Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Shah Faisal v. Union Of India

Allahabad High Court
Oct 13, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Court Opinion Summary — Harsh Kumar, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns two bail applications in Complaint Case No. 1 of 2015 arising from prosecution by the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), Noida, Police Station-D.R.I., District-Gautam Budh Nagar under Sections 132, 135(1)(a) and 135(1)(b) of the Customs Act, 1962.

According to the prosecution, intelligence led DRI to inspect premises of M/s S.N. Metal Casting Export and M/s Excel Enterprises, Moradabad on 24/25.3.2015, where cartons of foreign origin cigarettes were found and seized; the stock was alleged to be worth Rs. 11,90,00,000/-. Subsequently, a container imported by M/s Pacific Industries (SEZ) on 15/16.4.2015 seized at DRI, Mumbai allegedly revealed foreign origin cigarettes worth Rs. 4,95,00,000/-. The prosecution alleges that several partners and firms (including Javed Ahmad, Shah Faisal, Nazim Ali Khan, Munawwar Ali and others) formed a syndicate to smuggle foreign cigarettes into India under the guise of importing scrap, without licence and without payment of customs duty, causing an alleged financial loss of over Rs. 12,00,00,000/- to the Government.

The two applicants before the Court were Shah Faisal (applicant) and Munawwar Ali (applicant). Bail applications by each were heard; counsel for the DRI opposed the bail applications. After hearing counsel and considering the record, the Court rejected both bail applications.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether bail should be granted to the applicants, Shah Faisal and Munawwar Ali, in the prosecution under Sections 132, 135(1)(a) and 135(1)(b) of the Customs Act, 1962.
  2. Whether the statements recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act (as relied upon by the prosecution) are admissible and voluntary — an issue raised by the parties during submissions.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant Shah Faisal's Arguments

  • The applicant is falsely implicated and no incriminating article was recovered from his possession or on his pointing out.
  • He was not present at the place of alleged recovery on 24/25.3.2015 because he had gone to Mumbai from 22.3.2015 to 29.3.2015.
  • Witnesses to search and seizure are alleged to be planted and the applicant's statement recorded by the prosecution is asserted to be not voluntary.
  • The applicant was not looking after the business; a power of attorney in favour of Munawwar Ali (dated 20.3.2012) authorized Munawwar Ali to conduct business affairs, and the Ministry of Commerce and Industries accepted this authorization by letter dated 21.3.2012.
  • The statement recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act is asserted to be inadmissible.
  • No duty is chargeable within the SEZ area and therefore no offence of evasion of customs duty under Section 135(1)(b) is made out against him.
  • Even if any alleged import occurred, the power of attorney holder Munawwar Ali was responsible as he handled day-to-day affairs.
  • Co-accused Nazim Ali Khan and Wasim Ahmad had been granted bail by the Court in other applications; the applicant undertakes not to misuse liberty and was stated to be in jail since 18.6.2015.

Applicant Munawwar Ali's Arguments

  • The applicant is falsely implicated, is an innocent person and enjoys respect in the locality; he was not named in the F.I.R. and his name surfaced in confessional statements of co-accused.
  • He was not present at the spot at the time of search and seizure and recovery of alleged imported cigarettes.
  • Mandatory provisions for search/seizure compliance were not followed.
  • The recovered imported cigarettes are not prohibited or restricted for import into India.
  • The offence attracts a maximum imprisonment of seven years; the applicant is suffering from cardiac disease.
  • Co-accused Nazim Ali Khan and Wasim Ahmad have been granted bail by this Court in other matters (orders dated 19.7.2016 in Criminal Misc. Bail Application Nos. 36614 of 2015 and 29363 of 2015).

