- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bhavesh Motiani v. Union Of India And Others
Summary of Opinion: Bhavesh Motiani v. Union of India & Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner challenged an order dated 30.11.2018 of the Central Administrative Tribunal (Principal Bench, New Delhi) that transferred O.A. No. 421/2018 from the Ahmedabad Bench to the Principal Bench at New Delhi. At the time the O.A. was filed the petitioner was posted at Ahmedabad and that city was also his usual place of residence. Pleadings before the Ahmedabad Bench were complete and the matter was represented as ready for arguments there.
The respondents had filed an application before the Principal Bench seeking transfer of the O.A. on the grounds that 19 officers were transferred by a common order and that allowing separate O.A.s at different benches would cause multiplicity of proceedings and hardship for the respondents; a further ground was that the contesting respondents were situated in New Delhi. The Tribunal allowed the respondents' transfer application and directed the O.A. be transferred to the Principal Bench at New Delhi. The petitioner filed the present writ petition in the High Court challenging that transfer order.
The petitioner subsequently informed the Court that he had been posted to the North-East and that travel to Delhi would be inconvenient, time-consuming and expensive. The respondents contended that the petitioner had benefited from an interim order passed by the Ahmedabad Bench, that the matter had been adjourned from time to time, and that the respondents wished final disposal of the matter. The respondents also maintained there was no infirmity in the Tribunal's transfer order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Central Administrative Tribunal was justified in transferring O.A. No. 421/2018 from the Ahmedabad Bench to the Principal Bench at New Delhi under Section 25 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985.
- Whether the grounds relied upon by the Tribunal—(a) risk of multiplicity of proceedings because multiple officers were affected by a common transfer order and (b) respondents being situated in New Delhi—were sufficient to warrant transfer in the petitioner’s case.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The O.A. was filed before the Ahmedabad Bench where the petitioner was posted and resident; pleadings were complete and the matter was ready for final hearing at Ahmedabad.
- Transfer to Delhi would cause delay because the Principal Bench is over-burdened and the matter would need re-scheduling there.
- The petitioner was posted to the North-East and travelling to Delhi would cause inconvenience, substantial expense and require additional leave from work.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents had obtained the transfer because 19 officers were transferred by a common order and allowing separate O.A.s in different forums would produce multiplicity and hardship for respondents.
- The contesting respondents are situated in New Delhi, which supported transfer to the Principal Bench.
- The petitioner had taken benefit of an interim order passed by the Ahmedabad Bench and the matter had been adjourned several times; respondents wished for final disposal.
- There was no infirmity in the order passed by the Tribunal authorising transfer.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by noting Section 25 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, which confers on the Chairman of the Tribunal the power to transfer cases from one Bench to another. The respondents' transfer application to the Principal Bench had been allowed by the Tribunal on two principal grounds: (i) that 19 officers were transferred by a common order and multiplicity of proceedings would result if each officer filed O.A.s in the places where they were posted; and (ii) that the contesting respondents were situated in New Delhi, making transfer to the Principal Bench appropriate.
The Court analysed the first ground (multiplicity due to common transfer order) by observing that the transfer of the other 18 officers had been ordered on 26.07.2018 and, as a matter of fact recorded in the opinion, no other officer had filed proceedings challenging the transfer. The Court held that the petitioner's entitlement to object to the transfer could not be made to depend upon whether other officers had chosen to challenge or accept the transfer order; those other officers might not have had grounds to challenge, whereas the petitioner did have such grounds. Thus, the mere existence of a common transfer order affecting multiple officers did not automatically justify transferring the petitioner's O.A.
In relation to the second ground (that the respondents are situated in New Delhi), the Court reasoned that because the respondents are the Government and have presence all over the country, their being situated in Delhi could not, by itself, be a decisive basis for rejecting a valid challenge to transfer if the petitioner's grounds against transfer appeared to be valid.
The Court accepted the petitioner's specific submissions: that pleadings before the Ahmedabad Bench were complete and the matter was ready for hearing there, and that transfer would cause avoidable inconvenience and delay. On a conspectus of these facts and circumstances, the Court found force in the petitioner's submissions and concluded that the Tribunal's order of transfer should be set aside.
The petitioner also offered an assurance to the High Court that no adjournment would be sought before the Ahmedabad Bench. Taking that assurance into account, the Court directed the Ahmedabad Bench of the Tribunal to fix an early date and decide the matter expeditiously. The Court further directed that a copy of its order be brought to the notice of the Tribunal at Delhi and Ahmedabad.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The High Court set aside the Tribunal's order dated 30.11.2018 transferring O.A. No. 421/2018 from the Ahmedabad Bench to the Principal Bench at New Delhi; the writ petition was disposed of accordingly.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The O.A. remains to be heard at the Ahmedabad Bench. The Ahmedabad Bench was requested to fix an early date and decide the matter expeditiously.
