Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

D.R. Sharma v. Essar Oil Limited

Company Law Board
Apr 30, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner invoked the provisions of Sec. 111A(2) of the Companies Act seeking directions (as prayed in paragraph 8 of the petition) to transfer 2,800 debentures and to rectify the register in his favour. The petitioner stated that he purchased 2,800 debentures (at Rs. 35 each, total Rs. 61,600) through the stock market via Raj Kumar Shanna & Company on 28.6.1995, and that these debentures were lodged for transfer but returned due to signature mismatch. The petitioner further asserted that the debentures were stolen from his house on 8.2.2008 and that he sought duplicate debentures and transfer.

Respondent No. 1 (the company) filed a reply denying that the petition falls within Sec. 111A(2), asserting willingness to transfer subject to production of required documents, and stating that transfer documents for 2,800 debentures showed seller signature mismatches and were returned with an objection memo. The company said 200 debentures were transferred and dispatched in June 2006 but the remaining 2,800 were returned to the petitioner. The Registrar (Share Pro Services India Pvt. Ltd.) advised the petitioner to produce FIR/police complaint, proof of purchase, proof of payment, and obtain fresh transfer deeds or a court decree.

The company also indicated that these debentures were partly paid (Rs. 35 of Rs. 105) and, under a sanctioned scheme of arrangement, certain payments were made to registered holders. The company asserted it had placed stop marks and wrote to the original registered holders (Respondent Nos. 2–29) in May 2009 seeking confirmation or objections to the claimed transfer.

The Bench heard the parties, reviewed the documents, noted delays and deficiencies in the petitioner's documentation (including absence of an FIR on record despite the petitioner's assertion that one was annexed), and observed lengthy unexplained delay between the 1995 purchase and the 2006/2008 actions. The Bench made directions concerning conditions under which the company may act and disposed of the company petition (CP) with those directions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner is entitled to a direction under Sec. 111A(2) of the Companies Act to transfer 2,800 debentures and to rectify the register in his name.
  2. Whether the petitioner has established title to the debentures in view of returned transfer deeds (signature mismatches), alleged theft, and the delay between purchase (1995) and lodging/steps taken (2006–2009).
  3. What procedural steps the respondent company must take before transferring the debentures (for example, documentary proof, issuing notices to registered holders, and taking indemnity).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner purchased 2,800 debentures on 28.6.1995 through the stock market (via Raj Kumar Shanna & Company) for a lawful consideration of Rs. 61,600.
  • The petitioner lodged the debentures for transfer but they were returned untransferred due to a "fluting Signature mismatch" (signature mismatch).
  • The debentures were subsequently stolen in a house theft on 8.2.2008, and the petitioner sought issuance of duplicate debentures and transfer in his name from the Registrar/company.
  • The petitioner seeks directions that the company transfer the 2,800 debentures to him and rectify the register accordingly.

Respondent No. 1 Company's Arguments

  • Respondent No. 1 contended the petition does not fall within Sec. 111A(2) because the company has not refused to register the transfer; rather, it is willing to transfer once the petitioner produces necessary documents.
  • The company stated that out of 3,000 debentures (part C of OFCDs) lodged, 200 were properly transferred in June 2006 and dispatched; the remaining 2,800 showed signature mismatches and were returned with an objection memo dated 30.5.2006 (dispatched 9.6.2006).
  • All the debentures were partly paid to the extent of Rs. 35 out of Rs. 105 and remained registered in the names of original holders (Respondent Nos. 2–29).
  • The Registrar advised the petitioner to produce proof of purchase (broken contract/delivery note), proof of payment, FIR/police complaint, and to obtain fresh transfer deeds or a court order; names and addresses of sellers were provided to assist obtaining signatures.
  • The company asserted that mere purchase on the market does not confer title unless transfer deeds, duly executed, are lodged with the company; in the instant case, the debentures were returned under objection, so the petitioner has not acquired title.
  • The company placed stop marks and wrote to the registered holders requesting confirmation or objections; the company will act in accordance with law and the Registrar's procedures, including obtaining indemnity if it transfers the debentures.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Bench undertook a document-based and fact-based analysis and reached conclusions for the following reasons (as set out in the opinion):

