Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Apg Tower Pvt. Ltd. v. Alpana Gupta And Another

Delhi High Court
Jul 27, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent No. 1/plaintiff instituted a suit claiming ownership of a land measuring 12 Bighas 14 Biswas in village Alipur, Delhi, based on various documents dated 14 October 1998, including an Agreement to Sell, General Power of Attorney, Will, Receipt, Affidavit, and Indemnity Bond executed by respondent/defendant No. 2 Rakesh Bindal in favor of the plaintiff. The suit alternatively sought recovery of Rs. 8 lakhs with interest from defendant No. 2 and a permanent injunction restraining defendant No. 1 APG Towers Pvt. Ltd. from creating any third-party interest in the land.

The plaintiff alleged that defendant No. 2 had agreed to sell the land and put the plaintiff in possession. The sale deed in favor of the plaintiff was registered on 5 June 2013. However, defendant No. 2 had also executed and registered a sale deed in favor of defendant No. 1 APG Towers Pvt. Ltd. on 3 April 2013, who had obtained mutation in revenue records, resulting in the plaintiff's 'deemed dispossession'. The plaintiff's appeal against the mutation order was pending.

The defendants filed applications under Order VII Rule 11 CPC seeking rejection of the plaint on grounds including the plaintiff’s failure to seek setting aside of the sale deed in favor of defendant No. 1. The trial court dismissed these applications, leading to the present revision petitions under Section 115 CPC.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaint filed by the respondent No. 1/plaintiff was liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11 CPC for failure to seek setting aside of the earlier sale deed in favor of defendant No. 1 before claiming reliefs.
  2. Whether the respondent No. 1/plaintiff could be permitted to amend the plaint to include claims concerning the sale deed in favor of defendant No. 1 and recovery of possession.
  3. The procedural question of whether an application for amendment under Order VI Rule 17 CPC filed after an application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC must be considered first.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent No. 1/Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff asserted ownership of the land based on documents executed in 1998 and possession thereof.
  • Following the Supreme Court judgment in Suraj Lamp & Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana, the plaintiff sought execution of the sale deed.
  • The plaintiff contended that the sale deed in their favor was registered and that the defendants’ sale deed and mutation were wrongful.
  • Upon query regarding the existence of an earlier sale deed in favor of defendant No. 1, the plaintiff undertook to file an application for amendment of the plaint to claim reliefs related to the sale deed and possession.

Petitioners/Defendants' Arguments

  • The defendants contended that the plaint should be rejected as the plaintiff had not challenged the earlier sale deed in favor of defendant No. 1.
  • They objected to the plaintiff’s proposal to amend the plaint after dismissal of their application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
  • The defendants asserted that the application for amendment under Order VI Rule 17 CPC, if filed after the Order VII Rule 11 application, should be considered first as per settled law.
  • They pointed out that the application for amendment had not yet been filed and opposed the plaintiff’s request to be allowed to do so.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Suraj Lamp & Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana, (2012) 1 SCC 656 Context of sale deed execution and possession rights Referenced by the plaintiff to justify seeking execution of the sale deed in their favor.
Wasudhir Foundation v. C. Lal & Sons, 45 (1991) DLT 556 Priority of consideration of applications under Order VI Rule 17 CPC over Order VII Rule 11 CPC Applied to hold that an amendment application must be considered before rejection of plaint application.
Anita Kumari Gupta v. Ved Bhushan, FAO (OS) No. 357/2013 (order dated 6 May 2014) Same as above: procedural priority of amendment applications Reinforced the principle that amendment applications take precedence over plaint rejection applications.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first examined the plaintiff’s position in relation to the existence of an earlier sale deed in favor of defendant No. 1. The court questioned how the plaintiff could claim rights without setting aside that earlier deed. The plaintiff’s counsel indicated an intention to amend the plaint to include claims regarding the earlier sale deed and recovery of possession.

The court noted the settled legal position that applications for amendment under Order VI Rule 17 CPC must be considered before applications for rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, even if filed subsequently. Since the defendants’ applications under Order VII Rule 11 had been dismissed and the plaint had not been rejected, the plaintiff was entitled to apply for amendment.

The court declined to hear the revision petitions further, instead directing the plaintiff to file the amendment application within a stipulated time and mandating the trial court to consider it on merits. The court also provided that failure to file the amendment would result in rejection of the plaint and setting aside of the impugned order.

Holding and Implications

The revision petitions were disposed of with directions permitting the plaintiff to apply for amendment of the plaint by a specified date.

The trial court was directed to consider the amendment application on its merits, allowing defendants to oppose it. If the plaintiff failed to file the amendment within the time allowed, the plaint would stand rejected and the impugned order set aside, effectively allowing the revision petitions by default.

The plaintiff was also ordered to pay costs of Rs. 1,00,000/- to each petitioner along with the amendment application.

No new precedent was set; the decision primarily clarified procedural rights regarding amendment applications following dismissal of plaint rejection applications.

Show all summary ...

Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.:— These Revision Petitions, both under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) and arising from the same suit and by different defendants having common interest, impugn the order (dated 16 January, 2017 in Civil Suit No. 1641/2016 of the Court of Additional District Judge (ADJ)-1, North District, Rohini Courts, Delhi) dismissing the separate applications filed by the petitioners/defendants under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC for rejection of the plaint in the suit filed by the respondent No. 1 in each of the petitions.

