- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Umarpur Rice Mills (... v. New India Assurance ...
Factual and Procedural Background
The complainant, M/s. Umarpur Rice Mills (P) Ltd., a company engaged in processing paddy into rice, insured its mill, building, stock, and machinery with the New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (Opposite Party No.1) under policy no. 512502/11/09/11/00001708. On 2nd July 2010, a fire broke out at the mill premises, and the complainant submitted an insurance claim. The insurance company repudiated the claim alleging it was fraudulent, relying on surveyor reports stating no paddy stock was present during the fire, only husk. The State Bank of India (Opposite Party No.2), where the complainant's goods were hypothecated, and the Food Corporation of India (Opposite Party No.3) supported the complainant's contentions. The insurance company resisted the complaint, and the matter proceeded before the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the insurance claim filed by the complainant was fraudulent as alleged by the insurance company based on surveyor reports and related evidence.
- Whether the consumer forum has jurisdiction to adjudicate a complaint involving allegations of fraud requiring voluminous evidence.
- Whether the complaint can be decided under the summary procedure provided by the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, or should be referred to a civil court.
Arguments of the Parties
Complainant's Arguments
- The complainant operates a rice mill and regularly stocks paddy, which was insured.
- Fire occurred on 2.7.2010, and the insurance company was promptly informed.
- The surveyor's report denying the presence of paddy is false and contradicted by documentary evidence, including stock statements submitted to the State Bank of India and Food Corporation of India.
- The State Bank of India inspected the stock on 1.7.2010, confirming the presence of paddy.
- Appointment of two surveyors by the insurance company was improper without IRDA approval.
- No forensic analysis was conducted on samples taken from the site to support the surveyor's report.
- Fire brigade and police reports indicate loss of paddy and husk stock.
- The surveyor, Mr. J. Basheer and Associates, is alleged to be biased in favor of the insurance company, as supported by cited Supreme Court precedent.
Opposite Party (Insurance Company) Arguments
- The complainant's director was not assisted in preparing minutes in Bengali despite his alleged illiteracy, suggesting inconsistency.
- The surveyor inspected the godown and found no paddy stock, only husk was burnt.
- Appointment of the final surveyor did not require IRDA permission as it was not a second surveyor but a final one.
- The insurance policy covers only paddy/rice, and the claim was repudiated under Condition No.8 for fraud.
- The complainant claimed the full insured sum without specifying the actual loss suffered.
- The surveyors' reports dismiss stock statements submitted to the bank and Food Corporation as irrelevant since no paddy stock was found.
- No chemical testing was necessary as samples were collected only to determine the fire cause.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Protection Manufacturers Pvt. Ltd., AIR 2010 SC 3035 | Surveyor reports must be supported by evidence; unilateral appointment of surveyors without IRDA permission invalidates reports. | The court cited this case to question the credibility of the surveyor Mr. J. Basheer and Associates and the propriety of appointing multiple surveyors without IRDA approval. |
| Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Munimahesh Patel, IV (2006) CPJ 1 (SC) | Consumer forums conduct summary proceedings and should not adjudicate complex factual disputes involving fraud. | The court relied on this precedent to hold that allegations of fraud requiring voluminous evidence are not suitable for summary adjudication by consumer forums. |
| TRAI Foods Ltd. Vs. National Insurance Company & Ors., III (2012) CPJ 17 (SC) | Consumer forum jurisdiction should be exercised considering the nature and complexity of claims and evidence; complex claims requiring extensive inquiry should be decided by civil courts. | The court applied this principle to conclude that the present claim involving disputed facts and large damages requires adjudication by a civil court, not summary consumer proceedings. |
| Sri Venkateswara Syndicate vs. Oriental Insurance Company Limited & Anr, (2009) 8 SCC 507 | Surveyor reports are statutory and must be given due importance; insurers cannot repeatedly appoint surveyors to obtain tailor-made reports without valid reasons for rejecting prior reports. | The court emphasized the importance of surveyor reports and the need for cogent reasons to reject them, highlighting the contradictory evidence in the present case. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court recognized the core dispute regarding the presence of paddy stock at the time of the fire, with surveyor reports denying its presence and the complainant relying on stock statements and inspections by the State Bank of India and Food Corporation of India. The court noted that surveyors are appointed under statutory provisions and their reports carry significant weight. However, conflicting evidence, including contradictory reports from the police and the complainant's supporting parties, created genuine factual disputes.
