Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Somwati And Others v. Dharmendra Kumar And Another .

Allahabad High Court
Feb 25, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 was filed by the claimants seeking enhancement of compensation awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kaushambi by its award dated 22.3.2003 in MACP No. 7 of 2002. The claim petition alleged that Ram Jiyawan died on 5/6.12.2001 in an accident caused by the rash and negligent driving of Truck No. U.P.-78N/5378. Respondent No.1 was the owner of the offending vehicle and respondent No.2 was its insurer. The claimants (the deceased’s wife and seven minor children) alleged that the deceased earned Rs. 5,000 per month working as a labourer, from agricultural holdings and trading in pigs, and sought Rs. 15,25,000 as compensation.

The Tribunal found in favour of the claimants on fact and negligence and held the insurance company liable, awarding total compensation of Rs. 1,57,000 after: (a) taking a notional income of Rs. 15,000 per annum, (b) deducting one-third as personal expenses, (c) applying multiplier 15 (age 45), and (d) awarding Rs. 5,000 for loss of consortium and Rs. 2,000 for funeral expenses. The claimants appealed only to increase the compensation amount.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the notional income for the deceased should be fixed on the basis of minimum wages for an unskilled labour (Rs. 100 per day → Rs. 3,000 per month) instead of Rs. 15,000 per annum as used by the Tribunal.
  2. Whether the deduction for personal expenses should be one-third or a different fraction in view of the number of dependents and the principles laid down in Sarla Verma.
  3. Whether future prospects should be added to the income and at what percentage (as per Pranay Sethi).
  4. Which multiplier is appropriate for a 45‑year‑old deceased (the Tribunal applied 15; Supreme Court guidance in Sarla Verma prescribes 14).
  5. Whether compensation under conventional heads (loss of consortium, filial/parental consortium, love and affection, funeral, loss of estate) should be awarded and in what amounts consistent with recent Supreme Court authorities.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (Claimants)

  • The Tribunal erred in computing compensation on the basis of a notional income of Rs. 15,000 per annum; instead the notional income should be fixed at the minimum wages payable to an unskilled labour (Rs. 100/day = Rs. 3,000/month).
  • The Tribunal wrongly deducted 1/3 as personal expenses; deduction should be lower given the number of dependents.
  • The Tribunal failed to add future prospects to the multiplicand when determining compensation.
  • The conventional heads of damages were awarded meagerly and require enhancement.
  • Appellants cited Savita & Ors., Shrikrishna and Mishri Lal Yadav in support of the contention that notional income could not be less than Rs. 3,000 per month.

Respondent No.2's Arguments (Insurance Company)