Respondent (DRI, Customs and Central Excise) Arguments

  • The applicants are in collusion with each other (Shah Faisal being son-in-law of Munawwar Ali) and committed the offence in a planned manner by importing foreign cigarettes under the cover of scrap, giving incorrect descriptions, without authority and without payment of customs duty.
  • Applicants are partners in the firms alleged: Shah Faisal is a partner of M/s Pacific Industries and M/s S.N. Metal Casting Exports (SEZ); Munawwar Ali is partner of M/s Pacific Industries.
  • The applicants admitted commission of the offence in their voluntary statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act; the statements are voluntary and binding.
  • Material on record allegedly proves a syndicate with co-accused (Javed Khan, Imran, Anwar etc.) that imported cigarettes as aluminium scrap; goods were imported and loaded at various premises and stores as described in the record (including import to Pacific Industries on 21.3.2015 and subsequent loading and storage activities).
  • The applicants allegedly caused a loss of over Rs. 12,00,00,000/- to the public exchequer by non-payment of excise/customs duty and admitted that smuggled goods were sourced from Dubai by associate Anwar.
  • The applicants, if released on bail, would misuse liberty; medical ailment claims and alibi are disputed as false by the prosecution.
  • Bail applications of certain co-accused were decided differently (some granted, some rejected) and the prosecution urged that the present cases are not identical to those granted bail.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court recorded that it heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. In reaching its decision, the Court expressly considered the following factors as stated in the opinion:

  • The alleged complicity of the accused (their alleged collusion and syndicate activity as set out in the prosecution case).
  • The severity of punishment attached to the offences under the Customs Act as charged (Sections 132, 135(1)(a) and 135(1)(b)).
  • The totality of the facts and circumstances on the record presented at this stage of proceedings (including seizure particulars, alleged admissions and documentary/material evidence noted by the prosecution).

The Court noted that, while making these considerations, it was deciding the bail applications at an interlocutory stage and explicitly stated it was doing so "without commenting on merits of the case." On the basis of the factors listed above, the Court concluded that this was not a fit case for grant of bail to the two applicants.

Holding and Implications

REJECTED

Holding: The two bail applications of Shah Faisal and Munawwar Ali in Complaint Case No. 1 of 2015 (under Sections 132, 135(1)(a), 135(1)(b) of the Customs Act, Police Station-D.R.I., Noida) are rejected.

Implications: As a direct effect of this decision, the applicants remain in custody and their prayer for bail is denied. The opinion does not purport to set any new legal precedent; no broader legal implications or novel legal principles are articulated in the judgment beyond the Court's application of the stated factors (complicity, severity of punishment and totality of facts) to deny bail at this stage.

Source: Opinion of Harsh Kumar, J., as provided. This summary is confined strictly to the content presented in that opinion and does not add external facts or legal materials.

Show all summary ...

Harsh Kumar, J.:— Heard Sri. Vivek Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the applicant, Shah Faisal, Sri. Irfanul Huda, Advocate holding brief of Sri. Rizwan Ahmad (Qureshi), learned counsel for the applicant, Munawwar Ali and Sri. Sanjay Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, Custom and Central Excise.

2. The brief facts of the prosecution case are that as per information of Intelligence Officer, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, Noida (hereinafter referred ‘DRI’) accused Javed Ahmad, partner of M/s Excel Enterprises, Moradabad, Shah Faisal, partner M/s Pacific Industries and M/s. S.N. Metal Casting Exports Special Economic Zone, Moradabad (hereinafter referred to as ‘SEZ’). Nazim Ali Khan, partner M/s S.N. Metal Casting Export (SEZ), Moradabad, M/s Pacific Industries plot no. G-39 pocket A Phase-I, Pakwara, Moradabad, M/s S.N. Metal Casting Export G-48 pocket A Phase-1, Pakwara, Moradabad and M/s Excel Enterprises, 141 Daulat Bagh near Tara Building, Police Station-Nagfani, district-Moradabad and the syndicate of all the above persons have smuggled heavy quantity of foreign origin cigarettes in the name of import of scrap and other goods.