The court observed that the insurance company's allegation of fraud and the complainant's denial entail complex factual questions requiring voluminous evidence. Given that consumer forums conduct summary proceedings, such complex disputes are unsuitable for resolution in this forum. The court relied on Supreme Court precedents emphasizing that consumer forums should not adjudicate matters involving allegations of fraud or complex factual controversies requiring detailed evidence and investigation.
Consequently, the court concluded that the present complaint cannot be decided summarily under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, and must be referred to a civil court with proper jurisdiction for comprehensive adjudication.
Holding and Implications
The complaint (Consumer Case No. 76 of 2011) is dismissed.
The court held that due to the complexity of the factual disputes, particularly allegations of fraud requiring extensive evidence, the consumer forum lacks jurisdiction to decide the matter summarily. The complainant is granted liberty to approach the civil court of appropriate jurisdiction for relief. This decision directly affects the parties by dismissing the complaint at the consumer forum level but does not establish any new legal precedent.
NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION
NEW DELHI
CONSUMER CASE NO. 76 OF 2011
1. M/S. UMARPUR RICE MILLS (P) LTD. Through Its Director Mr. Mached Seikh. Having Its Registered Office At: 81, N.S. Road, Room No. 232
Kolkata - 700 001. ...........Complainant(s) Versus
1. NEW INDIA ASSURANCE CO. LTD. & ORS. Burdwan Branch Office - 512502, West Bengal.
2. State Bank Of India, Branch Manager, Bhaduripara, P.O.-Kalna Burdwan - 713409
West Bengal
3. Food Corporation Of India, Area Manager, District Office, Kalpatarru complex, 31-G.T. Road
Burdwan - 713 101
West Bengal ...........Opp.Party(s)
BEFORE:
HON'BLE MR. PREM NARAIN,PRESIDING MEMBER
For the Complainant : Mr. Rajiv Kumar Tripathi, Advocate with Mr. Anshuman Tiwari, Mr. S.C.Tripathi,
And Mr. Sunil Kumar Tiwari, Advocates
For the Opp.Party : For the Opposite party No.1 : Mr. P.K.Seth, Advocate For the Opposite party Nos.2 & 3: Ex-parte vide order dated
24.02.2015
Dated : 17 Dec 2019
ORDER
This consumer complaint has been filed by the complainant M/s. Umarpur Rice Mills (P) Ltd. alleging deficiency on the part of the opposite parties.
2. Brief facts of the case are that the complainant is a company incorporated under the Companies Act having its registered office at 81 NS Road room no.32 Kolkata-700001 (West Bengal). Company is engaged in the business of removing husk from paddy for conversion of it into rice for FCI/opposite party No.3. Opposite Party No.1 is an Insurance Company having its registered Head Office at 87, Mahatma Gandhi Road, Mumbai 400001. Opposite party No.2 is State bank of India, where the goods of the complainant company were hypothecated. Complainant is running the rice mill for the last several years with the plant capacity of 2400 quintal of paddy a day. To insure the mill, building, godown, office room, stock, plants &
1
machinery, furniture and chimney stocks, complainant-company bought insurance policy from opposite party No.1 bearing policy no.512502/11/09/11/00001708 on 17.12.2009. Total value of the sum assured was Rs.11,88,40,500/-, whereas, complainant paid Rs.2,42,434/- towards the premium for the policy. On the fateful day 2.7.2010 at about 6 am, fire broke out in the mill premises. The incident was immediately informed to the opposite party No.1. Vide the repudiation letter dated 17.01.2011, opposite party No.1 refused to allow the claim submitted by the complainant-company. It stated that as the claim was lodged in a fraudulent manner by resorting to fraudulent means to obtain benefit under the policy, the general condition no.8 of the policy becomes operative. So the claim was not payable.