  1. Chronology and delay: The petitioner claimed purchase in 1995 but did not clarify when he lodged the debentures for transfer; there was a significant unexplained delay (the petitioner approached the Bench in 2009, some 14 years after the 1995 purchase). The Bench noted that if the debentures were purchased in 1995, it was unclear why they were not lodged for transfer immediately thereafter.
  2. Missing/supporting documents: The petitioner alleged a theft on 8.2.2008 and stated that an FIR was annexed as 'A-2', but the Bench, on perusal, found no FIR—only a photocopy of a letter. The Registrar's letter dated 27.6.2008 acknowledged receipt of a petitioner letter (dated 24.3.2008) and noted the absence of an FIR or police certificate reporting loss/theft of debenture certificates.
  3. Registrar and company procedure: The Registrar advised the petitioner to obtain fresh transfer deeds from the sellers and stated that transfers would be effected if seller signatures matched specimen signatures on record. The Registrar also advised obtaining a decree from a competent court restraining the company from transferring the debentures to third parties, where appropriate.
  4. Petitioner's inaction: Despite the Registrar's guidance, the petitioner did not obtain fresh transfer deeds nor take steps to restrain the company from transferring the debentures. The Bench observed that the petitioner also failed to serve notices on the transferors/respondents after filing the petition and did not file proof of such notices.
  5. Company response and interim steps: The company recorded that the 2,800 debentures were lodged on 16.5.2006 and returned on 9.6.2006 due to signature mismatches. The company placed stop marks and, acting in bona fide intention, sent letters dated 16 & 19 May 2009 to the registered debenture holders (Respondent Nos. 2–29) informing them of the petitioner's claim and inviting confirmations or objections within 15 days.
  6. No adverse claim by third parties: The company reported that there was no response from the holders to those letters and apparently no adverse claim from third parties; however, the debentures still stood in the names of the original holders.
  7. Preconditions for transfer: The Bench concluded that the company is not prevented from taking action to transfer the debentures to the petitioner, but only if the petitioner proves his bona fide purchase and furnishes the required documents establishing ownership. Before any transfer, the respondent company must issue notices to all debenture holders. If no replies are received within three weeks from the date of such notices, the company may act according to law.
  8. Indemnity and reservation: If the company decides to transfer the debentures in favour of the petitioner, it shall obtain an indemnity from the petitioner in respect of the said debentures. If there exists any legitimate claim or court order affecting the debentures, the respondent company shall act in accordance with law.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: The petition (CP) was disposed of by the Bench with specific directions rather than being granted unqualified relief.

Direct consequences and operational implications:

  • The petitioner has not established entitlement to immediate transfer because of documentary deficiencies (no FIR produced on record, no proof of payment/purchase appended) and unexplained delay between 1995 and later steps; accordingly, the Bench did not direct an immediate transfer.
  • The respondent company is permitted to proceed with transfer only if the petitioner proves his bona fide purchase and furnishes the necessary documents establishing title (e.g., proof of purchase/payment, fresh transfer deeds where applicable).
  • Before taking action to transfer, the company must issue notices to all debenture holders. If no replies are received within three weeks from the date of notice, the company may act in accordance with law.
  • Should the company decide to transfer the debentures, it must take an indemnity from the petitioner to protect the company against future claims.
  • If there exists any legitimate claim or court order affecting the debentures, the respondent company must act in accordance with such law/orders.

The opinion does not purport to set any new legal precedent; it disposes of the petition by directing procedural steps and safeguards for transfer, conditioned on the petitioner establishing ownership and providing indemnity.

Show all summary ...

1. The present petition is filed by invoking the provisions of Sec. 111 A(2) of the Companies Act, praying this Bench to grant reliefs as prayed in para 8 of the petition. Shri Arun Jain. Learned PCS appearing for the petitioner narrated the facts which led to filing the present petition. He submitted that the petitioner had purchased 2800 Debentures of Rs. 35/- each of the Respondent No. 1 Company for a lawful consideration of Rs. 61,600/- from the stock market through Raj Kumar Shanna & Company, a recognized member of Bhuvaneshwar Stock Exchange vide purchase note 28.6.1995 Petitioner lodged the said 2800 debentures for transfer with the erstwhile company as the same was returned untransferred with the fluting Signature mismatch. It is submitted that in the meanwhile there was theft in the house on 8.2.2008 and all debentures were stolen along with other articles. Petitioner approached the Registrar of the Company for issue of duplicate debentures and transfer in his name. The Registrar of the Company i.e Share Pro Services India Pvt. Ltd. has advised the petitioner to approach competent Court of Law for a decree in favour of the petitioner. In view of the aforesaid, it is abundantly clear that the petitioner is the bonafide purchaser of the 2800 debentures from Respondent Nos. 2 to 29 through stock market mechanism for valuable consideration. The petitioner is the rigfhtful owner of the said 2800 debentures. In view of the above he sought direction to the Respondent No. 1 to transfer 2800 debentures in the name of the petitioner and rectify the register accordingly.

