Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

PRITAM SINGH v. ASHOK KUMAR

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Jan 16, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The defendant preferred a regular second appeal against concurrent judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below in a suit for recovery. The plaintiff/respondent filed a suit for recovery of Rs.8,07,000/- based on an agreement to sell dated 19.01.2011. The trial Court decreed the suit on 10.02.2016, awarding Rs.6,00,000/- with interest at 9% per annum from the date of the agreement until the date of the decree, and future interest at 6% per annum thereafter. The Lower Appellate Court upheld this judgment and decree on 18.01.2018. During the pendency of the appeal, the parties amicably resolved the dispute, and the decree holder stated before the executing court that the execution petition be dismissed as withdrawn being fully satisfied, and the judgment debtor’s property be released from attachment. Consequently, the execution petition was dismissed on 25.04.2018, and the property was released.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendant/appellant is entitled to a refund of the Court fee under Section 16 of the Court Fee Act following a compromise between the parties during the pendency of the appeal.
  2. Whether the provisions of Section 89 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) apply to appeals and counter claims, and whether the refund of Court fee depends on the compromise being effected before a Lok Adalat.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that Section 89 CPC applies not only to suits but also to counter claims, appeals, counter objections, and counter appeals.
  • The appellant argued that the benefit of Section 16 of the Court Fee Act is available in appeals where a settlement is reached, regardless of whether the compromise was effected before a Lok Adalat.
  • The appellant relied on the precedent of Pradeep Sonawat Vs. Satish Prakash @ Satish Chandra, 2015(1) RCR (Civil) 955 (P&H), to support the applicability of Section 89 CPC in appeals and the entitlement to refund of Court fee.
  • Additional reliance was placed on A. Sreeramaiah Vs. South Indian Bank Ltd., 2007(5) RCR (Civil) 374, and Kamalamma Vs. Honnali Taluk Agricultural Produce Co-operative Marketing Society as cited in Tarun Juneja Vs. Hukam Singh.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pradeep Sonawat Vs. Satish Prakash @ Satish Chandra, 2015(1) RCR (Civil) 955 (P&H) Applicability of Section 89 CPC to appeals, counter claims, and the entitlement to refund of Court fee under Section 16 of the Court Fee Act irrespective of compromise before Lok Adalat. The court accepted that Section 89 CPC applies in appeals and that refund of Court fee is available even if compromise is not before Lok Adalat.
A. Sreeramaiah Vs. South Indian Bank Ltd., 2007(5) RCR (Civil) 374 Supporting precedent regarding compromise and refund of Court fee. Relied upon to reinforce the appellant’s entitlement to refund of Court fee.
Kamalamma Vs. Honnali Taluk Agricultural Produce Co-operative Marketing Society as cited in Tarun Juneja Vs. Hukam Singh (15.09.2009) Supporting precedent related to compromise and refund of Court fee. Used to support the appellant’s claim for refund of Court fee.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court considered the amicable resolution of the dispute during the pendency of the appeal and the statement by the decree holder that the execution petition be dismissed as withdrawn. The court analyzed the applicability of Section 89 CPC, which facilitates settlement of disputes, and Section 16 of the Court Fee Act, which provides for refund of Court fees on withdrawal or compromise. Relying on the cited precedents, the court held that Section 89 CPC applies to appeals and counter claims, and that the refund of Court fee is not contingent upon the compromise being effected before the Lok Adalat. The court found it appropriate to accept the withdrawal of the appeal based on the compromise and to grant the refund of the Court fee to the appellant.

Holding and Implications

The appeal was withdrawn on the basis of compromise, and the appellant was held entitled to a refund of the Court fee under Section 16 of the Court Fee Act.

The direct effect of this decision is that the appellant receives a refund of the Court fee paid during the appeal. No new precedent was set beyond affirming the applicability of Section 89 CPC and Section 16 of the Court Fee Act in the context of appeals and compromises not effected before Lok Adalats.

Show all summary ...

[1]. Defendant has preferred the present regular second appeal against the concurrent judgments and decrees passed by the Courts below in a suit for recovery.

[2]. Plaintiff/respondent filed a suit for recovery of Rs.8,07,000/- along with interest on the basis of agreement to sell dated 19.01.2011. The suit was decreed by the trial Court vide judgment and decree dated 10.02.2016 and the plaintiff was held entitled to recover an amount of Rs.6,00,000/- along with interest @ 9% per annum from the date of agreement dated 19.01.2011 till the date of decree and future interest @ 6% per annum from the date of decree till actual realisation of the amount. The said judgment and decree passed by the trial Court was upheld by the Lower Appellate Court vide judgment and decree dated 18.01.2018.

[3]. During pendency of the present appeal, both the parties have entered into amicable resolution of dispute. Decree holder has suffered a statement before the Additional Civil Judge, (Senior Division), Phillaur in execution proceedings that the execution petition be dismissed as withdrawn being fully satisfied and the property of the judgment debtor may be released from attachment.

[4]. In view of statement made by learned counsel for the decree holder, the execution petition was dismissed as withdrawn being fully satisfied and the property of the judgment debtor was ordered to be released from attachment by the executing Court on 25.04.2018.

[5]. Defendant/appellant sought refund of Court fee under Section 16 of the Court Fee Act in the light of compromise entered into between the parties during pendency of the present appeal.

[6]. Vide order dated 19.07.2018, defendant/appellant was obligated to satisfy this Court whether the appellant is entitled to refund of the Court fee even in the absence of compromise effected before the Lok Adalat in terms of Section 89 CPC.

[7]. By referring to Pradeep Sonawat Vs. Satish Prakash @ Satish Chandra, 2015(1) RCR (Civil) 955 (P&H), learned counsel for the appellant contended that Section 89 CPC would apply even in cases of counter claims in suits and also in appeals, counter objections and counter appeals and benefit of Section 16 of the Court Fee Act is available to the appellant in appeal in case of settlement irrespective of fact whether it was before the Lok Adalat or otherwise. The refund of Court fee cannot be denied merely because the matter has not been settled before the Lok Adalat. Learned counsel also relied upon A. Sreeramaiah Vs. Sought Indian Bank Ltd., Bangolore and another, 2007(5) RCR (Civil) 374, Kamalamma Vs. Honnali Taluk Agricultural Produce Co-operative Marketing Society titled Tarun Juneja Vs. Hukam Singh decided on 15.09.2009.

[8]. In view of aforesaid position, I deem it appropriate to accept the prayer for withdrawal of the appeal on the basis of compromise and also hold that the appellant is entitled for the refund of the Court fee under Section 16 of the Court Fee Act. Needful be done by the Registry. Normal consequences to follow. 16.01.2019 (RAJ MOHAN SINGH) Prince JUDGE Whether reasoned/speaking Yes/No Whether reportable Yes/No