Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mukesh Goel v. Goel Entrade Pvt. Ltd. & Ors.

National Company Law Appellate Tribunal
May 15, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion — Company Appeal (AT) No. 117 of 2019

Factual and Procedural Background

The Appellant alleged a violation of a status quo order dated 29 November 2017 made in I.A. No. 46/2017 and filed an application under Section 425 of the Companies Act, 2013 seeking initiation of contempt proceedings against the Contemnor Respondents. The National Company Law Tribunal, Guwahati Bench heard the matter and, by an impugned order dated 17 December 2018, dismissed the contempt application. The Tribunal's reasons included observations about an apparent clerical mistake in the order, the applicant's failure to seek rectification, and the absence of proof that the contemnors were duly communicated the status quo direction or wilfully violated it.

The Appellant preferred the present appeal under Section 421 of the Companies Act, 2013, challenging the Tribunal's dismissal of the contempt application. The appellate bench recorded that the Tribunal had refused to initiate contempt proceedings after considering relevant facts and proceeded to dismiss the appeal with no costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appeal under Section 421 of the Companies Act, 2013 is maintainable against the Tribunal's refusal to initiate contempt proceedings under Section 425.
  2. Whether a person alleging violation of an order (and whose application for initiation of contempt proceedings is rejected by the Tribunal) is entitled to file an appeal under Section 421 when no penal order of punishment has been passed.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The appellate bench set out the statutory framework relevant to contempt proceedings under the Companies Act:

  • Section 425 of the Companies Act, 2013 vests the Tribunal and the Appellate Tribunal with power to punish for contempt, subjecting them to the provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 with specified modifications.
  • Section 420 of the Companies Act requires that the Tribunal give parties a reasonable opportunity of being heard; orders under Section 420 are appealable under Section 421.
  • The Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 provides related procedural provisions, including an appeal provision under Section 19 of that Act (as noted in the opinion).

Applying these principles to the facts, the court emphasized the evidentiary threshold for contempt: before finding wilful and intentional violation of a tribunal's direction, it must be proved beyond doubt that the contemnors were duly communicated the relevant order and that the violation was wilful and intentional. The Tribunal found no proof that the contemnors had been communicated the status quo order, and the applicant had not sought rectification of an apparent clerical mistake in the order that had "enormous implications" for the petition's outcome. Because the requisite communication and wilful violation were not established on the record, the Tribunal concluded the allegation against the contemnors was not proven.

The appellate bench observed these findings and noted that, given the Tribunal's definitive conclusion refusing to initiate contempt proceedings, the bench would not decide the broader question of maintainability of an appeal under Section 421 in the abstract. Instead, the court declined to interfere with the Tribunal's exercise of discretion on the facts before it.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Consequences and immediate effects:

  • The Tribunal's order of 17 December 2018 dismissing the application for initiation of contempt proceedings is upheld by the appellate bench.
  • No order as to costs was made ("No costs").
  • The appellate bench expressly refrained from deciding the broader legal question of the maintainability of appeals under Section 421 where initiation of contempt proceedings has been rejected; accordingly, no new precedent on that question is established by this decision.

Bench

The order records the members who delivered the decision: Justice S.J. Mukhopadhaya (Chairperson), Justice A.I.S. Cheema (Member, Judicial), and Kanthi Narahari (Member, Technical).

Show all summary ...

15.05.2019 The Appellant alleged violation of order of status quo dated 29th November, 2017 in I.A. No. 46 /2017 and moved an application under Section 425 of the Companies Act, 2013 for initiation of contempt proceedings against the Contemnor Respondents. The National Company Law Tribunal, Guwahati Bench (for short, the Tribunal) on hearing the parties dismissed the application by impugned order dated 17th December, 2018 with the following observations:

12. However, such a mistake, although appears to be quite clerical in nature, cannot be viewed liberally and lightly in a contempt proceeding, more so, when the petitioner/applicant in C.P. No. 25/2017 never made any request to rectify such mistake although--- such a Company Appeal (AT) No. 117 of 2019 mistake in the order aforesaid, was quite apparent. Rather, they chose not to rectify such a mistake having enormous implications on the outcome of the petition under consideration.

13. This is because of the fact that before being found a person guilty of wilfully and intentionally violating the direction of the court/tribunal, it must be proved beyond any doubt that the contemnors were duly communicated such an order requiring them to maintain status quo etc. in respect of Goel Entrade Private Limited. The applicant must also show that such direction was violated wilfully and intentionally showing utter disdain to such direction rendered by this Bench.

13. However, in the present case, there was no proof whatsoever that contemnors had ever been communicated with the aforesaid status quo order--- much lees--- their producing some evidence showing that the condemners, having been posted with the status quo order, requiring them to maintain status/quo in respect of the assets, shareholdings and composition of the Company Appeal (AT) No. 117 of 2019 Bard of Goel Entrade Private Limited, violated the same. In the face of such revelations, there cannot be any escape from the conclusion that allegation made against the contemnors remains far from being established.

2. The present appeal has been preferred by the Appellant under Section 421 of the Companies Act, 2013 on the ground of being aggrieved by the order as passed by the Tribunal is in violation.

3. Section 420 of the Companies Act, 2013 empowers the Tribunal to pass order after giving the parties to any proceedings before it, a reasonable opportunity of being heard. The order passed under Section 420 of the Companies Act, 2013 is appealable under Section 421 of the Companies Act, 2013.

4. The power to punishment to the contemnor is vested with the Tribunal under Section 425 of the Companies Act, which reads as follows:

425. Power to punish for contempt The Tribunal and the Appellate Tribunal shall have the same jurisdiction, powers and authority in respect of contempt of themselves as the High Court has and may exercise, for this purpose, the powers under the provisions of the Contempt of Courts Act, Company Appeal (AT) No. 117 of 2019 1971, which shall have the effect subject to modifications that (a) the reference therein to a High Court shall be construed as including a reference to the Tribunal and the Appellate Tribunal; and (b) the reference to Advocate-General in section 15 of the said Act shall be construed as a reference to such Law Officers as the Central Government may, specify in this behalf.

5. From the aforesaid provision, we find for the purpose of initiation of contempt proceedings the Tribunal is empowered with the same power as that of High Court and for the purpose power under the provisions of the Contempt of Court Act, 1971 is applicable subject to modification as shown therein.

6. As per Contempt of Court Act, 1971, the appeal lies under Section 19.

7. In the circumstances, the question arises for consideration is whether the appeal under section 421 is maintainable or not.

8. The other question is that if the Tribunal rejected the application for initiation of contempt proceedings under Section 425 of the Companies Act, 2013, the person who alleged violation of the order if he is entitled to file the appeal under Section 421 of the Companies Act, penal order of punishment having not been passed. Company Appeal (AT) No. 117 of 2019

9. In the present case, as we find that the Tribunal, after taking into consideration the relevant facts, has come to a definite conclusion and refused to initiate contempt proceedings, we are not deciding the issue aforesaid on merit as we do not want to interfere. The appeal is dismissed. No costs. [Justice S.J. Mukhopadhaya] Chairperson [ Justice A.I.S. Cheema ] Member (Judicial) [ Kanthi Narahari ] Member (Technical) /ns/gc