2. Respondent No. 1 company filed reply to the petition. Shri Radhakrishnan, Dy. General Manager, of the R1 company stated that the petition filed by the petitioner before this Bench does not fell within the ambit of Sec. 111A(2) of the Companies Act, 1956 as the company has not refused to register transfer of debentures. In feet, the Company has expressed its willingness to transfer the debentures in favour of the petitioner on submission of necessary documents, which have not been produced/furnished by the petitioner. He further submitted that of the total 3000 debentures being part C of the OFCDs alleged to have been purchased by the petitioner in the year 1995 and were lodged by him for transfer on 16.5.2006 after a gap of about 11 years. All of these debentures an partly paid to the extent of Rs. 35/- per debenture out of face value of Rs. 105/- per debenture. Out of the said 3000 debentures, the transfer documents for 200 debentures were found to be in order and the same were duly transferred in favour of the petitioner on 21.6.2006 and dispatched by registered post on 26.6.2006 Since the documents in respect of 2800 debentures lodged by the petitioner where the sellers signatures on the relevant transfer deeds differ with the specimen signatures recorded with the Registrar and Transfer Agent of the Company. Accordingly, the same were returned to the petitioner along with objection Memo dated 30.5.2006 and dispatched on 9.6.2006 by erstwhile Registrar and Transfer Agents by registered post. All the debentures are partly paid to the extent of Rs. 35/- per debenture and they are still held in the name of original holders (sellers). As per the terms of the prospectus, these debentures were to be redeemed on 20.4.2003 The company had filed a scheme of Compromise & Arrangement for restructuring the debentures and the same was sanctioned by the Hon'ble Gujarat High court. As per the said approved scheme of arrangement, the debenture holders/registered holders were sent with the 1 yearly interest Payment on 20.4.2007 All the 28 cases referred to are shown as outstanding. The 1 yearly interest payment was released on 20.4.2008 Out of the 28 debenture/registered holders referred to above, only on of the holders Ms. Sawatri Devi Lakhotia had encashed the said payment. All others are outstanding. The company has exercised prepayment option for payment of principal money and outstanding interests in three instalments. Accordingly, the company has dispatched 1 of principal amount and outstanding interest on 30.9.2008 to all debenture holders including the subjected 28 cases. Out of which 5 investors have encashed the warrants. The Registrar of the Company advised vide their letter dated 27.6.2008 to comply with the procedural documents like FIR, Police complaint, proof of purchase payment proof etc. or obtain order from a Court of appropriate jurisdiction by impleading the holders as necessary parties. This respondent after recording stop mark on the said 2,800 debentures with bonafide intention wrote letters to the holders of these certificates i.e the respondents 2 to 29 herein through the erstwhile registrar vide letters dated 16 & 19 May, 2009 regarding the alleged claim of the petitioner and requested them to confirm sale of their debentures or to raise objections. Mere purchase of debentures one cannot acquire title on the same unless the certificates evidencing the debentures are lodged with the company with validly executed transfer deeds. In the instant case the debentures returned to the petitioner under objection. Thus, it is quite clear that the petitioner has not acquired title on the said debentures. It was also advised to the petitioner to submit the following documents to help him establishing his title to the said debentures:

i) Proof of purchase of debentures such as broken contract/delivery note/bill

ii) proof of payment of consideration amount paid to the sellers.

iii) The Registrar and Transfer Agent also provided the names and addressed of the sellers for obtaining signatures on the transfer deeds.

It is submitted that since the matter involves dispute to the title, this Bench be pleased to record the version of the debenture holders with regard to i) sale of scheduled debentures, ii) No objection letter in favour of the petitioner.

In view of the reasons stated above the petition is devoid of merits and prayed this Bench to dismiss the same.