3. Hence the complaint.
4. The complaint has been resisted by the opposite party/Insurance Company by filing the written statement wherein it has been stated that the claim of the complainant is of fraudulent nature as the surveyor has observed in his report that no paddy was actually available in the factory and it was only the husk which was burnt in the fire. Condition No.8 of the terms and conditions of the policy clearly states that if a fraudulent claim is filed, the same will be repudiated by the Insurance Company and the claim has been repudiated under this condition No.8.
5. The other opposite party No.2, State Bank of India as well as opposite party No.3 Food Corporation of India also filed their written statements supporting the contentions of the complainant. The parties have also filed their evidence by way of affidavit, which have been taken on record.
6. Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. Learned counsel for the complainant stated that complainant is a rice mill, which purchases paddy and after processing the same the rice is supplied to Food Corporation of India. The complainant purchases the paddy and stores in its godown as the processing goes on for a long period. As soon as the fire broke out in the mill on 02.07.2010, the police, fire brigade and Insurance Company were informed. The surveyor visited the mill on 03.07.2010. The firefighting operation by fire brigade went on full day and the total stock in the factory was burnt. It was stated by the learned counsel that the surveyor has given totally a false report as the stocks were hypothecated to State Bank of India and regular stock statements were being submitted to the State Bank of India as well as to the Food Commissioner of the State. State Bank of India inspected the stock on 01.07.2010. Learned counsel stated that the Insurance Company had appointed two surveyors, whereas, there is no provision for appointing two surveyors in the Insurance Act, 1938. The second surveyor can only be appointed with the permission of the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority (IRDA). The surveyor has stated that when the surveyor visited the godown, he did not find any trace of rice. This assertion of the surveyor is totally baseless as all the documentary evidence is against this assertion. The State Bank of India in their written statement have admitted that the stocks were regularly submitted to the State Bank of India and there was rice/paddy bags in the godown of complainant at the time of fire. The fire report dated 02.08.2010 has also stated that husk of paddy and paddy was lost in the fire. Learned counsel further stated that J. Basheer the final surveyor has filed his affidavit, however, it is not clear whether this affidavit has been filed in his personal capacity or as representative of corporate surveyor.
2
7. Learned counsel for the complainant further stated that the samples were taken from the site, however, these samples were not sent to any forensic lab by the Insurance Company. Thus, there is no chemical analysis report available with the Insurance Company to prove and support the report of the surveyor. Learned counsel further stated that the quantity of paddy was verified by the Inspector Kalna FSD Burdwan on a regular basis and that was submitted to the State Bank of India. On 01.07.2010, the Inspector had verified the stock of the paddy and the same was submitted to the State Bank of India. The assertions of State Bank of India and Food Corporation of India made in their written statements cannot be ignored. It was further stated that even the fire brigade report mentions that the stock was of paddy. It is not correct to say that the factory was totally closed and was not operational. Even the surveyor's report says that some operations were going on. All these facts go on to prove that there was stock of paddy present in the mill at the time of fire accident.
8. It was also stated by the learned counsel for the complainant that Mr. J. Basheer and Associates is a favourite surveyor of the Insurance Company and has given report without any evidence. To support his contention learned counsel referred to the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Protection Manufacturers Pvt. Ltd., AIR 2010 SC 3035, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed the following:-
"33. Without any material to support the theory of arson projected by M/s. J. Basheer & Associates and sufficient material to hold otherwise, it would be entirely unjust and inequitable to accept such a theory without any evidence whatsoever in support thereof. Reference can be made in this context to the submission made by the counsel for the Insurance Company before the National Commission and quoted in para 17 above. Accordingly, we endorse the views expressed by the National Commission that the cause of fire was accidental 33and that the attempt made by M/s. J. Basheer & Associates to show that the fire had been caused by an act of arson, was motivated and intended to benefit the Appellant Insurance Company. The decisions cited by the parties were rendered in their own particular fact situations in accordance with law which is not disputed. The fact situations are, however, distinguishable.
35. The submissions of Mr. Piyush Gupta in regard to Section 64 UM of the Insurance Act, 1938, are also of substance, as the Appellant Insurance Company should have applied to the Regulatory Authority under the Act for a second opinion instead of appointing M/s. J. Basheer & Associates for the said purpose unilaterally. The reports submitted by M/s. J. Basheer & Associates are liable to be discarded on such ground as well."
