- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
ADV. AIRES RODRIGUES. v. STATE OF GOA, BY ITS CHIEF SECRETARY.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner (in person) filed a petition dated 13/2/2017 seeking a writ of mandamus or equivalent direction under Articles 174 and 226 of the Constitution to compel the Respondent to follow the Constitutional mandate by either summoning the Legislative Assembly or, failing that, dismissing the Government. General Assembly elections in the State were held on 4/2/2017, with counting scheduled for 11/3/2017. The constitutional requirement that not more than six months intervene between sittings meant a session needed to be held on or before 3/3/2017. The Governor issued a notification (published in the Extraordinary Official Government Gazette Series No.47 dated 26/2/2017) summoning the Legislative Assembly to meet on 28/2/2017. No interim order had been issued in the writ petition; the Assembly met and conducted a one‑day session on 28/2/2017. The High Court noted that events occurring within that one‑day session were not within the scope of the Court in this petition and disposed of the petition as infructuous.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a writ of mandamus or in the nature of mandamus should issue directing the Respondent to ensure compliance with the Constitutional mandate by summoning the House or, alternatively, dismissing the Government.
- Whether the Governor's power to summon the Legislative Assembly under Article 174 (read with Article 356) required a session to be held on or before 3/3/2017 in the factual context of elections held on 4/2/2017 and counting on 11/3/2017.
Arguments of the Parties
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Nabam Rebia | Elaboration of the scheme and purpose of Articles governing summoning of the Legislature. | Used as part of authority showing the scheme and purpose of Article 174 and related provisions. |
| Bamang Felix Versus Deputy Speaker and others (2006) (8) SCC 1 | Elaboration of the scheme and purpose of Articles governing summoning of the Legislature; defining the power of the Governor to summon the Assembly. | Relied on to demonstrate that the power of the Governor to summon the Assembly is well defined. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court noted the petition's foundation on Articles 174 and 226 and the six‑month requirement for summoning the Assembly. Given the election timeline (polling on 4/2/2017; counting on 11/3/2017), a session was required on or before 3/3/2017. The Governor issued a summons (Order dated 25/2/2017; published 26/2/2017) calling the Assembly to meet on 28/2/2017. There was no interim order in the writ petition restraining the summons nor any order dissolving the Assembly or dismissing the Government. The parties' counsel stated that the Assembly met and held a one‑day session on 28/2/2017. The court held that what transpired during that one‑day session was not within the scope of the High Court in this petition and that summoning such an Assembly posed no constitutional bar; it was within the frame of law. In view of these facts and legal position, the petition had become infructuous.
Holding and Implications
Petition disposed of as infructuous. No costs were awarded.
Direct effect: the writ petition was dismissed as having become infructuous because the Governor had duly summoned the Assembly and the Assembly met on 28/2/2017. The opinion does not indicate the setting of any new precedent beyond applying existing authorities cited above.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties finally. The petitioner, (a party in person) in the petition dated 13/2/2017, prays as under:
Heard the learned counsel for the parties finally. The petitioner, (a party in person) in the petition dated 13/2/2017, prays as under: a) That a writ of mandamus or in the nature of mandamus or any ther appropriate writ, Order or direction be issued directing the Respondent to ensure that the Constitutional mandate is followed of either summoning the House or in failure thereof for dismissal of the Government. Wp no.180 2017
2. This is on the foundation of Articles 174 and 226 of the Constitution of India. Article 174(1) is reproduced as under: "Article 174 (1): The Governor shall from time to time summon the House or each House of the Legislature of the State to meet at such time and place as he thinks fit, but six months shall not intervene between its last sitting in one session and the date appointed for its first sitting in the next session."
3. The scheme and purpose of the above provisions are clear and elaborated in various judgments of the Supreme Court and recently in Nabam Rebia, and Bamang Felix Versus Deputy Speaker and others (2006) (8) SCC 1. The power of the Governor to summon the assembly is well defined.
4. The mandate of Article 174 r/w Article 356 of the Constitution of India has been taken note of. It was necessary as stated, to have a session on or before 3/3/2017. In the present case, the General Assembly elections conducted in the State on 4/2/2017. The counting is scheduled on 11/3/2017. The mandate of holding the session within six months was on or before 3/3/2017. In the background, therefore, the Hon'ble Governor has issued and Wp no.180 2017 published the Extraordinary Official Government Gazette Series No.47 dated 26/2/2017 summoned the Legislative Assembly which is marked 'X" for identification and which reads as under: "Notification No.LA/Legn/2017/2459 The following order of the Governor of Goa dated 25th February, 2017 is hereby published for general information: "Order In exercise of the powers conferred by Clause (1) of Article 174 of the Constitution of India, I, Mridula Sinha, Governor of Goa, hereby summon the Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa, to meet at Assembly Hall, on Tuesday, 28th February, 2017 at 11.30a.m. Raj Bhavan, Sd/- Goa-403 004, (MRIDULA SINHA) 25th February, 2017. Governor of Goa." Assembly Hall, Sd/- Porvorim, Goa. (N. B. SUBHEDAR) 26th February, 2017. Secretary
5. Admittedly, there was no interim order or direction issued in the matter till this date in the writ petition including dissolution of the Assembly or the dismissal of the Government. The new Government is going to take charge in short time. A statement is made by the learned counsel appearing for the parties that based upon the above notification, the Legislative Assembly of the State of Goa met and conducted the one day session on 28th of February 2017. On that day, what transpired and/or what happened in one day assembly session is not the scope and power of Wp no.180 2017 High Court to deal with or on any such issues. Apart from this, there are no such averments and the prayers in the petition made related to the summoning one day Legislative Assembly.
6. Therefore in the background and in view of the position of law and facts, there is no constitutional bar or prohibition to summon such assembly. It is well within the frame of law. We see there is no reason to keep this petition pending. The petition is accordingly disposed off as infructuous. No costs. NUTAN D. SARDESSAI, J. ANOOP V. MOHTA, J. ap/-
Alert