- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kandhari Beverages Limited v. Haryana Tourism Limited And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent, Haryana Tourism Ltd. (Corporation), invited tenders for supplying Aerated Cold Drinks at its Tourist Complexes for the period 15.05.2001 to 14.05.2002. The appellant, a private company, submitted a tender which was accepted. Under Clause I of the agreement, the appellant was to pay Rs. 20 Lakh to the Corporation for Brand Promotion, to be spent as mutually agreed between the parties on marketing activities involving Haryana Tourism outlets.
The Corporation organized a Mango Mela in July 2001, spending Rs. 1 Lakh borne by the appellant. Plans for two Gurdaas Maan nights were cancelled abruptly by the Corporation, causing a loss of Rs. 4.7 Lakh to the appellant. Subsequent meetings were held regarding Musical Nights, with the appellant spending Rs. 13.92 Lakh. Despite this, the Corporation demanded Rs. 19 Lakh as sponsorship money and later terminated the contract unilaterally in January 2002.
The dispute was referred to arbitration. The first Arbitrator was transferred, the second did not proceed, and a third Arbitrator was appointed by the Managing Director of the Corporation. The final award dated 17.11.2005 directed the appellant to pay Rs. 9.5 Lakh within 30 days, dismissing the appellant’s counterclaim of Rs. 13.92 Lakh with interest.
The appellant filed an objection petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which was dismissed by the Additional District Judge, Chandigarh, by order dated 25.09.2014. The appellant then filed the present appeal under Section 37 of the Act seeking to quash the impugned order and award.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Arbitrator had jurisdiction to pass the impugned award?
- Whether the Arbitrator awarded the claim of Rs. 9.5 Lakh in accordance with the terms and conditions of the agreement executed between the parties?
- Whether the impugned award and judgment deserve to be set aside?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant contended there was no lapse on their part and that the respondent wrongly demanded Rs. 19 Lakh as sponsorship money.
- The appellant argued the Rs. 20 Lakh was to be spent on brand promotion only with mutual consent, which did not occur, hence no payment was due.
- The appellant challenged the appointment of the Arbitrator by the Managing Director of the Corporation, asserting the appointment was invalid as the arbitration clause ceased to exist upon recusal of the earlier Arbitrator.
- Several Supreme Court judgments were cited to support these contentions, including State Of West Bengal v. National Builders, Maharaji Educational Trust v. SGS Construction & Developers Pvt. Ltd., SBP & Co. v. Patel Engineering Ltd., and others.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent contended that the scope of judicial interference under Sections 34 and 37 of the Act is limited.
- The courts cannot act as an appellate authority over the Arbitrator’s decision and can only set aside awards on grounds specified in Section 34(2) of the Act.
- The respondent cited the Supreme Court judgment in Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd. to support the limited scope of interference.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| State Of West Bengal v. National Builders (1994) 1 SCC 235 | Validity of Arbitrator appointment and arbitration clause ceasing upon recusal | Appellant relied on this to challenge the appointment of the third Arbitrator by the Managing Director. |
| Maharaji Educational Trust v. SGS Construction & Developers Pvt. Ltd. 2012 (4) RAJ 70 (Delhi) | Arbitration procedural principles | Appellant cited this in support of arbitration appointment and procedural objections. |
| Konkan Railway Corporation v. Rani Construction Pvt. Ltd., 2002 (1) RAJ 165 (SC) | Arbitration procedural principles | Referenced by appellant on arbitration appointment issues. |
| SBP & Co. v. Patel Engineering Ltd., 2005 (9) SC 219 | Scope of judicial interference in arbitration awards | Appellant cited to argue against the award’s validity. |
| Pandey & Co. Builders Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Bihar (2007) 1 SCC 467 | Judicial review of arbitration awards | Appellant relied on this precedent for challenging the award. |
| GAIL v. KETI Constructions, 2007 (6) SCR 439 | Arbitration procedural principles | Appellant cited to support procedural objections. |
| Union of India v. PAM Developers Pvt. Ltd., 2014 (2) Arb. L.R. 27 (SC) | Arbitration procedural principles and scope of interference | Appellant referenced this case in support of arguments. |
| A. Ayyasamy v. Parmasivam (2016) 10 SCC 386 | Validity and scope of arbitration awards | Appellant cited this to challenge the award and arbitrator appointment. |
| Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd., J.T. 2003 (4) S.C. 171 | Limited scope of judicial interference under Sections 34 and 37 of the Act | Respondent cited to emphasize limited grounds for setting aside arbitration awards. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the appellant’s challenge to the Arbitrator’s jurisdiction and found that the appellant had raised this issue before the Arbitrator, who rejected it by order dated 17.03.2005. This order was never challenged and thus remains binding. The Court held that the appellant is precluded from raising the jurisdictional question at this stage and found the Arbitrator’s jurisdictional finding to be correct based on the arbitration clause.
