- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
(1) M/S Sai Sulphonates Pvt. Ltd. v. (2) Shri Smarajit Kumar Pal, Director Of No. (1) (S)
Structured Summary of the Tribunal Opinion (P.K. Choudhary, Judicial Member)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeals were filed against Order-in-Appeal Nos. 18/Kol.III/2013 dated 30.03.2013 and 56-57/Kol.V/2016 dated 14.09.2016 passed by the Commissioner of Central Excise (Appeals), Kolkata. The appellants are M/s. Sai Sulphonate Private Limited (Appellant No. 1) and its Director, Shri Samarjit Kumar Pal (Appellant No. 2). The company manufactures LABSA (Acid Slurry) (Chapter 34, CETA 1985) at two factories (Sarsuna and Jugberia) and produces a by-product, Spent Sulphuric Acid (Chapter 28).
On 23.08.2007 officers of DGCEI visited both factory premises and the office and seized records. Show-cause notices dated 30.11.2010 were issued proposing demands of duty, interest and penalties.
For the Jugberia Unit (Appeal No. E/70866/2013) the allegation was clandestine manufacture and removal during the period 12.10.2006 to 23.07.2007 (specific weighment-related demand referred to the period 12.10.2006 to 30.10.2006). The Adjudicating Authority confirmed demand of duty and imposed equal amount penalty on the company and a personal penalty on the Director; the Commissioner (Appeals) earlier set aside the penalty on the Director but, by the impugned order, upheld the adjudication. The company filed appeal to the Tribunal.
For the Sarsuna Unit (Appeal Nos. E/77038/2016 & E/77039/2016) the allegation related to entries in seized exercise books (dated 21.12.2015) showing dispatches without Central Excise invoices and without duty payment. The Adjudicating Authority confirmed demands and imposed penalties, including a Rs. 5 lakh penalty on the Director. The company and its Director appealed to the Tribunal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the charge of clandestine removal of finished goods can be sustained when it is based primarily on loose slips/private rough documents that lack description of goods and are disowned by the assessee.
- Whether entries in rough weighment/exercise books (seized) are sufficiently reliable to sustain a demand for duty for alleged removals without invoice/duty payment.
- Whether demand of duty on alleged shortages detected in stock verification is maintainable where stock verification used dip-method, weighment slips are absent, and some storage tanks were not considered in the verification (i.e., whether the stock-taking procedure and its recordation were adequate).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The charge of clandestine removal was founded on "loose slips" (three particular loose slips) which do not mention the description of goods; thus it is unclear whether the records relate to Acid Slurry or the by-product Spent Sulphuric Acid.
- The value differential between Acid Slurry (approx. Rs. 46,000 per MT) and Spent Sulphuric Acid (approx. Rs. 1,500 per MT) makes the distinction material; the department did not investigate this distinction based on the loose slips.
- The loose slips were disowned by the appellant and the department did not verify the entries by examining transporters/drivers or buyers.
- For Sarsuna Unit, entries in the rough weighment exercise books were unreliable: errors in lorry numbers, implausible loading/return timings (e.g., trips to Sumerpur and reload within 2-3 days), and misdescription (LAB shown as Acid Slurry) make the rough entries untrustworthy for raising demands.
- Nine consignments had proper Central Excise Invoices and corresponding weighments — copies of invoices were enclosed — therefore demands for those consignments are not maintainable.
- Two consignments had no entry in the rough exercise books but were nevertheless included in the demand.
- Regarding shortage demands, stock verification was done by dip-stock method; weighment slips were not on record; there were 12 storage tanks and two tanks were not considered in the stock verification. The appellants provided explanation for the omissions and the lower authorities did not contest that material fact.
Revenue's Arguments
- The loose slips were recovered from the appellant's factory and therefore formed a basis for the charge.
- The department's position (as put by the Authorized Representative) was that goods, although loaded into tankers, were tested and not accepted by buyers; allegedly the goods were not delivered — but the department maintained the records supported demand.
- The department submitted that the enquiry officer need not have examined transporters/drivers in each instance to rely on the seized documents.
- The Authorized Representative relied upon a precedent (Somani Iron & Steels Ltd. v. Cestat) relating to clandestine removal framed on private records.