- The petitioner gave an assurance not to seek adjournments before the Ahmedabad Bench, which the Court noted in its order.
- No broader precedent or new legal principle was articulated beyond the application of Section 25 and the Court's assessment of the specific facts; the opinion confines its decision to the facts and circumstances of this case.
Disposition of Related Application
CM.APPL. 172/2019 was disposed of by the Court in view of the order passed in the present writ petition.
This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion. No information beyond the text of the opinion has been added or inferred.
$~6 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Date of Judgment : 20th November, 2019 + W.P.(C) 30/2019
BHAVESH MOTIANI ..... Petitioner Through Mr. P.K. Sinha and Mr. Sushil Kumar, Advocates
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS. ..... Respondents
Through Mr. Anil Soni, CGSC with Mr. Devesh Dubey, Advocates for
respondents no.1, 2 and 4.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G.S.SISTANI HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI
G.S. SISTANI, J. (ORAL)
1. The present petition has been filed being aggrieved by order dated 30.11.2018 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi (the 'Tribunal'), by which O.A. No.421/2018 pending before the Ahmedabad Bench has been transferred to the Principal Bench of the Tribunal.
2. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the O.A. was filed before the Ahmedabad Bench, where the petitioner was posted at that time and which is also his usual city of residence. He submits that
1
pleadings are complete and the matter is ready for arguments before the Ahmedabad Bench. He submits that the Principal Bench is already over-burdened with a large number of cases and the matter is likely to get delayed by reason of the transfer. Additionally, the petitioner states that he is now posted to the North-East and it would be highly inconvenient for the petitioner to travel to Delhi and substantial expenses would be incurred and time would be spent; and the petitioner will even have to take additional leave from work.
3. Mr. Soni, learned counsel for the respondents submits that the petitioner has been taking benefit of the interim order which was passed by the Ahmedabad Bench. The matter has been adjourned from time-to-time and the respondents are keen that the matter is dealt with finally. Mr. Soni also submits that there is no infirmity in the order passed by the Tribunal, which would require interference by this Court.
4. We have heard learned counsel for the parties.
5. Section 25 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 reads as under:
"25. Power of Chairman to transfer cases from one Bench to another.—On the application of any of the parties and after notice to the parties, and after hearing such of them as he may desire to be heard, or on his own motion without such notice, the Chairman may transfer any case pending before one Bench, for disposal, to any other Bench."
6. The respondents had made an application for transfer before the Principal Bench at New Delhi. The grounds on which transfer was sought were that 19 officers were transferred by a common order; and if 19 officers were to file OAs in places of their transfer, it would lead to multiplicity of proceedings and hardship for the respondents. This
2
ground was considered favourably by the Tribunal. The second ground which found favour with the Tribunal while allowing the transfer petition was that the contesting respondents are situated in Delhi; and hence the OA was transferred to Delhi.
7. As far as the first ground is concerned, which was accepted by the Tribunal, admittedly the order of transfer of the 18 other officers was passed as far back as on 26.07.2018; and no other officer(s) has filed a proceeding challenging the transfer petition. In these circumstances, the decision of the petitioner's prayer in these proceedings cannot depend upon such other officers, who may have accepted the transfer order or have not had reason to impugn the same. Besides, such other officers may not have any ground to challenge the transfer orders, while the petitioner has had such ground.
8. The second ground which is relied upon by the Tribunal is that the respondents are situated in New Delhi; and if each officer files an OA before the Bench in whose jurisdiction the concerned officer resides, it would lead to several complications. Insofar as the matter of the respondents being situate in Delhi is concerned, being the Government, with presence all over the country this ground cannot be the basis to reject the petitioner's challenge if the grounds raised by the petitioner appear to be valid.
9. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the counter affidavit has been filed and the pleadings are complete before the Ahmedabad Bench and it would cause avoidable inconvenience to the petitioner, if the matter is transferred to Delhi. It is further submitted that the matter is ripe for final hearing before the Ahmedabad Bench, which hearing may
3
have to be re-scheduled on transfer to the Principal Bench, New Delhi which would again delay the matter.
10. Upon a conspectus of all the facts and circumstances of the case, we find force in the submissions made by the learned counsel for the petitioner. Accordingly, we set aside order dated 30.11.2018 passed by the Tribunal. Learned counsel for the petitioner has also given an assurance to this Court that no adjournment will be sought by the petitioner before the Ahmedabad Bench.
11. We request the Tribunal at Ahmedabad to fix an early date and decide the matter expeditiously.
12. With the above directions, the writ petition stands disposed of.
13. A copy of the order will be brought to the notice of the Tribunal at Delhi and Ahmedabad.
CM.APPL 172/2019
14. The application is disposed of in view of the order passed in the present writ petition.
G.S. SISTANI, J
ANUP JAIRAM BHAMBHANI, J
NOVEMBER 20, 2019
pst
4
Alert