- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd . v. Rinku Devi And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
This is an appeal (MAC.APP. 815/2019) by The Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. against an award of compensation dated 02.07.2019 passed by the learned Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (MACT). The insurer challenged the award on the ground that the Tribunal erred in not granting the right of recovery, alleging that the driving licence of the driver of the offending vehicle was found to be fake in view of evidence led by the insurer. The matter was heard by Justice Najmi Waziri and decided on 09.10.2019.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the insurer is entitled to the right of recovery from the owner/driver because the driving licence of the driver was found to be fake.
- Whether claimants should be granted compensation for 'loss of love and affection' under the non-pecuniary heads and, if so, the appropriate amount.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant (insurer) contended that compensation under the non-pecuniary (non-conventional) heads has been limited to Rs. 70,000/- in terms of the decision in Cholamandalam M/S General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Aarifa & Ors. (Civil Appeal No. 6020 of 2019), which in turn relied on the Supreme Court's decision in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi & Ors., (2017) 16 SCC 680, to hold that compensation under non-conventional heads could not be more than Rs. 70,000/-.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Lehru & Ors., (2003) 3 SCC 338 | The duty of the vehicle owner is only to see that the driver has a driving licence which appears to be genuine and that the driver possesses requisite driving skills and was tested before employment. | The court applied this principle to conclude that the owner had discharged the required duty (saw the licence, tested the driver's skills and even had the licence verified by the Issuing Authority), and therefore the owner/insured remained covered despite the licence and its verification later being found fake. |
| Cholamandalam M/S General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Aarifa & Ors., Civil Appeal No. 6020 of 2019 | Relied upon (as submitted by appellant) to limit compensation under non-conventional heads to Rs. 70,000/-, referencing Pranay Sethi. | The court noted the appellant's reliance on this decision but observed subsequent Supreme Court decisions addressing non-pecuniary awards and proceeded to apply those subsequent decisions instead. |
| National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors., (2017) 16 SCC 680 | Authority cited for the proposition that compensation under non-conventional heads could not exceed Rs. 70,000/- (as relied upon in Cholamandalam). | The court recorded that Cholamandalam relied on Pranay Sethi, but noted later Supreme Court decisions set specific amounts for heads such as loss of love and affection and loss of consortium. |
| Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram Alias Chuhru Ram & Ors., 2018 SCC OnLine SC 1546 | Fixes compensation post-Pranay Sethi: 'loss of love and affection' @ Rs. 50,000/- and 'loss of consortium' @ Rs. 40,000/- for each claimant. | The court relied on this decision to grant compensation towards 'loss of love and affection' at Rs. 50,000/- to each claimant. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first addressed the insurer's contention concerning the alleged fake driving licence. It noted the Tribunal's findings that the vehicle owner had seen the driving licence, tested the driver's driving skills before employment, and had the licence verified by the Issuing Authority. Although the licence and the verification were later found to be fake after the accident, the court observed that the owner's conduct demonstrated prudence. Relying upon the Supreme Court's dictum in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Lehru & Ors. (2003) 3 SCC 338 — that the owner's duty is only to ensure the licence appears genuine and the driver is tested for skill — the court concluded the owner had discharged the requisite duty and therefore the insured was covered. For this reason, the court found no basis to modify the impugned award on the ground urged by the appellant.
The court then observed that the claimants had not been awarded any compensation for 'loss of love and affection' under non-pecuniary heads. The appellant relied on recent authority (Cholamandalam) and Pranay Sethi to argue that non-conventional heads could not exceed Rs. 70,000/-. The court, however, noted that subsequent Supreme Court decisions had fixed specific amounts post-Pranay Sethi — referring to Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram — which set 'loss of love and affection' at Rs. 50,000/- and 'loss of consortium' at Rs. 40,000/- for each claimant. Applying that approach, the court granted Rs. 50,000/- to each claimant for loss of love and affection.
