- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Union Of India v. Service No. 3001528M Sanjay Kumar Singh
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent-plaintiff was enrolled in the Army on 17 June 2000 and discharged on 1 September 2000. He filed a civil suit before the Civil Judge, Civil Court Farrukhabad, challenging the legality of his discharge and alleging that the second medical examination conducted at the Regimental Centre was not mandatory and was biased. The Civil Judge (Junior Division), Farrukhabad, by order dated 23 November 2012, held the discharge order null and void and directed reinstatement of the respondent-plaintiff into Army service with all consequential benefits. Aggrieved, the Union of India and others preferred Civil Appeal No. 32 of 2005 before the District Judge, Farrukhabad, which was transferred to the Armed Forces Tribunal under Section 34 of the Armed Forces Tribunal Act, 2007, and registered as T.A. No. 35 of 2011.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the second medical examination of the respondent-plaintiff under the Unit Headquarter Quota (UHQ) was mandatory and lawful.
- Whether the discharge of the respondent-plaintiff on medical grounds was justified and in accordance with Army rules and regulations.
- Whether the Civil Judge (Junior Division), Farrukhabad, erred in holding that the discharge was illegal due to arbitrariness, bias, and violation of natural justice principles.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The respondent-plaintiff was enrolled under the Unit Headquarter Quota and was medically examined and declared fit initially.
- As per Army HQ letter No. 76063/DGMS-5A dated 6 July 1999, a mandatory second medical examination is required for recruits under UHQ quota.
- The respondent-plaintiff was referred for the second medical examination in accordance with this mandatory procedure.
- The second medical board found the respondent-plaintiff suffering from a deformity, "CUBITUS VALGUS (RIGHT)," which was a skeletal abnormality since childhood, assessed as a permanent disability not attributable to or aggravated by military service (NANA).
- The respondent-plaintiff was invalided out due to this medical deformity, which disqualified him from military service as per Army standards.
- The Civil Judge erred in holding that the petitioners acted arbitrarily or with bias and in faulting the absence of the medical officer as a party, which was legally incorrect.
Respondent-Plaintiff's Arguments
- The discharge was illegal.
- The second medical examination conducted at the Regimental Centre was not mandatory and was biased.
- The petitioners failed to produce the medical officer to rebut allegations of bias.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined the Army HQ letter No. 76063/DGMS-5A dated 6 July 1999, which mandates a second medical examination for recruits under the Unit Headquarter Quota. The respondent-plaintiff was lawfully referred for this examination, where he was diagnosed with a permanent skeletal abnormality (CUBITUS VALGUS) that disqualified him from military service. The court noted that the Civil Judge failed to consider the medical fitness standards necessary for recruitment and continuance in the Army and erred in holding that the petitioners acted arbitrarily or with bias. The court also observed that the respondent-plaintiff had not sued the medical officer personally, making the Civil Judge’s criticism of the petitioners for not producing the medical officer legally unsound. The tribunal found that the medical disability was a valid ground for discharge and that the respondent-plaintiff was not entitled to reinstatement.
Holding and Implications
The Transferred Application No. 35 of 2011 is allowed and the order dated 23 November 2002 passed by the Civil Judge (Junior Division) Farrukhabad is set aside.
The effect of this decision is the dismissal of the respondent-plaintiff’s claim for reinstatement following discharge on medical grounds. No costs were ordered. The ruling does not establish any new precedent but affirms the mandatory nature of the second medical examination and the validity of discharge based on permanent medical disability as per Army regulations.
B.B.P. Sinha, Armed Forces Member:— Being aggrieved by the decision of the Civil Judge, Civil Court Farrukhabad for Mandatory Injunction in terms of Section 39 of “Specific Relief Act” against the present petitioners, the Union of India & Others preferred Civil Appeal No. 32 of 2005 in the Court of District Judge, Farrukhabad which has been transferred to this Tribunal under Section 34 of the Armed Forces Tribunal Act, 2007 and has been registered as T.A. No. 35 of 2011.
