Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

P. Khadar Basha v. State Of A.P.

Telangana High Court
Aug 10, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners have been employed in Last Grade Services in Kavali Municipality, Nellore District, since 1989. Their services were not regularised because they did not complete five years of service by the cut-off date of 25.11.1993, as specified in G.O. Ms. No. 212 dated 22.4.1994. Consequently, they have been continued as Non-Ministerial Regulars (NMRs) or Daily Wage Workers. However, the respondents extended the minimum time scale of pay to them starting from 1997 but excluded other pay components such as annual grade increments, House Rent Allowance (HRA), and City Compensatory Allowance (CCA). The petitioners filed Original Application No. 3132 of 2013 before the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal seeking direction to release annual grade increments, HRA, and CCA along with arrears from the date of payment of the minimum time scale. The Tribunal dismissed the application, and the petitioners challenged that order through this Writ Petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioners, who have been extended the minimum time scale of pay, are entitled to annual grade increments along with HRA and CCA from the date of payment of the minimum time scale.
  2. Whether the petitioners can claim arrears for the annual grade increments and other allowances despite their non-regularised status.
  3. The extent and period for which arrears, if any, should be granted to the petitioners.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners sought payment of annual grade increments along with HRA and other allowances but conceded entitlement only to annual grade increments if other allowances are not permissible.
  • They relied on a Government Order (G.O. Rt. No. 1387 dated 19.10.2012) which directed the Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation (GVMC) to grant annual grade increments and arrears to Minimum Time Scale employees following Tribunal orders.
  • The petitioners also cited the Division Bench judgment in Government of Andhra Pradesh v. S. Nageswara Rao (2012 (2) ALD 26 (DB)) where similar claims by NMRs/temporary employees were allowed, emphasizing the principle of equal pay for equal work.
  • They contended that the definition of “time scale of pay” under Ruling-31(a) of Rule-9 of the Andhra Pradesh Fundamental Rules supports entitlement to periodical increments as part of the minimum time scale.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The learned Government Pleader for Services argued for limiting the grant of annual grade increments to a reasonable past period, contending that granting arrears from the date of extension of the minimum time scale would impose a huge financial burden on the exchequer.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Government of Andhra Pradesh v. S. Nageswara Rao (2012 (2) ALD 26 (DB)) Principle of equal pay for equal work; entitlement of temporary/NMR employees to annual grade increments and revised pay scales. The Court relied on this precedent to hold that the petitioners, being similarly situated temporary employees, are entitled to annual grade increments despite their non-regularised status.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court observed that the petitioners have been granted the minimum time scale of pay from 1997 but were excluded from receiving annual grade increments and other components of regular pay. The Court noted the Government Order (G.O. Rt. No. 1387 dated 19.10.2012) which directed the GVMC to implement Tribunal orders granting annual grade increments and arrears to Minimum Time Scale employees, indicating government recognition of such entitlement. The Court further examined the Division Bench judgment in Government of Andhra Pradesh v. S. Nageswara Rao, which emphasized the principle of equal pay for equal work, supporting the petitioners' claim to increments.

Moreover, the Court referred to the definition of “time scale of pay” in Ruling-31(a) of Rule-9 of the Andhra Pradesh Fundamental Rules, which defines time scale as pay rising by periodical increments from minimum to maximum, reinforcing that increments are integral to the time scale. The Court held that the petitioners are entitled to annual grade increments as part of the minimum time scale but are not entitled to all other allowances that regular employees receive.

Considering the financial impact and the fact that the petitioners filed the Original Application only in 2013, the Court exercised discretion to restrict the grant of arrears to the period from the date of filing of the Original Application onward, balancing the petitioners' rights with public interest.

Holding and Implications

The Court allowed the Writ Petition in part, directing the respondents to revise the minimum time scale of pay of the petitioners by adding annual grade increments as and when they fell due from time to time, with arrears payable only from the date of filing of the Original Application in 2013.

The direct effect of this decision is that the petitioners will receive annual grade increments and arrears from 2013 onwards but will not be entitled to other allowances such as HRA and CCA. The Court did not set any new precedent beyond affirming existing principles of pay entitlement for temporary employees under the time scale of pay.

Show all summary ...

