- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Scg Contracts India Pvt. Ltd. v. K.S. Chamankar Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant/defendant No. 1 filed applications seeking return or rejection of the plaint on the ground that this Court lacks territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit. The dispute relates to claims for payment for works allegedly executed at Maharashtra Sadan in New Delhi. The plaintiff invoked the Court's territorial jurisdiction based on the execution of works, billing, and payment activities occurring in Delhi. Defendant No. 3 (Maharashtra Sadan) has stated they are neither a proper nor necessary party and intends to seek deletion of their name. The defendant No. 1 also sought condonation of a 10-day delay in re-filing and requested extension of time to file a written statement.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether this Court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit based on the facts pleaded in the plaint, particularly regarding the place of execution of works, billing, and payments.
- Whether the plaint should be returned or rejected under Order VII Rules 10 and 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) for lack of territorial jurisdiction.
- Whether the defendant No. 1 is entitled to an extension of time to file the written statement despite the delay.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant/Defendant No. 1's Arguments
- The addresses of defendant No. 1 and defendant No. 2 are in Mumbai, indicating lack of territorial jurisdiction of this Court in Delhi.
- Defendant No. 3 (Maharashtra Sadan) is not a proper or necessary party and will apply for deletion.
- The plaintiff’s claim of territorial jurisdiction based on works executed at Maharashtra Sadan, billing, and payments in Delhi is contested.
- No leave under Section 20(b) of the CPC was sought to sue defendant No. 1 at Delhi.
- The plaintiff’s assertion that bills were raised at Delhi is false because the plaintiff submitted running bills to the Project Management Consultant (PMC) at the New Delhi site, who verified and forwarded the bills to defendants for payment.
- Payments were made by defendants either by cheque or RTGS after PMC verification at New Delhi.
- No substantial part of the cause of action arose at Delhi.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the plaint and supporting documents under the framework of Order VII Rules 10 and 11 CPC, which restrict consideration at this stage to the plaint and its averments. The Court noted that the defendant No. 1 had not filed a written statement disputing the facts pleaded in paragraph 26, which asserted territorial jurisdiction based on execution, billing, and payments in Delhi.
The Court found no inconsistency between paragraphs 15 and 26 of the plaint. It recognized that the PMC appointed by the defendants to receive and verify running bills at the New Delhi site acted as the defendants' agent, validating the plaintiff's claim that bills were submitted and payments processed in Delhi.
Further, the Court applied the legal principle that "the debtor must seek the creditor," supporting the assertion that the Courts at Delhi have territorial jurisdiction.
No other arguments were raised, and the Court concluded that the application challenging jurisdiction lacked merit.
Regarding the request for extension of time to file the written statement, the Court noted that the application appeared to have been filed to avoid the lapse of the filing deadline. Consequently, the Court granted extension only upon payment of costs by defendant No. 1 to the plaintiff's counsel, setting a strict deadline and condition for compliance.
Holding and Implications
The application challenging territorial jurisdiction was dismissed.
The defendant No. 1 was granted an extension of time to file the written statement until 15 December 2017, conditional upon payment of costs of Rs. 25,000/- to the plaintiff's counsel by the same date.
The decision maintains the Court's territorial jurisdiction over the suit based on the plaintiff's pleaded facts and does not set any new precedent. The direct effect is that the plaint remains admitted and defendant No. 1 must comply with the conditions to preserve the right to file a written statement.
Rajiv Sahai Endlaw, J.:—
IAs No. 14346/2017 (of D-1 u/O VII R-10&11 CPC) & 14347/2017 (of D-1 for condonation of 10 days delay in re-filing)
1. The applicant/defendant No. 1 seeks return/rejection of the plaint on the ground of this Court not having territorial jurisdiction to entertain the suit.
2. The counsel for the applicant/defendant No. 1 has argued (i) that in the memorandum of parties, the address of the applicant/defendant No. 1 as well as the defendant No. 2 is of Mumbai; (ii) that the counsel for the defendant No. 3 Maharashtra Sadan has already made a statement on 30 November, 2017 that they are neither proper nor necessary party and would file an appropriate application for deletion of their name; (iii) that the plaintiff in para 26 of the plaint has invoked territorial jurisdiction of this Court on the ground of the works of which payment is claimed having been executed at Maharashtra Sadan at New Delhi, the bills having been raised at New Delhi and the payments thereof having been made by the defendants to the plaintiff at Delhi and the payments due and claimed in the suit have also required to be made by the defendants to the plaintiff at New Delhi and on the basis of the plaintiff having their offices and work for gain at Delhi; (iv) that the plaintiff and the defendant No. 3 have not sought any leave under Section 20(b) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC) to sue the applicant/defendant No. 1 at Delhi; (v) that the plea of the bills having been raised at Delhi is false in view of para 15 of the plaint, where the plaintiff has pleaded that the defendants had appointed a Project Management Consultant (PMC) for the project and the plaintiff was raising running bills and the amount against the running bills was to be released after verification by the PMC; (vi) that the plaintiff submitted each running bills in favour of the defendant No. 2 at the work site at New Delhi and the bill was received by the PMC at site at New Delhi who checked and verified the bills of quantities and after verification forwarded the same to the defendants through emails and the defendants released the payment either through cheque or by RTGS; (vii) that no substantial part of the cause of action has arisen at Delhi.
3. At the stage of Order VII Rule 11 and Order VII Rule 10 of the CPC, the plaint and only the plaint and the documents of the plaintiff can be looked into. It is not as if on the averments in the plaint in the present case, if ultimately to be proved, the Courts at Delhi will not have territorial jurisdiction. The applicant/defendant No. 1 till ate has not filed the written statement and it is not known, whether the applicant/defendant No. 1 is disputing or controverting the facts as pleaded in para 26 of the plaint.
4. There is no inconsistency between para 26 and para 15 as is sought to be contended. The plaintiff has pleaded that the defendants had appointed PMC to whom the bills were to be submitted at New Delhi. The said PMC appointed by the defendants would be the agent of the defendants for receipt of the bills and it cannot be said that there is any apparent falsity in the plea of the plaintiff in para 26 of the plaint of the bills being submitted at New Delhi.
5. Even otherwise, I have drawn attention of the counsel for the applicant/defendant No. 1 to the principle of ‘debtor must seek the creditor’ and applying which principle also the Courts at Delhi would have territorial jurisdiction.
6. No other argument has been raised.
7. There is no merit in the application.
8. Dismissed.
CS(COMM) 199/2017
9. The counsel for the defendant No. 1 now states that seven days time be granted to file written statement.
10. None appears for the plaintiff inspite of advance copy stated to have been given.
11. The counsel for the plaintiff having not bothered to appear, need to issue notice to him for consideration of the said request, is not felt.
12. Though I refrained from imposing costs on the defendant No. 1, though the application aforesaid was found to be totally misconceived but now it appears that the application was filed only to avoid over the time for filing the written statement which had lapsed.
13. Further time cannot be granted without imposition of costs on the defendant No. 1.
14. Subject to the defendant No. 1 paying costs of Rs. 25,000/- to the counsel for the plaintiff on or before 15 December, 2017, the time for filing the written statement is extended till 15 December, 2017. If either of the conditions is not complied with, the right of the defendant No. 1 to file written statement shall stand closed without any further order.
Alert