2. Brief facts, as borne out from the Transferred Application are that the respondent-plaintiff was enrolled in the Army as on 17.06.2000 and discharged on 01.09.2000. The respondent-plaintiff after discharge from Army filed a Civil Suit before Civil Judge, Civil Court Farrukhabad wherein he had pleaded that his discharge is illegal and second medical examination carried out in the Regimental Centre is not mandatory and has been done in a biased manner. The Civil Judge (Junior Division), Farrukhabad in his decision dated 23.11.2012 held that the respondent-plaintiff's discharge order dated 01.11.2000/31.12.2000 is null and void and he be reinstated into the Army service on the rank held with all consequential benefits.
3. We have heard Shri Yogesh Kesarwani, Learned Counsel for the petitioners, Shri Yash Pal Singh, Learned Counsel for the respondent and perused the record.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that Sanjay Kumar Singh (Respondent-plaintiff) was enrolled into Rajput Regimental Centre, Fatehgarh on 17 June 2000 under Unit Headquarter Quota (UHQ). He was medically examined by Lt Col AK Jain, Regimental Medical Officer (RMO), The Rajput Regimental Centre on 22 June 2000 during the recruitment rally and declared fit. In accordance with Army HQ letter No. 76063/DGMS-5A dated 06 July 1999, the individual was sent to Military Hospital, Fatehgarh for second medical examination, from where he was further referred to Command Hospital, Lucknow. The individual was diagnosed as having deformity 20 degree carrying angle, CUBITUS VALGUS (RIGHT) and was found unfit in the Second Medical examination by a Medical Board. The disease ‘CUBITUS VALGUS” was opined by the Second Medical Board conducted in October 2000 to be ‘SKELETAL ABNORMALITY SINCE CHILDHOOD”. The disability was assessed as 6-10% for life which was opined ‘neither attributable to nor aggravated by military service (NANA)’.
5. We have carefully gone through the impugned judgment of learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) Farrukhabad.
6. The learned Civil Judge has held that the onus to prove the reason for referring the respondent-plaintiff for second medical examination was upon the petitioner-respondent which has not been discharged. In this regard, it may be mentioned that Army HQ letter No. 76063/DGMS-5A dated 06 July 1999 provides for a second Medical Examination, thus, the decision of the authority for referring the respondent-plaintiff for second Medical Examination cannot be said to be illegal or against the Rules and
7. Regulations. For convenience sake, Army HQ letter No. 76063/DGMS-5A dated 06 July 1999 is reproduced as under:—
“Tele: 3011063Dte Gen of Medical Services (Army)
Adjutant General's Branch
Army HQ “L” Block N. Delhi-110001
76063/DGMS/5A06 July 99
Headquarters
Southern Command (Med)
Eastern Command (Med)
Central Command (Med)
Northern Command (Med)
Western Command (Med)
RECRUITING MEDICAL PROCEDURES: ZROs
MODIFICATION
1. Changes as under have been made in the second medical examination procedures for candidates recruited through ZROs/BRO, UHQ quota:—
(a) Candidates recruited through UHQ quota will be subjected to a second medical examination at the authorized hospital. Centres will liaise with the Commandants/CO's hospital for the necessary arrangements. Candidates found fit/unfit will be dealt with in accordance with the procedure so far followed for ZRO/BRO recruited candidates second medical examination. ZRO/BRO recruited recruits will continue to undergo a second medical examination as hither to.
(b) Status of recruits found unfit at second medical examination. It has been clarified by the Rtg Dte that the personnel being subjected to the second medical examination are recruits. They will thus be treated as Recruits and not judged by standards for fresh Recruitment. Thus recruits with correctible disabilities like hydrocele etc will be referred to the authorized hospitals for treatment and retained in series in accordance with the stipulations of MT 3 letter No A/203/4/MT-3 dated 20 Feb 86 (Photocopy attached). All concerned and in particularly Sr Advisers in all specialties may be advised to ensure action on the subject. Present practice of declaring recruits unfit for treatable disabilities will ceases forthwith.