C.V. Nagarjuna Reddy, J.:— Order, dated 14.10.2016, in Original Application No. 3132 of 2013 on the file of the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal at Hyderabad (for short ‘the Tribunal’) is assailed in this Writ Petition.

2. The petitioners have been working in the Last Grade Services in Kavali Municipality, Nellore District, since 1989. As their services have not been regularised in view of the fact that they did not put in five years of service as on 25.11.1993, the cut-off date mentioned in G.O. Ms. No. 212, Finance and Planning (FW.PC-III) Department, dated 22.4.1994, they are being continued as NMRs/Daily Wage Workers all these years. However, the respondents have extended the minimum time scale to them. The petitioners have filed the above-mentioned O.A. before the Tribunal for a direction to the respondents to release the annual grade increments, HRA and CCA from the date of payment of the minimum time scale along with arrears. The said O.A. having been dismissed by the Tribunal, along with two other O.As, the petitioners filed this Writ Petition. We have heard Mr. P. Suresh Reddy, the learned senior counsel representing Mr. P. Raghavender Reddy, the learned counsel for the petitioners and the learned Government Pleader for Services (Andhra Pradesh) and perused the record.

3. It is not in dispute that the petitioners have been extended the minimum time scale from the year 1997. However, while paying the minimum time scale to the petitioners, the respondents have not included any other components forming part of the regular pay scale including the annual grade increments. Therefore, the petitioners approached the Tribunal for extending those benefits, which, as observed above, was rejected by the Tribunal.

4. Learned senior counsel for the petitioners submitted that though his clients have sought for payment of the annual grade increments along with HRA and other allowances, they may not be entitled to any allowances other than the annual grade increments. He has further submitted that the Tribunal allowed certain O.As filed for payment of annual grade increments, while it dismissed certain other O.As and that, both the temporary employees as well as the Government have filed Writ Petitions which are pending before this Court. He has invited our attention to G.O. Rt. No. 1387, Municipal Administration and Urban Development (D.1) Department, dated 19.10.2012, issued by the Government of Andhra Pradesh. It is profitable to extract the entire G.O. hereunder:

“In the reference read above, the Commissioner, Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation has stated that 113 Minimum Time Scale employees, working in Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation have approached the Hon'ble Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal in O.A. Nos. 7749/2006, 7823/2006, 7811/2006,375/2007 and 7781/2006 for sanction of annual grade increments and the Hon'ble Tribunal in its order, directed that the respondents to grant annual grade increments to the applicants in the time scale wherein their pay was fixed and also to pay the arrears and also extend the benefit of further pay revision made in 2005 and aggrieved by the above said orders of the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal, the Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation have filed W.P. Nos. 5934/2008, 6622/2008, 9113/2008, 8611/2008 and 9067/2008 in the Hon'ble High Court and the said W.Ps were dismissed, vide orders dated 07.9.2011. The Commissioner, Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation has filed Special Leave Petitions in SLP(C). CC. Nos. 6021/2012, 6024/2012, 5998/2012, 6031/2012 and 6028/2012 challenging the High Court order, dated 07.9.2011 and the said above petitions were also dismissed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court vide orders, dated 30.4.2012 and subsequently, the Hon'ble Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal has issued notice in C.A. Nos. 270/2012, 316/2012,275/2012, 269/2012 and 274/2012 to implement the orders of the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal by 16.7.2012.

2. The Commissioner, Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation has stated that the Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation has exhausted all the legal options and as there is no other alternative for its disposal and also in view of the contempt cases posted on 16.7.2017, in the Hon'ble Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal, requested the Government to issue necessary orders to implement the orders of the Hon'ble Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal, so as to avoid further legal complications.

3. After careful examination of the matter, in consultation with the advisory department and keeping in view of the orders of the Hon'ble Tribunal in O.A. No. 7749/2006 filed by Sri K. Appa Rao and four others, O.A. No. 7823/2006 filed by Sri Y. Venkata Rao and five others, O.A. No. 7811/2006, filed by-Sri S.V. Srinivasa Rao and 11 others, O.A. No. 375 of 2007 filed by Sri D. Venkata Rao and 11 others and O.A. No. 7781 of 2006 filed by Sri M.V. Ramana Murthy and 77 others working as Minimum Time Scale employees in Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation, the Government hereby accord permission to the Commissioner, Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation to grant annual grade increments to the applicants covered in the said O.As in the time scale, wherein their pay was fixed and also to pay the arrears and also extend the benefits of the further pay revision made in 2005, subject to condition, that the additional expenditure shall be met from the budget provisions of the Corporation funds only.