- For shortage claims the Revenue relied on the Madras High Court decision in Alagappa Cement Pvt. Ltd. v. CEGAT, which held that onus lies on the assessee for clandestine shortage and defects in record-keeping.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Somani Iron & Steels Ltd. v. Cestat, 2011 (270) ELT 189 (Allahabad) | Relied upon by the Revenue's Authorized Representative for the proposition concerning clandestine removal framed on private records. | The Tribunal noted that Somani dealt with clandestine removal based on private records but held that it was not applicable here because in the present case the loose slips were disowned by the appellant; therefore the decision was not followed. |
| Gupta Synthetics Ltd. v. CCEx., 2014 (312) ELT 225 (Tri.-Ahmd.) | Cited by the Learned Counsel for the appellant (specific principle not stated in the opinion). | The opinion records that the counsel relied upon this authority; the Tribunal's reasons do not elaborate an application of this specific case to facts. |
| CCEx. v. Saakeen Alloys Pvt. Ltd., 2014 (308) ELT 655 (Guj.) | Cited by the Learned Counsel for the appellant (specific principle not stated in the opinion). | The opinion records reliance by the appellant's counsel; the Tribunal did not expressly apply or distinguish this decision in its reasoning as recorded. |
| CCEx, Chandigarh I v. Laxmi Engineering Works, 2010 (254) ELT 205 (P & H) | Cited by the Learned Counsel for the appellant (specific principle not stated in the opinion). | Recorded as relied upon by counsel; no further specific application or analysis of this precedent appears in the Tribunal's reasoning. |
| CCEx, Chandigarh I v. Shingar Lamps Pvt. Ltd., 2010 (255) ELT 221 (P & H) | Cited by the Learned Counsel for the appellant (specific principle not stated in the opinion). | Cited by counsel; the Tribunal's written reasons do not indicate detailed reliance or disapproval of this authority. |
| CCEx. v. Arsh Casting Pvt. Ltd., 2010 (252) ELT 191 (H.P.) | Cited by the Learned Counsel for the appellant (specific principle not stated in the opinion). | Included in the list of authorities relied on by counsel; the Tribunal's analysis does not specifically apply this case. |
| CCEx., Haldia v. Lord's Chemicals Ltd., 2009 (245) ELT 695 (Tri.-Kol) | Cited by the Learned Counsel for the appellant (specific principle not stated in the opinion). | Recorded as relied upon by counsel; Tribunal's reasons do not expressly apply its rule to the present facts. |
| K. Rajagopal v. CCEx., Madurai, 2002 (142) ELT 128 (Tri.-Chennai) | Cited by the Learned Counsel for the appellant (specific principle not stated in the opinion). | Listed among the authorities relied upon; the Tribunal's decision does not elaborate a specific application of this precedent. |
| Commissioner Of Central Excise, Raipur v. Anil Agrawal, 2013 (287) ELT 489 (Tri. Del.) | Cited by the Learned Counsel for the appellant (specific principle not stated in the opinion). | Appears in the list of authorities relied upon by counsel; the Tribunal's written reasoning does not specifically discuss its application. |
| Alagappa Cement Private Limited v. CEGAT, Chennai, 2010 (260) ELT 511 (Madras) | Relied upon by the Revenue's Authorized Representative; recorded in the opinion as holding that the onus is on the assessee for clandestine shortage and defects in maintenance of records. | The Tribunal noted the precedent's rule but found it not applicable on facts because the appellants explained that two storage tanks' stock was not considered during verification and that fact was not seriously disputed by lower authorities; hence the Madras High Court authority did not dictate rejection of the appellant's explanation here. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal considered evidence and submissions for both units (Jugberia and Sarsuna) and reached conclusions grounded on the documentary record and the conduct of investigation as recorded in the appeal papers. The court's analysis proceeded in the following principal steps, reflecting only what appears in the opinion:
- Examination of the basis for clandestine removal (Jugberia Unit):
- The Tribunal observed that the charge was primarily founded on "loose slips" recovered from the factory and on statements recorded at the time of seizure.
- It found that the loose slips did not mention consignee names or descriptions of goods. The appellant had disowned those slips. The absence of description left open whether entries related to Acid Slurry or the by-product Spent Sulphuric Acid.
- The Tribunal noted no meaningful enquiry (such as examining transporters/drivers or buyers) had been made to verify whether goods were actually delivered or accepted by buyers.
- Given the lack of basic particulars in the slips and the absence of corroborative investigation, the Tribunal held that the charge of clandestine removal could not be sustained on the basis of the loose slips alone. The Tribunal specifically distinguished Somani (cited by Revenue) as not applicable because here the loose slips were disowned.