  • The Division Bench decision in First Appeal From Order No. 2006 of 2017 (Dalveer Singh v. Tiger Lili) supported the Tribunal's approach of taking Rs. 15,000 per annum, and thus the Tribunal committed no error.
  • Deduction of personal expenses was correctly made at one-third in accordance with Sarla Verma, applying the unit method for apportionment of personal expenses among dependents.
  • The Tribunal had already applied a higher multiplier (15) than prescribed by Sarla Verma (14) for a 45‑year‑old; therefore, this was not an appropriate case for increasing the award.
  • On these bases, the appeal should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Savita & Ors. v. The Divisional Manager (2018 (2) T.A.C. 376 (S.C.)) Cited by appellants to support the argument that notional income should not be less than Rs. 3,000 per month. The judgment was referred to by appellants; the Court noted it among authorities relied upon by appellants but the Court's decision relied primarily on the Division Bench decision in Mishri Lal Yadav for fixing minimum wages as notional income in this case.
Shrikrishna v. Surendra Singh & Ors. ((2014) (104) ALR 87) Cited by appellants in support of contention regarding notional income levels. Referred to by appellants; the Court recorded that appellants relied on it but the Court based its notional income conclusion on Mishri Lal Yadav.
Mishri Lal Yadav v. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. ((2018) 2 T.A.C. 434 (All)) Determination of notional income for a deceased not in regular employment on the basis of minimum wages for an unskilled labour (Rs. 100/day = Rs. 3,000/month). The Court followed this Division Bench decision and fixed the deceased's notional income at Rs. 100 per day (Rs. 3,000/month; Rs. 36,000/year) for the purpose of computing multiplicand, noting that Mishri Lal Yadav was delivered after some other cited decisions and was directly applicable.
First Appeal From Order No. 2006 of 2017 (Dalveer Singh v. Tiger Lili) Relied upon by respondent to justify the Tribunal's approach of using Rs. 15,000 per annum as notional income. The Court observed that this decision was relied on by respondent, but noted Mishri Lal Yadav (delivered later) was not brought to that Division Bench's notice; the Court preferred Mishri Lal Yadav's approach here.
Sarla Verma (Smt) v. Delhi Transport Corporation, (2009) 6 SCC 121 Guidance on deduction for personal and living expenses (paragraph 30) and prescription of multiplier for age categories (multiplier 14 for age 45 used by Supreme Court). The Court applied paragraph 30 to determine deduction of personal expenses: where dependents exceed six, 1/5 deduction is appropriate. The Court also applied Sarla Verma's multiplier guidance and used multiplier 14 for a 45‑year‑old deceased.
National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 25% addition as future prospects in appropriate cases; fixed Rs. 40,000 as reasonable compensation for loss of consortium. The Court applied 25% as future prospects to the adjusted income and adopted Rs. 40,000 for loss of spousal consortium following Pranay Sethi.
Magma General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Nanu Ram (2018 SCC OnLine SC 1546) Treatment of loss of consortium categories (spousal, filial, parental), awarding separate amounts for loss of consortium and treating loss of love and affection as a distinct head. The Court awarded Rs. 40,000 to each claimant entitled to spousal/parental/filial consortium and awarded additional amounts for loss of love and affection, following the approach in Magma General.
Trilok Chandra (referenced in Sarla Verma) Referenced as the origin of a "unit" system for calculating deductions towards personal and living expenses. The Court noted Sarla Verma's observation that while units in Trilok Chandra are used in some cases, the Supreme Court endorsed standardized deductions set out in paragraph 30; the Court applied the standardized deduction (1/5) rather than the unit method.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the Tribunal's award and the parties' submissions and concluded that the claimants were entitled to higher compensation. The analysis proceeded in clear steps, each tied to cited authorities and to facts found by the Tribunal:

  1. Findings of fact upheld: The Tribunal's unchallenged findings established the deceased's age (45 years), his dependence by eight family members (widow + seven minor children), and ownership of agricultural land (0.072 hectares). The Insurance Company did not challenge these findings.
  2. Notional income: The Court accepted the Division Bench decision in Mishri Lal Yadav, which fixed income for a person not in regular employment at the minimum wages for an unskilled labour (Rs. 100/day). Applying that principle, the Court fixed the notional income as Rs. 3,000 per month (Rs. 36,000 per annum) for computation of multiplicand in this case.
  3. On the respondent's reliance upon Dalveer Singh: The Court observed that Dalveer Singh was cited by the insurer but Mishri Lal Yadav (delivered on 25.1.2018) was not brought to the Division Bench's notice in Dalveer Singh (judgment 12.4.2018). The Court therefore followed Mishri Lal Yadav, which was directly applicable.
  4. Deduction for personal expenses: The Court rejected respondent’s submission favouring the unit method. Relying on paragraph 30 of Sarla Verma, which endorses standardized deductions, the Court applied the prescribed fraction for families with more than six dependents: a deduction of 1/5 of income as personal expenses. Thus, from Rs. 3,000/month the deduction was Rs. 600/month.
  5. Future prospects: Following Pranay Sethi, the Court added 25% as future prospects. The adjusted monthly figures (after deduction) were used to calculate the multiplicand.
  6. Multiplier: For a 45‑year‑old deceased the Court applied the multiplier of 14 as per Sarla Verma (noting that the Tribunal had applied 15, which was higher).
  7. Conventional heads: The Court applied the principles in Pranay Sethi and Magma General to award amounts under heads like loss of spousal consortium, parental/filial consortium, loss of love and affection, funeral expenses and loss of estate. The Court interpreted Magma General as directing that the Rs. 40,000 fixed in Pranay Sethi for loss of consortium is to be awarded separately to each claimant entitled to such a head and that loss of love and affection is a distinct head meriting a separate award.
  8. Computation and implementation: The Court set out each arithmetic step, showing (i) notional income Rs. 3,000/month, (ii) deduction Rs. 600/month, (iii) 25% future prospects Rs. 600/month, (iv) multiplicand Rs. 36,000/year, (v) applying multiplier 14 to arrive at Rs. 5,04,000 as loss of future income, and (vi) adding specified conventional heads to arrive at total compensation of Rs. 12,54,000. The Court directed that the enhanced amount carry the same interest as awarded by the Tribunal and prescribed how the excess awarded should be deposited by the insurer and fixed by the Tribunal in high-interest fixed deposit schemes, with directions on withdrawals and restrictions on loans/advances against those fixed deposits.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; TRIBUNAL AWARD MODIFIED