3. Upon above information the officers of Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (‘DRI’) inspected the premises of M/s S.N. Metal Casting Export and M/s Excel Enterprises, Moradabad on 24/25.3.2015 where cartons of foreign origin cigarettes were found stored of which inquest was prepared in accordance with the Rules and above stock of foreign cigarettes worth Rs. 11,90,00,000/- (Eleven crores ninety lacs) was seized. Subsequently, information was received that a container imported by M/s Pacific Industries (SEZ) on 15/16.4.2015 has been seized by D.R.I, Mumbai which was shown as scrap but upon removing the partition in the container, it was found that foreign origin cigarettes worth of Rs. 4,95,00,000/- (Four crores ninety five lacs) were stored therein in black plastic bags. It is the case of prosecution that the owners and partners of above mentioned firms have failed to show any authorisation letter or other documents for import of foreign origin cigarettes which were all the brands of ‘DJARUM BLACK’, GUDANG GARAM’ and DUNHILL. Upon investigation it was found that the partners of above firms namely, Javed Ahmad, Shah Faisal, Nazim Ali Khan, Munawwar Ali and Gulam Haidar do have nexus with each other and are involved in unauthorised import of foreign origin cigarettes without licence and without payment of requisite custom duty in the garb of import of scrap. It was found that by unauthorized import of foreign origin cigarettes and non-payment of custom duty, a financial loss of over Rs. 12,00,00,000/- (Twelve crores) has been caused to the government.

4. Learned counsel for the applicant, Shah Faisal submitted that the applicant has been falsely implicated in the present case; that no incriminating article was recovered from his possession or on his pointing out; that nothing material was recovered from the premises in question in presence of applicant who had gone to Mumbai for a period from 22.3.2015 to 29.3.2015 and was not present at the place of alleged recovery on 24/25.3.2015; that witnesses of search and seizure are planted; that the statement of applicant recorded by the prosecution agency is not voluntarily; that the applicant was not looking after the business of firms of which he is partner and on behalf of him his father-in-law, as well as power of attorney holder Munawwar Ali was looking after the business of firms and a deed of general power of attorney was executed by the applicant in his favour on 20.3.2012; that the Ministry of Commerce and Industries, Government of India had been informed about the authorization of Munawwar Ali which was accepted vide letter dated 21.3.2012 issued by the Assistant Development Commissioner & Security Officer Ministry of Commerce & Industries, Government of India, Moradabad; that the statement of applicant recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act is not admissible; that the applicant had no active and direct participation with the business or any activity of his firm because his power of attorney holder Munawwar Ali was looking after the affairs of the firms; that the search and seizure proceedings have been manipulated; that no duty is chargeable within the ‘SEZ’ area and no offence of evasion of custom duty is made out against the applicant under Section 135(1)(b) of the Customs Act, 1962; that the applicant has not committed any offence and has no knowledge of the alleged import of foreign origin cigarettes in the premises of firm; that even in case of the alleged import, if any, Munawwar Ali, the power of attorney holder of applicant is responsible as he was looking after the day to day affairs of the company; that co-accused Nazim Ali Khan and Wasim Ahmad have already been granted bail by this Court, vide orders dated 19.7.2016 passed in Criminal Misc. Bail Application Nos. 36614 of 2015 and 29363 of 2015 respectively; that the offence is punishable with a minimum imprisonment of one year and maximum imprisonment of seven years; that the applicant undertakes that he will not misuse the liberty of bail; that the applicant is in jail since 18.6.2015.

5. Learned counsel for the applicant-Munawwar Ali submitted that the applicant has been falsely implicated in the present case; that the applicant is an innocent person and carries great respect in the locality; that the applicant has not committed any offence and is not named in the F.I.R. rather his name has come to light in the confessional statements of co-accused persons; that the applicant was not present at the spot at the time of search and seizure proceedings and recovery of imported cigarettes worth Rs. 4,95,000/- (four lacs ninety five thousand) and Rs. 11,90,00,000/- (Eleven crores ninety lacs) from the premises in question; that the compliance of mandatory provisions has not been made; that the recovered material (imported cigarettes) are not prohibited or restricted for the purpose of import in India; that the offence is punishable with maximum imprisonment of seven years; that the applicant is suffering from Cardiac disease; that co-accused Nazim Ali Khan and Wasim Ahmad have already been granted bail by this Court, vide orders dated 19.7.2016 passed in Criminal Misc. Bail Application Nos. 36614 of 2015 and 29363 of 2015 respectively.