Heard the parties. It is the case of the petitioner that he purchased the debentures in the year 1995 through Stock Market Mechanism and he lodged the debentures for transfer, but same were returned with the a memo string signature mismatch. The contention of the Petitioner that there was theft in his house on 08.02.2008 and all the debentures was stolen along with other articles. Though the petitioner stated that a copy of FIR is annexed as ‘A-2’, however from the perusal of documents there is no FIR annexed except a photocopy of letter. The petitioner did not state that when did he lodged the debentures for transfer. If the debentures purchased in the year 1995 how could the debentures did not lodged for transfer immediately after purchase of debentures in the year 1995. The grievance of the petitioner that there was theft in his house on 08.02.2008 and the debentures were stolen. The petitioner did not state the reasons the delay from 1995 till 2008. The Registrar of the Company viz. Share pro Services Limited addressed letter dated 27.06.2008 to the petitioner acknowledging the receipt of petitioner letter dated 24.03.2008 It is observed by the Registrar that there was no copy of FIR as stated by the Petitioner or any certificate issued by Police Authorities reporting loss of theft of Debentures Certificates. The Registrar further advised the Petitioner to obtain fresh transfer deeds from the seller. It is also stated that if the signature of seller's match with specimen signatures of the Transferors with the records of the company the company will transfer the debentures in the name of the Petitioner. It is also advised by the Registrar to obtain a decree from the competent court of Law restraining the Respondent Company from transferring the debentures to third parties. In spite of letter of the Registrar to the petitioner, the petitioner had not taken any efforts in obtaining the fresh transfer deed from the transferors. It appears that the Police Authorities have not registered the case since the petitioner failed to annex copy of even though he stated that he annexed the copy of FIR. The Petitioner also did not take any appropriate steps restraining the Respondent Company from transferring the Debentures. On the other fund the of the Company i.e Share-pro Services Limited addressed letters dated 16.05.2009, 19.05.2009 to all the Debenture holders stating that the Petitioner was informed to them that he had purchased debentures from the Market 1995 and you had signed the transfer deed in conformation thereof at that time. It is also stated in the letter that if any objection in respect of transfer the Debentures he/she may be intimated to the Company in writing within period of 15 days from the date of letter. It is also clearly by the Registrar if no intimation/reply/objection is received by the company, the company will proceed in transferring the debentures in the name of the Transferee without any further reference. The Respondent company diligently acted in respect of the transfer of Debentures. However the Petitioner had not taken any steps either obtaining fresh transfer deeds even failed to send notices to the Respondents after filing the petition and no proof is filed along with the petition. Admittedly the transaction pertains to the year 1995 and the Petitioner approached this Bench in the year 2009 after lapse of 14 years and there is no explanation by the Petitioner for such innumerable delay. Even though the Petitioner arrayed the transferors as parties to the Petition but the Petitioner failed to send notices to parties. This Bench is of the view that the Petitioner has not taken any efforts in timely in obtaining the fresh transfer deeds from the transferors nor obtained any court orders prohibiting the company from transferring the Debentures to any third parties. There is no continuous cause of action from the year 1995 till 2008. The Petitioner failed to establish any case to grant the reliefs as prayed in the petition. Whilst the Respondent Company made out some case from its counter which gives a ray hope to the petitioners case. It is staled in its counter stated that they received 2,800 Debentures from the Petitioner on 16.05.2006 and same were returned to him for the reasons of signature mismatch on 09.06.2009 It appears that the Petitioner had lodged the Debentures in the year 2006 only and he did not take any further steps and foiled to lodge rectified documents with fresh transfer deeds. The Respondent Company stated that the Debentures are still standing in the name of present holder i.e Respondent No. 2 to 29 and the Respondent Company with bonafide intention wrote letters to the Respondent No. 2 to 29 calling their replies/objections. However there is no response from the Respondents and it appears that there is no adverse claim from any third parties. Keeping in view of the forgoing reasons the Respondent Company is not prevented from taking any action in respect of transfer of Debentures in the name of the Petitioner if the Petitioner proves his bonafide in respect of purchase of debentures and furnishes the required document to established ownership on the debentures. Before taking any action in respect of transfer of debentures the Respondent Company shall issue notices to all the debenture holders. If the company do not receives any replies within a period of three weeks from the date of notice the Respondent Company may act in accordance with law. In case of the Respondent Company takes decision to transfer the debentures in the name of the Petitioner the Respondent Company shall take the indemnity from the petitioner in respect of the said debentures. In case there is any legitimate claim and court orders on the said debentures the Respondent No. 1 company shall act in accordance with law. With the above direction the CP is disposed off.