Holding: The Court allowed the appeal and modified the Tribunal's award dated 22.3.2003. The Court held that the claimants are entitled to a total compensation of Rs. 12,54,000 (instead of Rs. 1,57,000 awarded by the Tribunal). The Court retained the same rate of interest as awarded by the Tribunal and directed respondent No.2 (the insurer) to deposit the balance/excess amount in the Tribunal within three months, to be placed in high-interest fixed deposits under specified conditions. The Court also set out the apportionment: half of the amount computed for future income plus Rs. 40,000 (spousal consortium) and Rs. 50,000 (love and affection) to the widow, with the balance divided equally among the seven children.

Implications for the parties: The direct effect is enhancement of compensation payable to the claimants to Rs. 12,54,000 and procedural directions for deposit, fixation of the deposit in high-interest schemes, and safeguards on withdrawal and loans. The opinion applies existing precedents (Mishri Lal Yadav; Sarla Verma; Pranay Sethi; Magma General) in the facts of this case but does not announce any novel legal principle beyond applying those authorities to compute the revised award.

Note: All content in this summary is based exclusively on the information contained in the provided opinion. No additional facts or external inferences have been introduced.

Show all summary ...

Salil Kumar Rai, J.:— Heard Mohd. Asim, Advocate holding brief of Sri. Ram Singh, the counsel for the appellants and Sri. Parv Agrawal, the counsel for respondent no. 2 - Insurance Company.

2. The present appeal has been filed by the claimants under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (hereinafter referred to as, ‘Act, 1988’) praying to increase the compensation awarded by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kaushambi through its award dated 22.3.2003 passed in Motor Accident Claim Petition No. 7 of 2002.

