Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shivkumar Kanhiyalal Shrivastav v. Rahul Sudhakar Anantwar .

Bombay High Court
Sep 5, 2018

Z.A. Haq, J.:— Heard.

2. This appeal is filed by the original complainant to challenge the judgment passed by the learned Magistrate, dismissing the complaint filed by him under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (for short “the Act of 1881”) and acquitting the respondent.

3. According to the complainant, mother of the accused was owner of 4.07% undivided portion of plot No. 2, admeasuring 1539.848 Sq. Mtrs. of Khasara No. 42/52, Mouja Khamla in Vasant Gruhnirman Sahakari Sanstha, Vyankatesh Nagar, Khamla together with apartment BS-4 Pranav Apartment admeasuring 60.78 Sq. Mtrs.. The accused was in need of money and, therefore, he approached the complainant with proposal of sale of the property. The complainant agreed to purchase the property and during further discussions, the accused had assured the complainant that he would obtain power of attorney from his mother and execute the sale-deed in favour of the complainant. As relations between the families of the complainant and the accused were good, the complainant accepted the proposal of the accused and it was agreed that the property would be sold for Rs. 25,00,000/- and the complainant had given an amount of Rs. 2,50,000/- to the accused as earnest money and earnest money note was executed on 28 February, 2012. As per the agreement, the sale-deed was to be executed within six months. The sale-deed could not be executed and, therefore, the accused had given the cheque (Exh. No. 25) dated 5 March, 2013 to refund the amount of Rs. 2,50,000/- received by him as earnest money. The complainant had deposited the cheque on the same day, however, it was not honoured and returned to the complainant by the bank alongwith memo dated 7 March, 2013 stating that the account was closed. The complainant had issued notice (Exh. No. 28) pointing out to the accused that the cheque issued by him was not honoured and calling upon the accused to pay the amount. The accused refused to accept the notice and it was returned to the complainant with the endorsement “unclaimed” and, therefore, the complainant filed the complaint under Section 138 of the Act of 1881.

4. The learned Magistrate, after conducting the trial, has recorded that the complainant has failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the accused had issued cheque (Exh. No. 25) towards discharge of legal debt or other liability, and dismissed the complaint.

5. The learned Magistrate has recorded that the cheque (Exh. No. 25) was of the account of Synergy Solution and Incorporation and the evidence of Saurabh Sushantkumar Chatergee (D.W.1), who was working as Deputy Branch Manager in H.S.B.C. bank at the relevant time, shows that the account of which cheque (Exh. No. 25) was issued, was operated by Vipin Dhopte. Learned Magistrate has further recorded that the cheque (Exh. No. 25) was issued on 5 March, 2013, however, the account was closed by the bank in 2010 and, therefore, the cheque was not having any legal sanctity. The learned Magistrate has relied on the fact that the agreement of sale (Exh. No. 27) was not registered and the complainant had not shown that mother of the accused had authorized the accused to enter into the agreement of sale. In the above facts, learned Magistrate recorded the findings that the complainant has failed to prove that the cheque (Exh. No. 25) was issued to discharge legally enforceable debt or other liability.

6. In the statement recorded under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code while answering the question No. 20, the accused stated that the cheque in question was taken by son of the complainant from the office of accused, at the back of the accused and without his knowledge. In the statement under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code, the accused has nowhere stated that he was not having any concern with Synergy Solution and Incorporation. There is nothing in the statement of the accused recorded under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code to suggest that the account of which the cheque (Exh. No. 25) was given was not operated by the accused and was operated by Vipin Dhopte only.

7. The accused has not disputed the signature on the cheque (Exh. No. 25). It is not the case of the accused that the other entries on the cheque are not in his handwriting. The notice (Exh. No. 27) was sent by the complainant on the address known to the complainant, however, the envelope containing the notice is returned to the complainant by the postal department with the endorsement “unclaimed”. The learned Magistrate has recorded that the summons of the complaint filed by the complainant is served on the accused on the same address.