6. Sanjay Kumar Singh, learned counsel for the DRI, Customs and Central Excise vehemently opposed the prayer for bail and contended that the applicants are in collusion with each other and undisputedly applicant-Shah Faisal is son-in-law of the applicant-Munawwar Ali who is his father-in-law; that both the applicants are in collusion with each other and they have committed the offence in a planned manner and have imported heavy quantity of foreign origin cigarettes under the cover of scrap material by giving incorrect description of goods imported and without any authority and without payment of requisite custom duty; that the applicant-Shah Faisal is partner of M/s. Pacific Industries and M/s. S.N. Metal Casting Exports (SEZ), Moradabad, while applicant-Munawwar Ali is partner of M/s. Pacific Industries; that both the accused have admitted the committal of offence by them in their voluntary statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act; that it is proved from the material on record that the applicants made a syndicate with co-accused persons, Javed Khan, Imran and Anwar etc. and used to import foreign origin cigarettes under the garb of import of aluminum scrap; that various exemptions have been permitted to the industries established in ‘SEZ’; that since the containers of alleged imported aluminum scrap were not required to be checked at the time of entry on ‘ICD’ or ‘SEZ the applicants have benefits provided to the firms without SEZ by unauthorized smuggling of foreign origin cigarettes; that unutilized cigarettes recovered from S.N. Metal Casting Exports G-48 pocket A (SEZ), Moradabad and M/s Excel Enterprises, 141 Daulat Bagh near Tara Building, P.S. Nagfani, district-Moradabad were imported at Pacific Industries on 21.3.2015 through two containers of 40 feet each and the same day 320 LDPE bags, DJARUM BLACK cigarettes, seven LDEP bags of GUDANG GARAM cigarettes and one LDEP bag of DUNHILL cigarettes were loaded in Eicher container and kept in the godown of M/s Excel Enterprises, Moradabad; that it has been confessed by the applicants that they used to import foreign origin cigarettes for other persons and also used to get heavy amount per carton and applicant-Munawwar Ali was authorised to load the goods at Excel Enterprises; that the applicants have caused loss to the tune of over Rs. 12,00,00,000 (twelve crores) to public exchequer by non-payment of excise duty; that it has been admitted by the applicants that the smuggled goods used to be loaded from Dubai by their associate Anwar; that the applicants are in collusion with each other and in order to seek bail are shifting liability of each other; that while applicant Shah Faisal has shifted all liabilities on his father-in-law and power of attorney holder, the applicant Munawwar Ali has not made any whisper in this regard; that due to alibi raised by applicant, Shah Faisal is false and can be looked into upon evidence during trial; that the applicant, Shah Faisal was active partner of firms and was looking after the business of firms very cleverly and allegations made against him are contrary, false and incorrect; that bail application of Javed Ahmad Khan has been rejected by this Court vide order dated 19.7.2016 in Crl. Misc. Bail Application No. 36608 of 2015; that the allegations of alleged illness of applicant-Munawwar Ali are false and incorrect; that the case of applicants is not identical to that of Nazim Ali Khan and Waseem Ahmad; that the statements of applicants under Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 has been given by them voluntarily and are binding on them; that the applicants if released on bail, shall misuse the liberty of bail.

7. Upon hearing learned counsel for the parties, perusal of record and considering the complicity of accused, severity of punishment as wall as totality of the facts and circumstances, at this stage without commenting on merits of the case, I do not find it a fit case for grant of bail to the two applicants.

8. The two bail applications of the applicants, Shah Faisal and Munawwar Ali in Complaint Case No. 1 of 2015, under Sections 132, 135(1)(a), 135(1)(b) of the Customs Act, Police Station-D.R.I., Noida, District-Gautam Budh Nagar are rejected accordingly.