Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S The Paper Products Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Mumbai-Iii .

CESTAT
Jul 4, 2017

D.N. Panda, Judicial Member:— It is settled principle of law by Apex Court in the case of Collector of Central Excise, Pune v. Daichi Karkaria Ltd. - 1999 (112) ELT 353 (S.C.), that there is no one to one correlation between the input and output. Therefore, the inputs on which CENVAT Credit was taken and destroyed in fire is not discernable. It is statutory provision in law that duty liability on final goods or output services stand reduced by setting off the CENVAT Credit availed on the inputs used in the manufacture of goods or provision of output services.

2. Appellant says that when the liability to pay excise duty did not arise due to loss of finished goods and semi-finished goods destroyed before their removal from the factory due to flood, in that situation, the question of reversal of CENVAT Credit did not arise. Therefore, appellant shall retain CENVAT Credit otherwise permissible to it without reversal of the proportionate input credit remained in the finished or semi-finished goods destroyed in flood.

3. Appellant further says that from the year 2007, specific provision has been made for the purpose of disallowance of CENVAT Credit on inputs contained in goods on which duty is remitted. Such a provision being declaratory in nature cannot be invoked in the present case pertaining to period of July, 2005.

4. Following the principles of law in the case of Union of India v. Martin Lottery Agencies Ltd. - 2009 (14) S.T.R. 593 (S.C.) by Apex Court, the provision which imposes a burden is always considered declaratory and cannot be applied retrospectively. Therefore, the provision introduced in 2007 requiring reversal of CENVAT Credit at the time of granting of remission of duty being obligatory in nature, will apply prospectively. However, such decision relates only to the extent of reversal of CENVAT Credit in respect of inputs involved in the finished and semi-finished goods.

5. Appellant's prayer on levy of interest calls for remand for re-adjudication as the appellant says that they are not liable to the same on liability relating to the raw materials destroyed in flood. The appellant is entitled to fair opportunity of hearing before the learned adjudicating authority and learned authority recording the pleading and evidence shall pass an appropriate order.

7. In result, the appeal is partly allowed to the extent indicated above.

8. Cross-objection filed by the respondent is also disposed of in the above terms.