8. Considering the evidence on record, I find that the learned Magistrate has not appreciated the evidence in the right perspective and in the light of the provisions of Section 139 of the Act of 1881, which creates statutory presumption in favour of the holder of cheque, the burden is on the accused to rebut the statutory presumption.

9. The Advocate for the respondent/accused has argued that even if it is held that the accused had issued cheque (Exh. No. 25), the cheque itself and the evidence on record shows that the account was of Synergy Solution and Incorporation and as it is not impleaded as party/accused, the complaint could not have been entertained.

10. The Advocate for the complainant has argued that Synergy Solution and Incorporation was a proprietary firm.

11. There is nothing on record to point out whether Synergy Solution and Incorporation was a proprietorship firm or a partnership firm or a company. In the statement of the accused recorded under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, there is nothing to show that the accused pointed out that Synergy Solution and Incorporation was a partnership firm or a company. On the contrary, as recorded earlier, the accused stated that the cheque (Exh. No. 25) was taken away from the office of the accused by the son of the complainant. In these facts, the submission made by the Advocate for the accused that the complaint filed by the complainant could not have been entertained as the partnership firm was not impleaded as party, cannot be considered.

12. The judgment given in the case of Bimal Singh Kothari v. State of Goa reported at 2008 (1) Mh.L.J. 841 relied upon by the Advocate for the accused does not assist the accused as in that case there was ample material before the Court to come to the conclusion that the account of which cheque was issued was maintained by a company.

13. In the present case, it is found that the cheque (Exh. No. 25) was issued by the accused. The accused has failed to discharge the burden of proving that the account in question was not maintained by him. Though the accused relied on some communications issued by the bank and on the evidence of the Deputy Branch Manager to urge that the account was maintained by Vipin Dhopte, there is no positive evidence on record on the basis of which it can be held that the accused was not maintaining the account in question. The cheque was not honoured as the account was closed. It is not that the cheque was not honoured as it was signed by the accused, who was not maintaining and/or operating the account in question.

14. At this stage, the Advocate for the accused has submitted that even if it is held that the cheque (Exh. No. 25) was issued to discharge legally enforceable debt or other liability, the prayers made by the complainant cannot be granted as the learned Magistrate has not recorded any finding on the other points.

15. Though the learned Magistrate has not recorded his findings on the other points, I find that there is sufficient evidence on record on the basis of which findings can be recorded by this Court on those points. The cheque was not honoured by the bank as the account was closed much earlier. The complainant had issued notice (Exh. No. 28) dated 22 March, 2013 to the accused. The envelope containing the notice was returned to the complainant by the postal department on 1 April, 2013 with the remark “unclaimed”. The notice (Exh. No. 28) was sent by the complainant on the same address on which the summons of the complaint is served on the accused. The cheque was returned to the complainant by the bank on 7 March, 2013 and the complainant had issued the notice dated 22 March, 2013 and the envelope containing notice was returned to the complainant on 1 April, 2013. Thus, the notice was issued within the period prescribed by Section 138 of the Act of 1881. The complaint was filed on 7 May, 2013. Again the complaint was filed within the prescribed period of limitation.

16. In the facts of the case, it has to be held that the complainant had complied with all the necessary requirements of Section 138 of the Act of 1881.

17. Hence, the following order:

(i) The impugned judgment is set aside.

(ii) It is held that the respondent/accused - Rahul Sudhakar Anantwar is liable to be convicted for the commission of offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881.

(iii) The respondent/accused - Rahul Sudhakar Anantwar shall deposit Rs. 5,00,000/- (Rs. Five Lakhs) within two months.

(iv) On deposit of the amount within stipulated time, Rs. 4,80,000/- (Rs. Four Lakhs Eighty Thousand) be given to the appellant/complainant.

(v) If the respondent/accused - Rahul Sudhakar Anantwar fails to deposit the amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- (Rs. Five Lakhs) within two months, he shall undergo simple imprisonment for one year.

(vi) The respondent/accused shall pay costs of Rs. 20,000/- (Rs. Twenty Thousand) to the appellant and produce receipt of it on record of this appeal till 26 October, 2018.

(vii) The appeal is allowed in the above terms.