Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Vaijnath Kondiba Khandke v. State Of Maharashtra

Bombay High Court
Jan 23, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Two criminal applications were filed for quashing of FIR bearing Crime No. 0268/2017 registered with M.I.D.C. CIDCO Police Station, Aurangabad for offences punishable under sections 306, 506 read with 34 of the IPC. The matter was taken up for final disposal at the admission stage with consent of the parties and heard finally.

The FIR and police papers state that deceased Kishor Parashar (aged 45), a clerk in the office of the Deputy Director of Education, committed suicide by hanging on 08.08.2017. The informant (his wife Deepali) alleged that Kishor was under tremendous mental tension due to heavy workload, stoppage of salary by accused no.1 (Vaijnath Khandke, the Deputy Director) and humiliations at the office; accused no.2 (Vidya Ghorpade) was alleged to be inefficient and allegedly got her work done by Kishor. The informant alleged these factors led Kishor to commit suicide.

The court heard counsel for the applicants (Shri Joydeep Chatterji and Shri Nilesh S. Ghanekar), the learned APP for the State (Shri V.M. Kagne) and counsel for respondent no.2 (Shri S. P. Brahme).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the FIR (Crime No. 0268/2017) should be quashed insofar as it relates to the applicants.
  2. Whether the allegations in the FIR, taken at their face value, constitute the offence under section 306 IPC (abetment of suicide) or otherwise disclose a case for prosecution.
  3. Whether the material on record shows instigation or creation of a situation causing such mental harassment as to amount to abetment of suicide.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

  • The allegations, even if taken at face value, do not disclose any criminal intention on the part of the applicants.
  • The facts do not make out an offence under section 306 IPC; there was no abetment by the applicants.

State / Respondent's Arguments

  • The applicants by their behaviour created a situation of unbearable pressure through mental harassment, leaving the deceased Kishor with no option but to commit suicide.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal [1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 : AIR 1992 SC 604] Criteria for exercise of power to quash FIR; seven criteria generally, two material criteria highlighted: (i) allegations taken at face value do not constitute any offence; (ii) allegations absurd or inherently improbable. The court referred to Bhajan Lal and identified two of the criteria as material when considering exercise of power under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
Ramesh Kumar v. State Of Chhattisgarh (2001) 9 SCC 618 : AIR 2001 SC 3837 That if a victim committing suicide was hypersensitive to ordinary petulance/discord, such reactions should not lead court to conclude accused instigated suicide; caution against treating ordinary discord as instigation. The court cited this principle to note that hypersensitivity of the victim may preclude finding of abetment and to caution against overreaching in assessment at quashing stage.
Dadarao v. State Of Maharashtra, 2017 ALL MR (Cri) 1538 Fact pattern: clerk committed suicide due to heavy workload; presence of suicide note; lack of temporal proximity between alleged instigation and incident. The applicants relied on this decision; it was cited as an instance where FIR against the superior was quashed on similar facts.
State of Maharashtra v. Ibrahim Pathan, 2017 ALL MR (Cri) 1542 Where abuse and alleged abetment arose from a petty quarrel and suicide occurred two days later, there was no evidence of goading and encouragement. The decision was cited for the proposition that absence of evidence of goading can lead to acquittal and does not support abetment charge.
Rajendrakumar & Others v. State Of Maharashtra & Others, 2017 ALL MR (Cri) 1869 Vague allegations of harassment and no specific role attributed; vague evidence of creation of mental tension. Cited as a case where FIR was quashed because of vagueness and lack of specific role of accused.
Dilip v. State Of Maharashtra (Nagpur Bench) (Criminal Application (APL) No. 332 of 2016), decided 05 August, 2016 Judicial officer's suicide note naming superiors; scrutiny found allegations vague and no case of instigation or goading. Referred to as precedent where accused were acquitted due to vagueness of allegations of instigation.
State of Kerala v. Unnikrishnan Nair, 2015 CJ(SC) 1275 Suicide note alleging cheating by colleagues; respondents were junior; vague allegations do not constitute abetment. Cited to show that vague allegations in a suicide note do not establish abetment.
Praveen Pradhan v. State of Uttaranchal, (2012) 9 SCC 734 No straight-jacket formula to determine instigation; instigation can be inferred from circumstances where persistent harassment and humiliation drive a person to suicide. Quoted for the principle that inference must be drawn from circumstances and persistent harassment may amount to instigation; used to show such situations may constitute abetment in appropriate cases.
Sunita Wawle v. State of Maharashtra (Cri. Appln. No. 2159/2017) decided 14.06.2017 Victim left a suicide note alleging ill-treatment; applicant's failure to perform duties and irresponsible performance did not amount to instigation. Cited as an example where ill-treatment and non-performance did not amount to instigation.
Dr. Shivanand v. State, 2017 ALL MR (Cri) 1401 Allegations against Medical Superintendent (non-allowance to resume duties, non-payment of certain expenses) insufficient to hold instigation; petitioner acted in official capacity. Cited to support the view that official acts in discharge of duties, even if harsh, may not constitute instigation for criminal liability.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by noting the limited and sparing exercise of its power under Section 482 Cr.P.C., referring to the Bhajan Lal criteria and emphasizing that appreciation of material at the quashing stage is only cursory; minute factual inquiries are to be left to the trial court.

