- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
SRI KESHAVA RAJANNA B v. SRI N RAJANNA
Structured Summary of the Opinion (Appeal from I.A.1 in O.S.465/2019)
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal is filed by the plaintiff who is aggrieved by the trial court's order on I.A.1 in O.S.465/2019. The plaintiff is the son of the 1st and 2nd defendants. Defendants No.3 and No.4 are his sisters and Defendant No.5 is a purchaser of one of the schedule properties.
The plaintiff's case, as set out in the plaint, alleges that there was an earlier partition of ancestral properties among his father (the 1st defendant) and the father's two brothers. After partition the 1st defendant migrated to Bengaluru, started Pankaja Dairy and acquired properties using proceeds from the sale of his allotted ancestral share; some properties were assertedly purchased in the name of the 1st defendant and some in the joint names of the 1st defendant and the plaintiff.
The plaintiff contends that the properties are joint family properties under the control of the 1st defendant as Karta, and that he (the plaintiff) worked full time at the dairy and contributed to family earnings and to acquisition of the suit properties. The plaint refers to gift and sale transactions affecting items of the suit schedule properties, and alleges that the 1st defendant, because of old age and ill-health (including a stroke and diabetes), had become mentally impaired and was being induced by others to alienate or gift properties.
The plaint refers to several events and dates in the record, including (as recorded in different paragraphs of the opinion) a gift deed dated 18.09.2013, an episode where the 1st defendant issued a cheque for Rs.7,40,000/- to a stranger (Rajashekar Mathikere) on 06.09.2014 followed by an FIR and repayment, and later registered gift and sale deeds (the opinion contains references to a registered gift deed dated 27.08.2015 and the plaint challenges a gift dated 27.08.2016 and a sale dated 24.09.2018). The opinion therefore contains multiple dates relating to gift transactions as they appear in the record.
Procedurally, the plaintiff filed a suit for partition seeking a one-fourth share and a declaration that certain gift and sale deeds are null and void, and he contemporaneously moved I.A.1 for a temporary injunction restraining the 1st defendant from alienating the suit properties during the pendency of the suit. The trial court dismissed the application for injunction; this appeal challenges that dismissal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a temporary injunction restraining the 1st defendant from alienating the suit properties during the pendency of the partition suit (I.A.1) should be granted.
- Whether the suit properties are joint family properties (and thus subject to partition) or are self-acquired properties of the 1st defendant.
- Whether the mental condition of the 1st defendant (as alleged by the plaintiff) affects the validity of the impugned gift(s) and sale and supports grant of interlocutory relief to prevent alienation.
- Whether the trial court properly exercised its discretion in refusing temporary injunction, given the risk of creation of third-party interests and multiplicity of proceedings.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Arguments
- The suit is for partition and for declaration that certain gift deeds and a sale deed are null and void; the plaintiff alleges that all suit properties flowed from proceeds of ancestral property sold after partition and therefore form an ancestral nucleus giving the plaintiff a right to partition.
- The plaintiff contributed to acquisition of some properties by working full time in the family dairy and by contributing to earnings and purchases.
- The 1st defendant's physical ailments and alleged mental imbalance (including an incident where he issued a cheque to a stranger and had to file an FIR) demonstrate vulnerability and a propensity to be induced into alienations; such alienations during the suit will create third-party interests and multiplicity of proceedings and will prejudice the plaintiff.
- The trial court failed to apply its mind in dismissing the injunction application.
Respondent No.1's (1st Defendant's) Arguments
- The properties are self-acquired by the 1st defendant and belong to him absolutely; the plaintiff therefore has no right to seek partition in those self-acquired properties.
- The 1st defendant asserts he is mentally fit and sane; he points to a medical certificate (obtained before filing the statement of objections) certifying physical and mental fitness.
- The 1st defendant had already executed a gift in favour of the plaintiff (accepted by the plaintiff), which, in the 1st defendant's submission, indicates ownership as self-acquisition; similar gifts were made to his daughters.
