Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Union Of India And Others v. Dilip Kumar Sanfui

Calcutta High Court
Sep 6, 2019

1. The Central Administrative Tribunal, Kolkata Bench (hereafter the tribunal) has allowed O.A. 479 of 2016 filed by the respondent by its judgment and order dated 2 April, 2019. The same is under challenge at the instance of the respondents in such original application.

2. The original applicant has been found by the tribunal to be entitled to MACP benefits and, accordingly, the respondents in the original application have been directed as follows:

“We further direct that Respondents shall reckon his appointment to PA as direct recruitment for granting MACP and revise the MACPs already granted, in accordance with the decisions cited supra and issue appropriate order within 3 months with all consequential financial benefits and arrears.”

3. There are divergent opinion expressed by various High Courts on the point as to whether movement through LGO Examination is to be treated as a fresh appointment or a promotion.

4. Since the issue requires further consideration, we admit the writ petition. Let affidavit-in-opposition be filed within two weeks after reopening of Court after Puja vacation; reply thereto, if any, may be filed within two weeks thereafter.

5. The writ petition shall be treated as ready for hearing after completion of the period fixed above for exchange of affidavits and thereafter the parties shall be at liberty to mention the writ petition for its consideration.

6. In so far as interim relief is concerned, we direct the petitioners before us to compute the quantum of financial benefits that the respondent would be entitled in terms of the order under challenge and to invest the same in an auto renewable fixed deposit account of a nationalised bank so that if the writ petition finally fails, the respondent may be entitled to the principal amount kept in fixed deposit together with accrued interest. Let this exercise of investing the amount in a fixed deposit be completed as early as possible, but not later than a month from date. A copy of the fixed deposit receipt shall be made over to the respondent.