- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Alogoma Steel Limited And Others v. State Bank Of India And Others
Debangsu Basak, J.:— The petitioners assail a decision dated August 31, 2018 and October 10, 2018 passed by the respondents Bank under the provisions of the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated July 1, 2015.
2. Learned Advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioners submits that, the petitioners were not forwarded with a copy of the resolution taken by the Identification Committee at the first stage, therefore, the petitioner was denied an opportunity of hearing by the Identification Committee. He relies upon a judgment and order dated May 3, 2019 passed in W.P. No. 7471 (W) of 2019 (Atlantic Projects Limited v. The Allahabad Bank) and pronouncement of the Supreme Court in the case of State Bank of India v. Jah Developers Private Limited. in support of his contentions.
3. Learned Senior Advocate for the respondent Bank submits that, the petitioners were aware of each and every decision of the Identification Committee. The petitioners were issued a show-cause notice dated May 25, 2016 on behalf of the Identification Committee. The petitioners replied thereto and the reply was considered and the decision dated August 31, 2018 was taken by the Identification Committee. Therefore, according to him, there is no infirmity in the impugned decision. He refers to the prayers made in the writ petition and submits that, the validity of the decisions taken by the Identification Committee are not under challenge.
4. Atlantic Projects Limited (supra) is of the view that the decision of the Identification Committee taken under the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated July 1, 2015 must be communicated to the delinquent for the delinquent to reply thereto. It expresses a view that, the Identification Committee must communicate its first decision to the delinquent. It is imperative that the first decision of the Identification Committee is communicated to the delinquent since the delinquent must have notice of the materials placed before the Identification Committee by the Bank and the reasons why the Identification Committee took such decision, for the delinquent to have an effective opportunity to contest such claim of the Bank.
5. In the facts of the present case, a Deputy General Manager issued the impugned show-cause notice dated May 25, 2016. The impugned show-cause notice does not have the decision of the Identification Committee in its entirety. Materials placed before the Identification Committee by the Bank do not find place in the impugned show-cause notice. The impugned show-cause notice is the understanding of the another of the show-cause notice of the decision of the Identification Committee. Such understanding cannot substitute the decision of the Identification Committee in its original form nor the materials placed by the Bank before the Identification Committee on which basis the Identification Committee arrived at its decision. The petitioners were therefore deprived of the materials, which were before the Identification Committee and which the Identification Committee considered to recommend providing under the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated July 1, 2015 against the delinquent. The petitioners, therefore, were denied an opportunity to meet the claim of the Bank in the proceeding.
6. Consequently, the impugned action of the Bank taken under the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated July 1, 2015 cannot be sustained.
7. Jah Developers Private Limited (supra) is of the view that, the principles of natural justice apply to a proceeding undertaken by the Bank under the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters. In the facts of the present case, the petitioner not being given a copy of the initial decision of the Identification Committee and such decision not being communicated to the petitioners, in my view, the principles of natural justice stands breached.
8. In such circumstances, all steps taken by the Bank under the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated July 1, 2015 against the petitioners are quashed.
9. As noted above, it is the contention of the Bank that the action taken by the Bank under the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated July 1, 2015 was not under challenge in this writ petition. With respect, the prayers made in the writ petition are such that it assails the decisions dated August 30, 2018 and October 10, 2018 and requires all acts, deeds and things done in connection with the classification of the petitioners as wilful defaulters to be quashed.
10. In the view of the prayers as appearing in the writ petition, it cannot be said that the action taken by the respondent Bank under the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated July 1, 2015 are not under challenge in the present writ petition.
11. Under such circumstances, W.P. No. 11436 (W) of 2019 is allowed.
12. This order, however, will not prevent the Bank from proceeding in accordance with law under the Master Circular on Wilful Defaulters dated July 1, 2015 afresh.
13. There will be, however, no order as to costs.
14. Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given to the parties upon compliance of all formalities.
Alert