Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Radhika Devi (S) v. Union Of India And Others (S).

Supreme Court Of India
Sep 23, 2019
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Naib Subedar Umed Singh was enrolled in the Army on 13.03.1976 and was posted at the International Border in “Operation Parakram” on 19.12.2001. On 21.05.2002 at about 4:00 pm, while participating in fire-fighting drill activities, he collapsed and was declared dead. The death certificate recorded the cause of death as ischemic heart disease leading to cardiac arrhythmia (ventricular fibrillation).

The Respondents granted the Appellant Special Family Pension. Dissatisfied that Liberalised Family Pension was not granted, the Appellant filed O.A. No. 167 of 2011 before the Armed Forces Tribunal, Principal Branch, New Delhi. The Tribunal dismissed the O.A. on 23.11.2011, holding that the Appellant was not entitled to either Liberalised Family Pension or ex-gratia payment.

The Appellant then filed a writ petition in the High Court of Delhi, which was allowed. The High Court held that the Appellant was entitled to Liberalised Family Pension and ex-gratia payment of Rs. 5 lakhs. The Appellant appealed further to seek Rs. 7.5 lakhs as ex-gratia instead of Rs. 5 lakhs. The Union of India also appealed against the High Court’s declaration of entitlement to Liberalised Family Pension and against the award of Rs. 5 lakhs as ex-gratia.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Appellant was entitled to Liberalised Family Pension under the Government of India Instructions dated 31.01.2001, given that the deceased died due to cardiac failure while posted in a notified operation.
  2. Whether the Appellant was entitled to ex-gratia payment of Rs. 7.5 lakhs, or only Rs. 5 lakhs, in light of the applicable instructions (including those dated 22.09.1998).

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kanchan Dua v. Union of India Civil Appeal Nos. 7459-7460 of 2010 Liberalised Family Pension under the Government of India Instructions is payable only to family members of Armed Forces personnel who have “died in action,” based on scrutiny of relevant circulars and modifications to beneficiary awards. The Court relied on this holding to conclude that a death due to cardiac failure (not “death in action”) does not qualify for Liberalised Family Pension, notwithstanding posting in a notified operation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the claim for Liberalised Family Pension with reference to Government of India Instructions dated 31.01.2001, which contemplate entitlement where an Armed Forces personnel dies whilst employed in an operation notified by the Government of India. However, the Court applied its earlier analysis and holding in Kanchan Dua v. Union of India, where it had reviewed relevant circulars and modifications (including those referenced as arising from a letter dated 24.02.1972) and determined that Liberalised Family Pension is payable only to families of Armed Forces personnel who “died in action.”

Applying that principle to the present facts, the Court found that the deceased’s death was due to cardiac failure (ischemic heart disease leading to ventricular fibrillation) and therefore did not constitute death “in action.” On this basis, the Court held that the Appellant was not entitled to Liberalised Family Pension and would receive only Special Family Pension.

On ex-gratia payment, the Court held that the Appellant was entitled to Rs. 5 lakhs as ex-gratia compensation in accordance with Instructions dated 22.09.1998, which (as described by the Court) provide for ex-gratia payment in all cases of death and disability in service to family members of Armed Forces personnel who died in harness. The Court rejected the claim for Rs. 7.5 lakhs because the death was not during enemy action in international war, border skirmishes, or action against militants/terrorists/extremists.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF: The Court set aside the High Court’s judgment to the extent it declared that the Appellant was entitled to Liberalised Family Pension, holding instead that she was entitled only to Special Family Pension. The Court upheld the High Court’s decision granting ex-gratia payment of Rs. 5 lakhs and rejected the Appellant’s claim for Rs. 7.5 lakhs.

The direct consequence is that the Appellant remains eligible for Special Family Pension and will receive ex-gratia compensation of Rs. 5 lakhs, but will not receive Liberalised Family Pension or ex-gratia of Rs. 7.5 lakhs. The opinion applies existing principles (including the Court’s holding in Kanchan Dua) and does not indicate that any new precedent was set beyond this application.

Show all summary ...

L. Nageswara Rao, J.:— Leave granted.

2. For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred to as they are arrayed in Civil Appeal Nos. 7525-7526 of 2019 arising out of SLP (C) Nos. 8588-8589 of 2014 filed by Smt. Radhika Devi.

3. Naib Subedar Umed Singh was enrolled in the Army on 13.03.1976. On 19.12.2001, he was posted at the International Border in Operation Parakram. While taking part in the fire fighting drill activities at about 4.00 pm on 21.05.2002, he collapsed and was declared dead. According to the death certificate, he died due to Ischemic heart disease leading to cardiac arrhythmia (ventricular fibrillation).

4. The Respondents granted Special Family Pension to the Appellant. Unsatisfied with the grant of Special Family Pension instead of the Liberalised Family Pension, the Appellant filed O.A. No. 167 of 2011 before the Armed Forces Tribunal, Principal Branch, New Delhi (for short “the Tribunal”). The Tribunal dismissed the O.A. on 23.11.2011, holding that the Appellant was not entitled to either Liberalised Family Pension or exgratia payment. Aggrieved by the order of the Tribunal, the Appellant filed a Writ Petition in the High Court of Delhi, which was allowed. The High Court found that the Appellant was entitled to Liberalised Family Pension and ex-gratia payment of Rs. 5 lakhs. The Appellant challenged the judgment of the High Court to the extent that ex-gratia payment of Rs. 7.5 lakhs was not awarded in her favour. The Respondent, Union of India has also filed an appeal questioning the judgment of the High Court in so far as it relates to the declaration that the Appellant is entitled to the Liberalised Family Pension and the award of Rs. 5 lakhs as ex-gratia amount.

5. The claim of Liberalised Family Pension by the Appellant is on the basis of the Instructions issued by the Government of India on 31.01.2001. As per the said Instructions, a member of the family of a deceased Armed Forces Personnel whilst employed in an operation notified by the Government of India would be entitled to Liberalised Family Pension. In Kanchan Dua v. Union of India Civil Appeal Nos. 7459-7460 of 2010, we have discussed in detail the modifications issued to the rules and regulations granting beneficiary awards to the family members of the Armed Forces Personnel who died in action by the letter dated 24.02.1972. We have also carefully examined the scope of the entitlement of Liberalised Family Pension in case of the death of persons employed in the operations notified by the Government of India. After a close scrutiny of the relevant circulars, we have held that Liberalised Family Pension in accordance with the Instructions issued by the Government of India is payable only to the family members of Armed Forces personnel who have died in action.

6. In view of the death of the Appellant due to cardiac failure, the Appellant is not entitled to Liberalised Family Pension. In so far as the payment of ex-gratia amount/compensation is concerned, we are convinced that the Appellant is entitled to Rs. 5 lakhs as ex-gratia compensation in accordance with the Instructions dated 22.09.1998. The special benefits that were granted by the Government of India for ex-gratia payment is payable in all cases of death and disability in service to the family members of the Armed Forces Personnel who died in harness. As the death of the Appellant's husband was not during enemy action in international war or border skirmishes and action against militants, terrorists, extremists etc., the Appellant is not entitled to Rs. 7.5 Lakhs as claimed by her.

7. We set aside the judgment of the High Court declaring that the Appellant is entitled for Liberalised Family Pension. She is entitled only for the Special Family Pension. Further, we uphold the judgment of the High Court that the Appellant is entitled for ex-gratia payment of Rs. 5 lakhs. With the above observations, the Appeals are disposed of, accordingly.