Regarding the award of Rs. 9.5 Lakh, the Court noted that the Arbitrator held the respondent did not spend any amount on marketing activities and that it would be unfair to require the appellant to pay the entire Rs. 20 Lakh. However, the Court found the Arbitrator’s findings perverse and contrary to the contract terms, as the contract required mutual agreement for expenditure and the Corporation did not spend any money on brand promotion.
The Court emphasized that since the Corporation did not incur any expenditure on marketing activities and the contract was terminated mid-term, the respondent had no right to recover any amount from the appellant. The Court found the respondent’s claim amounted to unjust enrichment.
The Court also criticized the lower court for dismissing the objection petition without appreciating the actual facts and figures, merely relying on Supreme Court judgments without applying them to the facts.
Consequently, the Court concluded that both the award and the impugned order deserved to be set aside.
Holding and Implications
The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the award dated 17.11.2005 and the order dated 25.09.2014 passed by the Additional District Judge, Chandigarh.
The direct effect of this decision is that the appellant is not liable to pay the Rs. 9.5 Lakh as awarded, and the objection petition is upheld. No new precedent was established; the ruling is confined to the facts and contractual terms of this case.
Jaswant Singh, J.:— Present appeal under Section 37 of arbitration and conciliation Act, 1996 (for short ‘Act’) is filed seeking quashing of order dated 25.09.2014 whereby Ld. Additional District Judge, Chandigarh has dismissed objection petition filed under Section 34 of the Act and upheld award dated 17.11.2005.
2. The facts emerging from pleadings and arguments of both the counsels are that the respondent-Haryana Tourism Ltd. (for short ‘Corporation’) invited tenders/quotations for the supply of Aerated Cold Drinks at its Tourist Complexes for the period 15.05.2001 to 14.05.2002. The appellant-Private Company filed tender and it was accepted by Corporation. As per Clause I of the agreement, the appellant-Company was supposed to pay a sum of Rs. 20 Lakh on account of Brand Promotion which had to be spent as per mutual agreement between the parties. The said Clause of the agreement reads as under:—
“The company would pay Rs. 20 Lakh to HTC on account of their Brand Promotion which will be spent as per mutual agreement between HTC and Coca Cola of marketing activities and programmes involving all Haryana Tourism outlets. These activities should include signage, press advertisements, fairs, food festivals, other events etc. at the same outlets.”
3. The Corporation organised a Mango Mela on 07/08 July' 2001 at Yaadwinder Garden, Pinjore and respondent-Corporation spent a sum of Rs. 1 Lakh and said amount was borne by the appellant-Company. The Corporation proposed to hold two Gurdaas Maan nights on 04.06.2001 and 07.06.2001 in its two outlets and as per appellant, they spent a sum of Rs. 4.75 Lakh towards arrangements, however, respondent-Corporation abruptly cancelled said programme resulting into loss of Rs. 4.7 Lakh to the appellant. Thereafter meetings took place between both the parties to hold Musical Nights of Gurdaas Maan/Malkiat Singh. As per appellant, they spent a sum of Rs. 13.92 Lakh still respondent asked the appellant vide letter dated 20.09.2001 to deposit a sum of Rs. 19 Lakh as sponsorship money. The appellant replied aforesaid letter but Corporation vide letter dated 17.01.2002 unilaterally terminated their contract. The matter reached to Sole Arbitrator who vide award dated 17.11.2005 directed the appellant to pay a sum of Rs. 9.5 Lakh within a period of 30 days. The appellant also lodged its counter claim of Rs. 13.92 Lakh alongwith interest @ 24%, however, learned Arbitrator dismissed claim of the appellant and allowed claim of the respondent to the extent of Rs. 9.5 Lakh. It is apt to notice here that first Arbitrator was transferred before conclusion of proceeding and second did not proceed with the matter and it was third Arbitrator appointed by Managing Director of Corporation who passed final award.
4. The appellant filed objection petition under Section 34 of the Act before learned Additional District Judge, Chandigarh who vide impugned order dated 25.09.2014 dismissed objection petition on the ground that there is no reason to interfere in the award because scope of interference is limited and no ground as contemplated under Section 34 is made out.
