Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Jharkhand Public Service Commission v. Manoj Kumar Gupta And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Dec 18, 2019
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Jharkhand Public Service Commission (JPSC) issued an advertisement dated 19-7-2006 for the Jharkhand Eligibility Test (JET), a State Level Eligibility Test (SLET) conducted under University Grants Commission (UGC) guidelines to determine candidates’ eligibility for appointment as lecturers in Jharkhand’s universities and colleges. The examination comprises three papers. Papers I and II are objective-type multiple-choice tests, while Paper III is descriptive.

The advertisement specified minimum qualifying marks for Papers I and II (50% aggregate for General/OBC, 45% for PH/VH, and 40% for SC/ST) and stated that Paper III would be evaluated only for candidates meeting those thresholds. It did not specify any qualifying marks for Paper III at the advertisement stage.

The writ petitioner secured the requisite 50% in Papers I and II but failed to meet a 60% cut-off applied by JPSC in Paper III after the examination. Declared unsuccessful, the petitioner filed a writ petition before the Jharkhand High Court. The High Court (2016 SCC OnLine Jhar 2891) allowed the petition, holding that JPSC could not prescribe 60% for Paper III after the selection process had begun and that this amounted to changing “the rules of the game.”

JPSC appealed to the Supreme Court, and the writ petitioner filed a cross-appeal. The Supreme Court decided both appeals together.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether JPSC was legally entitled to fix minimum qualifying marks for Paper III of the JET after the advertisement had been issued and the examination conducted.
  2. Whether prescribing such marks amounted to altering the “rules of the game” mid-process, thereby violating principles of fairness in public recruitment.

Arguments of the Parties

JPSC’s Arguments

  • UGC’s SLET scheme establishes a Moderation Committee expressly empowered to fix cut-off marks in each subject after evaluating overall performance.
  • Because the advertisement already restricted evaluation of Paper III to candidates securing 50% in Papers I and II, there was no requirement to announce Paper III cut-offs in advance.
  • Fixing the 60% threshold through the Moderation Committee did not alter existing rules but merely applied the scheme’s built-in moderation mechanism.

Writ Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The advertisement was silent on any qualifying marks for Paper III; imposing 60% post-facto unfairly disqualified candidates.
  • JET is an eligibility test, not a selection examination; hence, enlarging the pool of eligible candidates (by not fixing a high cut-off) better serves the purpose.
  • Introducing the 60% standard after the exam constitutes an impermissible change in the selection criteria mid-stream.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined Clause 4.1 of the UGC SLET scheme, noting that the Moderation Committee’s sole purpose is “deciding the cut-off marks in each subject for declaring the result.” The advertisement’s silence on Paper III cut-offs therefore did not preclude the Committee from setting such standards later.

The Court distinguished between altering established criteria and exercising delegated discretion. Because the advertisement never fixed Paper III marks, subsequent moderation did not change existing rules but supplemented them as contemplated by the scheme.

The Court observed that moderation allows flexibility: in subjects where Paper III performance is generally low, standards may be lowered, while in others they may justifiably be raised. Consequently, fixing 60% for the petitioner’s subject was within the Committee’s remit.

Rejecting the High Court’s view, the Supreme Court concluded that prescribing Paper III cut-offs after evaluating overall results is intrinsic to the moderation process and does not violate fairness principles.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Supreme Court set aside the Jharkhand High Court judgment (2016 SCC OnLine Jhar 2891). Civil Appeal No. 9441 of 2019 filed by JPSC was allowed, and Civil Appeal No. 9442 of 2019 filed by the writ petitioner was dismissed.

Implications: The decision confirms that, under the UGC SLET scheme, a Public Service Commission may lawfully fix or adjust qualifying marks for descriptive papers after the examination through a Moderation Committee, without violating the rule against altering selection criteria mid-process. The ruling directly reinstates JPSC’s 60% cut-off for Paper III, rendering the petitioner ineligible, and clarifies procedural discretion for future eligibility tests without establishing a new broad precedent.

Show all summary ...

Deepak Gupta, J.— The Jharkhand Public Service Commission (“JPSC”) issued an advertisement on 19-7-2006 inviting applications from candidates desirous of competing in the Jharkhand Eligibility Test (“JET”). This test is not meant for selection to any post but is conducted to determine the eligibility of the candidates for appointment as lecturers in universities and colleges of the State of Jharkhand. This test called the State Level Eligibility Test (“SLET”) is conducted as per the guidelines laid down by the University Grants Commission (“UGC”).