- Evaluation of rough weighment/exercise book entries (Sarsuna Unit):
- The Tribunal accepted the appellant's submission that the rough exercise book entries contained manifest errors — wrong vehicle numbers, implausible trip timings, and misdescription of product types — which undermined their reliability for establishing unsold/undutied removals.
- The Tribunal noted that nine consignments were supported by proper Central Excise Invoices and corresponding weighments, and thus demand in respect of those consignments was not maintainable.
- The court also observed that for two consignments there was no entry in the rough books but demand was still raised — further weakening the department's claim based on the seized books.
- Assessment of shortage demands arising from stock verification:
- The Tribunal recorded that stock verification was carried out by dip-stock method and that weighment slips were not on record.
- The appellant explained that there were 12 storage tanks and that two tanks' stock was not considered during the stock verification; this explanation was set out in the appellant's submissions and statement of the company's employee (Shri Tapas Acharya).
- The Tribunal found that the lower authorities did not rebut this fact with contrary material and, on that basis, concluded that the demand for duty on the alleged shortages could not be accepted.
- The Tribunal acknowledged the Revenue's citation of Alagappa Cement (Madras) for the proposition that the onus is on the assessee for clandestine shortage, but held that given the specific factual explanation about omitted tanks (not seriously disputed), that precedent did not carry the day for the Revenue in this case.
- Overall assessment and relief:
- Because the clandestine removal charges rested on disowned and non-descriptive loose slips without adequate investigative corroboration, and because the shortage demands were undermined by the undisputed fact that two tanks were excluded from stock verification, the Tribunal concluded that the impugned orders confirming demands and penalties could not be sustained.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The impugned orders of the Commissioner (Appeals) confirming the adjudication were set aside and the appeals filed by the appellants were allowed. (The opinion states: "In view of the above discussion, the impugned Orders cannot be sustained and accordingly set aside. The appeals filed by the appellants are allowed.")
Implications:
- The direct effect is that the demands of duty and penalties confirmed by the adjudicating authority and upheld in the impugned orders could not be sustained on the material before the Tribunal, and the appellants' appeals were allowed.
- The Tribunal's reasoning rested on the specific deficiencies in the department's documentary basis (disowned/indeterminate loose slips, unreliable rough weighment records) and on an unrefuted factual explanation about omitted storage tanks in stock verification. The opinion does not announce any new general principle of law beyond application of existing principles to these facts.
- The Tribunal explicitly found certain cited precedents inapplicable on the facts (for example, Somani Iron & Steels Ltd. and Alagappa Cement were considered but not held to mandate a contrary outcome on these facts).
P.K. Choudhary, Judicial Member:— These appeals have been filed by the appellants against the Order-in-Appeal Nos. 18/Kol.III/2013 dated 30.03.2013 & 56-57/Kol.V/2016 dt. 14.09.2016 both passed by Commr. of Central Excise (Appeals), Kolkata.
2.1 Briefly stated the facts of the case are as under:
2.2 The appellants are engaged in the manufacture of LABSA (Acid Slurry) classifiable under Chapter 34 to the Central Excise Tariff Act (CETA), 1985 through its factory situated at Sarsuna and Jugberia registered with the Central Excise Department separately. A bye product namely Spent Sulphuric Acid classifiable under Chapter 28 of CETA was emerged in continuous operation system and cleared on payment of duty. On 23.08.2007, the Officer of DGCEI visited the appellant's both the factories premises and office Premises and seized various records and documents.
2.3 Show Cause Notices dated 30.11.2010 were issued to M/s. Sai Sulphonate Private Limited (Appellant No. 1) for both Jugberia Unit and Sarsuna Unit and its Director Shri Samarjit Kumar Pal (Appellant No. 2) proposing demand of duty along with interest and to impose penalty.
2.4 In respect of Appeal No. E/70866/2013 (Jugberia Unit), it has been alleged that during the period from 12.10.2006 to 23.07.2007 the appellant clandestinely manufactured and removed their finished goods without payment of duty. There is a demand of duty of Rs. 4,80,516.00 on the charge of clandestine removal of the finished goods and denial of Cenvat Credit of Rs. 3,968.00 on the inputs. The Adjudicating authority confirmed the Central Excise duty of Rs. 4,84,484.00 along with interest and imposed penalty of equal amount of duty on the appellant company and also imposed personal penalty of Rs. 1,00,000.00 on the Director, Shri Samarjit Kr. Pal. The Commr. (Appeals) vide Order-in-Appeal No. 05/Kol.III/2014 dated 20.03.2014 set aside the penalty imposed on the Director. By the impugned Order the Commissioner (Appeals) upheld the Adjudication Order. Hence, the Appellant Company filed the instant appeal.