5. Mr. Kanwal Chaudhary, counsel for the appellant, vehemently contended that there was no lapse on the part of appellant. The respondent wrongly demanded a sum of Rs. 19 Lakh as sponsorship money and learned Courts below have committed patent error in awarding a sum of Rs. 9.5 Lakh because respondent never spent said amount for promotion of brand of both the parties. The appellant was not supposed to pay a sum of Rs. 20 Lakh to respondent whereas said money was supposed to be incurred with the mutual consent of both the parties. There was no question of making payment to respondent and learned Arbitrator has wrongly awarded a sum of Rs. 9.5 Lakh. The counsel further contended that appointment of Arbitrator was bad in the eyes of Law because Managing Director of the Corporation has no authority to appoint fresh Arbitrator when earlier Arbitrator could not pass the award. In case where appointment is by name or designation, on account of recusal of Arbitrator, arbitration clause ceases to exist. In support of his contention, learned counsel cited judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State Of West Bengal v. National Builders (1994) 1 SCC 235, Maharaji Educational Trust v. SGS Construction & Developers Pvt. Ltd., 2012 (4) RAJ 70 (Delhi), Konkan Railway Corporation v. Rani Construction Pvt. Ltd., 2002 (1) RAJ 165 (SC), SBP & Co. v. Patel Engineering Ltd., 2005 (9) SC 219, Pandey & Co. Builders Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Bihar (2007) 1 SCC 467 : 2007 AIR (SC) 465, GAIL v. KETI Constructions, 2007 (6) SCR 439, Union of India v. PAM Developers Pvt. Ltd., 2014 (2) Arb. L.R. 27 (SC), A. Ayyasamy v. Parmasivam (2016) 10 SCC 386 : AIR 2016 (SC) 4675.
6. Per contra, counsel for the respondent contended that scope of interference under Section 34 as well 37 of the Act is very limited and Courts cannot sit as Appellate Authority over the decision of Arbitrator. The award can be set aside only within parameters of Section 34(2) of the Act and Court has no power to re-appreciate evidences considered by Arbitrator. Learned counsel in support of his contention cited judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd., J.T. 2003 (4) S.C. 171.
7. Having scrutinized record of the case and hearing arguments of both counsel, this Court finds that below mentioned questions arise for adjudication:
i) Whether Arbitrator had jurisdiction to pass impugned award?
ii) Whether Arbitrator had awarded claim of Rs. 9.5 Lakh as per terms and conditions of agreement executed between the parties?
iii) Whether impugned award and judgment deserves to be set aside?
8. The appellant raised question of jurisdiction before the learned Arbitrator who vide order dated 17.03.2005 rejected contention of the appellant and said order still holds the field because it was never set aside by any higher court. The appellant did not challenge said order rather joined proceedings. As order dated 17.03.2005 was not challenged before appropriate forum, the appellant is precluded from raising said question at this stage and even otherwise findings of learned Arbitrator on this issue seems to be correct, in the light of arbitration clause of agreement.
9. Learned Arbitrator has awarded a sum of Rs. 9.5 Lakh holding that claimant did not spend any amount on marketing activities and programmes to be held on Haryana Tourism day, therefore, it would be unfair to order to pay entire amount which was to be paid by present appellant to respondent-Corporation. True that scope of interference at appellant stage is limited, however, an award cannot be upheld which is on the face of it is illegal or beyond the scope of substantive provision of the Act or the contract.
10. In the present case, a sum of Rs. 20 Lakh was to be paid by appellant to respondent-Corporation on account of their brand promotion which had to be spent as per mutual agreement between both the parties on marketing activities. It is conceded fact that corporation did not spend even singly penny on account of Brand Promotion i.e. marketing activities. It is also undisputed fact that Corporation vide letter dated 22.05.2001 cancelled holding of Cultural Evenings scheduled for 04.06.2001 and 07.06.2001.
11. A sum of Rs. 20 lakh was required to be paid by appellant, but it had to be incurred with the consent of both the parties and due to one or another reason mutual consent could not be reached. As the respondent-Corporation did not spend even single penny on marketing activities, it had no right to recover any amount from appellant. The respondent has no right to enrich itself when no expenses were incurred and contract was terminated mid of the term. The findings of Arbitrator are perverse and contrary to terms and conditions of contract (as reproduced hereabove) which is basis of claim awarded. Learned Objecting Court did not appreciate actual fact and figures and dismissed objection petition simply citing few judgments of Hon'ble Supreme Court. Therefore, award as well as impugned order dated 25.09.2014 passed by Ld. Additional District Judge, Chandigarh, deserves to be set aside and present appeal deserves to be allowed.
12. In view of above findings, present appeal is allowed, and impugned award dated 17.11.2005 and order dated 25.09.2014 passed by learned Additional District Judge, Chandigarh are set aside.
Alert