3. Motor Accident Claim Petition No. 7 of 2002 was filed by the claimants alleging that one Ram Jiyawan died on 5/6.12.2001 in an accident caused due to the rash and negligent driving of Truck No. U.P.-78N/5378 (hereinafter referred to as, ‘Offending Vehicle’). The respondent no. 1 is the owner of the offending vehicle which was insured with respondent no. 2. It was alleged in the claim petition that at the time of his death, Ram Jiyawan was earning Rs. 5,000/- per month by working as labour and from his agricultural holding and by trading in pigs. The claimants prayed for a compensation of Rs. 15,25,000/- for the death of the deceased. The claimants are the wife and the minor children of the deceased. The respondent nos. 1 and 2 filed their written statements denying the factum of accident as well as the negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle in causing the accident and also the entitlement of the claimants to compensation. The Tribunal framed Issues regarding the factum of accident, the negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle in causing the accident, the inter se liability of the defendants to pay compensation as well as the amount of compensation to which the claimants were entitled. As the present appeal has been filed by the claimants for increasing the compensation amount, therefore, I am not entering into the details of the findings of the Tribunal regarding the factum of accident, the negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle in causing the accident and the inter se liability of the defendants to pay compensation to the claimants. It is sufficient to state that in its award dated 22.3.2003, the Tribunal decided the Issues regarding the factum of accident and the negligence of the driver of the offending vehicle in favour of the claimants and held the Insurance Company liable to pay compensation. The Tribunal awarded a compensation of Rs. 1,57,000/- to the claimants after deducting 1/3 as personal expenses of the deceased from the notional income of Rs. 15,000/- per annum and by applying a multiplier of 15 because at the time of accident, the deceased was 45 years old. The Tribunal awarded a compensation of Rs. 5,000/- to the claimant/appellant no. 1 for loss of consortium and an additional compensation of Rs. 2,000/- for funeral expenses.

4. Assailing the amount of compensation awarded by the Tribunal through its award dated 22.3.2003, the counsel for the appellants has argued that the compensation payable to the claimants was to be determined on the basis of minimum wages payable to an unskilled labour because the claim-petition was filed under Section 166 of the Act, 1988 and the Tribunal had erred in awarding compensation on the basis of a notional income of Rs. 15,000/- per annum according to the second schedule to Act, 1988. The counsel for the appellants has referred to Savita & Ors. (S) v. The Divisional Manager (S), 2018 (2) T.A.C. 376 (S.C.) and the Division Bench judgments of this Court in Shrikrishna v. Surendra Singh & Ors., (2014) (104) ALR 87 and Mishri Lal Yadav v. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., (2018) 2 T.A.C. 434 (All.) in support of his argument that, in any case, the notional income of the deceased could not have been treated to be less than Rs. 3,000/- per month. It was further argued by the counsel for the claimants/appellants that the Tribunal had erred in deducting 1/3 as personal expenses of the deceased and has also awarded very meager compensation under the conventional heads. It was further argued by the claimants/appellants that while determining the multiplicand, the Tribunal has not added future prospects to the income of the deceased. It was argued that for the aforesaid reasons, the award of the Tribunal is liable to be modified by increasing the amount of compensation.

5. Rebutting the arguments of the counsel for the appellants, the counsel for respondent no. 2 - Insurance Company has argued that in view of the Division Bench judgment of this Court in First Appeal From Order No. 2006 of 2017 (Dalveer Singh v. Tiger Lili) and considering the fact that the accident took place on 5/6.12.2001, the Tribunal did not commit any error in determining compensation on the basis of a notional income of Rs. 15,000/- per annum. It has been further argued by the counsel for respondent that according to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma (Smt) v. Delhi Transport Corporation, (2009) 6 SCC 121, deductions against the personal expenses of the deceased were to be made by following the unit method whereby two units were to be allotted to the adult members of the family and one unit was to be allotted to the minor members of the family. It was argued that in view of the aforesaid, the Tribunal committed no illegality in deducting 1/3 as personal expenses of the deceased. It was further argued by the counsel for respondent no. 2 - Insurance Company that in its impugned award the Tribunal had already applied a higher multiplier of 15 while determining the compensation payable to the claimants which was contrary to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma (supra) prescribing a multiplier of 14 in case where the deceased was 45 years old and, therefore, it was not a fit case to modify the award of the Tribunal by increasing the compensation amount. It was argued that, for the aforesaid reasons, the present appeal was liable to be dismissed.

6. I have considered by the submissions of the counsel for the parties.

7. A perusal of the different judgments of the Supreme Court and this High Court and from reasons presently stated it would be evident that the claimants/appellants are entitled to a higher compensation than what has been awarded by the Tribunal.