The court observed there was no direct abetment alleged and that intention on the part of the applicants that the deceased should commit suicide was not pleaded. However, the court recognized the legal proposition that conduct creating a situation of tremendous mental tension capable of driving a person to suicide can amount to instigation (akin to an act imminently dangerous as described in Section 300(4) IPC). The Ramesh Kumar principle was noted to caution that where a victim is hypersensitive, ordinary discord should not be treated as instigation.

The court examined the material separately for each applicant:

  • Vidya Ghorpade: The only allegation was that she was inefficient and gave her work to the deceased. The court found that even accepting allegations at face value, her conduct would not amount to abetment because the deceased had no compelling obligation to perform her work and nothing would have happened had he refused.
  • Vaijnath Khandke: The record showed significant additional work burden placed on the deceased after Khandke's arrival, appreciation of the deceased's prior performance, imposition of additional charge, requirement to attend court and then work late, issuance of circulars linking reporting with stoppage of pay, and stoppage of salary for July 2017. The court found these allegations capable of description as persistent mental harassment and ill-treatment that might frustrate and depress the deceased. While the court expressly refrained from a detailed assessment of whether this material would suffice to prove instigation at trial, it held that such material might be sufficient and therefore quashing was not appropriate as to Khandke.

The court emphasized that its observations on sufficiency were limited to deciding the quashing applications and should not influence the trial judge at any stage (cognizance/framing of charge/final disposal).

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • Criminal Application No. 5174 of 2017 (Vidya Ghorpade): Allowed. FIR bearing Crime No. 0268/2017 is quashed insofar as it relates to Vidya Ghorpade.
  • Criminal Application No. 4724 of 2017 (Vaijnath Khandke): Dismissed. The application to quash is refused and prosecution as to Vaijnath Khandke will proceed.

Implications: The direct consequence is that prosecution is terminated against Vidya Ghorpade by quashing of the FIR as to her, while proceedings against Vaijnath Khandke continue. The court made no pronouncement creating a new legal rule; it applied existing principles and precedents to the facts and left factual determinations to the trial court.

Show all summary ...

A.M. Dhavale, J.:— Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. With the consent of the parties, taken up for final disposal at admission stage & heard finally.

2. Both the applications are for quashing of FIR bearing Crime No. 0268/2017 registered with M.I.D.C. CIDCO Police Station, Aurangabad, for the offences punishable u/s 306, 506 r/w 34 of IPC.

3. Heard Shri. Joydeep Chatterji & Shri. Nilesh S. Ghanekar, learned counsel for the applicants, Shri. V.M. Kagne, learned APP for State and Shri. S. P. Brahme, learned counsel for respondent no. 2.

4. The FIR and police papers disclose that, deceased Kishor Parashar, aged 45 years, husband of informant, was serving as a Clerk in the office of Dy. Director of Education, Aurangabad. Accused no. 1 - Vaijnath Khandke was Dy. Director (Education) while accused no. 2 - Vidya Ghorpade is a Clerk in the same department. On 08.08.2017, deceased Kishor along with his wife Deepali left the house at 10:00 a.m. Deceased Kishor left his wife at the house of his sister and went towards the office but the inquiry by Deepali revealed that he had not reached the office. He was not accessible on mobile. At 03:00 p.m. when daughter Ruchika reached the house, she saw two-wheeler of her father at the parking but the house was closed. On breaking open the house, it was revealed that Kishor had committed suicide by hanging himself from a ceiling fan. On the next day, Deepali lodged the FIR that her husband used to be under tremendous mental tension as he was overburdened with the work of four tables and was required to work upto 10:00 p.m. everyday. His salary was stopped by accused no. 1 - Vaijnath and he was always threatening and intimidating him. Accused no. 2 - Vidya was not efficient and she was getting all her work done from Kishor. Kishor was excellent in his work but due to overburden, stoppage of increment and humiliating treatment in the office, he committed suicide.