4. The Commissioner, Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation shall take action accordingly.

5. This order issued with the concurrence of Finance (PC. III) Department, vide order U.O. No. 22050/307/A1/PC.lII/2012, dated 18.8.2012, and vide their U.O. No. 8096/PFS(RE)/2012, dated 28.8.2012.”

5. From the above reproduced contents of the G.O., it is clear that certain O.As filed by the temporary employees of the Greater Visakhapatnam Municipal Corporation (for short ‘the GVMC’) were allowed directing grant of annual grade increments in the minimum time scale and the Writ Petitions filed against the said orders were dismissed by this Court. The SLPs filed by the GVMC were also dismissed by the Supreme Court. In paragraph-2 of the said G.O., it is stated that the GVMC has exhausted all legal remedies and that, there was no alternative other than implementing the order of the Tribunal. Accordingly, the Government has issued the said G.O. granting the annual grade increments to the applicants in the said O.As in the time scale wherein their pay was fixed apart from granting arrears also.

6. The learned senior counsel has also drawn our attention to the judgment of a Division Bench of this Court in Government of Andhra Pradesh v. S. Nageswara Rao (1) 2012 (2) ALD 26 (DB), wherein this Court allowed a similar claim made by NMRs/temporary employees of certain municipalities. In this context, it is apt to extract the observations of the Division Bench below:—

“There is no dispute that all of them were given regular scale of pay and also conferred the benefit of revised pay scales as and when new scales were implemented in the State of Andhra Pradesh. After giving regular scale of pay and also granting annual grade increments for some time, various Municipalities and Municipal Corporations stopped releasing increments and giving revised scales of pay, necessitating adjudication of the same by the Andhra Pradesh Administrative Tribunal. The respondents are casual/NMR/temporary Class-IV employees, who do similar work and discharge similar functions as any regular Class-IV employees. The principle of equal pay for equal work would bar the State or its agents from denying annual grade increments and revised scale of pay to the respondents. We are, therefore, not impressed with the argument that the grant of annual grade increments or grant of revised pay scales to the respondents would contravene the provisions of the A.P. Act 2 of 1994.”

7. In our view, the petitioners are entitled to the relief claimed by them based on the above-mentioned precedents. Even otherwise also, going by the definition of “time scale of pay” in Ruling-31(a) of Rule-9 of the Andhra Pradesh Fundamental Rules, the petitioners are entitled to payment of increments. This Rule reads as under:

““Time scale of pay” means pay which subject to any condition prescribed in these rules, rises by periodical increments from a minimum to maximum. It indicates the class of pay hirtherto known as progressive.

8. The above-extracted definition of “time scale of pay” leaves us in no doubt that the scale of pay has to change with the change of times by addition of periodical increments. Otherwise the expression “time scale” would have no meaning at all.

9. In the light of the above discussion, we are of the opinion that as the petitioners have been extended the minimum time scale, they are entitled to addition of increments from time to time in the minimum time scale without being entitled to all other allowances which a regular employee is entitled.

10. The learned Government Pleader for Services (Andhra Pradesh) submitted that the Court may consider limiting the grant of annual grade increments to the petitioners to a reasonable past period as, the relief of payment of arrears, if granted from the time of extension of the minimum time scale to the petitioners, would cause huge burden on the exchequer.

11. Though in strict sense, the petitioners are entitled to all the arrears, keeping in view the fact that they have approached the Tribunal only in the year 2013 and also the public interest, we restrict the said benefit only from the date of filing of the said O.A. by the petitioners. The Writ Petition is, accordingly, allowed in part to the extent indicated above. The respondents shall revise the minimum time scale of pay of the petitioners by adding the annual grade increments as and when they fell due from time to time.

12. As a sequel to disposal of the Writ Petition, WPMP. No. 33252 of 2017 filed by the petitioners for interim relief is disposed of as infructuous.