8. It is evident from the findings of the Tribunal that, at the time of accident, the deceased was 45 years old and the claimants/appellants are the dependents of the deceased. Further, it is also evident from the findings of the Tribunal that the deceased owned agricultural land and also worked as a labour. The fact that the deceased owned agricultural lands (measuring 0.072 hects.) was also proved from the documentary evidence on record. The aforesaid findings of the Tribunal have not been challenged by the Insurance Company.

9. In Mishri Lal Yadav (supra), this Court, for determining compensation under the Act, 1988 fixed the income of the deceased who, at the time of accident, was employed at sweat meat shop but was not in regular employment, on the basis of minimum wages payable to an unskilled labour, i.e. Rs. 100/- per day. It appears that in First Appeal From Order No. 2006 of 2017, referred by the counsel for the Insurance Company, the Division Bench judgment of this Court in Mishri Lal Yadav (supra) was not brought to the notice of the Court. The judgment in Mishri Lal Yadav (supra) was delivered on 25.1.2018 while the judgment in First Appeal From Order No. 2006 of 2017 was delivered on 12.4.2018. In Mishri Lal Yadav (supra), the accident took place in 2002 and in the present case the accident occurred in 2001. Thus, in the light of the Division Bench judgment of this Court in Mishri Lal Yadav (supra), the notional income of the deceased for determining compensation under the Act, 1988 had to be fixed as Rs. 100/- per day, i.e., Rs. 3,000/- per month which, at the time of accident was the minimum wages payable to an unskilled labour in the State of Uttar Pradesh. Thus, the notional income of the deceased for determining the multiplicand in the present case would be Rs. 36,000/- per annum.

10. There were eight dependents - the widow and seven minor children - of the deceased, who are also appellants in the present case. The contention of the counsel for respondent no. 2 that according to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma (supra), the unit system had to be applied for deducting the personal expenses of the deceased cannot be accepted. In paragraph no. 30 of its judgment, the Supreme Court observed as follows:

“30. Though in some cases the deduction to be made towards personal and living expenses is calculated on the basis of units indicated in Trilok Chandra, the general practice is to apply standardized deductions. Having considered several subsequent decisions of this court, we are of the view that where the deceased was married, the deduction towards personal and living expenses of the deceased, should be one-third (1/3) where the number of dependent family members is 2 to 3, one-fourth (1/4) where the number of dependent family members is 4 to 6, and one-fifth (1/5) where the number of dependent family members exceed six.”

(emphasis added)

11. Because eight family members were dependent on the deceased, therefore, 1/5 of the income of the deceased is to be deducted as his personal expenses. Thus, Rs. 600/- has to be deducted from the income of Rs. 3,000/- per month of the deceased.

12. At the time of his death, the deceased was 45 years old. According to the judgment of the Supreme Court in National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680, 25% is to be added as future prospects in the income of the deceased. Further, according to the judgment of the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma (supra), a multiplier of 14 is to be applied while determining the compensation payable to the claimants.

13. In addition to the pecuniary damages, calculated as aforesaid, the claimants are also entitled to compensation under the conventional heads as provided by the Supreme Court in Pranay Sethi (supra) read with Magma General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Nanu Ram, 2018 SCC OnLine SC 1546.

14. In Pranay Sethi (supra), the Supreme Court held that Rs. 40,000/- would be a reasonable compensation for loss of consortium. Subsequently in Magma General (supra), the Supreme Court, after referring to Pranay Sethi (supra), held that a spouse is entitled to loss of spousal consortium in case of death of a spouse in accident and parents are entitled to loss of Filial Consortium where they have lost their minor child, or unmarried son or daughter, and children are entitled to loss of parental consortium for the death of their parents in motor vehicles accident under the Act, 1988. In Magma General (supra), the Supreme Court awarded compensation of Rs. 40,000/- for loss of Filial Consortium to each of the dependents of the deceased. From a reading of Paragraph nos. 8.7 and 9 of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Magma General (supra), it can be concluded that the compensation of Rs. 40,000/- fixed by the Supreme Court in Pranay Sethi (supra) for loss of consortium is to be awarded separately to each of those claimants who are entitled to compensation for loss of spousal consortium, Filial Consortium or parental consortium. It is also noticeable that in Magma General (supra), the Supreme Court treated loss of love and affection as a category separate from loss of consortium and awarded compensation for loss of love and affection in addition to compensation for loss of consortium. Further, the Supreme Court upheld the judgments of the High Court awarding a total of Rs. 1,00,000/- as compensation for loss of love and affection with Rs. 50,000/- to each of the two claimants.