Finally, the court specified the financial consequences and directions for deposit and disbursement: the enhanced amount of Rs. 2,00,000/- with interest at 9% from the date of filing of the claim petition until realization must be deposited before the Tribunal within three weeks to be released to the award beneficiaries as per the prescribed scheme; and the statutory amount with accrued interest must be deposited into the 'AASRA' Fund opened in the Delhi High Court.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF
Direct effect on the parties:
- The appeal challenging the MACT award on the ground of a fake driving licence and seeking a right of recovery was not allowed — the court upheld the Tribunal's approach that the owner had taken the steps required by law and the insured remained covered.
- The court granted compensation towards 'loss of love and affection' at Rs. 50,000/- to each claimant (applying the approach in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd.).
- The insurer (appellant) was directed to deposit an enhanced sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- with interest at 9% from the date of filing to the Tribunal within three weeks for disbursement; the statutory amount with interest was to be deposited into the AASRA Fund.
The opinion does not state that it is laying down any new precedent; the decision applies existing Supreme Court dicta and subsequent authorities to the facts before the court.
$~10 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
% Decided on: 09.10.2019 + MAC.APP. 815/2019, CM APPL. 44502/2019 & CM APPL. 44503/2019
THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO LTD ..... Appellant Through: Mr. Pradeep Gaur, Advocate. versus
RINKU DEVI & ORS ..... Respondents
Through:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAJMI WAZIRI
NAJMI WAZIRI, J. (Oral)
1. This appeal impugns the award of compensation dated 02.07.2019 passed by the learned MACT in New No. 49365-16 on the ground that it has erred in not granting the right of recovery, despite the driving licence of the driver of the offending vehicle having been found to be fake in view of the evidence led by the insurer.
2. The Court would note that the impugned order has dealt with the aforementioned issue elaborately, inasmuch as the owner had stated that he had seen the licence of the driver and tested the driver's driving skills before he was employed. The driving licence appeared to be genuine. But the vehicle owner went a step further, he had the driving licence duly verified by the Issuing Authority. Evidently, he could not have done anymore than
1
this. His prudence is evident. It is another matter though that after the accident, upon another examination it was found that both, the driving licence and its verification were fake. Be that as it may, the duty and requirement of the owner, as per the dicta of the Supreme Court in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Lehru & Ors., (2003) 3 SCC 338, is only to see that the driver had a driving licence which appeared to be genuine and that he possessed the requisite skills and that he was tested for his driving skills before being employed to drive the vehicle.
3. This exercise having been carried out by the insured/owner of the vehicle, he is duly covered and protected. Therefore, there is no reason to modify the impugned order, on this ground.
4. At this stage, the Court would note that the claimants have not been granted any compensation towards 'loss of love and affection' which is a factor to be taken into consideration on the ground for compensation under non-pecuniary head.
5. The learned counsel for the appellant submits that the compensation under non-conventional head has been limited to Rs. 70,000/- in terms of the dicta of the Supreme Court in Cholamandalam M/S General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Aarifa & Ors., bearing Civil Appeal No. 6020 of 2019. The learned counsel for the appellant further submits that the said order has relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors., (2017) 16 SCC 680, to hold that the compensation under non-conventional heads could not be more than Rs. 70,000/-.
2
6. The Court is of the view that in other cases passed by the Supreme Court after Pranay Sethi (supra), it has fixed the compensation towards 'loss of love and affection' @ Rs. 50,000/- and compensation towards 'loss of consortium' @ Rs. 40,000/- for each of the claimants as laid down in terms of the dicta of Supreme Court in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd.
v. Nanu Ram Alias Chuhru Ram & Ors. 2018 SCC OnLine SC 1546.
7. In view of the aforesaid order, the compensation towards 'loss of love and affection' @ Rs. 50,000/- to each of the claimants is hereby granted.
8. The enhanced amount of Rs. 2,00,000/-, alongwith interest accrued thereon @ 9% from the date of filing of the claim petition till its realization, shall be deposited before the learned Tribunal within three weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order, to be released to the beneficiary(ies) of the Award in terms of the scheme of disbursement specified therein.
9. The statutory amount, alongwith interest accrued thereon, shall be deposited into the 'AASRA' Fund, opened in Delhi High Court.
10. The appeal is disposed-off in the above terms.
NAJMI WAZIRI, J
OCTOBER 09, 2019
AB
3
Alert