9. It was argued that above judgment is a sample case to show the conduct of Mr. J. Basheer and Associates, surveyor who always intend to act like agent of the Insurance Company and therefore the report of Mr. J. Basheer and Associates has to be examined cautiously.
10. On the other hand, learned counsel for the Opposite party Insurance Company stated that in para 10 of the complaint it has been stated that Director Mr. Mached Seikh was not educated and hence request was made to make the minutes in Bengali language, however, no assistance was provided. The minutes were made in English. The learned counsel argued that the letter head (pad) is in English, therefore, it is not possible to believe that Mr. Mached Seikh was not knowing English. The surveyor has clearly observed in para 9.2 of his report that he
3
inspected godown, however, no sign of paddy was found in the godown. It is not correct to say that the second surveyor was appointed without the permission of IRDA under Section 64UM of the Insurance Act, 1938. In fact, Mr. S. Sengupta was the preliminary surveyor and final surveyor was Mr. J. Basheer and Associates. Thus, there was no need to obtain any permission from IRDA to appoint the final surveyor. Learned counsel further stated that in this report, finally, it has been concluded that there was no paddy kept in bags or in loose condition in the said affected godown.
11. From the perusal of the policy, it would be clear that the policy covers only the paddy/rice. Even the report of Office of the Officer-in-charge sent to the surveyor in reply to his letter addressed to the S.P. of the Burdwan District clearly mentions that the stock of 60,000 quintals husk of paddy is mainly involved in the fire. No estimate of paddy is mentioned in the report.
12. It was further pointed out by the learned counsel that the total insured amount has been claimed without clearly mentioning about the details of the loss. Sum assured is the outer limit and the complainant has to clearly state as to what loss has happened and what is its value. Learned counsel further argued that the preliminary surveyor as well as the final surveyor both have found that there was no stock of paddy and it was only the husk. It was further stated that as there was no loss of paddy, so, the surveyor has not considered the statement of stocks sent to the bank and the FCI. As there was no loss of paddy so, the cause of fire is irrelevant and therefore, there was no need to send the samples for testing as the same were collected only for knowing the cause of fire.
13. I have carefully considered the arguments advanced by the learned counsel for the parties and examined the record. The main controversy in the present case is that preliminary surveyor as well as final surveyor both have given the report that there was no stock of paddy when the fire broke out in the godown, whereas the complainant is relying on the stock statement submitted to the State Bank of India and to State Food Controller. So far as the insurance claim is concerned, surveyor is required to be appointed where the claim is more than Rs.20,000/- . This is a mandatory requirement. Once the surveyor is appointed, his report cannot be brushed aside without any cogent reasons, rather, it has to be given importance and has to be considered while deciding the insurance claim. Hon'ble Supreme Court in ["Sri Venkateswara Syndicate vs. Oriental Insurance Company Limited & Anr", (2009) 8 SCC 507], has observed that:
"31. The assessment of loss, claim settlement and relevance of survey report depends on various factors. Whenever a loss is reported by insured, a loss adjuster, popularly known as loss surveyor, is deputed who assesses the loss and issues report known as surveyor report which forms the basis for consideration or otherwise of the claim. Surveyors are appointed under the statutory provisions and they are the link between the insurer and the insured when the question of settlement of loss or damage arises. The report of the surveyor could become the basis for settlement of a claim by the insurer in respect of the loss suffered by the insured.
32. There is no disputing the fact that the surveyor/surveyors are appointed by the insurance company under the provisions of the Insurance Act and their reports are to be given due importance and one should have sufficient grounds not to agree with
4
the assessment made by them. We also add, that, under this Section the insurance company cannot go on appointing surveyors one after another so as to get a tailor- made report to the satisfaction of the officer concerned of the insurance company; if for any reason, the report of the surveyors is not acceptable, the insurer has to give valid reason for not accepting the report."
