Yogi Raj, SHO (PW 3) handed over the case property on 13-9-1996, was not examined, thus link evidence was incomplete; in spite of the same, the trial court and the High Court have committed error in convicting the appellant. Further, it is submitted that though the independent witnesses were there in the patrolling party, such witnesses were not examined and conviction was solely based on the official witnesses. Further, it is submitted that S.K. Asthana, ASP, who is claimed to have joined to the party by the police, was not even examined and in fact he was not there and opium was not recovered in his presence. It is also pleaded, thus, that there is a violation of provision under Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985.
8. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant, to buttress his submissions, placed reliance on the following judgments:
(i) Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of Maharashtra (2006) 10 SCC 681.
(ii) Noor Aga v. State of Punjab (2008) 16 SCC 417.
(iii) Mohan Lal v. State of Punjab (2018) 17 SCC 627.
9. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent State has submitted that the prosecution has proved the case by leading cogent evidence, which proved guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt and there are no grounds to interfere with the same. The learned counsel has submitted that merely because prosecution has not examined any independent witness, same would not necessarily lead to the conclusion that the appellant has been falsely implicated. He placed reliance on the judgment in Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab (2011) 3 SCC 521. Further recent judgment of this Court in Varinder Kumar v. State of H.P. (2020) 3 SCC 321, is also relied on wherein this Court has held that all pending criminal prosecutions, trials and appeals prior to the law laid down in Mohan Lal (2018) 17 SCC 627, shall continue to be governed by the individual facts of the case.
10. According to the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, Joginder Singh, ASI to whom Yogi Raj, SHO (PW 3) handed over the case property for producing the same before the Illaqa Magistrate and who returned the same to him after such production was not examined, as such, link evidence was incomplete. In this regard, it is to be noticed that Yogi Raj, SHO handed over the case property to Joginder Singh, ASI, for production before the court. After producing the case property before the court, he returned the case property to Yogi Raj, SHO (PW 3) with the seals intact. It is also to be noticed that Joginder Singh, ASI was not in possession of seals of either of the investigating officer or of Yogi Raj, SHO. He produced the case property before the court on 13-9-1996 vide application, Ext. P-13, the Judicial Magistrate concerned of First Class, after verifying the seals on the case property, passed the order, Ext. P-14 to the effect that since there was no judicial malkhana at Abohar, the case property was ordered to be kept in safe custody, in Police Station Khuian Sarwar till further orders. Since Joginder Singh, ASI was not in possession of the seals of either of SHO or of the investigating officer, the question of tampering with the case property by him did not arise at all.
11. Further, he has returned the case property, after production of the same, before the Illaqa Magistrate, with the seals intact, to Yogi Raj, SHO. In that view of the matter, the trial court and the High Court have rightly held that non-examination of Joginder Singh, did not, in any way, affect the case of prosecution. Further, it is evident from the report of the Chemical Examiner, Ext. P-10, that the sample was received with seals intact and that the seals on the sample, tallied with the sample seals. In that view of the matter, the chain of evidence was complete.
12. The next contention of the learned Senior Counsel Shri Mahabir Singh is that ASP, who was summoned to the spot, in whose presence search and recovery was effected, was not examined. As such, it is submitted that the non-examination of ASP is fatal to the case of prosecution and it is in violation of Section 50 of the NDPS Act, 1985.
13. It is the specific case of the prosecution that on 12-9-1996, Darbara Singh, SI (PW 2) along with other police officials were going from Dalbir Khera-2 towards Waryam Khera in a private jeep, when they reached near the bridge of Canal Minor, the appellant-accused was seen coming from opposite direction carrying a bag. It is alleged that on seeing the police party, he turned towards the southern banks of the canal but was apprehended on suspicion. It is specifically pleaded that the ASP, Abohar who was called at the spot and in his presence his bag was searched which resulted into recovery of 1 kg 750 g of opium. The trial court as well as the High Court, has recorded a finding that the perusal of the record reveals ASP was summoned number of times but either service was not effected or as and when he was served, he sent a request for exemption from personal attendance stating valid reasons. Further, it appears that the High Court has issued directions to the trial court to decide the case before 30-4-1999. As much as S.K. Asthana, ASP was not examined by 30-4-1999, a request for an extension was sought by the Special Judge, Ferozepur and it was adjourned to 17-5-1999. Even by 17-5-1999, ASP could not be served as he was on leave. In view of such reasoning assigned by the trial court, as well as the High Court, merely because S.K. Asthana, ASP was not examined, it cannot be said that prosecution has failed to prove its case. It is clear from the evidence on record that he was summoned at the time of search and seizure and only in his presence search was conducted, as such, there is no violation of Section 50 of the NDPS Act.
14. Further, it is contended by the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant that no independent witness was examined, despite the fact they were available. In this regard, it is to be noticed from the depositions of Devi Lal, Head Constable (PW 1), during the course of cross-examination, has stated that efforts were made to join independent witnesses, but none were available. The mere fact that the case of the prosecution is based on the evidence of official witnesses, does not mean that same should not be believed.
15. The judgment in Jarnail Singh v. State of Punjab (2011) 3 SCC 521, relied on by the counsel for the respondent State also supports the case of the prosecution. In the aforesaid judgment, this Court has held that merely because prosecution did not examine any independent witness, would not necessarily lead to conclusion that the accused was falsely implicated. The evidence of official witnesses cannot be distrusted and disbelieved, merely on account of their official status.
16. In State (NCT of Delhi) v. Sunil (2001) 1 SCC 652 it was held as under:
“It is an archaic notion that actions of the police officer should be approached with initial distrust. It is time now to start placing at least initial trust on the actions and the documents made by the police. At any rate, the court cannot start with the presumption that the police records are untrustworthy. As a proposition of law, the presumption should be the other way round. That official acts of the police have been regularly performed is a wise principle of presumption and recognised even by the legislature.”
17. The learned counsel also placed reliance on the judgment of this Court in Mohan Lal (2018) 17 SCC 627 to support his argument that the informant and the investigator cannot be the same person. But in the subsequent judgment, in Varinder Kumar (2020) 3 SCC 321 this Court held that all the pending criminal prosecutions, trials and appeals prior to law laid down in Mohan Lal (2018) 17 SCC 627, shall continue to be governed by individual facts of the case.
18. Having regard to the oral and documentary evidence placed on record, we are in agreement with the findings recorded by the trial court and the High Court. From the evidence on record in this case the prosecution has proved the guilt of the appellant beyond reasonable doubt. The conviction recorded and the sentence imposed is in conformity with the provisions of law and evidence on record, thus no interference is called for. Accordingly, this appeal is devoid of merits, and the same is dismissed.
19. As the appellant-accused is on bail, the bail bonds are cancelled. He shall surrender within a period of four weeks from today, to serve remaining period of sentence, failing which, the Chief Judicial Magistrate, shall take necessary steps to take the appellant into custody to serve remaining period of sentence.
Alert