2. The test consists of three papers — the first two papers are multiple choice questions to be answered on an Optical Mark Reader (“OMR”). One test is of a general subject and one test is of the subject for which the candidate applies. The third paper is a descriptive type question paper dealing only with the subject selected by the candidate. Relevant portion of the advertisement reads as follows:

“A candidate who does not appear in Paper I will not be permitted to appear in Paper II and Paper III. Paper III will be evaluated only for those candidates who are able to secure the minimum qualifying marks in Paper I and Paper II as per the table given in the following:
Category Minimum qualifying marks Paper I Paper II Paper I + Paper II General/OBC 40 40 100 (50%) PH/VH 35 35 90 (45%) SC/ST 35 35 80 (40%)

3. The writ petitioner obtained 50% marks in Papers I and II but he did not do as well in Paper III. JPSC fixed a cut-off percentage of 60 for Paper III which the writ petitioner did not attain and as such he was declared not successful and, therefore, ineligible to be considered for appointment as lecturer.

4. Aggrieved by the said action, the writ petitioner filed a writ petition before the High Court which allowed 2016 SCC OnLine Jhar 2891 the same. The appeal filed by JPSC before the writ court was also allowed mainly on the ground that the Public Service Commission could not have fixed qualifying marks of 60% and this amounted to changing the rules of the game after the advertisement had been issued and process of selection had started. It held that once the candidate had obtained 50% marks, the candidate could not be disqualified and JPSC was not bound by the instructions of UGC in this regard. The High Court also directed that the case of the writ petitioner would be considered on the basis of performance. The High Court held that no cut-off marks had been provided for Paper III.

5. We have heard Shri Sunil Kumar, learned Senior Counsel appearing for JPSC who drew our attention to the scheme framed by UGC for SLET. The scheme has a provision for constitution of a Moderation Committee which will help in deciding the cut-off marks in each subject for declaring the result. The relevant portion of the scheme reads as follows:

“Moderation Committee : The Committee will help in deciding the cut-off marks in each subject for declaring the result. The Committee will consist of the following:
1. Chairman of Steering/Advisory Committee.
2. State Government Representatives.
3. Two Professors of the different State Universities in rotation.
4. One Professor from outside the State.
5. Member-Secretary (State agency).
6. One nominee of the U-CAT out of two nominated by UGC.
7. Member-Secretary, (UGC Official) U-CAT, UGC.”

Mr Sunil Kumar contends that the Moderation Committee, keeping in view the various factors, decides what should be the cut-off marks in each subject and this does not have to be decided at the stage of issuance of advertisement. On the other hand, Shri Abhishek Vikas, learned counsel appearing for the original writ petitioner, submits that the advertisement does not envisage any minimum cut-off marks for Paper III. He further submits that this is only an eligibility test and the field of choice becomes larger if more people are held eligible. Both sides have challenged the judgment 2016 SCC OnLine Jhar 2891 of the High Court and we are deciding both the appeals by this common judgment.

6. A perusal of Clause 4.1 of the scheme clearly indicates that the Moderation Committee has been constituted only for the purpose of deciding the cut-off marks in each subject for declaring the result. The advertisement clearly indicates that only those candidates who obtained 50% marks in Paper I and II would be eligible to take the test in Paper III. The minimum qualifying marks in case of General/OBC candidates was 50%. At this stage, there was no need to fix the qualifying marks for Paper III. That need will arise only when the Moderation Committee meets and decides what should be the level of competence expected from the people who are to be considered for appointment as Lecturers. It is for the Moderation Committee to decide what should be the cut-off marks. There could be the subject where all the people who qualified Paper I and II get very low marks in Paper III and the Moderation Committee may be justified in lowering the standards and prescribing lower qualifying standards. On the other hand, there may be a subject where there are many candidates who do extremely well in Paper III and the Moderation Committee may decide to fix a higher minimum standard. The constitution of a Moderation Committee is normally done only to do this sort of moderation.

7. As far as the finding of the High Court that the rules of the game were changed after the selection process had started, we are of the considered view that this is not the case as far as the present case is concerned. There were no minimum marks provided for Paper III in the advertisement. This could be done by the Moderation Committee even at a later stage. This is not a change brought about but an additional aspect brought in while determining the merit of the candidates who are found fit to be eligible for consideration for appointment as Lecturers.

8. In view of the above, we are of the considered opinion that the High Court erred in holding that JPSC could not fix the minimum marks for Paper III. Hence, we set aside the judgment 2016 SCC OnLine Jhar 2891 of the High Court dated 9-11-2016. Civil Appeal No. 9441 of 2019 arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 14926 of 2017 filed by the Jharkhand Public Service Commission is allowed and CA No. 9442 of 2019 arising out of Special Leave Petition (Civil) No. 31106 of 2017 filed by the other side (writ petitioner) is dismissed.