14. The report of the Police Inspector submitted to the S.P. of the District also states that there was 60,000 quintal of husk which was burnt. There is no mention of paddy in this investigation report dated 02.08.2010. Clearly, Police is an independent agency and the investigation of the Police can also not be brushed aside without any reason. Thus, the reports of the surveyors and the report of the police clearly state that there was no paddy in the godown when the fire broke out and it was only the husk. On the other hand, State Bank of India, which has given credit facility to the complainant has filed written statement stating that they were regularly inspecting the stocks and the last statement of stock was submitted on 01.07.2010 and the same was checked by the officials of the State Bank of India. Clearly State Bank of India is an interested party because they have to support the claim of the complainant so that in case the claim is approved they will get the major share as repayment of loan. This observation is not meant to undermine the veracity of the written statement filed by the State Bank of India. The extract of the register signed by the Food Inspector inspecting the stocks has also been filed in support of the complainant's case. The surveyor has also observed that the mill was closed for about three months. This observation also supports the fact that there may not be any paddy in the godown because all the paddy would have been processed by that time and the rice given to the FCI. Clearly, there are contradicting reports and further evidence is required in the matter to reach to any conclusion about the stocks of the paddy/rice at the time of fire in the mill. Without any details and proper evidence about the value of stocks of paddy as loss suffered at the time of the claim cannot be considered. Thus, this complaint cannot be decided in the summary procedure as it would require voluminous evidence by both the sides in order to reach to any conclusion about the stock of paddy/rice in the godown at the time of fire. Moreover, the Insurance Company has alleged fraud on the part of the complainant in order to get undue benefit under the policy. A consumer forum cannot deal with a complaint where issue of fraudulent claim is involved. In observing this, I am supported by the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Munimahesh Patel, IV (2006) CPJ 1 (SC) wherein Hon'ble Supreme Court has observed as follows:-
"10. Proceedings before the Commission are essentially summary in nature and adjudication of issues which involve disputed factual questions should not be adjudicated. It is to be noted that Commission accepted that insured was not a teacher. Complainant raised dispute about genuineness of the documents (i.e. proposal forms) produced by the appellant.
12. The nature of the proceedings before the Commission as noted above, are essentially in summary nature. The factual position was required to be established by documents. Commission was required to examine whether in view of the disputed facts it would exercise the jurisdiction. The State Commission was right in its view that the complex factual position requires that the matter should be examined by an appropriate Court of Law and not by the Commission."
5
15. Similarly, Hon'ble Supreme Court in TRAI Foods Ltd. Vs. National Insurance Company & Ors., III (2012) CPJ 17 (SC), has observed:
"6. The only question to be decided is, when should this jurisdiction be exercised by the Commission. In our view the Commission should address itself to the quantity of the claim, the nature of the claim, the nature of the evidence which would be required to be submitted both in respect of the claim and the damages suffered and the nature of the legal issues before deciding that the matter ought to be decided by the Civil Courts in the regular course. It is not disputed that the Consumer Forum has been set up to grant speedy remedy. The Consumer Forums have been given the responsibility of achieving this object. They were not meant to duplicate the Civil Court, and subject the litigants to delays which have become endemic in the Civil Courts.
7. Although the reason given in the impugned order of the Commission for referring the present matter to the Civil Court is cryptic, we have been through the records filed before us and are satisfied that the Commission's decision was correct. There is no doubt having regard to the nature of the claim, the large amount of damages claimed, and the extensive inquiry into the evidence which would be necessary in order to resolve the disputes between the parties that this is not a matter to be decided summarily at all."
16. From the above judgments, it is brought out that complaint case where forgery and fraud has been alleged by one party against the other party and the same is denied by the other party cannot be decided in a summary procedure under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 because it requires lot of voluminous evidence to be produced by both the parties in support of their assertions, which is not possible in the summary proceedings. Proper forum for adjudication of such complaints is only the Civil Court having proper jurisdiction.
17. Based on the above discussion, this complaint cannot be decided under the summary procedure laid down in the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 as it would require voluminous evidence to be produced by both the parties in support of their assertions. The proper forum for the present complaint would be the civil court of appropriate jurisdiction. Accordingly, the CC No.76 of 2011 is dismissed. However, the liberty is granted to the complainant to approach the Civil Court of proper jurisdiction for seeking relief in the matter, if so advised.
......................
PREM NARAIN
PRESIDING MEMBER
6
Alert