15. Thus, the claimants are entitled to a compensation of Rs. 15,000/- for loss of estate, Rs. 15,000/- for funeral expenses, the claimant no. 1 is entitled to Rs. 40,000/- for loss of spousal consortium, the claimant/appellant nos. 2 to 8 are entitled to Rs. 40,000/- each for loss of Parental Consortium due to the death of their father. In addition to the aforesaid amount, the claimants are also entitled to Rs. 50,000/- each for loss of love and affection.

16. In view of the above, the compensation amount payable to the claimants is computed as follows:

(i) Notional income of the deceased = Rs. 3,000/- per month.

(ii) Deduction towards personal expenses of the deceased = Rs. 600/- per month (1/5 of his income).

(iii) 25% future prospects = Rs. 600/- per month (i.e. 25% of Rs. 2,400/-).

(iv) The multiplicand would be (Rs. 2,400 + Rs. 600 × 12) = Rs. 36,000/-.

(v) Applying the multiplier of 14, the loss of future income = Rs. 36,000/- × 14 = Rs. 5,04,000/-.

(vi) Loss of love and affection = Rs. 4,00,000/- (Rs. 50,000/- to each of the eight claimants).

(vii) Loss of spousal consortium to respondent no. 1 = Rs. 40,000/-.

(viii) Loss of Parental Consortium to claimant/appellant nos. 2 to 8 = Rs. 2,80,000/- (Rs. 40,000/- to each of the claimants).

(ix) Loss of estate = Rs. 15,000/-.

(x) Funeral expenses = Rs. 15,000/-

Total compensation awarded = Rs. 12,54,000/-.

17. Thus, it is held that the claimants are entitled to a compensation of Rs. 12,54,000/- It is clarified that the amount computed as aforesaid by this Court shall carry the same interest as awarded by the Tribunal through its award dated 22.3.2003. The award dated 22.3.2003 passed by the Tribunal is modified to the aforesaid extent.

18. The compensation amount shall be apportioned among the claimants as follows:

(1) Half of the amount computed above against loss of future income in addition to Rs. 40,000/- for loss of spousal consortium and Rs. 50,000/- for loss of love and affection awarded to appellant no. 1 along with the interest accruing on the said amounts shall be paid to the claimant/appellant no. 1 who is the widow of the deceased.

(2) The balance amount left after the amount paid to claimant/appellant no. 1 shall be divided equally between claimant/appellant nos. 2 to 8.

19. The Tribunal had awarded a compensation of Rs. 1,57,000/- to the claimants. The balance amount/excess amount as awarded by this Court in the present appeal shall be deposited by respondent no. 2 in the Tribunal within three months from today. The amount so deposited by respondent no. 2 under the order of this Court shall be fixed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kaushambi in the highest interest bearing fixed deposit schemes either of the post office or of any nationalized bank. The receipts of the fixed deposits shall be handed over to the claimants/legal representatives of the deceased who shall be entitled to withdraw the maturity amount on the expiry of the period of the fixed deposits. The maturity amount shall be credited by the bank/post office in any savings account held singly by the claimants/legal representatives of the deceased. The concerned bank or post office shall not permit any loan or advance against the fixed deposits made in favour of the claimants/legal representatives of the deceased. The Tribunal, while depositing the amount in the fixed deposit schemes, shall communicate the directions issued by this Court to the concerned bank/post office.

20. With the aforesaid directions and observations, theappeal is allowed.