- There is no material to show that all properties were acquired from proceeds of ancestral property; the trial court correctly exercised its discretion in refusing injunction and its order should not be interfered with.
Other Respondents
- Defendants Nos.3 and 4 filed a written statement; defendant No.1 filed statement of objections to I.A.1. The learned counsel for respondent No.4 supported the impugned trial court order.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The appellate judge reviewed the plaint, the impugned order and the statements of objections. The trial court's reasoning (as recorded) was that the 1st defendant had begun Pankaja Dairy in 1957, had been a public office-holder (a corporator and member of the legislative assembly), and that several properties were acquired by the 1st defendant before the plaintiff's birth and some during the plaintiff's minority. On that basis the trial court concluded that the plaintiff's pleaded contribution to acquisition of the suit properties was a matter to be adjudicated at trial and that there was an existing gift in favour of the plaintiff, so injunctive relief should not be granted.
The appellate court reviewed the general principle (explicitly stated in the opinion) that in partition suits an application to restrain alienation of properties will generally be granted to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and the creation of third-party interests. Applying that principle to the present facts, the appellate judge observed:
- The plaintiff has pleaded that there was a partition among the 1st defendant and his two brothers and that the 1st defendant thereafter sold his allotted share and used the proceeds to acquire the disputed properties; the plaintiff also alleges personal contribution via work at the dairy toward acquisition of some items.
- The plaintiff has pleaded at least one indicia of the 1st defendant's impaired decision-making (the cheque to a stranger for Rs.7,40,000/- and subsequent FIR and repayment). The opinion notes this allegation is not denied by the 1st defendant and, while not alone determinative of mental incapacity, cannot be ignored at the stage of deciding an interlocutory application.
- The trial court had not considered the consequences of allowing alienation during the pendency of the suit — specifically the risk of third-party interests and multiplicity of proceedings — and had not directed any interim restraint despite recognizing that the question of contribution and status of the properties required full evidence.
- The appellate judge reasoned that if the plaintiff's pleadings indicate a triable issue as to joint family origin of the properties and contribution by the plaintiff, the pragmatic course to secure the subject matter of the suit is to preserve it from sale during the litigation; doing so would not prejudice the 1st defendant's rights beyond preserving the status quo for adjudication.
On that basis the court concluded that the trial court had not properly exercised its discretion in refusing injunction and that the appeal should be allowed to impose an interim restraint preventing alienation during the suit.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is allowed; the impugned trial court order is set aside; I.A.1 is allowed and the defendants are restrained from alienating the suit properties until disposal of the suit. (As recorded in the opinion: "i. Appeal is allowed. ii. The impugned order is set aside. iii. I.A.1 stands allowed. The defendants are restrained from alienating the suit properties till disposal of the suit.")
Implications:
- Direct effect: The defendants are prohibited from alienating the suit properties pending final adjudication of the partition suit, thereby preserving the status quo and preventing creation of third-party interests that could cause multiplicity of litigation.
- Scope: The opinion's remedy is interlocutory (temporary) and directed at preserving the subject matter for trial; the appellate decision does not decide the substantive merits of whether the properties are joint family assets or self-acquired, or whether the impugned gift(s) and sale are valid — those matters remain for full trial and evidence.
- Precedential impact: The opinion applies the well-stated practical principle (not citing external authority in the text) that interlocutory relief in partition suits is often appropriate to prevent third-party interests and multiplicity; the opinion does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond this application to the facts of this case.
Signed in the opinion: SD/- JUDGE (order as recited in the provided opinion).
This appeal is filed by the plaintiff aggrieved by the order of the trial court on I.A.1 filed in O.S.465/2019.