2. Contents of this letter may e disseminated to all concerned under your jurisdiction.
3. Please ack.
(Auth: Minutes of the meeting held in AG's office on 26 Apr 99).
Sd/- x x x x x
(AB Pradhan)
Dir MS (PS)
For DGMS (Army)
Encls: As mentioned
Copy to:—
AG/Rtg Dte 6SP - Necessary instructions for subjecting UHQ candidates to a second medical examination be issued at earliest.
AG's Sectt - for information.”
(Emphasis Supplied)
8. The respondent-plaintiff was recruited in the Unit Headquarter Quota (UHQ). Thus, the petitioner-respondents were well within their right to refer the respondent-plaintiff for second Medical Examination. As per Army Headquarter letter, quoted hereinabove, every recruit enrolled in the Army is required to undergo a mandatory second medical examination. On the basis of said Army letter the respondent-plaintiff was referred for Second Medical Examination in which he was found suffering from deformity of ‘CUBITUS VALGUS (RIGHT) which according to the Second Medical Board would persist throughout life.
9. It is also worthwhile to mention that vide order dated 31.08.2017, this Tribunal directed the respondent-plaintiff to appear before the Medical Board on 08.09.2017 in Command Hospital Lucknow for further examination and re-assessment of his disability. On re-assessment of the disability of the respondent-plaintiff, the Medical Board found that his disability “CUBITUS VALGUS BOTH ELBOW” is 6% to 10% due to non service factor with remark “Disability is normal developmental condition of elbow and not acceptable as per standard of recruitment of Army”.
10. The opinion of Graded Specialist (Orthopaedics), Base Hospital, Lucknow exhibits that “Individual was detected to be having a carrying angle of both elbow of 20o. This was more than the cut off limit of 10o as required for army recruitment at that time which was later revised to 15o. The Medical Specialist in his Opinion in Part III observed that “This is a normal developmental condition of elbow. However the cut off degree of carrying angle for requirement for recruitment in army has been laid down as 15o, presently by relevant Army Orders.”
11. There being mandatory requirement of Second Medical Examination of individuals recruited under the Unit Headquarter Quota, there is no bias on the part of the concerned Medical Officer of the Army in referring the respondent-plaintiff for Second Medical Examination. The respondent-plaintiff was invalided due to medical deformity which as per Medical opinion would persist throughout the life and is not permissible as per Military standards which would have disallowed the respondent-plaintiff to become an efficient solider. The learned Civil Judge has not taken all these vital factors into consideration while allowing the case of the respondent-plaintiff.
12. The learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Farrukhabad while allowing the claim of the respondent-plaintiff has held that the action of the petitioner-respondents suffers from the vice of arbitrariness, bias and the principles of natural justice have not been followed. The learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) Farrukhabad has held that the petitioner-respondents have not produced the Medical Officer concerned to refute the grounds taken by the respondent-plaintiff and the order invaliding out the respondent-plaintiff suffers from bias. We are of the opinion that the ground taken by the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) Farrukhabad is per se wrong inasmuch as the respondent-plaintiff had not arrayed the Medical Officer in personal capacity. Thus, the learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) Farrukhabad committed a legal wrong while arriving at a finding that the petitioner-respondents have not produced the Medical Officer to disprove bias. Thus, the findings recorded by the Civil Judge (Junior Division) Farrukhabad on this count cannot be upheld.
13. We have carefully gone through the judgment of the Court below and are of the considered opinion that it does not deal with the vital issue of medical fitness necessary for recruitment and continuance in the Army for an efficient solider. The medical disability suffered by the respondent-plaintiff does not entitled him to be retained in the Army service.
14. In the result, Transferred Application No. 35 of 2011 is allowed and the order dated 23.11.2002 passed by Civil Judge (Junior Division) Farrukhabad is set aside.
15. No order as to costs.
Alert