2.5 In respect of Appeal Nos. E/77038/2016 & E/77039/2016 (Sarsuna Unit), it has been alleged that the entries dated 21.12.2015 of the seized exercise books, show dispatch of the finished goods from the factory of the Appellant No. (1) without issuance of Central Excise Invoice and without payment of Central Excise duty. Show-cause notice proposed to demand of Rs. 25,51,360/- along with interest. The Adjudicating Authority confirmed the demand of Central Excise duty of Rs. 25,74,565/- along with interest and imposed a penalty of equal amount of duty on the Appellant Company and also imposed penalty of Rs. 5.00 lakhs on Shri Samarjit Kr. Pal, Director of the Appellant Company. Hence, the Appellant Company and its Director filed these appeals.
3. Heard both sides and perused the appeal records.
4. With regard to the Appeal of Jugberia Unit, I find that on 23.08.2007 the Central Excise Officers visited the appellant's factory and office and seized several records and also recorded the statement of Shri Tapas Kumar Acharya, Commercial Executive of the appellant company. There is a demand of duty of Rs. 3,73,503.00 on 41.4 M.T.s of Acid Slurry alleged to have been cleared clandestinely during the period from 12.10.2006 to 30.10.2006. There is a further demand of Rs. 1,07,014.00 and Rs. 3,967.00 on shortage of finished goods and duty paid inputs as detected during the Stock Verification.
5. The appellant contended that the charge of clandestine removal is based on some loose slips and in particular against three loose slips. The Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant argued that there is no mention of the description of the goods in these three loose slips. It is further contended that it is not clear from the statement and the documents as to whether the appellant cleared the Acid Slurry or its bye product Spent Sulphuric Acid. It is submitted that the value of Spent Sulphuric Acid is much less than the value of the Acid Slurry. The value of the Acid Slurry during the period was Rs. 46,000.00 per M.T. (approximately) whereas the value of Spent Sulphuric Acid was only Rs. 1,500.00 per M.T. The department had not made any enquiry on the basis of the said loose slips. The Learned Counsel particularly submitted that the appellant disowned the said documents.
6. With regard to the Sarsuna Unit, the appellant submits that the entries in the rough exercise books, it is evident that the entries in the rough weighment exercise books were not at all reliable. This was mentioned in the statement placed at P/147 & 147A of the Appeal Paper Book. On a perusal of the said statement, it would be evident that there are apparent errors in mentioning the lorry numbers inasmuch as such lorries were shown to have been loaded and the goods were sent to Sumerpur, U.P. and it was shown that the said lorries were again loaded within 2-3 days, which is absurd and impossible. It is not possible for a tanker lorry to carry the goods to Sumerpur in U.P. and to return and again to place for loading within 2/3 days. In some cases, it was also shown that receipt of LAB had been wrongly shown that Acid Slurry in the rough weighment. Hence, it was submitted by the appellant that the entries in the rough weighment exercise books, were not reliable for the purpose of raising the demand.
7. The appellant in their submission dated 31.08.2016 before the ld. Commissioner (Appeals) further stated that in respect of 9 (nine) consignments, the weighments were covered by proper Central Excise Invoices. Those entries correspond with the Central Excise invoices, copies of which had also been enclosed along with their submissions. Hence, in such cases, the demand of duty was not maintainable. There were mistakes in the dates, vehicle numbers etc. in the rough exercise books. This will be evident from the statement at Page 137 of the Appeal Paper Book.
8. The appellant also submitted that in respect of two consignments as mentioned in the statement at Page 158 of the Appeal Paper Book, there was no entry in the rough exercise books, but demand of duty had been raised.
9. On the other hand the Learned Authorized Representative on behalf of the Revenue submitted that the loose Slips were recovered from the factory of the appellant. I find that the appellant took a stand before the lower authorities that the demand was raised on the basis of rough piece of paper alleged to be maintained by the employee of the appellant company. The goods although loaded in the Tanker, but before removal of the goods from their factory, those were tested to see as to whether the goods were in accordance with the specifications of their customers, but these goods were not found according to the specification of the buyer and the goods were not unloaded, the goods were not delivered from the factory. The main contention of the appellant is that the Enquiry Officer have not examined the Transporter/Truck Driver and whether the lorry was actually sent to the destination. Hence, the demand of duty on the basis of such documents cannot be sustained.