2. The plaintiff is the son of the 1st and 2nd defendants. Defendants no.3 and 4 are his sisters and defendant no.5 is the purchaser of one of the items of the suit schedule properties. The plaintiffs case is that there was a partition of the ancestral properties among his father and fathers two brothers. His father migrated to Bengaluru after partition. He purchased some properties in his name and some other properties in his and plaintiffs names. According to the plaintiff all the properties belonged to joint family and that the 1st defendant is the Karta of the joint family. The 1st plaintiff and the 1st defendant started a dairy called Pankaja Dairy in property No.14/1 at Sarvagna Nagar, Ward No.85, Bengaluru. The plaintiff spared his full time in looking after the dairy and contributed for the earnings of the family and purchase of all the suit properties. The 1st defendant executed a gift deed in the name of the plaintiff in respect of land bearing Sy.No.80/2, Old Sy.No.27/1 measuring 2 acres
10 guntas situated at Kyalasanahalli Village, K.R.Puram Hobli, Bengaluru East Taluk on 18.09.2013. The 1st defendant became sick and was suffering from many ailments. He suffered a stroke also. He was suffering from diabetes and because of all these ailments he became mentally imbalanced and lost the understanding capacity. On 6.9.2014, one Rajashekar Mathikere, a totally stranger obtained a cheque from the 1st defendant for Rs.7,40,000/- by luring him that he would cure his disease and thus deceived him. Therefore the 1st defendant filed a complaint at Police Station against Rajashekar Mathikere. Police registered a complaint and secured the presence of Rajashekar Mathikere. He confessed his guilt and returned Rs.7,40,000/-. Giving this background, it is alleged by the plaintiff that taking undue advantage of the health condition of the 1st defendant some unscrupulous persons tried to play fraud on him to grab the properties. The 1st defendant, because of his old age and other ailments has become adamant and tried to create charge on the schedule properties though there was no necessity to alienate them. Defendant no.4 prevailed upon the 1st defendant and lured him to obtain the registered gift deed dated 27.08.2015. The 5th defendant who is another stranger to the family induced the 1st defendant to execute the sale deed in his favour on 24.09.2018 in respect of a property bearing Old Sy.No.51, New Sy.No.51/2 measuring 2 acres. The plaintiff has therefore stated that all these transactions show very clearly that the 1st defendant is wasting the joint family properties even though he has no absolute right to execute sale deed. Therefore the plaintiff filed a suit for partition seeking his 1/4th share and for declaring that the gift dated 27.08.2016 and the sale dated 24.9.2018 are all null and void. Along with the plaint he made an application for temporary injunction to restrain the 1st defendant from alienating the suit properties till disposal of the suit. The trial court dismissed the application. Therefore this appeal.
3. Defendants 3 and 4 filed written statement and defendant no.1 filed statement of objections to I.A.No.1 and contended that the suit properties belonged to him absolutely as they are all self acquisitions. He asserted that he is mentally fit and sane. He further stated that he executed the gift deed in favour of the plaintiff in respect of one item of the suit property and in the same manner he gifted other properties to his daughters. His plea is that the plaintiff has no right to seek partition in the properties which are all his self acquired and therefore he cannot maintain the application for temporary injunction also.
4. The learned counsel for the appellant argues that the plaintiffs suit is for partition and declaration that the gift deeds and sale deed are null and void. The plaintiff has clearly stated that all the suit properties were purchased by the 1st defendant after alienating ancestral properties situated at his village. Therefore there is ancestral nucleus. Moreover the plaintiff also contributed for acquisition of some of the properties by managing the dairy. The plaintiff has clearly alleged that his father has become sick and is mentally insane. This is evidenced by his issuance of cheque for a stranger for Rs.7,40,000/-. Subsequent registration of FIR and repayment of money by the stranger to the 1st defendant shows the mental condition of the 1st defendant. This being the sate of affairs, if the 1st defendant alienates the properties which are all the subject matter of the suit during pendency of the suit, the interest of the plaintiff will be affected. 3rd party interest will be created and it will lead to multiplicity of proceedings. The trial court has not at all applied its mind while passing the impugned order.
5. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the 1st respondent argues that all the properties were acquired by the 1st defendant. The plaintiff has no right to seek partition in the self acquired properties. There is already a gift in favour of the plaintiff. He accepted the gift and this acceptance shows that the properties were acquired by the 1st defendant. The plaintiff was born in the year 1970 and some of the properties were acquired before his birth. Though some items were purchased after the birth of the plaintiff, it cannot be said that the source for acquiring all the properties was from the proceeds of sale of the ancestral properties. Absolutely there is no material to come to this conclusion. The plaintiff has made false allegations that he is insane. Before filing the statement of objections he got himself examined at Bowring Hospital. The doctor certified that he is physically and mentally fit. This medical certificate shows that plaintiff has made false allegations. Rightly the trial court has arrived at right conclusion not to grant injunction. The trial court has exercised its discretion properly and there cannot be interference with the impugned order in this appeal.
6. The learned counsel for respondent no.4 supported the impugned order.
7. I have perused the plaint and impugned order, the statement of objections filed by the 1st defendant to the application and the impugned order. The trial court has assigned the reasons that the 1st defendant started Pankaja Dairy in the year 1957. He was a corporator and was also elected to legislative assembly. All the properties were acquired by the 1st defendant before the birth of the plaintiff and some other properties during his minority. In these circumstances question of contribution by the plaintiff for purchasing the suit properties does not arise. The averments in the plaint that the plaintiff has made contribution for purchasing the suit properties can be thrashed out after recording evidence. There is also a gift in favour of the plaintiff and therefore all these circumstances put together show that the injunction as sought by the plaintiff cannot be granted.
8. In a suit for partition, whenever an application is made by the plaintiff to restrain the defendant from alienating the properties, temporary injunction will generally be granted to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and creation of 3rd party interest. Here is a case filed by the plaintiff against the father, mother and sisters. He does not say that the gift made by his father in his favour is bad. But he challenges the gift made in favour of his two sisters. He has given one instance to show his father is mentally insane. It is stated that he issued a cheque for Rs.7,40,000/- to a stranger to take treatment for his ailments. Registration of FIR and subsequent recovery of Rs.7,40,000/- is also pleaded by the plaintiff to show the mental condition of 1st defendant. It is to be noted here that this allegation is not denied by the 1st defendant, and of course this allegation alone does not indicate the mental condition of the 1st defendant, but it cannot be ignored at the stage of deciding application for temporary injunction. The plaintiff has clearly stated that there was a partition among the 1st defendant and his two brothers and after the partition, the 1st defendant sold the share allotted to him and then migrated to Bengaluru. From the proceeds of sale, he acquired properties which are all subject matter of the suit. Therefore it is his contention that all the suit properties belong to joint family. It is also stated by the plaintiff that he too worked in the dairy and earned money. His contribution may also be there in acquisition of some of the items of suit properties, but this is to be proved by the plaintiff, as no decision can be taken at this stage of deciding the application for temporary injunction. The 1st defendant asserts that all the properties belong to him absolutely and therefore the burden is also on him to show that the properties are all his self acquisitions. The factual position being so, the only course open to the court is to see that the properties remain in the hold of the family to prevent creation of 3rd party interest. The trial court has not dealt with the aspect as to what happens if 3rd party interests are created during the pendency of the suit. If it comes to conclusion that the plaintiff has to prove that he too made contributions for acquisition of the property and thus there exists a case for trial, the best way open to the trial court was to direct the 1st defendant not to sell the properties. The purpose of granting injunction is to see that subject matter of the suit is not wasted or alienated. Thus seen, I am of the opinion that the trial court has not exercised its discretion properly. The interest of the 1st defendant will not be affected in any way if he is directed not to sell the properties. His mere assertion of absolute right over the properties cannot be a ground for denying temporary injunction. In these circumstances I come to conclusion that the appeal deserves to be allowed. Hence the following: ORDER
i. Appeal is allowed.
ii. The impugned order is set aside
iii. I.A.1 stands allowed. The defendants are restrained from alienating the suit properties till disposal of the suit. SD/- JUDGE
Alert