- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Brg Iron & Steel Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of W.B.
Shivakant Prasad, J.:— Affidavit-of-service filed in Court today be kept with the record. In response to service effected on the State through Public Prosecutor Mr. Pratick Bose, learned advocate has entered appearance who submits that it is absolutely a complaint case. None appeared on behalf of the Opposite Party No. 2, complainant company despite receipt of the notice by the Opposite Party No. 2.
2. In this revisional application the petitioner company represented through petitioner no. 2, the Chairman and Managing Director has assailed the complaint being case no. C 19076 of 2014 (T.R. No. 3023 of 2014) under Section 406/420/422 of the Indian Penal Code pending before the learned 19 Metropolitan Magistrate, Kolkata and all orders passed therein.
3. The petitioner no. 1 is a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 2013 engaged in the business of steel. The Opposite Party No. 2 and the Petitioner No. 1 company have business relationship and various orders were placed by the petitioner company to the Opposite Party No. 2 for supply of various construction materials from time to time and in terms of payment made by the petitioner to the Opposite Party No. 2 in terms of invoice raised by Opposite Party No. 2 the petitioner company has time to time made payment to the Opposite Party No. 2 but one of such commercial transaction between the parties Opposite Party No. 2, complainant company supplied various chemical products for a sum of Rs. 1,79,408/- but due to dispute and differences arose between the petitioner and the opposite party no. 2 in regard to the supply of materials though there was no criminality in the transaction yet the Opposite Party No. 2 filed a complaint before the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Kolkata on 30.05.2014 on the allegation that the petitioner company have not made payment of due amount of Rs. 1,79,408/- for the materials supplied to them vide bills/challans. On the basis of this complaint learned Metropolitan Magistrate, 19 Court, Kolkata on taking the statement on solemn affirmation of the complainant and its other witnesses examined under Section 200 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, process under Section 406/420/422 of the Indian Penal Code was issued against the petitioners. It would appear that by order dated 24.06.2016 prayer of the petitioner was granted fixing 05.09.2016 for appearance in default for issuance of warrant of arrest and since none appeared on the adjourned date warrant of arrest was issued against the accused no. 1 fixed on 23.11.2016.
4. The petitioner has challenged the process issued in the said complaint case on the contention that the petitioner has already paid all dues to the complainant/opposite party no. 2. It is also contended that the dispute is civil in nature and the claim can be settled only by instituting proper proceeding, if at all, as no criminality can be attached with and the petitioner company cannot be coerced by the Opposite Party No. 2 to settle a civil suit by instituting a criminal complaint against the petitioner and its Managing Director. In fact, in terms of settlement executed by and between the parties, the petitioner company has already paid a sum of Rs. 12,41,836.50 which is evident from Annexure “E”. It is also depicted from the receipts issued by AKJ Engineers Private Limited, complainant company that by two separate cheques being Cheque No. 319198 dated 28.08.2015 for Rs. 6,41,836/- and Cheque No. 319197 dated 28.08.2015 for Rs. 6,00,000/- drawn on United Bank of India were received by the complainant company in full and final settlement of the dispute. The statement of account of the petitioner company also reveals that the complainant company has received the said amount. The settlement was arrived at not to proceed with or to withdraw the complaint but no step was taken by the Opposite Party No. 2/complainant.
5. In the context above, the complaint does not disclose the alleged offence under Section 406/420/422 of the Indian Penal Code as the mere breach of contract cannot give rise to prosecution under the said provision of Indian Penal Code unless ingredients of the offence are made out in respect of the fraud or dishonest intention shown against the petitioner at the beginning of the transaction.
6. Therefore, I am of the view that the intention of the complainant was only to realise the dues from the petitioner company and the complaint has been filed afterthought.
7. I am of the view, that continuation of the proceeding before the learned Magistrate would amount to abuse of the process of the Court. Accordingly, the revisional application being CRR No. 3217 of 2016 is allowed. Consequently, the proceeding in complaint being case no. C 19076 of 2014 (T.R. No. 3023 of 2014) under Section 406/420/422 of the Indian Penal Code pending before the learned 19 Metropolitan Magistrate, Kolkata and all orders passed therein stands quashed.
8. Thus, CRAN No. 2530 of 2018 is also disposed of.
9. Urgent photostat certified copies of this order, if applied for, be made available to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.
Alert