5. It is argued that, the allegations against the applicants even if taken at their face value, do not disclose any criminal intention on the part of both the applicants. The allegations do not make out any offence u/s 306 IPC. There was no abetment by the applicants.

6. Per contra, learned APP and advocate Shri. S. P. Brahme argued that, the applicants by their behaviour created situation so as to create unbearable pressure by mental harassment and deceased Kishor was left with no option but to commit suicide.

7. After carefully considering the arguments and the judgments cited and the papers produced, we find that the power of quashing FIR can be exercised in sparing manner where there is a clear case of abuse of process of court and no material to allow the prosecution to be continued. In State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal” [1992 Supp (1) SCC 335 : AIR 1992 SC 604], seven criteria are given for exercising powers. Following two are material.

(i) The allegations taken at their face value do not constitute any offence or make out a case against the accused.

(ii) The allegations are absurd and inherently improbable that no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion of sufficiency of grounds.

8. We must make it clear that, appreciation of material for sufficiency can be only at cursory level and this Court while invoking powers u/s 482 Cr.P.C. cannot go into minute aspects. It should be left to the trial Judge to decide the merits and demerits of the facts alleged at the time of taking cognizance, framing of charge or final disposal.

9. The facts herein indicate that, there was no direct abetment and the applicants cannot have any intention that the deceased should commit suicide. Even when the accused persons have no such intention, if they create situation causing tremendous mental tension so as to drive the person to commit suicide, they can be said to be instigating the accused to commit suicide. It is akin to act imminently dangerous as described in Section 300(4) of IPC. As held in Ramesh Kumar v. State Of Chhattisgarh . reported in (2001) 9 SCC 618 : AIR 2001 SC 3837, if it transpires to the Court that a victim committing suicide was hypersensitive to ordinary petulance, discord and differences in domestic life quite common to the society to which the victim belonged and such petulance, discord and differences were not expected to induce a similarly circumstanced individual in a given society to commit suicide, the conscience of the Court should not be satisfied for basing a finding that the accused charged of abetting the offence of suicide should be found guilty.

10. The applicants relied on Dadarao v. State Of Maharashtra, 2017 ALL MR (Cri) 1538. In this case, a clerk had committed suicide due to heavy workload which he was unable to carry out. He had left behind a suicide note. There was no proximity of time between alleged instigation and date of incident. The FIR against the superior Executive Engineer was quashed.

11. State of Maharashtra v. Ibrahim Pathan, 2017 ALL MR (Cri) 1542. In this case, the accused had abused and abetted the deceased on a petty quarrel and after two days, the deceased committed suicide. It was held that there was no evidence of goading and encouragement. Hence, the acquittal was held proper.

12. Rajendrakumar & Others v. State Of Maharashtra & Others, 2017 ALL MR (Cri) 1869. The deceased was a salesman and he was allegedly harassed for not recovering dues from the customers. No specific role was attributed to any of the accused. There was vague evidence about creation of mental tension. Hence, the FIR was quashed.

13. In Dilip v. State Of Maharashtra . decided by Division Bench of Nagpur Bench on 05 August, 2016 (Criminal Application (APL) No. 332 of 2016), a judicial officer committed suicide leaving behind a note disclosing names of District Judge and other superior colleagues that they were responsible for his suicide as he was harassed by them. On scrutiny of the material, it was found that the allegations were vague and no case was made out for showing instigation or goading. Hence, the accused were acquitted.

14. In State of Kerala v. Unnikrishnan Nair, 2015 CJ(SC) 1275, the deceased had left behind a suicide note alleging that two colleagues from CBI had cheated him and put him in deep trouble. The respondents were junior to the deceased. Considering the vague allegations, it was held that there was no abetment.