2. Notice of Civil Revision Petition No. 99/2017 was issued and the Trial Court record requisitioned.

3. The respondent No. 1/plaintiff instituted the suit from which these petitions arise i) for declaration that the respondent no. 1/plaintiff is the owner of land admeasuring 12 Bighas 14 Biswas of village Alipur, Delhi on the strength of documents dated 14 October, 1998 viz. Agreement to Sell, General Power of Attorney, Will, Receipt, Affidavit, Indemnity Bond executed by the respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal in favour of the respondent no. 1/plaintiff; ii) in the alternative, for recovery of Rs. 8 lacs with interest from the respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal; and, iii) for permanent injunction restraining the respondent/defendant no. 1 APG Towers Pvt. Ltd. from creating any third party interest in the aforesaid land.

4. It was inter alia the case of the respondent no. 1/plaintiff i) that the respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal had vide documents of 14 October, 1998 agreed to sell the land to the respondent no. 1/plaintiff and put the respondent no. 1/plaintiff in possession of the said land; ii) that after the judgment of the Supreme Court in Suraj Lamp & Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Haryana, (2012) 1 SCC 656 : AIR 2012 SC 206, the respondent no. 1/plaintiff approached the respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal to have the sale deed executed in favour of the respondent no. 1/plaintiff; ii) that the total sale consideration as per the documents of 14 October, 1998 was Rs. 8,00,000/- and out of which Rs. 2,00,000/- were paid to the respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal at the time of execution of the documents dated 14 October, 1998 and the respondent no. 1/plaintiff at the time of approaching the resodnent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal for having the sale deed executed in her favour tendered the balance consideration of Rs. 6,00,000/-; iii) that the respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal informed the respondent no. 1/plaintiff that since the respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal had already on 14 October, 1998 also appointed an attorney to execute the sale deed, the respondent no. 1/plaintiff should approach the said attorney; iv) that the sale deed of the land was registered in favour of the respondent no. 1/plaintiff on 5 June, 2013; v) that however the respondent no. 1/plaintiff also realized that the respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal had also executed and registered a sale deed of the same land in favour of petitioner/defendant no. 1 APG Towers Pvt. Ltd. on 3 April, 2013; vi) that petitioner/defendant no. 1 APG Towers Pvt. Ltd. also applied for mutation of the land in the revenue records in their favour and which was granted resulting in ‘deemed dispossession’ of the respondent no. 1/plaintiff from the land; vii) that the appeal preferred by the respondent no. 1/plaintiff against the order granting mutation was still pending; viii) that the petitioner/defendant no. 1 APG Towers Pvt. Ltd. and respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal applied for rejection of the plaint stating that without seeking the relief of setting aside of the sale deed executed by respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal in favour of petitioner/defendant no. 1 APG Industries Pvt. Ltd., the respondent no. 1/plaintiff was not entitled to any relief; ix) that the ancillary objections qua valuation and limitation were also taken; and, x) the said application has been dismissed by the learned ADJ.

5. I have in the circumstances, at the outset only enquired from the senior counsel for the respondent no. 1/plaintiff that the sale deed by respondent/defendant no. 2 Rakesh Bindal in favour of petitioner/defendant no. 1 APG Towers Pvt. Ltd. being of an earlier date than the sale deed in favour of the respondent No. 1/plaintiff, how can the respondent no. 1/plaintiff, without having the said sale deed set aside, assert any rights in the land and claim any reliefs with respect thereto.

6. The senior counsel for the respondent no. 1/plaintiff after some argument, under instructions, states that the respondent no. 1/plaintiff will make appropriate application in the suit for amendment of the plaint to claim the reliefs of declaration qua the sale deed in favour of petitioner/defendant no. 1 APG Towers Pvt. Ltd. and for recovery of possession and value the suit accordingly.

7. The counsels for the petitioners/defendants object.

8. It is the settled position in law (see Wasudhir Foundation…Plaintiff; v. C. Lal & Sons…Defendant. 45 (1991) DLT 556 and order dated 6 May, 2014 in FAO (OS) No. 357/2013 titled Anita Kumari Gupta v. Ved Bhushan) that an application under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC, even if filed after the filing of an application under Order VII Rule 11 of the CPC, has to be considered first.

9. The counsels for the petitioners/defendants state that in the present case, the application has already been decided.

10. The position would have been different if the applications of the petitioners/defendants had been allowed. In that case, it could have perhaps been urged that in appeal against the rejection of the plaint, the plea could not be taken (though amendment in appeal is also permissible). However in the present case, the applications were dismissed and this proceeding challenging the order of dismissal is in continuation and since the plaint has not been rejected as yet, the respondent no. 1/plaintiff is entitled to apply for amendment.

11. Accordingly, it is not deemed appropriate to hear these petitions.

12. The petitions are disposed of with the following directions:

(i) The respondent no. 1/plaintiff is at liberty to apply for amendment of the plaint on or before 11 August, 2017;

(ii) If the said application is filed, the same shall be considered by the suit Court on its own merits and it will be open to the petitioners/defendants to take all pleas in opposition thereto;

(iii) However if the application for amendment is not filed within the time aforesaid, then the right to apply for amendment in pursuance hereto shall stand closed and these petitions shall be deemed to have been allowed and the impugned order set aside and the plaint in the suit as existing shall stand rejected.

13. The respondent no. 1/plaintiff is also burdened with costs of these petitions of Rs. 1,00,000/- to each of the petitioners payable along with the application for amendment.