10. I find that the employee of the appellant company had not mentioned the name of the consignee in respect of the clearance on the basis of loose slips. I also find that the loose slips do not mention the description of the goods. Thus, there is force in the argument of the Learned Counsel as to whether the loose slips were used for the clearance of the Acid Slurry or Spent Sulphuric Acid. Apparently, the Investigating Officer had made out the case of such clandestine removal on the basis of the loose slips without basis of any enquiry to the extent of clearance of the goods, buyer name through investigation. Hence, the charge of clandestine removal merely on the basis of the loose slips, cannot be sustained. The Learned Authorised Representative relied upon the decision of the Hon'ble Allahabad High Court in the case of Somani Iron & Steels Ltd. v. Cestat, 2011 (270) ELT 189 (Allahabad). In that case the charge of clandestine removal was framed on the basis of private records. In the present case the charge was made on the basis of loose slips which were disowned by the appellant. Therefore, the said Case Law is not applicable herein.
11. The Learned Counsel has relied upon the various decisions of the Tribunal and High Court as under:—
(i) Gupta Synthetics Ltd. v. CCEx., Ahmd. II: 2014 (312) ELT 225 (Tri.-Ahmd.);
(ii) CCEx. v. Saakeen Alloys Pvt. Ltd.: 2014 (308) ELT 655 (Guj.);
(iii) CCEx, Chandigarh I v. Laxmi Engineering Works: 2010 (254) ELT 205 (P & H);
(iv) CCEx, Chandigarh I v. Shingar Lamps Pvt. Ltd.: 2010 (255) ELT 221 (P & H);
(v) CCEx. v. Arsh Casting Pvt. Ltd.: 2010 (252) ELT 191 (H.P);
(vi) CCEx., Haldia v. Lord's Chemicals Ltd.: 2009 (245) ELT 695 (Tri.-Kol);
(vii) K. Rajagopal v. CCEx., Madurai: 2002 (142) ELT 128 (Tri.-Chennai);
(viii) CCEx., Commissioner Of Central Excise, Raipur v. Anil Agrawal: 2013 (287) ELT 489 (Tri. Del.).
12. Regarding the shortage of the materials, the appellant has contended that the weighment was not done physically and there was no weighment slip available on record. The Stock Verification was done by method of Dip Stock Taking for the measurement of the dips of the material in the storage tank. The main contention of the Learned Counsel of the appellant is as under—
“In the present case, it is mentioned in the reply to the show-cause notice that there were 12 storage tanks in their factory for storing of raw materials as well as finished goods. Shri Tapas Acharya specifically mentioned in his statement submitted before the Central Excise Officers that they have 12 storage tanks of which 2 tanks were used for storing LAB as input and 2 tanks were used for storing Sulphuric Acid as input, 1 tank was used for storing Spent Sulphuric Acid as finished by-product., 4 tanks were used for Acid Slurury as finished products, 3 tanks were used for storing intermediate products, though recorded in the finished account based on the per charge ratio of calculation maintained on the date of stock taking. Physical stock was not ascertained of those 3 intermediate tanks resulting in shortage of 11064 kgs. of Acid Slurry, which were of low AD materials. Likewise, for shortage of finished by-product, Spent Sulphuric Acid to the extent of 6135.8 kgs., as not clarified by Sri Acharya that no individual tankwise verification was conducted, rather consolidated stock verification report was prepared by the said stock taking officers and placed for confirmation. The physical stock verification was not, therefore, not proper and tenable. The appellants submit that since the stock verification was not done properly and the method of stock verification has not been mentioned in the show-cause notice, and the calculation sheets have not been enclosed in the show-cause notice, such alleged shortage with regard to finished goods and raw materials are not maintainable”.
13. I find that the appellant raised these facts before the lower authorities. It appears from the record that the stock of two tanks was not considered during the stock verification. The appellant raised this issue before the lower authorities and it was not refuted by any material. As such, the demand of duty on the shortage cannot be accepted. The Learned A/R of the Revenue referred to the decision of the Hon'ble Madras High Court, in the case of Alagappa Cement Private Limited v. CEGAT, Chennai - 2010 (260) ELT (511) (Madras). In that case, the Hon'ble High Court held that the onus is on the Assessee for clandestine shortage and defect in maintenance of records. In the present case the appellant had given the explanation for alleged shortage in so far as stock of two tanks was not considered. This fact was not seriously disputed by the lower authorities. Hence, the case laws would not be applicable herein.
14. In view of the above discussion, the impugned Orders cannot be sustained and accordingly set aside. The appeals filed by the appellants are allowed.
Alert