15. In Praveen Pradhan v. State of Uttaranchal, (2012) 9 SCC 734, it was observed that there can be no straight-jacket formula to determine which act amounts to instigation and which does not. It is further observed that in a particular case there may not be direct evidence in regard to instigation which may have direct nexus with the suicide. Inference has to be drawn from the circumstances to determine whether a situation was created to totally frustrate the person and drive him to commit suicide. It was a case of a qualified graduate engineer subjected to persistent harassment and humiliation and additionally, also had to endure continuous illegal demands made by the appellant, upon non-fulfillment of which, he would be mercilessly harassed by the appellant for a prolonged period of time. He had also been forced to work continuously for a long durations in the factory, vis-a-vis other employees which often even entered to 16-17 hours at a stretch. Such harassment, coupled with the utterance of words to the effect, that, “had there been any other person in his place, he would have certainly committed suicide. It was held that, it amounted to instigation.

16. In Sunita Wawle v. State of Maharashtra (Cri. Appln. No. 2159/2017) decided on 14.06.2017 by the Division Bench of this Court to which one of us (A.M. Dhavale, J.) was a party. The victim had left behind a suicide note that on account of ill-treatment at the instance of the accused she was committing suicide. The applicant Sunita was not performing her duties as a Counselor faithfully. Due to her irresponsible performance, the image of the medical college was damaged. It was held that, it did not amount to instigation.

17. In Dr. Shivanand v. State, 2017 ALL MR (Cri) 1401, the Division Bench of this Court held that the allegations against Medical Superintendent that he did not allow him to resume duties and he harassed the deceased by non-payment of TA bills and Water bills and expenses for repair of official vehicle were not sufficient to hold that there was instigation to him. It was held that the petitioner was acting in his official capacity.

18. Considering the guidelines and applying them to the facts of the present case before us, we find that the only allegations against Vidya Ghorpade - Clerk, applicant in Criminal Application No. 5174 of 2017 is that she was not good in her work and she was giving all her work to the accused. The material shows that, she was sr. clerk and was also holding additional charge of Asst. Superintendent. Even accepting these allegations at the face value, we find that the act would not amount to abetment for the simple reason that the deceased had no compelling reasons to perform her work and if he would have refused to perform her work, nothing could have happened to him.

19. As far as Vaijnath Khandke, the applicant in Criminal Application No. 4724 of 2017 is concerned, he was a Dy. Director of Education. Though he had issued a circular stating that, every member should complete their work during office hours, the material on the record shows that, there was heavy work given to deceased Kishor. Besides, he was given additional charge of one Shinde from April-2017. The deceased was required to attend the court upto 5:00 p.m. and thereafter he was required to do his office work. In spite of working upto 10:00 pm he was unable to complete his work and was attending the office even on holidays. One circular was issued by the Dy. Director that everybody should produce his report of work done and if no such report would be given, his payment would be stopped. The documents on record show that, for years the work of deceased Kishor was appreciated with highest gradings ‘A’ or ‘A+’. After arrival of Khandke as Dy. Director in October-2016, Kishor was heavily burdened. He could not get time to even write the worksheet. His salary was stopped for the month of July-2017. Besides, there are allegations that Khandke, who was the Dy. Director and could have ruined the service career of Kishor was humiliating him by taunts. Stoppage of salary for the month of July-2017 must have been a big blow to deceased Kishor when he had an excellent career. He was working day and night and taking sincere efforts, still he was awarded with stoppage of increment. One would mentally get completely depressed. In the circumstances, we find that the allegations made against Vaijnath are capable of description of persistent mental harassment and ill-treatments of such nature that the deceased would find himself in depressing circumstances and would be frustrated. Having said that, we hold that we are not going to assess here whether the said material was sufficient or not for instigating the deceased to commit suicide. We hold that, such material might be sufficient. We make these observations only for the purpose of deciding this application and it should not influence the trial Judge at any stage. In view of this, we hold that, this is not a fit case for invoking powers u/s 482 of Cr.P.C. with respect to Vaijnath Khandke. In the result, we pass the following order.

(i) Criminal Application No. 5174 of 2017 filed by Vidya Ghorpade is hereby allowed. FIR bearing Crime No. 0268/2017 registered with MIDC CIDCO Police Station, Aurangabad for the offence punishable u/s 306, 506 r/w 34 of IPC is quashed to her extent.

(ii) Criminal Application No. 4724 of 2017 filed by Vaijnath Khandke is dismissed.